More

Foster Students: Half Do Not Finish High School, Nearly All Don't Finish College

Foster Graduation

KELLI KENNEDY   10/31/11 04:54 PM ET   AP

When Carey Sommer entered foster care in California, he left his mom, his high school and his friends. Bounced from home to home, he changed high schools nine times until the disheartened teen finally dropped out.

"I just started to not really care about high school because I figured I'm just going to move anyway – why does it matter?" said Sommer, who was told it would take an extra year and a half to graduate to make up for credits he lost changing schools.

Sommer, 19, is among the roughly 50 percent of the nation's 500,000 foster kids who won't graduate from high school, experts say.

Nearly 94 percent of those that do make it through high school do not finish college, according to a 2010 study from Chapin Hall, the University of Chicago's research arm.

Some members of Congress and advocates are trying to strengthen laws to ensure the child welfare system not only makes sure that foster kids are safe, but that they get a quality education.

"Schools are often the most important source of focus and stability for children in foster care," said a letter from federal agencies responsible for education and child welfare to state officials as classes were starting this fall.

The letter advised officials of a 2008 law that requires the children to remain at the same school after they are placed in a new foster home. It is routinely ignored by state and local officials who say it's impractical and too expensive. The law, however, lacks any penalties.

Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., proposed a bill to strengthen the measure and include education officials, in addition to their child welfare counterparts. The bill passed in committee with bipartisan support and is awaiting Senate approval.

At a town hall in October, Sens. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, and Mary Landrieu, D-La., who co-chair the Senate Caucus on Foster Youth, stressed that officials should ensure that foster children succeed academically, just as any parent would make sure their child excels at school.

"Many of these children are strong, resilient, smart and hard-working, but we treat them as if they're broken, and that's a problem. We have to give them an opportunity to be in a stronger setting," Landrieu said.

The departments of Education and Health and Human Services will meet with state officials in November to discuss practical ways to implement the law. Among the hurdles that Grassley said that officials around the country face is trying to cut through bureaucracy between two federal agencies, the state and local governments.

Around the country, small-scale efforts are already taking root.

Teacher Mike Jones took over his high school's discipline program in Sacramento, Calif., and noticed foster children made up the majority of suspended and expelled students. Jones started a monthly luncheon, where they could talk about their struggles.

Since the program started, grade-point averages have risen and discipline issues dropped. The Courageous Connections program has expanded to several schools and nearly 100 foster students meet in various small groups a few times a month. All 30 seniors in the program in the past four years graduated.

Sacramento officials also spent more than $1 million developing a software program so that education and child welfare officials in more than 20 counties in California can share attendance, grades and other records.

Trish Kennedy, director of foster youth services for the Sacramento County Office of Education, said there were many instances in which a child was improperly placed in courses because the student's transcripts did not keep up with their moves.

Kennedy's office offered the software to other states for free. So far, none has taken it.

In Orange, Mass., the school district hired a liaison to meet with foster parents. For a few years, the low-income district used grant money to keep foster kids in their original schools, but eventually had to pay the bill itself – about $25,000 a year – and had to stop.

It was especially difficult figuring out how to transport foster kids who had just come into the system and were staying in temporary placements or emergency shelters.

"We were almost like robbing another program to try to keep these kids in our school district," said Paul Burnim, who was then the district superintendent. "I don't think we give school personnel or kids the chance. The resources aren't there. It's expensive, but it's more expensive to ignore it."

Federal officials say states have the flexibility to use foster care grant money to cover such transportation costs.

Florida child welfare officials are in the early stages of "Everybody's a Teacher," an initiative uniting school and child welfare officials with community leaders.

Our Kids, which oversees more than 3,800 Miami-area foster kids, hired three guidance counselors to work in the schools to make sure they are staying on track. They developed a video conference system so the children could attend court hearings without missing school.

In Baltimore, Molly McGrath, director of the city's Department of Social Services, which has 4,000 foster kids, recently paid for a group of high school foster students to visit college campuses. But McGrath said colleagues scolded her, saying she was wasting money sending foster kids to visit colleges they wouldn't get into.

"The general societal expectation is very, very low," she said. "There should be expectation that they're going to graduate and going to college and succeed. That shouldn't be such an oddity."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

When Carey Sommer entered foster care in California, he left his mom, his high school and his friends. Bounced from home to home, he changed high schools nine times until the disheartened teen finally...
When Carey Sommer entered foster care in California, he left his mom, his high school and his friends. Bounced from home to home, he changed high schools nine times until the disheartened teen finally...
Filed by Emmeline Zhao  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 59
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vobox3343
Each day is a new day - make the most of it
03:50 PM on 11/02/2011
Feeling un-loved has its consequences.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sunnybunny
01:59 PM on 11/02/2011
If they take these kids away from their parents they are responsible for properly caring for them. That would include making sure they go to school until they graduate high school if that takes walking them to each of their classes. As a parent that is what I would think would be the lengths I would go to to insure my child went to school. I don't think it's too much to ask of state care.
11:30 AM on 11/02/2011
Kids are not always seperated from families under clearcut circumstances and are not always better off in the system than they might have been at home. It is especially scary that kids taken from their families can be handed over to people with ideological, religious, financial (or worse) reasons for seeking out access to children.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
broui
No d#%& cat. No d#%& cradle.
08:56 AM on 11/02/2011
My wife are fostering to adopt. Our new son came into our home Friday.

His story is tragic thus far. He was adopted by his aunt at 9 months weighing 7 pounds. Let that sink in. Then, when he hits the 3rd grade, she decides she didn't "bond" with him and puts him up for adoption. Another family thinks they'll adopt him and keeps him for 6 months. But, they too don't "bond" with him. He's back in the system. Another family has him for 4 months. No "bonding" occurs and he's back in the system.

He's now been diagnosed in the 5th grade with PTSD. He has lice. He's malnourished. He's behind in his academic skills...

But, he's a great kid. He simply wants to be in a home where he's wanted. We haven't had the adoption conversation because we're going slow with him on that given the past he's had.

Who tries kids on like clothes only to take them back when they don't fit?

Sick world. Sick world.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LisaCACO
someone ate my micro-bio!
12:00 PM on 11/02/2011
we're also planning to foster adopt. I can't imagine trading a kid in like a car, exchanging him/her for a newer model. each "return" does such damage-wishing your child all the best. so glad he has a warm, loving home now.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FiredUpRTG
Don't start no stuff; won't be no stuff…
06:21 PM on 11/01/2011
As kids, foster children need counseling to build self-esteem and confidence. But most people don't think it's necessary as long as the foster parents are treating the children well. It should continue through college and into the first years of employment as adults.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LisaCACO
someone ate my micro-bio!
12:02 PM on 11/02/2011
and funding. I have to say that being dumped out into the cold cruel world with no family and no money at the age of 18 or 21 is just unbelievable. Think about all the kids who live at home in their 20s, and imagine your child having no place to go. it's just beyond a shame.
05:13 PM on 11/01/2011
I was a member of a local CDC. We discovered that there was NO transition information pertaining to living on your own. Most foster parents "kick" the foster child "out" when the foster are funds stop. These young people have been told where to live, what to do. They do not know how to interview for a job, balance a checkbook, etc. We started a transitional housing program for these young adults by building 4 homes each with 4 bedrooms, kitchen with seperate cabinets, and a laundry room. They can stay up to 2-years, rent was about $40.00 per month and the rest is paid by a corporate sponser. A councilor available for 1-person or a group to discuss problems and expectations of a resposible adult for "the outside world of a foster child". Many come from this program successfully, others break the house rules and eventually are released on their own. We did not soliciate these young adults. Brochures are sent out and only those that respond on their own.; These usually go back to finish high school or get a GED, whichThat is usually one of the first accomplishments they do on their own, by their own choice and that really adds pride to their life and helps to maintain a positive mental attitude. This program is in its 5th year, We need these young adults to become responsible citizens and this is one way we could contribute positively to their future.
photo
reviewingthesituation
Southern liberal feminist
04:43 PM on 11/01/2011
Shuffled around like battered suitcases: how are they supposed to focus on academics?

Some family members of mine have to take "foster parent" classes in prep for adoption. prospective foster parents are repeatedly told not to get "too attached" because the goal of foster care is to return the children to the parents. Exasperated, family member asked speaker: If past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior, how can you have the goal of sending these kids back to homes where they were neglected or abused?

He was met only with a hostile silence and a repetition of the original goal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LisaCACO
someone ate my micro-bio!
12:05 PM on 11/02/2011
i've taken classes here in colorado and while you're the foster parent, the child's parents are also taking classes, getting help and being monitored. the goal is that with education and help, they can change their behavior, get off drugs, whatever. if it works, the child is returned home. if it doesn't, the child is adopted out. in my state, the goal is no more than a year of foster care before a decision is made.
photo
reviewingthesituation
Southern liberal feminist
12:56 PM on 11/02/2011
More reasonable, surely, but shouldn't the goal be the well-being of the child, period?

What happens if the parents skip those behavior-modification classes? Are parental rights automatically terminated?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sunnybunny
02:12 PM on 11/02/2011
Not all children that are taken from their homes are taken because of neglect or abuse. There are many circumstances that may lead to a child being placed in foster care and it is usually better for the child if you respect their relationship with their parents regardless. I don't think that has to mean not letting yourself become attached. You can love a child and not have to feel like it is "your" child.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:32 PM on 11/01/2011
I grew up in foster care - 7 different foster homes between the ages of 7 and 19. I used to be a single mother on welfare. But I put myself through college and law school on a combination of Pell Grants, scholarships and student loans. It wasn't easy; in fact there were times I almost gave up. When I was released from foster care at the age of 19, I had no family, no money and only a high school education. They give you nothing - just throw you out there into the world. A couple of the foster families were abusive, some were kind, some tried to instill a sense that I could accomplish something. Bouncing around from home to home and school to school is awful; I have no long-term friendships. You can overcome it, but it does leave permanent scars - depression, PTSD and other medical problems. Difficulty forming attachments. I have now been practicing law for 23 years. I'm one of the ones who made it, but I am in the minority and I know why.
photo
reviewingthesituation
Southern liberal feminist
04:43 PM on 11/01/2011
You just became one of my heroes.
12:37 AM on 11/02/2011
Awesome. I'm proud of you. As someone who was in foster care since the age of 10, I can relate. I found the best way to deal with all the negatives of a broken home was to never assign blame, unless it belongs to me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kmchafin
02:19 PM on 11/01/2011
Cal,

Foster Care IS a political issue and each state treats foster children somewhat differently. I have had 4 kids from another state, so I dealt with the foster programs in 2 states for about 17 years. I can say that foster care is WORSE then it was in the 90's. and continues to decline.

As far as high school for foster kids there are a few issues not recognized or dealt with:
1) Mental Illness. These children have all sor5ts of uissues such as depression, PTSD or fetal alcohol effect, etc. Trying to get mental health services for foster kids is a nightmare and what you do get is unqualified to treat kids from that background
2) These kids need MORE time in the system due to their issues ut the states try to push them into "Independent Living" to get them off thier records...The result is kids with no diploma and homeless
3) These kids ARE broken in a sense and they need much much more then a nice bed to sleep in. I had one son who graduated college at age 17, genius level, yet far below his capabilities as he was fighting depression The stories of his earlier life would curl the hair of a war vet

We should be ashamed but then it would take a real conscience to feel shame, wouldn't it
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cindy Bloom
All I want is fairness 4 all, is that a bad thing?
02:05 PM on 11/01/2011
I know a couple of families who raised many foster kids. Despite noble efforts, many of them did not graduate from high school. While some ended up in jail or pregnant, some of them became self-sufficient and independent adults (after getting their GED). Nature versus nurture? The bottom line is that they're children, and they need all the loving and financial support society can provide. On one hand Republicans want to defund programs to help these kids. Then, on the other hand they want to make all abortions illegal, thus creating even more unwanted children in society.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:46 PM on 11/01/2011
Shame on you that post here trying to make this a political issue.
photo
reviewingthesituation
Southern liberal feminist
04:46 PM on 11/01/2011
Cindy Bloom didn't make it political. It is political because the money to care for these children comes from taxes. Now do you get it?
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
broui
No d#%& cat. No d#%& cradle.
08:59 AM on 11/02/2011
It is political. Maybe not left/right, maybe it is.

One of the first things cut everytime is social services.

As foster parent, I can tell you that this area is grossly understaffed and underfunded. That didn't happen by magic.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:37 PM on 11/01/2011
You mean to tell me that the youth who come from wildly unstable families do not perform as well as those who do? You're telling me foster care can be less than ideal ? What next? The earth isn't flat?
VA Jill
Retired RN, Army mom. Bring the troops home!
11:29 AM on 11/01/2011
I don't know why, given the state of the foster care system, this should surprise anyone. I suppose it would be too much to hope that the system would at least ATTEMPT to give the kids some stability instead of shuffling them around from home to home like so many dominoes. Not to mention kicking them out when they turn 18, whether they've finished high school or not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frdafury
There's no kill switch on awesome!
04:00 AM on 11/01/2011
"Many of these children are strong, resilient, smart and hard-working, but we treat them as if they're broken, and that's a problem. We have to give them an opportunity to be in a stronger setting," Landrieu said.

Isn't it the parents that are broken and that is why these children are in Foster Care in the first place? I find it incredibly troubling that we blame the blameless in this instance and make them take the punishment that should be shouldered by the parents. Unfortunately that isn't the case. The kids are looked at as being broken or at fault and treated accordingly. They are the victims here.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:51 AM on 11/01/2011
continued:

I don't understand why more states are not using that program to help share student records quickly. Our Kids sounds like another program that was well thought out and works for the students.

All students need visions for their future. Adults are supposed to be mentors to children and help them see what is possible, without assuming they know what the child's future will be. Everyone has dreams and hopes for their lives and no one should ever say "this isn't for you" based on someone's place in life. Many things are possible. Students need to know they should work for their dreams, but need to set goals to reach and continue to dream and plan for what they want in life.