iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Haiti Earthquake Recovery: Where Did All The Money Go? (INFOGRAPHIC)

First Posted: 01/11/12 08:25 AM ET   Updated: 01/11/12 02:50 PM ET

Thursday marks the second anniversary of the Haiti earthquake that killed 316,000 people, but experts say it could be at least another 10 years before the country sees any noticeable recovery.

Donors pledged an estimated $4.6 billion in the aftermath of the earthquake, according to the UN yet, only 43 percent of those relief funds have been disbursed and more than 500,000 Haitians still remain homeless. Part of the problem, watchdog groups say, is that charities spent a considerable amount of money on soaring rents, board members' needs, overpriced supplies and imported personnel, the Miami Herald reports.

"A lot of good work was done; the money clearly didn't all get squandered," Jake Johnston, a researcher at The Center for Economic Policy Research, told the Miami Herald. "A lot just wasn't responding to needs on the ground. Millions were spent on ad campaigns telling people to wash their hands. Telling them to wash their hands when there's no water or soap is a slap in the face."

Some of that good work includes removing half of the debris caused by the toppling of hundreds of buildings, creating 300,000 temporary jobs and helping more than 1,000 families return home, Haitilibre.com reports.

But as more than half a million people remain living in packed dismal tents, that are often overwhelmed with violence and disease, charities are trying to devise long-term solutions to get Haitians off the streets and into shelters.

The American Red Cross, which received about $486 million in donations following the earthquake, announced that instead of constructing additional transitional residences, it intends to focus its efforts on building permanent homes and repairing damaged ones.

"Although progress is not as fast as we would like, recovery is well underway," Gail McGovern, president and CEO of the American Red Cross, said in a statement. "The pace of home construction has increased rapidly, with the American Red Cross and the rest of the global Red Cross network providing housing to more than 100,000 people at the two-year mark."

Oxfam is another organization looking to solve the country's infrastructure problems, not just create temporary solutions. It's working on rebuilding in inner-city neighborhoods and rural areas outside Port-au-Prince, the organization announced on its website.

While Oxfam is doing its part, the nonprofit is also calling on the new administration to step up to improve the lives of suffering Haitians.

"The second anniversary of the devastating earthquake must be a call to action," Oxfam's country director in Haiti, Cecilia Millan, said in a statement. "Despite the apparent slowness of reconstruction, this remains an opportunity for Haiti's political and economic elite to address the chronic poverty and inequality that has plagued the country since [declaring its] independence."

The relief organization is also urging donors to "honor their promises to Haiti" and not let the slow progress in rebuilding turn them away. But, experts are skeptical as to how much the ravaged country can rely on philanthropists at this point.

"Quite honestly, donor funding is never going to be enough," Tom Adams, the U.S. State Department's Haiti special coordinator, told the Miami Herald. "In some areas, we are really just starting, because we wanted it to be a Haitian-led effort, not a donor-led effort. We are criticized for not having spending the money faster, but in some ways that's a virtue. To spend intelligently, it has to be done in partnership with the government and other donors."

HUFFPOST INFOGRAPHIC:

SLIDESHOW:

Haiti's Slow Recovery
1  of  7
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
In this Jan. 5, 2012 photo, a woman wears a T-shirt with the name of President Michel Martelly as she walks through the Beaubin camp for people displaced by the 2010 earthquake in Petionville, Haiti. Two years afterwards, more than half a million Haitians are still homeless, and many who have homes are worse off than before the Jan. 12, 2010 quake, as recovery bogs down under a political leadership that has been preoccupied with elections and their messy aftermath.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST IMPACT

Thursday marks the second anniversary of the Haiti earthquake that killed 316,000 people, but experts say it could be at least another 10 years before the country sees any noticeable recovery. Don...
Thursday marks the second anniversary of the Haiti earthquake that killed 316,000 people, but experts say it could be at least another 10 years before the country sees any noticeable recovery. Don...
Filed by Eleanor Goldberg  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 278
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
11:34 AM on 10/28/2012
i am sitting at this monent in an orphanage in port a prince haiti reading these comments.... i am from minnesota....it would be valuable for me to know which of the people who comment have been to haiti.......the internet is loaded with comments by ignorant people who have never experienced anything that they comment on.....please read and learn from the comments of those who have been there and do the rest of the world a favor and dont comment.....
11:43 PM on 03/21/2012
I have evidence that Salvation Army (Armee Du Salue) in Delmas 2nd in Port-au-Prince misused the money they raised. They spent the money on themselves. The hotel they stayed they force the owner to start serving steaks even though that was not part of the menu. Because of that the owner of the hotel charged an arm and a leg for the stick. The workers drive expensive SUVs and spend the money in the Hills of Port-au-Prince where the rich people live.

How do I know all that? I volunteered with them it killed me watching all happening. I dinned with senators and in high class French restaurants in Haiti with the money they raised to help the Haitians. The restaurant is owned by a good friend of the person in charge of the Salvation Army center in Haiti so they spend a load of money there. My God, a glass of wine was like $30USA.

I have witnesses. Want to know more? contact me GlobalReachLLC (at) gmail (dot) com
10:44 AM on 02/13/2012
I really did not know much about the crisis AFTER the earthquake until I watched "Haiti: Where did the money go?" on PBS last night. I learned that conditions 20 months after the earthquake are deplorable with 500,000 people living in tent cities with 200 people per latrine which are not cleaned. Most outrageous are the NGOS, apparently running Haiti in absence of a working government, which cannot meet the most minimal standards of shelter, clothing, food, and sanitary conditions despite receiving BILLIONS of aid dollars. In fact, only 7 cents of every dollar donated to Haiti get to Haiti. The other 93 cents comes back to the US. Haiti can not hope to progress until basic human needs are met.

At the end of the program, I asked myself "What can I do to end this horror?" but the program had just one suggestion: investigate an NGO before you donate money. I find this suggestion totally unrealistic. How can an average person tell if an NGO is doing an adequate job when it seems difficult for even experts to account for NGO spending? Having received billions of dollars, could the Red Cross or ANY NGO point to anything worthy of bragging rights? I want to do something but am reluctant to donate money to any NGO. What should I do? What should the US do? Clearly we are failing to require adequate oversight. What should Congress do? What is right?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patblue
12:10 AM on 01/29/2012
One of the reason Haiti is so po.or is because they had to pay "back" France over billions of dollars because France was hurt about Haiti revolution and wanted to hurt Haiti.. Not to mention the United States putting an embargo and outlawed all trade in Haiti.
06:12 AM on 01/13/2012
What s the birth rate? Who got rich on the money sent? Maybe we should study this and give the examiner s jobs...2 more years of commercials pleading.
12:42 PM on 01/16/2012
Haiti has a birth rate is 24.4 births per 1000 which translate to a fertility rate is 3.07 children per women, which puts it behind other Guatemala, Belize, Honduras and Bolivia in the Western Hemisphere.

NGO executives and the contractors, most of which American, they hired got rich. Haitian contractors were awarded less than 5% of contracts while Haitian government received 1% of the donated money.
06:01 AM on 01/13/2012
I bet Japan, that just got hit with a tsunami, looks better than Haiti now.
04:02 PM on 01/13/2012
Japan looks better because it had some of the strongest earthquake resistant codes on the planet & the money to build to those standards. Haiti never did - it is not the quaking itself that causes many casualties, it is the poorly constructed buildings collapsing on people that pushes the death toll up in the thousands. Even in the US, we can be vulnerable to death by poorly constructed buildings - especially now that fracking by the oil & gas companies is causing some moderate to severe quakes in areas that had no history of quakes and thus no building codes requiring resistance. Better hope you are never a victim of a poorly built building!
05:55 AM on 01/13/2012
Please America, send us more money so we can buy more food to breed more children that we can't afford to feed.
04:10 PM on 01/13/2012
How are people who lack shelter & food supposed to come up with the $$$ for contraception in order to meet your qualification for being deserving of assistance. And before you say celibacy costs nothing, remember that the homeless women in Haiti have no way to protect themselves against unwanted advances from men - its not like they have the option of locking themselves in their homes and calling out for pizza to feed their families! Some may also be trying to feed their kids without resorting to crime by selling the one thing they've got left - their bodies! Your next incarnation should be as a girl born in the slums of the world somewhere so you can get a clue!
12:06 AM on 01/14/2012
The definition of insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different outcome. Why don't you help Angelina Jolie raise 10 billion for Haiti, get Bono from U2 to record a song, and then I'm sure the problem will be solved.
05:35 AM on 01/13/2012
I don't mean to be unsympathetic, but how many people were homeless before the earthquake? Haiti is a poor country and needs help but so do poor people in the US. Why are we in the US responsible for taking care of the problems of the rest of the world? Why can't they get off of their keysters and work to get themselves out of this mess instead of still living in a tent after two years and waiting for others to give them a free handout! So.. I"m going to send money to a charity so they can pay their rent and not get any of it to where it's intended to go ? Maybe the Haitian Government, who is very rich, can take care of their own people?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:26 AM on 01/13/2012
o bbamma prints lots of money ,he will take care of this problem.
04:39 AM on 01/13/2012
I can not believe what I have read about my donations I have been sending to help the people of Haiti, I am a old man of 75 in years, I do not have much money then my S.S Check each month.
But I have found a way to save some from each monthly check to send to Haiti for the poor folks. And to read this made a tear run down my cheek.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
adam646l
"Lib" is not a dirty word.
04:55 AM on 01/13/2012
Sir, with all due respect, you must have a word with your priest, minister or physician. How wonderful that you participate while some sit back and do nothing. I do not know much about these things, however, it would seen that the money has not been terribly mishandled. God bless you and keep you.
05:56 AM on 01/13/2012
You are a sucker, and you deserve to be ripped off.
04:13 AM on 01/13/2012
Because Haiti gets hit by strong hurricanes every few years...and is a hot, humid country, building with reinforced concrete has a lot of good points. Concrete is cheap, keeps you cool and is strong enough to withstand hurricane winds. But in an earthquake prone region, concrete is a terrible idea without strict code enforcement....something that has always been lacking in Haiti, a country riddled with corruption from top to bottom. Contractors mix in too much sand and stint on the necessary rebar. Then, they pay off the inspectors...should any turn up. When a good shake comes along poor people have always gotten crushed under the rubble. But in fairness to the Haitians, even though there have been earthquakes in the past, there has never been one as severe as this gargantuan one.
A possible solution: use of steel ship-container boxes for permanent housing. There is a glut of them around the world now that the world economy has contracted and they can be purchased from some languishing shipping companies for next to nothing. Yes, these containers are small, but they are also incredibly strong...and the sides can be torched out and joined together with others, or even stacked one atop another. Entire apartment complexes can be fashioned by welding these small rectangles into imaginitive and futuristic looking structures....and the welding and acetalene torch cutting for windows and doors is the kind of work that would give alot of semi-skilled men employment opportunities.
03:13 AM on 01/13/2012
Clearly, These people are stupid and can never rebuild anything.
04:33 AM on 01/13/2012
No, not stupid...just arrogant and undisciplined. You can't tell a Haitian anything. In fact, you can't get a word in edgewise. They are know-it-alls who quickly reveal themselves as knowing alot about nothing....the result of being cut off from the rest of the Americas and Europe by their unfortunate past. While others in this hemisphere were transforming themselves, Haitians stayed mired in the thinking of the 1700s....a legacy of their decision to break away from French rule. Talking to a typical Haitian is like having a conversation with a modern day Robespierre. One quickly tires of their wild suppositions, idiotic conclusions and non-stop inanities. Their slave ancestors took advantage of French weakness during the French Revolution and drove out their masters with very little trouble. Then, when Napoleon sent several thousand of his troops to re-take the island public sanitation had deteriorated to a point where typhus and malaria were rampant. Most of Napies men died of disease shortly after disembarking. In spite, the French turned their backs on the island...and Southern legislators in our congress did the same thing...fearful our own slaves might get ideas. Thus...centuries of isolation...and a sort of creeping madness to the culture.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
metalsmithgirl71
Just say NO to GMO's!
06:16 AM on 01/13/2012
wow. i read that four times.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
adam646l
"Lib" is not a dirty word.
04:59 AM on 01/13/2012
Wow dude! You are "smart enough"to sit in judgment of these good people but not terribly "swift" with a suggestion as to how you might be able to help the good people of Haiti.

You should be ashamed of yoursef
photo
kasel1
Sarcastic physicist, musician, author
02:49 AM on 01/13/2012
"...the money clearly didn't all get squandered." These people are criminals. Fund drives and benefit concerts and relief funds. And who gets the money? Not the people who need it. this is why for charity, I try to give actual needy people food and shelter or money. They may squander it, but at least that's their choice. Give it to established charities and guerillas in Africa, staffers in the US, and countless other gangsters wind up living the good life while people starve. Welcome to the human race.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
lifehub
I don't answer (to) libs.
05:02 AM on 01/13/2012
The celebrity shows and music entertainments for charities should always be held suspect to begin with. The money claimed to be made from many of these so-called charity events are not double-checked by anyone to make certain it's going to the charities at all. Keep in mind that when 9/11 occured, not only was their massive fraud and theft regarding donations, but the director of American Red Cross was fired for same fraud and theft of donated monies.

The Humane Society of the United States pulls the same lowly stunts with the animal shelters they claim to 'donate' to and 'help'---only1%, if that. The rest goes to executive salaries, bonuses, and valuable perks. Don't take my word for it, see it for yourself at humanewatch.org.
Steve68112
Provoking thought through sarcasm
02:43 AM on 01/13/2012
Never donate money to any organization if the president, ceo, or lead director is paid more money than you. That is the first clue they have more money than they need or that they do not know how to manage it. In this case, with over $3 billion in donations, the story said there are still over 500,000 homeless and they helped a whole 1,000 people return home. Really? wtf? And their 'help' probably consisted of putting up 'signs' saying it was now ok to return home. BIG deal. For this amount of money they could have purchased BRAND NEW construction equipment, bulldozed out entire ruined sections of the city, installed sewers, running water, electricity, and built new housing for most of them, plus water treatment, sewage, and power plants. Not fancy housing, but new and sufficient housing nevertheless. These aid groups are more about themselves than really providing serious help. They could even have had money to put up some schools and minor medical facilities and ultimately stop the cycle of poverty. These groups are an embarrassment to the Western Hemisphere, as is the pathetic uncoordinated action of the U.S. We give huge aid amounts to countries around the globe who are ready to stab us in the back at a moments notice, but we can't give a relatively tiny amount to help these people who are literally on our doorstep, just because they appear to have no resources we want or strategic value to their territory. Shame.
02:05 AM on 01/13/2012
I'm sorry people stole or some how lost the money but that picture they showed looks like call of duty zombies