iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Beethoven's Deafness May Have Influenced His Music Throughout The Years: Study

Beethoven Deafness Music

The Huffington Post   First Posted: 12/25/2011 2:16 pm Updated: 12/26/2011 9:53 am

Ludwig van Beethoven, the eponymous classical music composer, is famous for churning out compositions despite his deafness. And now new study in the British Medical Journal shows that his musical compositions actually seem to be influenced by his worsening deafness with age.

Beethoven's deafness is attributed to severe tinnitus, which is a sensation of ringing or noise in the ears, according to BBC News.

The researchers reported that Beethoven first wrote about his hearing problems in an 1801 letter, saying: "In the theatre I have to get very close to the orchestra to understand the performers, and that from a distance I do not hear the high notes of the instruments and the singers' voices."

Researchers reported in the journal article that the hearing in Beethoven's left ear was first affected, "and he reported (bilateral) tinnitus, high tone hearing loss associated with poor speech discrimination, and recruitment with loud noises." In 1818, Beethoven began communicating with people via writing in notebooks, and researchers reported that Beethoven may have been completely deaf by 1825.

As a result, the BMJ article shows that Beethoven's later work -- when his hearing problems had grown more severe -- used more lower-pitched notes versus high-pitched notes.

BBC News reported:

The report's author Edoardo Saccenti said: "These results suggest that, as deafness progressed, Beethoven tended to use middle and low frequency notes, which he could hear better when music was performed, seemingly seeking for an auditory feedback loop. "When he came to rely completely on his inner ear he was no longer compelled to produce music he could actually hear when performed and slowly returned to his inner musical world and earlier composing experiences."

While interesting, Dr. Thomas Balkany, director of the University of Miami Ear Institute, told HealthDay that the journal article is very speculative of Beethoven's work, as "there is no formal hearing testing presented to determine the degree or frequencies of hearing loss."

These days, tinnitus can be improved as long as it's treated, according to the Mayo Clinic. The hearing condition affects as many as one in five people.

When tinnitus is a result of an underlying condition, a person can receive treatment by either getting earwax removed, treating a vascular condition or changing medication, the Mayo Clinic reported. Otherwise, a white noise machine, hearing aid or masking device can help to make the sound less noticeable.

There are also some medications that can help relieve symptoms of tinnitus (though there is not yet a drug that can cure tinnitus), according to the Mayo Clinic.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST HEALTHY LIVING

Ludwig van Beethoven, the eponymous classical music composer, is famous for churning out compositions despite his deafness. And now new study in the British Medical Journal shows that his musical comp...
Ludwig van Beethoven, the eponymous classical music composer, is famous for churning out compositions despite his deafness. And now new study in the British Medical Journal shows that his musical comp...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 133
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:48 AM on 01/01/2012
Duh.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Melody Breyer-Grell
Singer, Writer, Recording Artist
10:54 PM on 12/27/2011
Is is possible that this article is so ridiculed because of its generic headline?

I actually found it interesting to ponder that perhaps his later music used more highs because he was totally deaf so using just lows was not an issue.. it was all in his mind at that time..
08:47 AM on 12/27/2011
It's important to remember that the cheapest price may not be worth the money if it doesn't supply adequate coverage. Like most things in life - you get what you pay for. A slightly more expensive policy may offer the right amount of coverage while a cheaper one might cost you more in the long run
http://www.lifeinsurancehelpinformation.com/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:45 AM on 01/01/2012
Get off this site, you spammer.
10:37 PM on 12/26/2011
It's silly to assume his growing deafness DIDN'T shape his compositions, perhaps improved the quality in so many ways. He was & IS the best of the best in classical music, period.

His 9th Symphony was IMO his best effort & his magnum opus, my personal fave. Schiller's poetic lyrics for the 9thadded a humanistic quality it would not otherwise have had.
09:33 AM on 12/27/2011
The "Beethoven was deaf, wrote strange music for the time" is common knowledge among classical music fans. This article isn't at all revolutionary, and I'm not sure why scientists are bothering to do more research on topics which are already very well defined. However, I'm glad this article might reach people who aren't so well-indoctrinated in the world of classical music.

In all the late symphonies there's great parts for piccolos, high violins, French horns... the "low" quality to Beethoven's preference of sonorities in undeniable, but he saves some of his best moments for the very highest, most etheral instruments ("Turkish March" in no. 9). So, a serious study of Beethoven's omission of high notes and instruments can only be carried out with an extensive study of his scores throughout his career. This would require a very well-trained musicologist, perhaps with some medical background, not an ear doctor.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
nikanj
free the fnords
12:57 PM on 12/27/2011
Are you familiar with the Ninth's 'Dark Twin', the Missa Solemnis ?

Written more or less concurrently with the Ninth but only rarely performed
(it's a wicked hard piece), the second of the two Masses Beethoven wrote.

Definitely a work which deserves more recognition.
10:33 PM on 12/26/2011
I remember reading somewhere that those 1st 4 notes of his famous 5th Symphony were the knock on his by Death itself. He was clearly able to "hear" & demonstrate that.

Others have speculated that it's the death of Europe he was recounting in his 5th, probably true, his hatred for the failed panacea of Napoleon & the entire Romantic Movement accounts for that.
10:43 PM on 12/26/2011
What nonsense! Very little of Beethoven's music has such programmatic characteristics. Almost all his music is about the manipulation of musical materials, not the telling of some silly "story."

I wonder why the article doesn't link the now-proven high levels of lead in Beethoven's corpse to his hearing problem.
10:51 PM on 12/26/2011
I beg to differ -- Beethoven was deeply involved in the Realpolitik of his day & is reflected in his music. His falling out with Bonaparte has been extensively documented. He was also a classic Obsessive/Compulsive personality, the film Immortal Beloved captures that very well -- Gary Oldman should have been Oscar-noiminated for it but no one loves Beethoven in Hollywood anymore.

Lead was used in paint & making drinking vessels in the early 1800s too, they didn't know about its lethal effects. It's true, many died then from lead poisoning in early canned foods. Ludwig van Beethoven may well have been one of those victims.
photo
seanrm92
The Radical Neutral
08:31 PM on 12/26/2011
You have no idea how much I do not want to meet the person who conducted this study. How boring do you have to be to conduct an entire study only to arrive at the conclusion that "Beethoven's music was influenced by his ability to hear"?

By the way, I conducted my own study and found that the things I type into my computer are greatly influenced by my ability to type.
09:37 PM on 12/26/2011
As Sherlock Holmes says, its the details that matter most. Little things. Why does everyone on HuffPo constantly complain about what studies did what, and that the results aren't exciting or groundbreaking enough for them?!
You guys have no idea how hard it is to do them, testing every tiny thing thoroughly to ensure your result is perfect, testing things people assume or take for granted. Stop just ragging on everyone, I actually like that they confirm things, having scientific proof of things is nice.

Every study isn't meant to discover life on Mars or something earth shattering!
10:37 PM on 12/26/2011
God is in the details.

Then again so is the Devil ....
01:36 AM on 12/27/2011
TOTALLY BRILLIANT. Most studies are crap produced for the purpose of HYPING the characters and institutions involved. It's free media publicity to "announce a study". these are ridiculous as science.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddanimal
07:38 PM on 12/26/2011
The health news section of HuffPo used to be pretty good, with intelligent, stimulating articles that fostered discussion.

Then, AOL took over. Now the articles are all insipid fluff that read like articles from trashy magazines like Cosmo: 5 foods for the flu etc. And garbage like this article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D OBrien
We can be heroes, if just for one day!
07:20 PM on 12/26/2011
Ya think?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lucky13thday
07:13 PM on 12/26/2011
...and the impressionist painters were nearly all nearsighted(that's actually true)... Go figure huh...
unique
Animal lover forever
05:04 PM on 12/26/2011
For me this was an interesting article.
All my life I have been hard of hearing
and wear hearing aids. I was never
interested in music, because, I was
not able to hear high and low pitches.
People sometimes make fun of me
due tomy speaking slightly nasal.
Good article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D OBrien
We can be heroes, if just for one day!
07:21 PM on 12/26/2011
Yeah, I used to get that alot too!-John Lennon
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mbrahms26
12:03 PM on 12/26/2011
And I thought Beethoven was a dog!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D OBrien
We can be heroes, if just for one day!
07:22 PM on 12/26/2011
Stop watching Faux, try PBS!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Cohen
10:08 AM on 12/26/2011
Ok I'm a professional classical musician, with an additional interest in recorded sound. I watched the video these guys produced, with a string quartet in tow to provide musical examples.

In my judgement they have proved absolutely nothing. It's speculative churning, and their charming violinists play out of tune :-( But it's good to talk about Beethoven, so Merry Christmas.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
se72748
08:36 AM on 12/26/2011
DUHHHH.ya think so?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddanimal
01:17 AM on 12/26/2011
In other news: Picasso's painting were strongly influenced by his ability to see.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wilkesgm
06:12 PM on 12/26/2011
Regrettably not. His paintings were strongly influenced by not seeing what he was looking at and dollar signs.
Topdown1
That's what she said!
12:22 AM on 12/26/2011
Now that's what I call breaking news!!!