iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

California's Central Valley Slammed By Record Air Pollution

California Pollution

TRACIE CONE   01/ 7/12 02:58 PM ET   AP

FRESNO, Calif. — This is the time of year when residents who often live with the nation's worst pollution often can draw a breath of fresh air. But this winter has not been kind to people who want to play outside in California's Central Valley.

A dry December and January has stagnated air across California, but nowhere is the situation more serious than between Modesto and Bakersfield, where nearly every day dirty air has exceeded federal health standards.

It's the worst air quality recorded in a dozen years, and it's the unhealthiest kind_ microscopic, chemical-laden particles that can get into lungs and absorbed into the bloodstream to create health risks in everyone, not just the young and infirm.

The southern San Joaquin half of the valley stretches 200 miles from Stockton to Bakersfield and is home to 4 million people. It traditionally records the highest level of particulate matter and ozone pollution in the United States and has a rate of asthma three times the national average, according to the American Lung Association.

Air quality advocates have argued for years that the local air district's focus on fireplace burn bans ignores other major sources of industrial pollution, such as dairies, feed lots and oil rigs. "The air board's strategy is failing," said Kevin Hall, executive director of the Central Valley Air Quality Coalition.

Air officials say their policies are sound, but there is little they can do with La Nina conditions in the Pacific creating stagnant air.

Fighting air pollution in the Central Valley is a task that so far has not succeeded in meeting federal health standards. Surrounded on three sides by mountains, the valley opens in the north toward San Francisco and Sacramento, where weather patterns suck emissions south.

Cutting through the valley are the state's two main north-south highway corridors, the routes for nearly all long-distance tractor trailer rigs, the No. 2 source of particulate pollution in the valley. Also in the mix are millions of acres of plowed farmland and 1.6 million dairy cows and the flatulence and ammonia-laden manure they create.

Without wind and rain, the air sits, trapped as if in a pot with a lid.

Since 2003, the San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District has targeted fireplace soot as biggest source that is easiest to end and calls "no burn days" based on weather forecasts.

Fires were banned on nearly every day in December, including Christmas Eve and New Year's, and the 60 people who patrol neighborhoods writing citations to offenders have been busy. Violations doubled in some areas and were up to five times higher in others last month as the district cracked down during unseasonably cold weather.

"When we have weather conditions like this, there is nothing we can do really to meet the federal standards," said Seyed Sadredin, executive director of the district. "Even if we shut down I-5 and (U.S. Highway) 99 and shut businesses we would still violate the standard because there's no dispersion. The best we can do is to minimize the damage, and the best way to do that is with the fireplace rule."

The struggle with particulate pollution comes after the district failed during the summer months, despite a publicity campaign, to keep ozone emissions under EPA limits to avoid ongoing federal fines.

Warnings about the potential adverse health effects of air pollution become a year-round event in the valley. And those warnings are about to start coming more furiously. This week district officials lowered by nearly half the level of pollution they say is safe for outdoor activities.

The air district helped fund a study of 1 million residents in 2011 that found that emergency room visits for asthma and heart attacks went up when particulate pollution went up. That convinced officials that the federal government's standard, which relied on a 24-hour average of air quality, was too high. Small particulates in the bloodstream can break off plaque in the coronary artery, creating a logjam and a heart attack.

"The old level may work for Beijing, China, but we need to bring it down to where it really belongs," said David Lighthall, the district's health science adviser. "We are recognizing that the air quality is different from one time of day to another and we're trying to give people the information they need to make decisions about outdoor exercise."

The district sends advisories to schools and those signed up for email alerts, called "Real Time Outdoor Activity Risk" warnings, whenever the air reaches the "unhealthy" level so that teachers know whether to call off recess and residents can decide to postpone a jog or a bike ride. On Friday morning, for instance, some Fresno residents received an email alert at 10 a.m. working that the air was "Level 5 Very Unhealthy" for everyone, indicating the highest levels of pollution.

"We can give people a tool, whether an athlete or school manager, and ensure they do stay indoors at particular times when air quality is threatening, and also find out when a better time to go out would be," Lighthall said.

Just before Christmas, the Center for Race, Poverty and the Environment sued the U.S. EPA on behalf of Central Valley residents alleging it has not pressed California for a viable, enforceable plan to improve air quality.

"We are going to need far tighter rules coming out of the air district if we are really going to make progress in meeting federal standards," said Tom Franz of the Bakersfield-based Association of Irritated Residents, one of the groups suing.

Air pollution officials say the technology doesn't yet exist to lessen the valley's pollution and bring the region into compliance, though the district is investing in research and giving grants for things such as the new generation of battery powered leaf blowers and lawn mowers.

______

Twitter: (at)TConeAP

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

FRESNO, Calif. — This is the time of year when residents who often live with the nation's worst pollution often can draw a breath of fresh air. But this winter has not been kind to people who wa...
FRESNO, Calif. — This is the time of year when residents who often live with the nation's worst pollution often can draw a breath of fresh air. But this winter has not been kind to people who wa...
Filed by Joanna Zelman  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 359
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
csuciadams
Planner/Engineer Extraordinaire
12:30 PM on 01/09/2012
"Air pollution officials say the technology doesn't yet exist to lessen the valley's pollution and bring the region into compliance..."

What a bunch of horse crap that is! We have all the technology we need, we just don't have the right leaders in place with the commitment to make it happen!

Vote them all out and save our planet! We are nothing without our air, land, and water. Why are we allowing it to be destroyed at such a rapid pace?

I am only 28, but the continued exploitation of this planet has been increasing in just my short time here. We have to put a stop to it before we have nothing left for future generations.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Josh RageLyfe
rage life party it up
03:56 PM on 01/09/2012
F&F!
01:56 PM on 01/10/2012
Well except the district is right and you are wrong in this case. there isn't the technology to get this district into compliance with EPA's ever lowering thresholds for compliance. The district also doesn't have all the control.

It was USEPA that set emissions stnadards for heavy trucks in the 90's, The district has no control over that, It is US trade policy that makes CA ports the number 1 access point for asia trade and sends trucks up % en masse. Could the feds have invested in paths that would help absolutely.

I took the liberty of providing a link to a tool you can use to look at the entirety of PM2.5 data for the SJ valley. Run it on PM 2.5 (combustion products first regulated under clinton and lowered in 06 by Bush) You will not the days exceeding the average declined considerably to 06 when the standard changed and then immediately started declinging again as this district acted. Threshold to exceed the daily average lowers and days in non compliance dropping. This year weather is a huge aberration with zero storm flushing events to clean the air. 11 data isn't yet in the system.

http://www.arb.ca.gov/adam/trends/trends1.php

you can also run it on PM10 data whose standards have also lowered over the years with data going back to 1988. Again the district is doing it's job and considering this is CA's agricultural heartland the numbers are impressive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
csuciadams
Planner/Engineer Extraordinaire
07:12 PM on 01/10/2012
I don't agree, they have the ability to regulate diary farms and other point source pollution. The could require lower VOC chemicals in nearly everything. We don't have to live a polluted lifestyle. It shouldn't be the cheapest way as the best way. The air district is playing within very tight rules, but is not doing anything to make sure those rules are changed to benefit them greater.

Why doesn't every member of the board advocate for hydrogen or electric vehicle standards on the state or federal level?
07:17 AM on 01/09/2012
SOX2 and NOX2 are the 2 most lethal chemicals known to the human body that comes from car and truck exhaust. Co2 or ozone depleting chemicals are another chemical that also is emmitted from this exhaust, do not confuse the two. Sox and Nox are 2 of the worst carcinogens in the world, so for all of you no belivers out there, which there are a few from what Ive read from the comments on this page I suggest this to test your theory:Wrap some duct tape around your tailpipe of your car. and for about 10 seconds a day for about 8 months breath you car exhaust to see if you dont develop some sort of mutliple myloma or sarcoma or genetic abnormality, then report back to us about how "goosestepping Nazi" ticket writers who are actually hurtng the sick, and our children more than they are actually than a heathy adult.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chipher
06:34 AM on 01/09/2012
...the dirtiest and now radioactive smog particles...tinyurl.com/85ky34r
photo
farmilyman
everything is illusion
03:23 AM on 01/09/2012
Although we have the technology, people and politicians are convince we still need dirty energy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
csuciadams
Planner/Engineer Extraordinaire
12:31 PM on 01/09/2012
It is rhetoric like saying we don't have the technology that allows the myth to perpetuate. I'm wondering which member of the air board said that. I want a quote so I can call them personally and speak truth to power.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
act1girl
12:15 AM on 01/09/2012
The San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District has their fireplace nazis writing out citations for us burning our fireplaces when temps in this valley dip well below freezing at night and have for the past several weeks. Fireplaces are the least of the problem as this article clearly states. Fining us for trying to keep our homes warm in the winter to lessen pollution is like putting a band aid on a gaping wound. How about reducing the emissions blowing in from the Bay Area first. Make the Bay area people spend a fortune to smog their vehicles like we have to here in the Valley. By choosing not to burn my fireplace, my electric bill was just under $1000 for the month of December, up from $335 the month before. It's cold. It's winter. And NOBODY on the SVAPCD is an elected official anyway. So if any of you fireplace police on foot patrol goose step by my house and see unauthorized particulate matter billowing from my chimney, don't even waste your time writing a ticket. It's just me trying to keep my family warm.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
JScott
John Galt's last name is McGuffin-Smithee
11:10 AM on 01/09/2012
In all new construction they only allow gas logs, woodburning fireplaces are no longer allowed.
Wonder if they gave you incentives to insulate you house and put in dual glazed windows.
07:56 PM on 01/08/2012
CARB data sites are unwieldy, but for ozone in the San Joaquin Air Basin, the number of days the air basin has exceeded the ozone standard so far in 2012 is . . . zero. Zip, zilch, nada. The peak ozone level recorded so far the first week of this year is 0.051 parts per million, comfortably below the national standard of 0.075 ppm. While the San Joaquin Air Basin exceeded the federal 8-hour ozone standard 132 days in 2011 compared to 122 in 2009 (and 115 in 2010), the peak recorded level in 2011 (0.109 ppm) was lower than the peak level in either 2009 (0.110 ppm) or 2010 (0.115 ppm). So where’s the “record level” of air pollution again?
photo
blackwind
Relax, nothing is under control
09:29 PM on 01/08/2012
Third paragraph in the story.
Read it.
01:28 AM on 01/09/2012
I read it. It's contradicted by the actual data.
outnow
Ban the bomb
10:32 PM on 01/08/2012
You're talking just ozone. The article talks of particulate matter with chemicals that trigger asthma and cause lung disease as well as usually having record levels of ozone and particulate matter year after year. Read the third and fourth paragraphs.
09:59 AM on 01/09/2012
The long-term story for fine particulates (PM2.5) is embarrassing to this article. Let’s look at Fresno, which has only two EPA monitors with complete data. Both monitors shows that Fresno actually met the national standard for PM2.5 in 2010. (2011 EPA data not yet available.)

Since asthma rate are trending up while at the same time as pollution is trending down - most people would recognize that something else is causing the increase in asthma rates.
05:39 PM on 01/08/2012
The facts are just the opposite of this article. Did anyone even try to check the supposed "facts" in this article? It's easy to find. Air pollution in the central valley has been declining over the past 20 years

http://www.arb.ca.gov/aqmis2/ozone_annual.php
photo
blackwind
Relax, nothing is under control
09:32 PM on 01/08/2012
Try the second and third sentences in the story.
All will be revealed.
photo
cambo
On the grand MN's side.
05:24 PM on 01/08/2012
All around the world now we have bans for smoking in any public place due to health regulations yet every city in the world has pollution problems due mainly to fosiil fuel burning cars, some a lot worse than others but this pollution seems to be ok as far as the government is concerned. We will just keep turning a blind eye until we can't anymore.
photo
Strings55
A scoundrel still loved by Jesus
07:50 PM on 01/08/2012
Except the story is wrong.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
yeti7
don't need no stink'n badges
04:31 PM on 01/08/2012
Air pollution in the photo?? I don't kno but Mexico City would love to have a day that looks this clear.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cigi
02:48 PM on 01/09/2012
That is an interesting observation....maybe "regs" do work to some degree. I would never choose to have the same air quality tht Mexico City has.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
yeti7
don't need no stink'n badges
04:39 PM on 01/09/2012
just the stopping of open pit burning (trash/garbage dumps) help 75% probably.
If you ever been to EL Paso, Texas almost all the air pollution is from Juarez, Mexico.
04:21 PM on 01/08/2012
This story has been totally debunked and huffp0's amateur propagandists only discredit themselves and huffp0.
photo
blackwind
Relax, nothing is under control
09:36 PM on 01/08/2012
Says who?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cigi
02:48 PM on 01/09/2012
Source please.
BrighterStar
Let Freedom Ring
04:13 PM on 01/08/2012
This article is devoid of numbers that can be checked. That is probably because the truth is that the air pollution in CA is,and has for twenty years, been on a cleaner trend.
photo
blackwind
Relax, nothing is under control
09:40 PM on 01/08/2012
What does the trend of the last twenty years have to do with this story?
A clue can be found in the first three words of the second sentence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NWBrunette
Blessed Girl
03:37 PM on 01/08/2012
Apply reasonable pollution controls to the Ag industry like we do to most other industries and you'd be surprised how fast things will improve. Of course it's unlikely to happen as long as they get to primarily employ illegals. Address the real problems, or stay happy breathing the bad air.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doc holliday 4357
If you’ve got a business you didn’t build that
02:44 PM on 01/08/2012
"The air district helped fund a study of 1 million residents in 2011 that found that emergency room visits for asthma and heart attacks went up when particulate pollution went up."

The study limited itself to the warm humid summer months. Heat and humidity are triggers for asthma and this was conveniently excluded.

See for yourself:

http://www.csufresno.edu/ccchhs/institutes_programs/CVHPI/publications/AQR_web.pdf


" Small particulates in the bloodstream can break off plaque in the coronary artery, creating a logjam and a heart attack."

The cited study did not come close to investigating this.
outnow
Ban the bomb
10:44 PM on 01/08/2012
Heat and humidity increase the presence of spores from Aspergillus and other fungi spores. Those with hypersensitivity or allergy to Aspergillus flood the ER in Late August and early in September. Many asthma patients have allergies to fungal spores. The ozone and other particulate matter is an important health risk, but fungal spore allergies should be mentioned.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
doc holliday 4357
If you’ve got a business you didn’t build that
02:30 PM on 01/08/2012
"the technology doesn't yet exist to lessen the valley's pollution "

Irony.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Foodgrade
Learn to grow banannas