More

Attack On Gay Student By Bully At Union-Scioto High School In Chillicothe, Ohio Under Investigation

First Posted: 10/28/2011 4:45 pm Updated: 12/28/2011 5:12 am

Gay Teen Attack

Authorities are continuing to evaluate evidence in the alleged attack on a gay Ohio teen whose mother believes may have been targeted due to his sexual orientation.

Video of the incident that appears to show the attacker, who has not been named, waiting for the gay student inside a classroom was posted on Facebook. The grainy footage is believed to have been shot on the aggressor's cousin's cell phone. Still, as The Chillicothe Gazette reports, no one else has come forward who believes the fight may have been motivated by the sexual orientation of the victim, who has chosen to remain anonymous:

According to the initial report obtained Thursday by the Gazette, the two boys were on their way to a third-period class when they "bumped shoulders." The 15-year-old suspect told deputies he has a mental illness, that he "just zoned out," and didn't know why he punched Collins' son, according to the report.

[Rebecca] Collins' son sustained a black eye, a knot behind his ear, a chipped tooth and a possible concussion, Collins said.

While Collins told deputies she thought the fight was motivated by her son's sexuality, the report indicates Osborne told the deputy he talked to the teacher and students in the classroom and no one reported the student saying anything about Collins' son's sexuality.

While the attacker was given a three-day suspension for the fight, the Gazette quotes the victim's mother as saying she feels Unioto High School, where he son is a freshman, has not done enough to clamp down on bullying. "I've called and called and called...[The response] has been real lackadaisical, 'kids will be kids,'" Collins said, noting that her son has repeatedly been called names relating to his sexuality. "To me, it's not only the kids doing it. The teachers aren't stepping in."

Though his office is evaluating whether to file an assault or felonious assault charge against the attacker, Ross County Prosecutor Matt Schmidt added that Ohio lacked existing legislation to enhance the charges even if officials could prove the attack was motivated by the victim's sexuality. There is a federal hate crime law, he added, but the federal district attorney would have to file the charge, and Collins could approach him about it.

James Osborne, principal at Union-Scioto High School, condemned the "unfortunate" attack. "I am not saying we have never had any reports of bullying -- we have just as much as any school," he told ABC. "But we've never had anything of this magnitude."

Need help? In the U.S., call 1-800-273-8255 for the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline or visit stopbullying.gov. You can also visit GLSEN, the Gay, Lesbian & Straight Education Network, which strives to assure that each member of every school community is valued and respected regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity/expression and The Trevor Project or call them at 866-488-7386.

Tyler Clementi
1  of  13
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
The disturbing rash of LGBT teen suicides began receiving attention last fall. Among those who took their own life was Tyler Clementi, an 18-year-old Rutgers University student who jumped off the George Washington Bridge between New Jersey and New York after his roommate allegedly filmed him having sex with another man.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST GAY VOICES

Authorities are continuing to evaluate evidence in the alleged attack on a gay Ohio teen whose mother believes may have been targeted due to his sexual orientation. Video of the incident that appe...
Authorities are continuing to evaluate evidence in the alleged attack on a gay Ohio teen whose mother believes may have been targeted due to his sexual orientation. Video of the incident that appe...
Filed by Curtis M. Wong  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 177
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
thewirah
In the time of chimpanzees I was a monkey
08:57 AM on 12/02/2011
Hang the bully.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:30 AM on 12/02/2011
HuffingtonPost dont link the video, i think its extremely irresponsible! it only encourages it to get more views and gives these bullies an audience. instead look up his yearbook photo and plaster it all over the web, along with a couple of teachers of the kid who judging by his character, can give some great negative feedback and ruin this kids reputation.
until that starts happening this will just continue
11:39 AM on 12/05/2011
I'm not promoting what this child did. It was horrendous and he should be punished accordingly. No one deserves that kind of treatment. I hope the boy at the receiving end of that hate is ok and is able to move on from what happened. That being said, doesn't your example of retribution,basically promote bullying? I mean, your basically saying that this kid bullied so in turn put his photo on the internet to be criticized by his teachers and mocked, ridiculed and well... bullied for his actions by the rest of the world. No offense, but, what is that kind of punishment supposed to teach? That if you're a bully, you will be bullied back? Or that bullying is ok under certain circumstances? It just sounds rather counter productive. Should he be punished? By all means, but publicly ridiculing him and mocking him solves nothing. It just turns the tables and repeats the cycle.
02:09 PM on 11/23/2011
" The 15-year-old suspect told deputies he has a mental illness, that he "just zoned out," "
I'd like to learn more about this part. What kind of mental illness? What kind of drugs, if any, are prescribed?
For one example, "biploar disorder", which is a real condition for some people, but is not a disease, has been hugely over-diagnosed -and mostly mis-diagnosed- in recent years, mainly as a result of the development of new, patented, quite expensive drugs for it.
Teens and even small children, in a novel, politically correct, and institutionalized new form of child abuse, are being prescribed drugs called "atypical antipsychotics", which are very powerful and can have serious side effects.
The atypical antipsychotics are heavy "downer" drugs that poison the system to create an artificial depression, presumably to stave off a manic episode that could lead to worse depression.
The idea sounds good, but is wrong [with qualifications]; and the drugs used to "treat" it can be nasty.
I tried them, briefly, as a result of an incorrect diagnosis. They had the effect of seriously "zombifying" me. I stopped taking them, and immediately felt much better again. They may work well and be appropriate for some people, but certainly not for as many people who are getting prescriptions for them. It's another big pharma scam.
If the kid is being given any such drugs, I would tend to be more tolerant, because it's possibile that psychiatric drugs are partially responsible.
04:28 PM on 11/02/2011
If the attacker really did suffer from mental illness, his cousin would have jumped in to save both of the boys from getting hurt. If he wasn't strong enough to do so, he would have screamed for help. Instead, he chose to record the beating with his cell phone and post it on Facebook for all the world to admire. This whole thing sounds premeditated.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
practiceempathy
Tolerance need not yield to willful ignorance.
11:35 AM on 11/02/2011
I'd like all the trolls who routinely come to this site to degrade gay people and to express their anti-gay animus, to sit through this video and know that they are contributors to this sort of social barbarism. They fuel it. They know it. They refuse to own it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
practiceempathy
Tolerance need not yield to willful ignorance.
11:25 AM on 11/02/2011
"kids will be kids"

This is itself bullying. It's complicity in the phenomenon. It's adults who were once bullies passing on the tradition.
06:50 PM on 11/01/2011
Three days! What about jail!!
02:12 PM on 11/23/2011
It should be aggravated battery or something like that. If I did anything like that I would get at least a year in jail for it in this state.
photo
suburbanmom
Liberal Midwest Mom and RN
07:12 PM on 10/31/2011
As the mother of a gay teen, I sent this school an email (posted elsewhere) regarding my concern. This is the response I recieved. It is not enough.
"Dear Suburbanmom, Thank you for your concern. I assure you that this is type of behavior is not acceptable or tolerated in our high school. The great things that take place at UHS far out number incidents such as this one. Unfortunately Unioto has become the target of a media blitz which did not contain all of the facts and at times seem to conveythe message that we tolerate these acts of violence. Yes the fight did take place at UHS and the administration responded at the time, with the facts given, according to our code of conduct. When we learned that a video of the fight had been placed on Facebook and remarks were made in regards to the gay gender, we immediately searched for the video and was able to obtain a copy. We were not able to meet with the student who iniated the fight until recently due to his absence from school. Although I cannot discuss the discipline with you, I can tell you that it has been revisited and further disciplinary measures have been taken. Unfortunately for UHS, the social media will not know this or all the other great things that take place at UHS.
Wilma Gillott
Asst. High School Principal/Curriculum Director
Union Scioto Schools "
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dale720240
11:04 PM on 10/31/2011
Pretty bad. First of all Wilma should recognize that this was not a fight. This was an attack. Second this has nothing to do with "the gay gender." (This shows she's totally clueless--being gay is not a "gender"; "we immediately searched...and was..." Geez, maybe Wilma should sit in on Freshman English). Third, she should page through the comments after related stories on the local Chillicothe paper website. Rightly or wrongly, the public is under the impression that "fights" are tolerated at UHS as regular events in the life of the school--"kids will be kids" according to the principal--until someone gets seriously hurt or decides life is not worth living.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
practiceempathy
Tolerance need not yield to willful ignorance.
11:23 AM on 11/02/2011
Good for you, suburbanmom.

Um.

What the heck?

"and remarks were made in regards to the gay gender"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dennybop
My micro-bio is empty
05:21 PM on 10/31/2011
I wonder if this kid "zoned out" before or after he decided to lay in waiting for his victim. It's a poor excuse and one even his parents probably don't believe. The law doesn't recognize this as mental illness or "zoning out". They call it "premeditation".
thewirah
In the time of chimpanzees I was a monkey
08:59 AM on 12/02/2011
Charles Manson also zoned out, no big deal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dennybop
My micro-bio is empty
05:06 PM on 10/31/2011
It's been established that Ohio lacks the ability to charge the accused with a "hate crime". So what?!!! Why hasn't this kid been charged with assault? I'm not convinced the attack wasn't at least partially based in homophobia. But it's clear that some form of bullying took place. Beating the tar out of someone would never be accepted in the adult world. It shouldn't be excused among teens.
02:51 PM on 10/31/2011
No one will speak up? Are we surprised after watching a video taken by the young man's cousin which shows him waiting for his victim and then making sure he got every brutalizing image. Not one student stepped up to intervene then. It is absurd for the school system to try asserting this was not a hate crime.
I suggest Superintendent Garrett, you start by saying this horrific event was mishandled and that this won't happen again because the safety of ALL student's is your first priority. Then you issue a public apology to this Mother and her son, and you state that the school board will publish SOP's on how to handle this type of crime.
Also Mr. Garrett since the perpetrator's cousin was complicit why wasn't this individual punished as well? As for the defense being used by the "Bully" of being mentally ill, I agree. My problem is the 3 day suspense or if he is charged with a crime being thrown in jail. I suggest a full med and psych work-up along with social services digging into his home life. Get him what he needs now or don't let him back into the school system. Our Gay Brother is going to be just fine, damn he already knows who he is and his Mom loves him and no one will silence her!
Mr Garrett start with a strong dose of Moral Ethics! I wish you good will and strength of character.
Peace.
Jackie
Teach1996@aol.com
01:58 PM on 10/31/2011
Sorry, we have to ultimately blame Christianity and that horrible bible they hold so sacred as it continues to justify this sort of thing.

Maybe the Mormons had the right idea, write your own bible.
02:29 PM on 10/31/2011
I would have faved you, but please let me assure you that the Mormons do NOT have "the right idea" - on ANYTHING to do with God's gay and lesbian children.
07:34 AM on 10/31/2011
I think they should send in a contingent of gay "Navy Seals" to help with the interrogation and dealing with the kids who are bullies in the school.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tim Flannery
My Micro Bio is Empty!
03:05 PM on 11/07/2011
JoeBoy... Dykes on Bykes would be happy to fullfill your request.. I'm sure!
photo
yorktown1979
I don't get no respect!
06:21 AM on 10/31/2011
Obviously Ohio's Prosecutors are worthless as they have failed to do their job thus far.
08:00 PM on 11/14/2011
Agreed, but the mother could insist that assult charges be brought against the attacker.

Worse though, I imagine authorities would only act if something much more serious would have happened to Zach. All it takes is a blow to the head, or a fall to the ground...

"Boys will be boys" except not all boys fight nor are all boys taught to fight by thier parents.
01:36 AM on 10/31/2011
i really have a hard time believing the attackers storyt, i mean even if it was a hate crime against a gay student.. the attacker said he zoned out?? i mean really, if he zoned out after being bumped, wouldnt he have beat the kids like right after he got bumbed, in the hallways.. but instead he waits for him in a classroom befgore he beats him.. that doesnt sound like he zoned out. and a 3 day suspension is really not enough i mean come one, people get suspended for a week for doing less then what this kid did.
08:00 PM on 11/14/2011
Where is the arrest for assult?