More

HuffPost Social Reading

Military Suicides: One Third Of Personnel Told Of Plans To Die, Defense Department Report Finds

Military Suicides

First Posted: 09/22/2011 5:23 pm Updated: 11/22/2011 4:12 am

DENVER -- A third of military personnel who committed suicide last year had told at least one person they planned to take their own lives, a newly released Defense Department report says.

Nearly half went to see medical personnel, behavioral health specialists, chaplains or other service providers sometime in the 90 days before they died, according to the 2010 Department of Defense Suicide Event Report.

That doesn't necessarily reflect a failure in the Defense Department suicide prevention program, said Richard McKeon, chief of the Suicide Prevention Branch at the federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.

"It's not that some person blew it," McKeon said Thursday. But physical and behavior health care personnel, counselors and other providers need to monitor their programs and look for improvements, he said.

"(Providers) need to be aware of what those opportunities are, and need to be regularly evaluating their efforts on what is working or what is not," McKeon said.

The 250-page report released late Wednesday analyzes 295 confirmed or "strongly suspected" suicides that were reported last year, down from 309 the year before. Caucasian service members under age 25 and in the lower ranks were at the highest risk, the same as the year before.

The 2010 total includes active-duty, reserve and National Guard personnel. It reflects a slight downward revision from the 301 suicides the Defense Department reported in January, which included about 70 that were still under investigation.

The Defense Department has been coping with rising suicide numbers during its protracted wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. Individual service branches have tracked suicides for years, and in 2008, the Defense Department began using a standard form for collecting information called the Department of Defense Suicide Event Report or DoDSER.

Among the findings from the 2010 reports were that 34 percent of those who took their own lives communicated their intentions to someone, most commonly to their spouse or a friend. In 2009, the figure was 28 percent.

About 46 percent had been seen at a military treatment facility sometime in the 90 days before death. The treatment services include physical and behavioral health, substance abuse, family advocacy and chaplains.

McKeon said those statistics don't indicate whether the spouses, friends or others acted on the information, and if they did, what action they took. Nor do they show whether service providers intervened or whether intervention would have been successful, he said.

"People are often uncomfortable talking about suicide" with someone who appears vulnerable, fearing they might actually give someone the idea, McKeon said. There is no evidence that discussing suicide makes it more likely, he said.

"It's important to ask about it," McKeon said. "Even mental health professionals have trouble asking about it."

All branches of the military have "gatekeeper" programs designed to educate everyone in suicide prevention, said McKeon, who served on a Defense Department task force on suicide prevention.

Fort Carson, Colo., uses the Army's Ask, Care, Escort program, or ACE. It teaches all soldiers to ask whether someone is contemplating suicide, show concern if they are and escort them to a superior officer or service provider.

"Ask directly: `Are you thinking of killing yourself?'" said Kim Henry, the substance abuse program manager at Fort Carson.

"It's a very direct question. Not, `Are you thinking of hurting yourself,' (but) `Are you thinking of killing yourself?'" she said.

Squad leaders, sergeants, company commanders and other first-line supervisors go through a more extensive, two-day intervention training, Henry said.

Fort Carson has reported one soldier suicide so far this year with three other possible suicides under investigation. Last year, the post reported seven suicides.

___

National Suicide Prevention Hotline: 800-273-8255.

___

FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
DENVER -- A third of military personnel who committed suicide last year had told at least one person they planned to take their own lives, a newly released Defense Department report says. Nearly ha...
DENVER -- A third of military personnel who committed suicide last year had told at least one person they planned to take their own lives, a newly released Defense Department report says. Nearly ha...
Filed by Chris Gentilviso  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 368
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
11:07 AM on 09/29/2011
Ashley Joppa Hagemann lost her husband June 28th. Jared Hagemann, Army Ranger, 25, had told everybody his plans, and held the gun to his head in several incidents. He had been diagnosed with PTSD yet to avoid a 9th deployment to Afghanistan he killed himself, please have a listen to her anguished report last month: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsuNhDeK48Y She got in Don Rumsfeld's face: http://www.youtube.com/toddboyle#p/u/0/fr85iXFpVvo Spoke again last Saturday http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b9UGi2JR8bc
12:22 PM on 09/24/2011
I am one of those military persons that was told by someone that they attempted suicide and later killed themselves. I made the mistake of informing my chain of command at the 54th Quarter master Company at Fort Lee thinking that they would do right by the soldier and they blew it! The guy killed himself after they failed to take appropriate action. So, Mr. Keon Shut up!, and quit denying the truth and admit the Army failed these soldiers. Some how I doubt Mine was an isolated case!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ladywiccan
a wife, mother and grandmother
10:54 PM on 09/23/2011
garysfg don't let my screen name fool you, I know first hand what it's like I serverd during Nam and was attached to a mash unit so I think I know what it's like don't judge the book by it's cover, also my husband and five cousins served during the same time frame so go peddle your papers some where else
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TERPMOM
02:27 PM on 09/23/2011
People do not, kid, joke or try to draw attention to themselves by saying have thought or are thinking about suicide. Every person should understand this. A therapist who is confidentally alerted by their patient has to make a 'pact' with that person that they will get in contact with them or immediatly call a crisis hotline. Apparently this does work. I know I didn't go there.
02:08 PM on 09/23/2011
Why do 35% of the soldies now get PTSD and it was a rarity in the Korean War. In Korea combat was a contact sport. All the Vietnam vets, with PTSD, that I have spoken to never saw an enemy soldier. In Korea as an infantryman we were eye ball to eye ball with them on almost a dailt basis. I do not have PTSD and neither do any of the fellows who were in my outfit. My outfit saw more combat than any other in Korea. I believe all the PTSD now is caused by a chemical we were not subject to in Korea. Is it caused by chemicals in the clothing, something in the food or water or what. Tests should be performed to find out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Macfarlane
Proud to have been allowed to serve in Vietnam
04:58 AM on 09/24/2011
I'm not sure those of us without degrees in psychology are qualified to judge whether someone has PTSD and depression can be hard to spot. I've served with guys from the Korean war and Nam but knew only one who committed suicide. It surprised us all.

Korea was one of those fights where our guys were badly outnumbered when the Chinese really got into it. The Marines up north in the Chosin reservoir area lived a horror with the snow and bitter cold but It had to have been bad for all you guys in that fracas. Thanks for your service. Isn't it too bad Eisenhower didn't make an issue about our POWs held by the Chinese and North Koreans after the treaty?
11:02 AM on 09/29/2011
Ah but the war itself lacked legitimacy.
02:07 PM on 09/23/2011
Therapy has been scientifically proven to help those that want it and believe in it. Kind of like church except a lot of people go, don't believe and exhibit nothing like Christian like behavior in their daily lives. Don't be upset that therapy didn't work you. You most likely like being miserable and blaming it on others.
03:05 PM on 09/23/2011
Therapy has been scientificall proven as much as god has been scientifically proven. Some people never feel miserable no matter what they go through while other get periodically depressed no matter how good things are. Back in the 70s all therapists believed depression was caused by being abused as a child. I know of one depressed woman where it was poven that no childhood abuse had occurred that the therapist said it must have occurred in her previous life. Therapy was BS then and it still is. The cause of depression and suicide is chemical. You cannot alter chemistry with BS talk. Find out what the chemical cause on the depression is and treat that.
03:06 PM on 09/23/2011
I've been diagnosed with PTSD but I don't believe that, I don't think what I saw was that bad or what I did was wrong. Hence my user name as HAH BS to them. I loved it over there, wish I could still be there.
05:49 PM on 09/23/2011
It's not a matter of how bad something is or doing anything wrong. It's a matter of how each person reacts to a certain situation. If several people see a car accident some won't be bothered at all, some a little and maybe one or two will kind of freak out. PTSD, like most mental health diagnosis, just gives mental health personnel an idea of what may be going on with a client. Many soldiers are not effected by combat but some are. I've worked with many, including special forces, who love it over there and there is nothing wrong with that. The comraderie, trusting in your guys, the constant adrenaline. That being said you can only live on adrenaline and life threatening situations for so long. PTSD comes down to a level of functioning. If you are functiong alright you probably don't need to be too concerned with the diagnosis unless if affecting sleep, moods, relationships, alcohol or drug abuse, etc. If it is then there is an issue that you could address if you want. Several clients got out and went back with contractors. Either way if you feel you need help or those that love you feel you need to help try not to take it personnally or as a sign of weekness. I have had special forces sargeant majors and colonels as clients. At times we all need a little help. Good luck and thanks for serving and getting back safely.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sparkygirl91
Never apply lipstick while driving on gravel
01:50 PM on 09/23/2011
If someone tells you they're going to kill themselves, take it very seriously and do something! Had the doctor who was supposed to be treating my brother did, he'd probably be alive today.
01:48 PM on 09/23/2011
Abandoning the constricted military was a huge mistake. An all volunteer force may sound workable, but extended tours, repeating tours, and placing the burden on one segment of society is always a mistake. Every physically and mentally capable male should be subject to 2 years of active duty military service. No matter the race, the religion, the wealth. No exceptions, no deferments, no avenue for political influence to avoid service. Today we have a president and we are very close to having an entire legislative branch that has never served in the military. Less than 1% of our military age population actually serve in the military. The balance gets a free ride. Shameful.
tennisguy
Too much preparation and there is no first step.
02:28 PM on 09/23/2011
Reads good! However, it would probably be like Nam, in which conflict the kids of the upper classes got deferment after deferment, and rarely served in combat. Do you remember that Cheney got five deferments, and never served.
03:07 PM on 09/23/2011
And so it's his fault? Please.
12:19 AM on 09/24/2011
It's hard enough working with the ones who volunteered you want to force kids to serve in the military?
tennisguy
Too much preparation and there is no first step.
01:22 PM on 09/24/2011
The military wouldn't care about the high cost. But the taxpayers need a break. Moreover, we would not be in, or stay in, a lot of conflicts if the kids of the well-to-do had to serve. They have always been given a pass since WWII.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Risky Rich
01:43 PM on 09/23/2011
So, you say you would like to commit suicide. No doc., I want to kill my self. OH, that makes a difference, her use my gun
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mithrall
My inner child is a mean little S.O.B.
01:34 PM on 09/23/2011
This is just the beginning. The effects of multiple tours in hostile zones will have devastating effects on both the soldiers and their families as well as the country. It's very heart warming to see the videos of soldiers suprising their kids by showing up unexpectedly at their school etc but that doesn't magically repair all the damage that's been done by his/her absence. Nor does it heal the psychological wounds of the soldiers themselves. Depression and PTSD are hard to see coming, by the time you realize you or a loved one might have a problem it's already pretty well progressed. Hard core soldiers aren't going to readily admit to anything they percieve as a weakness on their part, they will try to "tough it out", so often they wont get help in time.
01:24 PM on 09/23/2011
Why shouldnt they think about suicides, most of them have joined the service because there is NO employment at home, and wind up as cannon fodder to protect corporate interests in foreign nations under the guise of helping people that dont want them there. What are they going to do when the come home, go on uemployment? Yeah , I know, I'm an unpatriotic nut case, Well Why dont you ask them, Do you think the military will let you tell them the truth about how they really feel?
01:58 PM on 09/23/2011
Have you ever served? Have you done more than sit smuggly in your Conspiracy theory fueled, cynical world. In the 70s and 80s people who went into the military were said to be people who couldn't get a job. These men and women deal with more stress on a day to day basis than most people do. The suicide rate was higher than civilians before there was a war or a poor economy. They are not allowed to call in sick or quit because it's to tough. Some of them have done and seen things that are deeply distubing. If you couple that with with a sociaty that publicly praises them, but is unable to relate to them (less than 5% of the population has served) its not surpising the results. I you look beyond the stats to the poeple you would find that most of them thought that they let someone done, themselves, thier family, or the friends the lost. Thier stories are a tragedy, not fodder for your political rants.
06:50 PM on 09/23/2011
Are you telling me that common people, absent the event of naked agression, signup because they WANT to go to war? WAR is supposed to be HELL, that is why it should always be a last resort. The MIC is not a conspiracy, it EXISTS, it is being exploited and so are these young soldiers, These occupations are not "wars" they are police actions.This is not a political rant, and their tragedy is americas trajedy. It is my Tragedy becuase I alone can do nothing to stop it.
oceanview136
The Truth and Nothing but the Truth
01:10 PM on 09/23/2011
I honestly believe that ANYBODY that threatens, or talks about suicide, should be taken very seriously !!!
ae12wrangell
Everybody is entitled to my opinion
12:58 PM on 09/23/2011
Excellent choice! Suicide. If those servicemen do choose to die, then the money they had earned in 401K's, etc would be voided, and paid back to the United States, and the widow/widower is on his/her own, and no support from Department of Veteran's Affair's
03:10 PM on 09/23/2011
Do you realize that over 80% of servicemembers receive no pensions, if yuou don't stay twenty you don't get anything. I don't know about the new Thrift Savings Plan.
ae12wrangell
Everybody is entitled to my opinion
12:57 AM on 09/24/2011
Admiral Mike Mullen and General David Petraeus are only teenager's? They look good though.
12:46 PM on 09/23/2011
Misleading headline. It would sound like 1/3 of a;ll military personnel have mentioned suicide, and the artcle states that it is 1/3 of those who commit sucide, which is certainely much less that 1/3 of the entire armed forces.
12:43 PM on 09/23/2011
Since in rality the numbers in the military is samll compared to the rest of the people in the world/country, I wonder how many suicides in other occupations did the same thing?