iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Horse Slaughter Ban Lifted: Congress Reinstates Federal Funding


First Posted: 11/29/2011 5:59 pm Updated: 11/30/2011 5:23 pm

Horse slaughter policy in America has entered a new era.

Back in 2006, Congress instituted a ban on the use of federal money toward the inspection of horses headed for slaughter. The USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service requires that meat undergo a federal inspection before being distributed as food, and the absence of that funding stood as a formidable fiscal barrier.

Five years later, that ban has been lifted. The Christian Science Monitor writes that a Nov. 18 Department Of Agriculture bill quietly reinstated the use of federal funding.

The Oklahoman adds that a Government Accountability Office report played a role in the change. Entitled "Actions Needed To Address Unintended Consequences from Cessation of Domestic Slaughter," the July 2011 report highlights how horse welfare declined over the past few years. The United States' domestic ban shifted the market to foreign countries like Canada and Mexico, with hundreds of thousands of horses still slaughtered in 2010.

"The extent of the decline is unknown due to a lack of comprehensive, national data, but state officials attributed the decline in horse welfare to many factors, but primarily to the cessation of domestic slaughter and the U.S. economic downturn," the report writes.

The decision does not sit well with some animal rights groups. The Equine Welfare Alliance, a group focused on horses' welfare, released a position paper in response to the GAO report, slamming "disturbing omissions" that favored slaughter lobbyists.

"The GAO has a reputation for objective and thorough research and fair reporting," the group writes. "Every indication is that this standard was abandoned in the compilation of this report, and that the result is little short of a propaganda tool for horse slaughter interests."

Supporters of the bill see a different side. State Rep. Sue Wallis (R-Wyo.) told The Oklahoman back in November, "everyone in the horse world is so excited we may have an opportunity to turn the whole equine market around."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

Horse slaughter policy in America has entered a new era. Back in 2006, Congress instituted a ban on the use of federal money toward the inspection of horses headed for slaughter. The USDA's Food Sa...
Horse slaughter policy in America has entered a new era. Back in 2006, Congress instituted a ban on the use of federal money toward the inspection of horses headed for slaughter. The USDA's Food Sa...
Horse slaughter policy in America has entered a new era. Back in 2006, Congress instituted a ban on the use of federal money toward the inspection of horses headed for slaughter. The USDA's Food Sa...
Horse slaughter policy in America has entered a new era. Back in 2006, Congress instituted a ban on the use of federal money toward the inspection of horses headed for slaughter. The USDA's Food Sa...
Filed by Chris Gentilviso  |  Report Corrections
 
 
  • Comments
  • 687
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
05:12 PM on 02/02/2012
Killing horses for meat ..really???? As if there isnt enough animals being killed for meat, let alone beause of some of them being over popluated. People are sick in the head they need to leave these beautiful animals alone. I mean whats next humans eating humans. Obama makes me sick to my stomach he has created so many problems so this really doesnt surprise me that he is trying to lift the ban on horse meat. I can not wait til he and his followers are out of the white house. What has American come to????? A country without GOD!!!
01:41 PM on 12/22/2011
Why did Obama sign this bill? Horse slaughter is hardly economically profitable! Horses have a right to roam on Federal Lands: He could have trashed the bill when it got to his desk; Some horse breeders have been anticipating this bill since the election of 2008; early in 2009 there were rumblings in the news about horse slaughter factories in certain states being built or reopened; how many horses have been bred since then; whose hands are getting washed from "any" profits? Places like Chicago used to be meat packing centers; Disgraceful! Who is going to buy the horsemeat! Bet there are plans to market horsemeat in Asia:

What is also an issue is that the timing of bill signature strangely coincides with the release of the new blockbuster film "War Horse". Glorification of horses in a popular movie while they are being loaded on trucks and sent to the slaughterhouse; Sickening! Horse adoption groups for stable horses are a better option and allocating Federal lands where wild horses can continue to roam free is a priority.

Appalling record regarding wildlife extends to horses; one of Obama's first acts as President with the Interior Secretary was to remove the wolf from the endangered species list in the northwest; Now, the wolves in the upper great lakes region have been removed from the endangered species list by the same cohort; and a horse slaughter bill; Guess all things go hand-in-hand; what is next legalization of illegal dog-fight rings?
03:08 PM on 02/15/2012
In case you haven't noticed rescue organizations are swamped with horses they can't use. You can only save so many. And for what purpose?
08:55 PM on 12/06/2011
I would never take a horse to market that has potential. But: It is un believable how many culls are out there, and people are dumping them on public lands, turning them loose in neighboring counties. The rescue calls are increasing at a fast rate. I read an article from Texas and in this small county they have over 40 calls per week.
The quality of horses Will only get better if the culls are gone. Lets use common sense rather than emotions it works much better.
11:58 PM on 12/05/2011
The horse industry has no means for culling and improein the breeds without slaughter. What do you do with a nuckle head, rank misfit, you get rid of him. The slaughter market is the only way to cleanup the breeds and get these nuckle heads out of the gene pool. It is unreasonable to exspect someone to support the nuckle heads til they die. If all horses were good usable horses this would not be true but thid unfortunantly is not the case. I plan to move as many culls as I can. it is the humain thing to do.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
04:18 PM on 12/06/2011
You've lost your mind , compassion and soul.. I pity you.....
08:49 PM on 12/07/2011
Slaughter is an out for irresponsible owners/breeders. Too many people who have no business breeding horses are doing it hoping to make money. Maybe the worst of the breeders need to be culled, especially the ones who can't spell.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles Queen
I am a disabled nam vet
05:16 PM on 12/04/2011
Theres really nothing at all wrong with this.Many countrys eat horse meatactually extremely good,a bit sweeter than beef,sweet but not in a surgary way.No fat good for the body health wise.I don't advocate running out and killing you'r horses.I have 9 right now but their not for eating,their for riding.They can breed certain ones together to make oes that would be intended to be used for meat to sell in stores.If nobody told you that you were eating it,you would never know it
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
05:34 PM on 12/06/2011
You're a sick man Charles!!!!! I pity you and feel sorry for you at the same time. Shameful, simply shameful.....
09:05 PM on 12/07/2011
Nothing wrong? How about the public safety issue aspect? American horses are not raised for consumption so the majority of them have been given bute at least once in their lives, along with plenty of common meds that are not meant for animals raised for consumption. Bute was banned by the FDA because it can cause serious illness or death in humans. One dose of bute and the animal is not ever supposed to get into the food chain. The EU is wising up to this health threat and may ban the importation of all American horse meat. I hope they do.
Americans are not going to start eating horse meat so the creeps calling for reopening of slaughter plants are only hoping to make money selling toxic horse meat to other countries. Horse slaughter is a very inhumane business, see the many undercover videos for proof.
And Canada already has an established slaughter business but the horse market there is as bad as it is here. So slaughter will not help the horse market. It is only providing a free disposal service for irresponsible owners & breeders.
10:36 AM on 03/27/2012
I found this article for a college essay, and I am very intrigued with some of the comments listed. Let's get real and think for a second. Do you have any idea what cattle breeders are giving their calves, or what chicken farmers are feeding their chickens? No, you don't. All cattle are not raised in pastures with green grass and sunshine. Realistically, the common American is not going to want to consume horse meat. I myself am part of this group, but I still support this bill and what it hopes to accomplish. Horse meat is primarily used for animal consumption in things such as dog and cat food. Hooves are used to produce glue, and skin is used to make clothing and upholstery. Although horse slaughter seems wrong, it is a very practical practice that not only helps the horse population, but provides thousands of jobs to Americans that would otherwise be without. Some of you may say it is just a way for irresponsible and uncaring owners to get rid of animals, but it is completely accepted with other livestock. Not everyone in the agriculture field is as well off as others. Shouldn't they be given a way to help themselves? Shouldn't they be given a chance to help their families? Horse feed is not cheap you know.......
11:34 PM on 12/03/2011
I am also a horse owner and I support this too. Of course I don't want to see a picture of a horse that is gonna be slaughtered. But who would? I know this is the best thing for the horses. My question is where are all the ppl who are against horse slaughter when horses needed them most? I don't remember ppl caring when farmers, ranchers and horse owners were BEGGING for help. Horses are being horribly neglected & abused. This has gotten MUCH worse in the last 5 years with no slaughter. If you ppl who are against this think your are doing horses a favor by being on their side. YOUR NOT.
09:13 PM on 12/07/2011
I call BS, you can sell a horse to slaughter today if you want, it did not go away. Anyone who wants horse slaughter available just wants to enable irresposible breeders & owners by providing a free disposal service. Horse slaughter is not humane, as most undercover investigations have proven. The dealers who transport to slaughter are just as inhumane, whether the transport is to a US plant or one outside the country. See youtube videos of Horse Slaughter Killer for testimony by a long time horse dealer. The best thing for horses is not inhumane death at slaughter.
05:27 PM on 12/03/2011
I BELIEVE THE PRESIDENTS HANDS ARE TIED WHEN IT COMES TO MANY LAWS SIGNED INTO PLACE,, JUST LOOK AT THE JOBS BILL ... THIS GOVERMENT JUST DOES NOT WORK TOGEATHER, I AM SURE HE HAD TO GIVE SOMETHING TO THE OTHER SIDE TO KEEP THE COUNTRY FROM DEFAULT AND THIS WAS ONE OF THEM,,, BIG RANCHERS,MONEY,PROFITS, BINGO THERE YA GO,,, GREED RUNS WILD IN THIS COUNTRY NOW,,,,, YOU KNOW ABOUT LOBBYIST...
02:13 PM on 12/02/2011
"... and he whispered to the horse, trust no man in whose eyes you do not see yourself as an equal."
This is a disgrace to humanity. Our horses are part of our heritage; they have served us in war & peace and this is the kind of thanks we give them. This is all about money, as usual, and the horse people who advocate this lift on the slaughter ban are obviously part of the problem. Most people who use and breed horses do it for the money, not the love of the equines as evidenced by this statement from State Rep. Sue Wallis (R- Wyo.)State Rep. Sue Wallis (R-Wyo.) "Everyone in the horse world is so excited we may have an opportunity to turn the whole equine market around."And she really does mean "market!" Shame on these heartless, greedy people!
photo
HerrMonk
Fighter, Trainer, Nat.Sec.Consultant, Libertine
03:53 PM on 12/02/2011
And people have eaten forever...

...or at least until we stopped using them for work and transportation and they became status symbols/pets almost exclusively of the rich.
09:27 PM on 12/07/2011
Cultures change - Americans today do not eat horses. And horses in the US are not raised for consumption so their meat is full of toxins that should not be in the food supply.

I know plenty of people who are not even close to rich but own horses. People make choices - not everyone chooses the newest gadgets, designer shoes, a tv in every room, and a new car every 3 years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
04:20 PM on 12/06/2011
I'm with you all the way Patty........
Fanned and faved.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
seckhoff
Famous in the apple barns
11:20 AM on 12/02/2011
The HuffPo is showing its ignorance here. This appears on the same page as a piece on how the new ag bill endangers food sources. In an era when people are more concerned than ever about where their food comes from, the HuffPo appears to be advocating a widely-delegitimized form of cruelty. Horse slaughter is the preferred income-salvage technique for Western breeders whose operations are like giant puppy mills.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
12:22 PM on 12/02/2011
Good comment. I was also wondering about the BLM and if the lifting of this ban will result in more wild horse slaughtering. Do you know?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
04:30 PM on 12/06/2011
Nasch, you simply can't imagine whats going on with the wild horses. A chopper runs many babies to death, some pilots are able to flip them over with their landing gear. I have so many videos on facebook of what they do. It's horrific.....They will go to slaughter...
05:55 AM on 12/02/2011
Another feather in Obama's cap.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
12:22 PM on 12/02/2011
I hope you meant that as snark.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bmuesli
01:14 AM on 12/02/2011
Sue Wallis is an embarrassment to the legislature. Anyone who proclaims excitement at the slaughter of horses has something seriously wrong with them.
photo
HerrMonk
Fighter, Trainer, Nat.Sec.Consultant, Libertine
03:54 PM on 12/02/2011
You have the same opinion about people who like to eat cow?

Or do horses have special status for some reason?
Oneandoneandone
Professional Spitfire
07:12 PM on 12/02/2011
I can't speak for bmuesli, but I would say yes. Being excited about slaughter is wrong.
06:28 PM on 12/02/2011
I'm a horse owner and I"m excited about this reinstatement. Oh, and there's nothing wrong with me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
04:58 PM on 12/06/2011
Yes Brandi, there is something wrong with you, please read what you wrote.
You've lost your heart, compassion and soul...I pity you.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lesann
Resistance is Futile
11:00 AM on 12/07/2011
Excited? Really?

I disagree. There is something wrong with you.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MIMom
Your ad here.
10:19 PM on 12/01/2011
Turn the market around by killing them? Ooookay.
07:18 PM on 12/01/2011
This has to do with nothing more than money and business. One fool in our gvernment, I believe a Representative from Georgia, said that as so many horses are sold for meat to be processed outside of the US (such as Mexico) that at least if approved here it would be overseen and be humane slaughter. Are you kidding me? Anyone that has seen any of the footage out there about how animals are treated in the food industry knows it is anything but humane. I think evryone in D.C., including the President, should be made to sit thru a complete viewing of "Earthling" as well as all the footge shot by people undercover while working in these places.
08:14 PM on 12/01/2011
Thank you for mentioning the Earthlings documentary! I have not seen it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judith Jaehn
Animal Activist!
12:21 AM on 12/02/2011
Yes!! Everyone should be made to watch Earthlings.....But are we sure that the President or Congress have a soul, I truly don't think so...If he wanted to he could over ride this with an Executive Order......Keep calling the Whitehouse many times a day and tell them that you are outraged, but as hard as it is, remain nice on the phone............We must win this, we've come so far....
05:33 PM on 12/01/2011
Anybody know if horses have self awareness? Not looking for anecdotal evidence from a horse owner here. Have horses ever been subjected to a mirror test and passed?
photo
HerrMonk
Fighter, Trainer, Nat.Sec.Consultant, Libertine
03:59 PM on 12/02/2011
http://ezinearticles.com/?Does-Lukas-Know-Hes-Lukas?-Conducting-An-Experiment-in-Self-Awareness&id=6070028

Something to keep an eye on.

But, I doubt that we'll find that they are. They are herd animals. Like most herd animals, they get hungry and have a strong fight or flight instinct.
03:20 PM on 12/01/2011
FANTASTIC "war horse" is coming out-
do not kill horses -that is just sick-
eat your grandmother instead-nice old meat indeed