iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Swapping Tail Pipes For Pedals: Small Changes Could Pay Huge Dividends For Public Health And Economy

Urban Biking

First Posted: 11/02/11 02:10 PM ET Updated: 11/02/11 02:48 PM ET

Like a growing number of Americans, Jonathan Patz rides his bike to work. He even drags a wheeled blue bin behind his bike for trips to the grocery store. Sure, this environmental scientist naturally wants to do his part to preserve the planet's future, but his motivation is also personal: He knows his wallet, waistline, heart, lungs and neighbors will benefit today.

"If we were to think about reducing greenhouse gases to solve the global warming problem, we could have some immediate major health benefits," says Patz, director of the Global Health Institute at the University of Wisconsin, Madison, and lead author of a new study highlighting the "four-way win" that comes with swapping cars for bikes: reduced greenhouse emissions and gains in air quality, fitness and the economy. Patz is also a professor in Madison's Nelson Institute and Department of Population Health Sciences.

In the study, published today in Environmental Health Perspectives, Patz and his colleagues looked to the more than 30 million people residing in urban and suburban areas of Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio and Wisconsin. They asked: What if during the nicest six months of the year, those residents left their cars at home for round-trips of five miles or less? And what if they chose to replace half of those short car trips, which account for about 20 percent of all vehicle miles traveled, with cycling? According to their calculations, making those short trips on bicycles could save approximately four trillion pounds of carbon dioxide emissions, 1,100 lives and $7 billion in mortality and health care costs for the region every year.

"Fighting global climate change could be one of the greatest public health opportunities we've had in a century," Patz told Dalai Lama Tenzin Gyatso last month in the Tibetan leader's home in Dharamsala, India.

"This is where I look to your wisdom and writing," he added. "Everything starts with the individual -- we start with ourselves."

"Wonderful," Dalai Lama replied, bowing his head to Patz. "Wonderful. Very good."

Michael Brauer likes the idea, too. Every day, he rides his bike to The University of British Columbia in Vancouver, where he is a professor of population and public health. He chooses to pedal partly for the physical activity and partly because he simply enjoys it more than driving.

But not all cities are as bike-friendly as Vancouver or Madison, the latter having earned the League of American Bicyclists' "gold-certification." And then there's "platinum" Boulder, Colo., where Brauer claims you can "cycle through the city without coming into contact with cars."

He suggests the benchmarks used in the study are "aspirational" but not realistic, at least not in the short term. "Many people cannot get anywhere even if they want to by choosing to walk or cycle for short trips," says Brauer. Neighborhoods are simply not designed that way: Roads may not be connected or amenities may be too far from residences.

Brauer also notes that the new study does not account for the air pollution risks and physical hazards bikers face on urban roads. Still, that doesn't deter him from biking. The benefits far outweigh the costs, he tells HuffPost. (Researchers in Holland calculated the benefit-to-cost ratio at nine-to-one.)

Further, Brauer suggests that any health trade-offs could easily be eliminated by separating bike lanes from busy car thoroughfares, as is currently being done in Manhattan. Even better, designating every second street exclusively for cars or bikes would simultaneously address the air pollution issue.

"It doesn't have to be fancy or complicated," he says. Or expensive: Considering the money that could be saved, urban biking can even make good economic sense. "Think about the costs of the way our cities and transportation networks are designed now," says Brauer. "If you made some changes to reduce the related health costs, that money could be used to pay for better infrastructure." Bike-friendly additions might include share programs and additional bike racks on buses and curbside.

European nations have been pursuing similar changes for decades, with promising successes.

Patz suggests that the behavioral changes reflected in his study -- even if implemented solely in the upper Midwest -- would be equivalent to bringing the entire country in alignment with the national ozone standard. As it turns out, a large fraction of dirty emissions come out of the tailpipe within the first few minutes of starting a car. Cutting short trips therefore provides a disproportionately large reduction in particulate matter and other dangerous pollution.

Patz points to a natural case study: the 1996 Summer Olympics in Atlanta. During the games, the city experienced a 23 percent reduction in morning traffic, a 28 percent drop in peak levels of ozone pollution and 42 percent fewer emergency room visits from children suffering asthma attacks.

"And any improvement in air quality benefits the entire population, so in aggregate the public health benefits of even relatively small improvements can be large," adds Brauer. "These health costs and benefits clearly should be incorporated into transportation infrastructure planning."

"We need to make our cities not just built for automobiles," Patz says, "but built for people."

Related On The Huffington Post:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST HEALTHY LIVING

Like a growing number of Americans, Jonathan Patz rides his bike to work. He even drags a wheeled blue bin behind his bike for trips to the grocery store. Sure, this environmental scientist naturally ...
Like a growing number of Americans, Jonathan Patz rides his bike to work. He even drags a wheeled blue bin behind his bike for trips to the grocery store. Sure, this environmental scientist naturally ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 160
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jachavez
02:34 PM on 11/11/2011
Good article. Can't help but wonder what it'd be like if the entire world made that kind of change.
http://realesttalkblog.blogspot.com
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:20 PM on 11/06/2011
In the Honolulu library there is a great book about building sustainable cities, including designs for people friendly streets, sidewalks, and bike trails. Unfortunately, no one at Honolulu Hale (city hall) seems ever to have read it. There are only a few lanes and they are poorly designed and seldom used, this in a city where it is possible to ride 365 days a year. What we need is for bike riders, pedestrians, and other intelligent life forms to get together and form a political coalition that can make real change.

The suburbs are the worst idea that America ever had. Once we committed to building them we committed to building millions of miles of roadway, devoid of bike lines, sidewalks, or any amenities that might make life there worth living. The next generation needs to take a long hard look at what kind of world it wants to live in and then make the political changes at the local and state level that it will take to do what needs to be done. Good luck.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:45 PM on 11/06/2011
Every time I visited Oahu from my island, Hawaii, I found the roads overcrowded and a mess. I hated going there.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:00 PM on 11/06/2011
I know, awful, isn't it? I came here from Alaska. There are more people in Honolulu than the entire state of Alaska and I think half of them are on the roads at any given time.

It may be illegal to ride bikes on the sidewalk here but it is suicide to ride them in the street.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gottlieb
hated by left since 1973 and right since 1982
03:06 PM on 11/06/2011
I walk since I don't have the balancing skills for a bike but I agree with the author. I am biased toward walking but I am happy to share the sidewalks with bicyclists since the streets are not safe. Here in Portland, Oregon; "50% of neighborhoods have people living within a half mile of sidewalk-accessible grocery stores, schools, parks and transit." The Portland Plan proposed by 1000 Friends of Oregon has a goal of 90% by 2035. http://www.friends.org/latest/draft-portland-plan-released-public I think we need to be aware of the demographics of our aging population, riding a bike will not be an option to more and more of the population. Walking is also great exercise and leads to better health without the need for petroleum to make bicycle tires. Portland pedestrians and bicyclists are united in creating alternatives to get people out of their cars, separating cars from bicycles for safety, and smart street design for all users. Portland is ranked 7th nationally for attracting young adult immigration which our bike friendly policies contributes to. Using a bicycle for personal transportation is not just healthy but makes economic development sense. Bicycles are also much less dangerous to pedestrians than cars.
09:17 AM on 11/06/2011
My daughter lives in Philadelphia and does not own a car. She mostly uses her bicycle but she has had at least three accidents that I know of, one a hit and run, and two drivers opening their doors without looking to see if a bicycle is coming. Bike lanes and streets dedicated to bicycles would be great. In this economy especially, many young people in cities cannot afford cars and public transportation is not as efficient as the bicycle. The young people like my daughter are not deterred by snow or rain either.
09:12 AM on 11/06/2011
The secondary author of this study is the son-in-law of a close friend of mine :)
10:10 PM on 11/03/2011
In the same vein, I'm also concerned about why no one knows about those great car substitutes they are inventing on three-wheeled motorcycle platforms called "Trikes." If you don't have to mix with big cars and trucks, you can go anywhere in them just as you would in a car. They get about 100 mpg and some are being modified as hybrids getting close to 200 mpg. My favorites are the XR3, Aptera, and Tango (George Clooney has one and looks great in it.)

I wish the news outlets would publicize these alternative transportation vecicles. We need to have mainstream public awareness of these options or we'll never meet our lower energy goals.
10:16 PM on 11/03/2011
Please, media outlets:

Start writing and publishing articles about these things every day and put them in with the regular news so everyone knows about them and starts asking for them. It's the only way we're going to lower our fossil fuel consumption. You are the only ones with the power to kickstart this conversion.
10:50 PM on 11/03/2011
Oops! The Tango is actually a very narrow 2 seater, 4 wheeled, electric vehicle, but it represents another kind of vehicle that the mainstream public knows nothing about. We need to see articles about these options on a regular basis to get the word out to everyone.
10:07 PM on 11/03/2011
I'm also baffled at why I can't find a pedal vechicle that has a rain cover. It started raining the last time I rode my bike. I had to rush home, being blinded by the raid all the way. Whenever I see people in other countries in their down town area, they have all sorts of clever bikes with canopies, extra seats, etc. They can't afford cars and have modified thier bikes in many versatile ways to get the maximum use out of them. In the USA, it's very black and white. Use a car or the standard two-wheeled bike. I found a three-wheeled bike, but the selection was sparse. There wasn't anything available that had a roof or windshield to keep the rain off. Without them, you're really limited in how much use you can get out of your bike. We need to have more options available to us so we can use our bikes for daily chores on a regular basis. Otherwise, they're limited to short-term, recreational use on the weekends.
01:57 AM on 11/04/2011
z, You may want to consider recumbents if this is an important issue for you. I have seen canopy rigs on a few and I believe that windshields are often sold as standard aftermarket equipment. Keep in mind that any type of canopy will act as sail, which is NOT something you want on a bicycle. Personally I find recumbents just as easy to ride, but not as safe because you can't see as far, or be as visible because of the low profile. What you really need to do is purchase a decent rain suit and goggles (cheap clear safety goggles work, but can fog up) from REI, Performance Cycles, or some other internet vendor. Remember that motorcyclists ride in the rain all the time and they are going much faster! Mostly you're going to have to toughen up a bit, but you can get used to it once you get in shape.
09:59 PM on 11/03/2011
Getting around my town on a bike is pretty easy. The problem we have is that our town is geographically separated from the surrounding towns with no way to get to the next town unless we take a very busy highway or a desolate back road - neither have a bike lane. There is a very limited amount of shopping and activities in this town creating a need to go the next town for most things. It can't be done on a bike without risking your life. The problem here seems to be a lack of initiative to cooperate with the next town on creating safe bike paths between the two towns. It's as if no one here cares about this. We need to change our culture on a national scale to include bicycling as a normal mode of transportation between towns, as well in-town.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DonVitoCorleone
Autodidact, and proud of it!
09:46 PM on 11/03/2011
There are rumors in Wisconsin that our illustrious governor wants to change the state motto from "forward" to "backward." As part of his agenda, he eliminated every dime going to bike paths and related activities from the state transportation budget. In one fell swoop we went from state government that aggressively promoted bicycling to one that aggressively discourages cycling. We even have an repub assemblyman who wanted to pass state laws that would reverse some of Madison's bike laws such as "red boxes." Fortunately, cities like Madison, LaCrosse, and Milwaukee have bucked this trend, and when we can recall our governor we can hopefully get common sense back on track.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DonVitoCorleone
Autodidact, and proud of it!
09:30 PM on 11/03/2011
It seems there are a couple of interesting threads here....

1. Bikers are unsafe inconsiderate idiots that endanger driver's safety.
2. Drivers are unsafe inconsiderate idiots that endanger biker's safety.

Use common sense, follow the rules of the road and give each other a break. As both a biker and driver I try to be live by this rule. I also work at a university where pedestrians, bikers, inexperienced young drivers, skateboarders, motorized wheelchairs and even a segway or two fly around like they're the only ones on the road/sidewalk/crosswalk. You don't have to like it but you have to do everything you can to avoid a confrontation or accident. Its just part of life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:59 PM on 11/03/2011
I am not at all a biker but drivers are mostly unsafe, inconsiderate idiots that endanger EVERYONE'S safety. I believe that the requirements to get one's license in America are way too loose. Other driver's terrify me no matter how I'm using the same road. I'm not a perfect driver myself, but I seem to be one of the few who is aware of the fact that I'm driving a 2 ton death machine that can kill someone in seconds.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dutchman
Two wheels good; four wheels bad.
08:53 PM on 11/03/2011
It's like my micro-bio says......
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
08:02 PM on 11/03/2011
I like the part about separating bikes from cars. Wouldn't be so hard to do through a serious national trail network. But nooooo...
02:11 AM on 11/04/2011
art, There really are A LOT of trails around the country. NYC , DC, and Pittsburgh to name a few have incredible separate from highway trail systems around them. You can actually ride from Pittsburgh to DC and not once share a road with cars! Get it out of your mind that there is going to be a "national" trail system. Trails are something that cyclists can work on locally and actually get results. But people have to actually cycle in the community to make it look worthwhile. Incidentally, people do cycle across the United States all the time. Check out Adventure Cycling if that is something you want to do.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
10:47 AM on 11/04/2011
Excellent information. I guess it wouldn't hurt to have a top down national *vision*, however, even if implementatiion is entirely local. By the way, I've often thought that if a national intercontinental highway system was conceived, it wouldn't be asking too much that there be a system of trails as well. :-)
06:32 PM on 11/03/2011
"But not all cities are as bike-friendly as Vancouver or Madison."

And not many drivers are friendly to bikers!

Design me a city where it doesn't take me 30-45 minutes to DRIVE to work and I will gladly ride a bike. Sadly, this won't happen anytime soon. Best bet is for the car manufactures to go full steam ahead with electric and/or hydrogen cars, then everything's a win win with no major reconstruction/design required.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
08:03 PM on 11/03/2011
You forgot the exercise part. :-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
silverwolf13
I know that I do not know.
10:44 PM on 11/12/2011
There are plenty of CITIES that meet that criterion. If you live in the outer burbs, that's another matter.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Repubnomore
11:36 AM on 11/03/2011
There's an interesting commentary on this and another Chicago-related Huffpost cycling story on the front page of Chicago Now.

http://www.chicagonow.com/easy-as-riding-a-bike/2011/11/cycling-scofflaws/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LauraBethT
11:05 AM on 11/03/2011
Just make sure they follow the rules of the road. Twice on my 20 minute drive to work this morning I had cyclists fly past me at stop signs at busy intersections. Standard rules apply, stop means stop. They expect me to be considerate in my car, fine. But they need to extend the same courtesy and follow the rules too.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ThePeoriaKid
"I've Got Morons On my Team.."
01:09 PM on 11/03/2011
Funny, I was thinking the same of the cars that intentionally crowd me to the curb.

The only rules they seem to follow are the laws of physics...
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
08:06 PM on 11/03/2011
With a comprehensive, thought-out national trail network (an oxymoron, right?) cars and bikes would go on separate pathways.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MrBIgp
If I'm wrong, please show me
08:45 PM on 11/03/2011
My experience is that bicyclists are very inconsiderate of pedestrians. I've talked to many elderly people who are regularly frighted by bicyclists whizzing by them. I rarely see bicyclists stop for stop signs and I can't remember ever seeing a bicyclists stop for pedestrians in a cross walk - even though in California the same rules apply to bicyclists as do to cars.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LauraBethT
12:02 PM on 11/11/2011
My sister was walking today and was hit by someone on a bike. Lovely eh?