iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Undocumented Youth Lobby For Dream Act

Dream Act Protest

First Posted: 11/21/11 07:52 AM ET Updated: 11/21/11 10:38 AM ET

DALLAS, Texas -- Julieta Garibay, 31, has a master's degree in nursing. But Garibay, an undocumented immigrant who arrived from Mexico two decades ago, makes a living as a babysitter.

Like Garibay, Diego Sanchez arrived in the U.S. at a young age. Now he's student body president at a private university in Miami, where the scholarships he's earned for choir and cross country are helping him pay for college.

Paula Zapata, a 26-year-old Colombia native who uses a wheelchair because of a congenital condition, studied communications at the University of Houston. But Zapata, who like Garibay and Sanchez has long lived in the U.S. without documentation, has little chance of becoming a legal resident or U.S. citizen under current immigration laws, severely limiting her job projects and her rights in the country she's spent most of her life.

Now Zapata, Garibay and Sanchez are actively supporting the DREAM Act, which would grant legal status to members of the military and students who came to the country illegally at a young age.

The proposal, which was nearly approved by Congress at the end of last year and has now become a focal point in the national debate over immigration, would benefit around 2.1 million undocumented immigrants in the U.S., according to the Migration Policy Institute.

And throughout the country, young people have mobilized in support of the legislation.

Last weekend, Garibay, Sanchez and Zapata all attended the national congress of United We Dream, the largest organization of undocumented college students in the United States. Some 450 students from 28 states gathered at the event, held in Dallas, attending workshops and conferences on immigration, education, politics, leadership and civil rights. They also heard from undocumented workers and labor representatives.

Their backgrounds and accents differed, but many people at the conference were the exact type who could benefit from the legislation: Undocumented young people educated in the United States after being brought to the country by their parents. And many emphasized that they considered the U.S. their country.

At the event, some shared stories about their hardships. Others focused on their accomplishments in the U.S. They were among the best students in their states, a few said; they were presidents of student associations and admitted to some of the most prestigious colleges in the country.

Felipe Matos, a national committee member of United We Dream, said the organization planned to focus on more than just the DREAM legislation. Matos said the group is planning voter registration drives, and hopes to focus on comprehensive immigration reform and the recent surge in anti-immigrant sentiment.

Matos, who was born in Brazil, was voted best college student in Florida in 2008 by the American Association of Community Colleges. He participated in a march with three other so-called Dreamers from Miami to Washington, D.C. to raise awareness about undocumented students.

"We need to change ideas about us and inspire other youth to be more active," he said.

President Obama has expressed support for the act and immigration reform, and the administration recently announced a policy change that would spare many Dreamers from deportation as Homeland Security instead focuses its resources on deporting undocumented immigrants with criminal records.

According to the policy, the administration has also begun reviewing some 300,000 pending deportations to weed out the "low-priority" cases. Yet the administration's recently released deportation numbers showed the administration hasn't been slow to deport the undocumented tonight: Nearly 400,000 people were deported in fiscal year 2011, a record number, according to the filing.

Though the DREAM Act hasn't succeeded on the national stage, measures giving undocumented immigrants access to public colleges have passed in some states. For instance, Texas Gov. Rick Perry, now running for the Republican presidential nomination, signed a bill in 2001 that allowed undocumented immigrants who are Texas residents to obtain in-state tuition rates.

But those reforms don't affect the young immigrants' undocumented status.

Zapata, now 26, said her parents brought her to the U.S. when she was four.

"If I had legal papers, I would get help for my disability," said Zapata. "There needs to be a change in the ignorance over the situation of thousands of undocumented students, people should know the truth about this movement."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST LATINO VOICES

DALLAS, Texas -- Julieta Garibay, 31, has a master's degree in nursing. But Garibay, an undocumented immigrant who arrived from Mexico two decades ago, makes a living as a babysitter. Like Garibay...
DALLAS, Texas -- Julieta Garibay, 31, has a master's degree in nursing. But Garibay, an undocumented immigrant who arrived from Mexico two decades ago, makes a living as a babysitter. Like Garibay...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 823
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (8 total)
04:52 PM on 12/21/2011
I support the Dream Act. I believe that people who are brought to the US as children by their parents have done nothing wrong and should be given a chance to become productive, contributing members of society and the economy.

I'm married to my wonderful Swiss husband who went through the lengthy process to legally immigrate to the US and later on became a US citizen as well. I've also gone through the process of moving with him to Switzerland (admittedly a pretty easy process since I'm married to him) and even with all that I still believe that there are a lot of good, honest, hard working people out there who deserve a chance to have a decent life, no matter how they got to where they are.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:54 PM on 12/21/2011
If your husband went through the legal citizenship channels he should be disgusted by the DREAM Act. It undermines all of his time and effort.
photo
spytheweb
Black Democrat
08:45 PM on 12/21/2011
There are 6 billion 700 million non US citizens on the planet, do you believe they all should be given a right to come to America and live? I say hell no!

My wife is from Korea, she is now a US citizen, never has anyone from her family asked to have us sponsor any of them, we never even talked about it. The dream act is just another backdoor amnesty like the 14th amendment, which will some day be closed. These illegal alien students are citizens of another country that has it's own government and President.

Any amnesty will just flood the country with more illegals with no enforcement, where does it stop? Where does enforcement come in, when is enough, enough?
04:33 PM on 12/21/2011
Even Rick Perry has more compassion than a lot of the comments here. I feel like I'm in some weird twilight zone where the HuffPo has suddenly turned into Fox News...
photo
spytheweb
Black Democrat
08:49 PM on 12/21/2011
"weird twilight zone"? Because people want our laws enforced? What Bizzaro world do you live in? Look around, no country allows themselves to be overrun by illegal aliens.
06:24 PM on 02/05/2012
I support the Dream Act. People should stay here instead of going back to their country to process their papers. Some people don't have nowhere to go, no family to turn to and that alone would lead to suicide. There are so many illegal students who pay their college tuition in cash and hoping for a bright future. I think that it is the illegal aliens who are keeping this country going.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:55 PM on 11/23/2011
These gimme-grants tell their respective stories of hardship, but they can't be bothered with the hardship of legal immigration. They're not worthy of being in this country.
04:28 PM on 12/21/2011
Yeah, I'm sure most other 4 year olds are totally capable of going through the legal immigration process when their parents bring them into the US.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:37 PM on 12/21/2011
No excuse. Whether these people came here on their own or were brought be their parents, there is already a legal process for immigration. If they truly care about being Americans, that means they want to follow the laws. They may leave and get in line like everyone else and go through the established immigration channels. Anything else and they are just selfish, law-breaking leeches.
photo
spytheweb
Black Democrat
08:53 PM on 12/21/2011
"I'm sure most other 4 year olds are totally capable of going through the legal immigratio­n process"

Illegal aliens have a good use for their children, as pawns. Now they think hey my kids don't have to even be born in America to get the rights of a citizen, we can just drag them across the border and put them in any school and we're set. Fools like you support this.
12:49 PM on 11/23/2011
Mexico and similar countries have stricter immigration laws than we do and would put Americans in prison for being undocumented in their country. Their parents knew they were breaking the law. Hispanics have the highest dropout rate in HS than any other ethnicity based on 2008 statistics of 16-24 year olds.

Sad part is that for every good story (like these kids); there are three that prove we need stricter immigration laws!

I cannot see allowing the Dream Act to pass b/c (after all it's about education) in reality these kids are not the norm, but the minority.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Viper1st
multi quasi faceted
10:29 AM on 11/24/2011
It's okay with Mexican Nationals that their country, of their citizenship allegiances has stricter immigration laws than the USA ~ just that the USA does not.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2011/10/11/ap/latinamerica/main20118649.shtml

It's okay with Mexican Nationals that their country, of their citizenship allegiances is building a border fence on their borders ~ just that the USA does not

http://www.examiner.com/immigration-reform-in-national/hypocritical-mexico-is-now-building-their-own-wall-on-border-with-guatemala-press-ignores
11:24 AM on 11/25/2011
But they don't like it when America tries those exact same things. Remember what the Mexican President said about our immigration reform??
09:04 AM on 11/23/2011
Education = The Immigrant Dream??? Perhaps, but only immigrants from India and Senegal and Korea and China. The notion that Latinos, as a people place, an emphasis on academic achievement is laughable. Go to any school with a large percentage of Latino students and tell me what you see. What is the drop out rate among Hispanics? This is just another social service they soak up at the expense of the very few of us who still pay taxes. Nice job!!!
12:50 PM on 11/23/2011
Its a known fact Hispanics have the highest drop out rate of any ethnicity in the US! But they ignore that fact (or call me racist for saying it).
01:38 PM on 11/23/2011
pretty high attrition rate for federal grants also
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
01:28 PM on 11/22/2011
German Nazi vs Teabagger:
Bad economy: check - check
Scapegoat: Jews - "illegal Mexicans"
Deny education: check - check
Label: non-person - alien
Support for eugenics: check - check
Work within the realm of the existing law whenever possible: check - check
Germany for Germans - America for Americans
Using hate propaganda: check - check
Using racial hatred to come to power: check - check
Mass terror: ICE - gestapo
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Just-a-Guy
'cuz youd rather talk to someone you disagree with
01:33 PM on 11/22/2011
Rounding up ethnic groups and committing genocide?

Fail

Go watch Schindler's List again. You need a refresher.
01:41 PM on 11/22/2011
That was not happening in the 1930's. These things take time to develop.
photo
rubbercow
Pretty vacant
01:54 PM on 11/22/2011
Illegal Immigrant vs. Nazi

Bad economy: check - check
Scapegoat: US citizens - Jews
Label: racist, xenophobe, thief, etc. - alien
Work within the realm of law whenever possible - check - check
Everyone else's country for illegal immigrants - check
Using hate propaganda - check - check
Using racial hatred to come to power: check - check
Mass terror: Criminal gangs - gestapo

Deny education - you mean not giving them a tax break for in-state tuition at university? We already provide them with free k-12

Eugenics - please provide cites to this outlandish claim.
02:38 PM on 11/22/2011
And don't forget the school children in Alabama missing classes.
If they could do more to deny education, they would.

Also, take a look at this:
http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread591771/pg1
02:45 PM on 11/22/2011
Stephen Jay Gould asserted that restrictions on immigration passed in the United States during the 1920s (and overhauled in 1965 with the Immigration and Nationality Act) were motivated by the goals of eugenics. During the early 20th century, the United States and Canada began to receive far higher numbers of Southern and Eastern European immigrants. Influential eugenicists like Lothrop Stoddard and Harry Laughlin (who was appointed as an expert witness for the House Committee on Immigration and Naturalization in 1920) presented arguments they would pollute the national gene pool if their numbers went unrestricted.[citation needed] It has been argued that this stirred both Canada and the United States into passing laws creating a hierarchy of nationalities, rating them from the most desirable Anglo-Saxon and Nordic peoples to the Chinese and Japanese immigrants, who were almost completely banned from entering the country.[98]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics

Historically, the anti-immigrant crowd has had strong support for eugenics in this country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Just-a-Guy
'cuz youd rather talk to someone you disagree with
01:23 PM on 11/22/2011
3. Can be known gang members.

This just sealed he deal for me. No DREAM act. Ever.
01:11 AM on 11/23/2011
They can also have one major felony in their record too. So we will not even deport dangerous criminals under the Dream act.
photo
TggerJen
Protect at snowleopard.org
01:30 PM on 11/23/2011
The DREAM Amnesty was never about a small group of well-educated illegal aliens. The 'hardship exception' allows for all the requirements to be waived and there's a family unity clause too. It is just a way to con the American people into granting a massive amnesty that will cost us billions in more freebies for illegal aliens.
photo
spytheweb
Black Democrat
12:59 PM on 11/22/2011
Teabaggers are present day national socialists.
They are doing many of the same things that were done in Nazi Germany, including denying education. Nothing new.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Just-a-Guy
'cuz youd rather talk to someone you disagree with
01:13 PM on 11/22/2011
Nobody is getting marched into ovens.

False equivalence
01:43 PM on 11/22/2011
Nobody was getting marched into the ovens in the 1930's either.
01:47 PM on 11/23/2011
do you hear yourself? Hitler used socialism / progressivism to lure the weak-minded in

If he himself morphed into a Right-Winger, it was made possible by millions of unemployed and disillusioned Germans who were convinced that their misfortunes were not their fault and that they should blame the minority that had all of the 'wealth' as the real reason
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:51 AM on 11/22/2011
I see a lot of anti-immigrants (nativists?) who oppose the Dream Act commenting here complaining about "supporting this people with MY taxes" and they all seem to ignore this:
immigrants, yes, illegal immigrants too, do pay taxes, a lot of money in taxes is contributed by these people through the ITIN numbers, so it's not your tax dollars only they'd be benefitting from if the Dream Act passes.
Also, if you care so much where your tax dollars go, you should be a lot more worried about that money going to funding illegal wars of occupation, that's where most of your tax dollars go, into bombing innocent people, the Dream Act is insignificant in comparison.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Haun
the first 374 fans are always the hardest
11:59 AM on 11/22/2011
"I see a lot of anti-immig­rants (nativists­?) who oppose the Dream Act commenting here complainin­g"

~ I see alot of us complaining about illegal aliens, not immigrants...not the same
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:34 PM on 11/22/2011
I was an illegal immigrant for many years, now I'm a legal resident. What's the ONLY difference between these two? A ring in my finger.
It's not like if there were two large, well distinct groups of people, the legal immigrants on one side and the illegals on the other side and you can support one while hating the other; most illegal immigrants aim to eventually become legal, and if they're lucky the do, but there are no easy ways to achieve that, other than marrying a citizen.
12:37 PM on 11/22/2011
It's undocumented immigrants.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alitoo
01:24 PM on 11/22/2011
You do realize that the Inspector General of the Treasury issued his report in September which found that illegal aliens who filed under ITINs not only got refunds of whatever they paid in, but recieved over and above that $4.2 BILLION in the child tax credit. So much for "paying" taxes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
2warvet
I have nitrogen narcosis, what's your excuse?
02:18 PM on 11/22/2011
Just stop it. You will confuse people when you start doing things like using facts....
02:44 PM on 11/22/2011
When you pay taxes with your ITIN you're eligible for all the same type of refunds and tax credits that any regular tax payer and there's nothing wrong with that. I'm an independent contractor so every year I payed thousands of dollars in taxes and get NO refund at all, through my ITIN number. Get your facts right, kid.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:34 AM on 11/22/2011
I wonder just how many of these comments--particularly those anti-Dream Act comments--here are made by Latinos?? I noticed that as soon as this section became part of HP, the anti-Latinos swarmed this site.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vicky Valentine Proud
It is what it is.
01:39 AM on 11/23/2011
Ma'am, do you know your geography?? It is easier to cross the border between Mexico and the US than it is to swim across the Pacific Ocean to get here. I acknowledge that illegal aliens are not just all Latinos, there are from everywhere and as such, they all should be returned there promptly. There are even Middle Easterners who find their way here through Mexico, but as far being anti-Latino, the Latinos make the biggest noise about this issue because they are the biggest offenders. I don't see too terribly many other ethnic groups coming out and making a huge deal of it, probably afraid of being deported, which they ALL should be. We are not haters, we are simply people who want the laws enforced, that's all. Not racial prejudice here.
photo
TggerJen
Protect at snowleopard.org
01:34 PM on 11/23/2011
Excellent comment! Fanned and faved!!
photo
PLDgyrl
We won Mitches!!!!!!!
09:31 PM on 11/24/2011
Oh come on be honest - for alot of people it is racial.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:11 AM on 11/22/2011
Way too many nativists on this site . . .why? They claim to be different from a certain group in 1930s Germany, but everything they say and everything they do mirrors that group. So how are they different? They sure haven't proved any difference to me.
photo
rubbercow
Pretty vacant
11:19 AM on 11/22/2011
Why don't you demonstrate how people who would like to see illegal immigration controlled are similar to "a certain group in 1930's Germany"? This is such a preposterous position to take that it would be laughable were it not so sad.

Is any one here advocating for the elimination of Hispanics? Where are the concentration camps for Hispanics? You do, of course, realize that what the Nazis perpetrated was likely the most heinous atrocity ever committed by men? You are willing to say that asking our government to protect the rights of its own citizens by disallowing a group of individuals to cheat and laugh at our legal system is tantamount to Nazism? Unbelievable.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:43 AM on 11/22/2011
Apparently you are as ignorant of Latino history in the Southwest as you are ignorant of history, rubbercow. I grew up there and are aware firsthand of the discrimation they have endured in a land they inhabited long before the Anglo population showed up. I am also aware of the economic contribution that your so-called illegals have made to that part of the country; but you are either ignorant of that historical fact, or else choose to ignore it. Groups like your belovèd Minutement are a thinly disguised hate group little different from the Klan. The national socialists of WW2 Germany did not begin by calling for elimination of the Jews, just a Germany for Germans. This is EXACTLY the position you nativists take once the smoke screen is blown away . . . and you know it. If you do not, then you are hopelessly blind. Get out your history books, read them, study them, research what I have said . . . but you won't, because you are smuggly happy with your opinion based upon cherry-picked "facts". Btw, the National Socialists also made sure that theirs was in line with the "legal system".
11:32 AM on 11/22/2011
Sorry to burst your ignorance, but I am a long time liberal and Democrat. I see that you think that US citizens are the same as smugglers who smuggle themselves into the US. If you cannot tell the difference between citizens, and aliens then there is no hope for rational discourse. Think that illegals should also have the vote since there is NO difference in your so called mind?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:37 AM on 11/22/2011
Just curious, but in what part of the country do you live? It doesn't seem likely to me that you live in the SW, given your comment; if you do, it seems likely that you moved there from somewhere else.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:39 AM on 11/22/2011
Is your opinion the same for other immigrants who have come into the country by other than legal means?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Haun
the first 374 fans are always the hardest
11:07 AM on 11/22/2011
nice try...nobody is buying it
12:31 PM on 11/22/2011
It doesn't matter if you buy it. These are facts. They don't depend on your opinion.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dtairtime
It is what it is
11:20 AM on 11/22/2011
Few have any idea what it really is.

Do you think support would fall if the public learned the dream act had these provisions.
1. All costs paid by taxpayers.
2. Dreamers can have TWO criminal convictions and unlimited arrests.
3. Can be known gang members.
4. Hardship exemption can be used unilaterally on all applicants.
5. They can reward their parents for bringing them here by immediately petitioning for the parents to stay.
6. They can be "children" up to 35 years old.
7. Proof that they came here when they claim can be verbal only. Proving they didn't come when claimed would take massive amounts of taxpayer money.
8. Can't be deported once they apply for any reason.
9. No limit on numbers.
10. They can have a 2.0 GPA in basket weaving or frisbee flying and be considered the best and brightest - of what I don't know.


These are just a few of the things most of the public has no idea about. Funny that the little details don't quite meet the talking points the chamber of commerce puts out on this idea.


One of the bills:
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c111:S.3992:
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Just-a-Guy
'cuz youd rather talk to someone you disagree with
01:20 PM on 11/22/2011
"3. Can be known gang members."

Are you kidding?

Wow. That is eye-opening. I didn't support any version of this DREAM act before. This ensures that I never will.
09:02 AM on 11/22/2011
Why are the teabaggers disproportionately white?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
missouriwatcher
military veteran, veteran teacher, father, grandpa
11:18 AM on 11/22/2011
I think you hit on the answer with your previous comment; just look at the responses, just look at the subgroups within the tbaggers. Also very interesting the passively positive support given to the tbaggers, and the opposite response the establishment has given to the OWS protesters. Those already in control like the tbaggers and resist any other voices; the Allies may have won the battle, but the mentality of the Axis apparently won the war.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
08:57 AM on 11/22/2011
On 25 April 1933, the Nazi government introduced a 1.5 quota for new admissions of German Non-Aryans—i.e. essentially of German Jews—as core issue of a law claiming to generally limit the number of (Aryan and non-Aryan) students admitted to high-schools (höhere Schulen) and universities. In addition, high-schools and universities deemed to have more students than required for the professions for which they were training their students were required to reduce their student enrollment; doing so, they had to reach a maximum of 5% of German non-Aryan students. The law was supposedly enacted to avoid overcrowding schools and universities,[2] which referred to German concerns at the time that large numbers of students would decrease the quality of higher education. In the beginning of 1933, about 1% of the German population was Jewish,[3] but for several decades more than 1% of German students had been Jewish.[4] After 30 July 1939, Jews were no longer permitted to attend German public schools at all, and the prior quota law was eliminated by a non-public regulation in January 1940.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_quota
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
James Haun
the first 374 fans are always the hardest
10:47 AM on 11/22/2011
not sure what exactly this has to do with the article - unless you are trying to imply that people who wish for our laws to be followed are following the national socialist agenda of the 1930's...we have seen this lame fallback many, many times...might want to find a new motiff to drum up hysteria...
12:33 PM on 11/22/2011
I am saying that the teabaggers are modern day national socialists. That is why similarities with the nazi Germany are all over the place.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Alitoo
01:29 PM on 11/22/2011
You do realize that German Jews were just that GERMAN Jews? Citizens of Germany? Illegal aliens of any nationality are not only NOT CITIZENS of this country, they're not even legal residents and as such should be deported.