NYR More

How Libraries Are About More Than Books

Libraries

First Posted: 11/30/11 11:27 AM ET Updated: 11/30/11 03:53 PM ET

This is the third installment in our series 'Libraries in Crisis.' The opening piece, about how cuts threaten the public library, can be read here. For more from the series, visit our dedicated page.

MINNEAPOLIS -- These are complicated times for public libraries. Even as budgets are slashed nationwide, more people than ever are visiting their local library. Even as the unemployed seek out the quiet space and free Internet access, the group most attached to libraries remains working mothers, often accompanied by their children.

And, in case you hadn't heard, books aren't quite as popular as they used to be.

"So the question, and it's a huge question, is, 'What even is a library anymore?'" said Cesar Pelli, the world-renowned architect and designer of the Minneapolis Central Library.

While this large urban library has greater resources than many of its suburban and rural counterparts -- the building itself, which opened in 2006, cost some $138 million -- librarians across the country are looking to institutions such as this to show the way forward. For their part, the librarians here say their hope is that this library can be more of a cultural center than a book repository.

When visitors walk into the Minneapolis building, the first collection they see is about 300 computers, each of which is in use about 90 percent of the time. Nationwide, the number of physical books borrowed from libraries is slowly declining, although books remain a core reason why people visit their libraries. The staff in Minneapolis estimates that computer access is the primary reason that most patrons, especially low-income and unemployed people, visit.

2011-11-30-1103libraries.gif

But the library also offers English language classes in the New Americans Center. The teen room, designed with teen advice, has laptops for use in the library, a vending machine, and a sound system and CD collection. Elsewhere there's a soundproof piano room.

Betsy Williams, the coordinating librarian, says staffers are adapting to their new roles. They've been surprised by the intensity of computer use and have had to get used to answering more questions about Microsoft Word than about the library's book-search system.

They're also coming to terms with how many people seem eager to sit on the floor and use their own laptops.

"The shift to more mobile computing has us thinking about our use of space, and our library is only five years old," Williams added. "If people don't want to sit at a desktop, how can we accommodate them best? What can we offer to laptop users other than free Wi-Fi?"

Pelli, for his part, said he was looking forward when he designed the space. "Unquestionably the function of a library is changing very rapidly, and we knew that a decade ago," he said by phone. What the architects could do was to "keep the structure extremely flexible."

Literally it is. The air and electricity in the building is distributed under the floors, not through the inner walls. Without beams and other structural impediments, the rooms can be changed in a weekend. The local library system has made this kind of flexibility a requirement in its design standards for construction projects of all sizes.

Other library systems are taking similar approaches. In Fairfax County, Va., where budget cuts have forced hundreds of layoffs and the cancellation of magazine subscriptions, there is still money from bonds to pay for library construction. Edwin S. Clay III, the director of libraries since 1982, said that libraries have "never been more relevant," but that they are increasingly filling the voids left by other public institutions.

"We're becoming lots of folks' offices, especially as they look for work," Clay said. "We're not the school system, but we're focusing on childhood literacy. We're teaching people how to use computers. We're stepping up and saying, 'How can we help?'"


FOLLOW HUFFPOST BOOKS

This is the third installment in our series 'Libraries in Crisis.' The opening piece, about how cuts threaten the public library, can be read here. For more from the series, visit our dedicated page. ...
This is the third installment in our series 'Libraries in Crisis.' The opening piece, about how cuts threaten the public library, can be read here. For more from the series, visit our dedicated page. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 76
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:06 PM on 12/02/2011
Many of the libraries in Chicago have issues with homeless people, but then again, if you live in a huge city, it's expected that you'll run into homeless people. Because the libraries are free, homeless people often use them to stay away from the rain, heat, cold, etc. Unless they're coming at you with violence in mind, I don't know what the issue is - it's a public building and homeless people are part of the public. Regarding crime, rape, etc - homeless folks haven't cornered the market on crime.
I think libraries are very import to our society because it allows for all members of society, no matter what their economic status is, to access information, be it the Internet, reading, voting. Are they perfect? No, of course not - show me a system that's perfect, and I'll be sure to find some flaws in it, as well.
05:15 PM on 12/01/2011
I work in the library of a community college, and the students use books as frequently as they use internet resources.

One factor (I hate to say it) that has helped diminish the libraries reputation is the unionization of the employees. Now the employees are more concerned with themselves and their jobs and bennies than they are about public service and devotion to free access to knowledge. Detroit Public Library system is a classic example.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AndyWright68
Freedom is inevitable!
09:24 AM on 12/01/2011
Libraries ARE more than just books. They are institutions that fund computers, internet, coffee etc. through the use of violent threats against peaceful people and the theft of their hard earned money.

Refuse to pay the taxes that fund these socialist programs and armed thugs with badges will chain you up, kidnap you, lock you in a cage and steal your home and property. If people really want libraries then they will VOLUNTARILY fund them. If the people do not want them they will keep their hard earned money and use it to make a better life for their family or do whatever they want with THEIR money.

Theft and violence in wrong even when it is the government doing it.
11:53 AM on 12/04/2011
Fanned
09:23 AM on 12/01/2011
Bah! We don't need libraries. We have Barnes and Noble in every town, and Kinko's for internet access.
04:38 PM on 12/09/2011
I must not live in every town because there isn't a Barnes and Noble or a Kinko's. Thank goodness we have an awesome library.
09:15 AM on 12/01/2011
I think the public library is horrible and I will never set foot in one again. I fail to see why tax dollars are wasted on these institutions. They could charge lending fees for books (and now ebook). If people want free internet they should go to a cafe.

In my personal experience libraries (mostly urban ones) are nothing more than homeless shelters where homeless men look at porn and go to the bathroom on the floor. It also seems like a great place to be sexually assaulted especially if your a woman. Don't fall asleep in a public library because who knows what you may wake up to. I also wouldn't leave any child there unattended as it is most certainly not a safe place.

Libraries were not always like this and perhaps rural or suburban libraries are better. The modern urban library is a myth. It is a homeless shelter with pornography and all they do now is serve as a warehouse for the branch libraries.
09:39 AM on 12/01/2011
The library that I go to in DC does not allow homeless people (or any people) to be disruptive and I rarely see homeless people in there. If the librarians smell alcohol on anyone, that person is asked to leave. Although I've never seen anybody looking at porn, the thing that bothers me is that people are allowed to come in and watch youtube and play games when there are people there that actually need to use the computer to apply for jobs because they either don't have internet or they don't have Microsoft Office (me!). In addition, libraries are also a great place to print off stuff or make copies for a minimal fee as a cheaper alternative to kinkos. Libraries are a great resource for kids and they are sometimes a very important part of someone's daily job search. In addition, I love reading actual books and find that the library is a great place to borrow a book for a book club without having to buy it. I think maybe you should talk to someone in your community about your terrible libraries but the ones in DC seem fine to me. They're not perfect but they're not nearly as bad as you make them seem.
photo
colgan
Thanks M and D for raising me to think for myself
12:37 PM on 12/01/2011
If your library is as bad as you make it seem I shudder to think what your community is like.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
FreedToChoose
...excepting when I'm not.
09:13 AM on 12/01/2011
Our public library struggles for funding as do so many others.

Just a reminder: Most, maybe all, accept your unwanted books and media if they are in good shape and fit their mission. Cash is also welcome.

My reading has taken me to books beyond what the local libraries offer, but the ILL (Inter-Library Loan) program allows me to get everything I want at no charge, a service I appreciate and support with an appropriate donation.
09:11 AM on 12/01/2011
The Minneapolis Central Library smells like unwashed homeless people; it's just GROSS! I can't use the computers without gagging from the stench and my eyes water-up; it's a shame.
08:40 AM on 12/30/2011
Walk down the block to another one. Cross the river to Pierre Bottineau. Take the bus Uptown to Walker, jumpt he train to East Lake. The list goes on activate your card in St.Paul. DON'T HATE.
Don't take your privilege for granted.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Titus
Bourbon, no ice
08:14 AM on 12/01/2011
The public library is one of the greatest institutions in our country. It provides access to knowledge without regard to one's economic status. The idea of the library is one that should be cherished and supported because it is truly an example of democracy at its best. An informed society is a progressive and growing society. The library is one of the cornerstones of providing information to our citizenry that helps us grow.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mero909
None of our comments will matter anyway
09:19 AM on 12/01/2011
I agree, but information is changing shape and is being delivered in a more efficient way (not to mention saving more trees). Libraries may end up becoming just a place w/ rows of computers and free internet. Which is fine.
09:38 AM on 12/01/2011
I agree, information access has evolved. That said, I still enjoy pulling numerous books off the shelves to cross reference items. Mainly this is just a way to keep my mind sharp in my old age. Yes, I can click the mouse and go anywhere quickly to do this but I find I get too lazy. Guess I'm too old to move on, but hey, I'm HERE every morning getting my news updates.
11:39 AM on 12/01/2011
The library is and always has been about more than simply "information." Public libraries provide educational and recreational programming for every age level. They provide early literacy exposure to toddlers and pre-schoolers through story times; they provided bibliographic instruction and homework assistance to elementary school children; they provide information literacy instruction and assistance to adults. None of that can be replaced with "rows of computers and free Internet."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AndyWright68
Freedom is inevitable!
09:25 AM on 12/01/2011
And it is funded through theft and violent threats against peaceful people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Titus
Bourbon, no ice
09:39 AM on 12/01/2011
Really? how is that?
photo
colgan
Thanks M and D for raising me to think for myself
12:39 PM on 12/01/2011
Oh pu-leeze.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
07:59 AM on 12/01/2011
I would say public libraries are a close second to public schools in importance to society.

The mere fact that functional literacy is now the expected norm in this country speaks volumes. Knowledge IS power, and the whole point of this country is that the power should rest with the people. That's part of why Fox pisses me off so much - they go out of their way to misinform, and to keep their audience ignorant, and that's bad for democracy, and bad for this country.

A public library is where, for no cost at all, and a little patience, you can access ANY INFORMATION you need. Doubly so now that pretty much all of them have internet.
09:26 AM on 12/01/2011
1. Public libraries WERE important to society. Now they are homeless shelters with welfare services (at least the large urban ones.)
2. Power does rest with the people and education should be valued but is not. Liberals have trashed the education and library system in favor of social justice rather than actual learning and thus have irrecoverably harmed the political process.
3. Fox news does no more harm in telling their view of events than any other news group. If your issue with Fox is that they misinform rather than have a conservative POV, then you should be equally angry at all the networks, MSNBC, CNN, and almost every newspaper being published including the NYT. Since you only call out Fox and not the others my guess is that you do not like their POV and that you tolerate misinformation if it matches with your POV.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alteredstory
Hold on to the center
10:02 AM on 12/01/2011
Um. When was the last time YOU were in a library? I've been in two in the last two weeks, and you know what I saw? People reading books. People using the internet. People LEARNING.

Boston public library and Cambridge public library - can't exactly call those "rural".

You've got an imaginary image of what you THINK libraries are today, but you clearly don't have much experience using them (unless, apparently, you're homeless).

Fox lies about evolution, climate change, public opinion, and so on. They don't just report with a conservative point of view, they LIE.

I don't tolerate lying. In areas where I can check what they say against reality, they fail, and on a regular basis. It's not about my point of view, it's about physics, and ecology, and biology, and medicine - it's about measurable falsehoods on a regular basis.

You can have your point of view, but you don't get your own special set of facts. That falls under the category of denial of reality, and LYING.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AndyWright68
Freedom is inevitable!
09:27 AM on 12/01/2011
I would say public libraries are a close second to public schools in coercion, extortion, theft and threats of violence against peaceful people. They should all be closed down and if the people want them they will fund them voluntarily.
photo
beerbagger
12-pack of genius
06:37 AM on 12/01/2011
1. Denver Public Library needs to get it's act together and support Apple OS.

2. Libraries are amazing social-anthropological research facilities. The people watching is awesome.

3. Libraries could be a missing link in our education system. Why they are not geared more towards public early and continuing education is a tragedy. There are so many reasons why they need to be a central hub of public knowledge ranging from topic A-Z. We really need to get back to local!!!
07:32 AM on 12/01/2011
When public libraries were first developed in this country in the late 19th and early 20th century, they were specifically designed as "universities of the people." They did include recreation and information as part of their mission, but the primary focus was on education. They also served as centers of community activity. They held that role until the 1970s, more or less. In the 1990s, in order to remain "relevant," they shifted their focus to being "information institutions." When I graduated from library school in 1986, public libraries were offering career counseling services, English as a Second Language services, programming for seniors as well as children, citizenship services -- and a lot of that was dropped with the rush to try to become one of the big boys of "information." Big mistake and they are paying for it now.

While it's ludicrous to suggest that "everything in on the Internet" and that everyone is capable of finding valid and reliable information without assistance, the reality is that a lot of information is easily available online and that a large number of us can find effectively and efficiently from home. As you note, libraries really must return to their focus on self-education.
photo
beerbagger
12-pack of genius
07:45 AM on 12/01/2011
F&F!!!

My mother retired from psychology and later re-entered the workforce as a reference librarian at an inner city library. She definitely wasn't in it for the money. She gained so much pleasure from research and continuing to help people. One of her biggest complaints was that they seemed to also be a day care center for latch-key kids. It drove her bonkers that the director would not make an effort to engage or allow anyone to spark these kids imaginations. Then again she seemed to be too friendly in helping people track down books, journals, articles... stuff that libraries were starting to shun.

Many people, myself included like interacting with quasi-social librarians who also enjoy reading, thinking & expressing. Years ago a I discovered Kurt Vonnegut at the suggestion of young cute librarian... Google will never do that.
09:18 AM on 12/01/2011
Large public libraries are more like homeless shelters with welfare services. It is a shame.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
breakingpoint
War is a Racket - Smedley Butler
05:11 AM on 12/01/2011
the Internet should be a public utility - not for profit
09:17 AM on 12/01/2011
yea and I want a free house , food, electricity, heating, and cooling. I shouldn't have to pay for anything.
11:27 AM on 12/01/2011
Electricity is a public utility. So is water and natural gas. They are non-profit public utilities in most of the country. No one said "free."

Try again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mero909
None of our comments will matter anyway
09:21 AM on 12/01/2011
While I understand what you're getting at, I have to disagree. Who is going to pay for the tremendous cost of bandwidth usage? Internet as a "human right" is flawed due to this fact.
09:32 AM on 12/01/2011
Breakingpoint said "not for profit", not "free". That means users pay for what it costs to use, administer and upgrade.
06:05 PM on 11/30/2011
I'd like to see some actual proof that books aren't as popular.
photo
captainindustry
just a better con artist
05:52 AM on 12/01/2011
agreed. Look at Harry Potter.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mero909
None of our comments will matter anyway
09:21 AM on 12/01/2011
Ironically, I read the Harry Potter books as PDFs on my iPad. I never read them as paper-based books.
07:04 AM on 12/01/2011
Of course some books will always be very popular, but the info in books that was often accessed for reference study, can now be more easily accessed by computer. Also, as I get older, and my eye sight is not what it used to be, I rely heavily on books in a CD format that I can listen to in the car while traveling from one errand to another.

In addition, now that people have had to cut back on Netflix & Blockbuster, our local library is packed with families looking to check out movies & music albums for the weekends.

In my location, the stores are often empty, but the library is packed everyday.
GraceNotes
We live for books.
11:02 AM on 12/01/2011
We still need librarians to discern what is and is not valuable information. A teacher came into the library just this week. Her students were doing reports on the presidents. She commented that she had looked at Wikipedia, and her only complaint was that the entries were too long.
11:35 AM on 12/01/2011
But you are still using books. The content is what matters, not the format.