iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Babies Learn To Talk By Reading Lips, New Research Suggests

Babytalk

LAURAN NEERGAARD   01/16/12 02:55 PM ET  AP

WASHINGTON — Babies don't learn to talk just from hearing sounds. New research suggests they're lip-readers too.

It happens during that magical stage when a baby's babbling gradually changes from gibberish into syllables and eventually into that first "mama" or "dada."

Florida scientists discovered that starting around age 6 months, babies begin shifting from the intent eye gaze of early infancy to studying mouths when people talk to them.

"The baby in order to imitate you has to figure out how to shape their lips to make that particular sound they're hearing," explains developmental psychologist David Lewkowicz of Florida Atlantic University, who led the study being published Monday. "It's an incredibly complex process."

Apparently it doesn't take them too long to absorb the movements that match basic sounds. By their first birthdays, babies start shifting back to look you in the eye again – unless they hear the unfamiliar sounds of a foreign language. Then, they stick with lip-reading a bit longer.

"It's a pretty intriguing finding," says University of Iowa psychology professor Bob McMurray, who also studies speech development. The babies "know what they need to know about, and they're able to deploy their attention to what's important at that point in development."

The new research appears in this week's issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. It offers more evidence that quality face-time with your tot is very important for speech development – more than, say, turning on the latest baby DVD.

It also begs the question of whether babies who turn out to have developmental disorders, including autism, learn to speak the same way, or if they show differences that just might provide an early warning sign.

Unraveling how babies learn to speak isn't merely a curiosity. Neuroscientists want to know how to encourage that process, especially if it doesn't seem to be happening on time. Plus, it helps them understand how the brain wires itself early in life for learning all kinds of things.

Those coos of early infancy start changing around age 6 months, growing into the syllables of the baby's native language until the first word emerges, usually just before age 1.

A lot of research has centered on the audio side. That sing-song speech that parents intuitively use? Scientists know the pitch attracts babies' attention, and the rhythm exaggerates key sounds. Other studies have shown that babies who are best at distinguishing between vowel sounds like "ah" and "ee" shortly before their first birthday wind up with better vocabularies and pre-reading skills by kindergarten.

But scientists have long known that babies also look to speakers' faces for important social cues about what they're hearing. Just like adults, they're drawn to the eyes, which convey important nonverbal messages like the emotion connected to words and where to direct attention.

Lewkowicz went a step further, wondering whether babies look to the lips for cues as well, sort of like how adults lip-read to decipher what someone's saying at a noisy party.

So he and doctoral student Amy Hansen-Tift tested nearly 180 babies, groups of them at ages 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 months.

How? They showed videos of a woman speaking in English or Spanish to babies of English speakers. A gadget mounted on a soft headband tracked where each baby was focusing his or her gaze and for how long.

They found a dramatic shift in attention: When the speaker used English, the 4-month-olds gazed mostly into her eyes. The 6-month-olds spent equal amounts of time looking at the eyes and the mouth. The 8- and 10-month-olds studied mostly the mouth.

At 12 months, attention started shifting back toward the speaker's eyes.

It makes sense that at 6 months, babies begin observing lip movement, Lewkowicz says, because that's about the time babies' brains gain the ability to control their attention rather than automatically look toward noise.

But what happened when these babies accustomed to English heard Spanish? The 12-month-olds studied the mouth longer, just like younger babies. They needed the extra information to decipher the unfamiliar sounds.

That fits with research into bilingualism that shows babies' brains fine-tune themselves to start distinguishing the sounds of their native language over other languages in the first year of life. That's one reason it's easier for babies to become bilingual than older children or adults.

But the continued lip-reading shows the 1-year-olds clearly still "are primed for learning," McMurray says.

Babies are so hard to study that this is "a fairly heroic data set," says Duke University cognitive neuroscientist Greg Appelbaum, who found the research so compelling that he wants to know more.

Are the babies who start to shift their gaze back to the eyes a bit earlier better learners, or impatient to their own detriment? What happens with a foreign language after 12 months?

Lewkowicz is continuing his studies of typically developing babies. He theorizes that there may be different patterns in children at risk of autism, something autism experts caution would be hard to prove.

___

EDITOR'S NOTE – Lauran Neergaard covers health and medical issues for The Associated Press in Washington.

Click through this gallery of seven more amazing things you probably didn't know about babies:
Loading Slideshow...
  • Their Baby Cuteness Doesn't Predict Adult Attractiveness

    A study published in the journal <em>Infant Behavior & Development</em> revealed that the standard "<a href="http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCQQtwIwAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch?v%3DXTV8bOv3Jhs&ei=0uLBToKrMuPu0gHkmNH0BA&usg=AFQjCNFtutJJhlTFZJ2fm-cmsDo46XMpzw" target="_hplink">You Must Have Been a Beautiful Baby</a>" has little to do with reality. When 253 college students were asked to rank photos of the same individuals as infants and young adults (without being told who was who), there was <a href="http://bodyodd.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/08/31/7542626-must-have-been-a-beautiful-baby-maybe-not" target="_hplink">no relationship between how cute the students found the babies and how attractive they found the grown-ups</a>.

  • They're Good At Sharing

    No, really, it's true. It doesn't matter how many times you've heard the shout "Mine!" -- research shows babies can sense fairness at 15 months. During one study at the <a href="http://www.washington.edu/news/articles/babies-show-sense-of-fairness-altruism-as-early-as-15-months-1" target="_hplink">University of Washington</a>, 47 babies observed videos of an experimenter distributing milk and crackers to two people. When one recipient received more food than the other, the babies paid more attention. That means they had expected a fair distribution. The researchers also found that babies who did notice unfairness were more likely to share their own toys.

  • They Read Minds

    OK, so they're not exactly psychic. But a <a href="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/11/111101130204.htm" target="_hplink">recent study</a> from the University of Missouri found that babies just 10 months old are starting to follow the thought processes of others. Yuyan Luo, an associate professor of developmental psychology who conducted the study, tells The Huffington Post, "Babies, like adults, when they see something for the first time -- when something is surprising -- they look for a long time. It shows [they recognize] something is inconsistent." It's called the "violation of expectation," she explained. When babies are surprised by something or notice something unexpected has happened, they tend to gaze at that thing longer. In Luo's research, babies watched actors consistently choose object A (such as a block or a cylinder) over object B. When an actor then switched to object B, the babies stared for about five to six seconds longer, meaning they recognized the change in preference.

  • They're A Little Bit Racist

    Don't judge a book by its cover. Treat all people the same. We're all equals. These are sentiments parents strive to teach their kids from a very young age. And they should. Starting, like, immediately. Researchers at the University of Sheffield in the United Kingdom found that babies at three months <a href="http://www.world-science.net/exclusives/060212_racefrm2.htm" target="_hplink">begin showing a preference for the faces of people of their own race</a>. But not all hope for equality is lost. The same study showed that babies who are exposed to people of all different races are less likely to develop bias at such an early age.

  • The Rhythm Is Gonna Get Them

    Researchers from Brigham Young University found that five-month-old babies can <a href=" http://news.byu.edu/archive08-oct-babymusic.aspx" target="_hplink">identify an upbeat song as being different from a series of sad, slow songs</a>. In other words, they are happy. They know it. They will clap their hands. Or stare longer, as the case may be. The experimenters showed babies an emotionless face while music played. When they played a new sad song, the babies looked away. When the music pepped up, the babies stared for three to four seconds longer.

  • They Can Tell The Good Guy From The Bad Guy

    Babies have a sense of morality at six months old, <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1275574/Babies-know-difference-good-evil-months-study-reveals.html" target="_hplink">say Yale researchers</a>. During the Yale study, babies watched a puppet show in which a wooden shape with eyes tried to climb a hill over and over again. Sometimes a second puppet helped him up the hill, and other times a third puppet pushed him down. After watching the act several times, the babies were presented with both puppets. They showed a clear preference for the good characters over the bad ones by reaching to play with the good puppet.

  • They Can Read Lips ... Kind Of

    Dr. Janet Werker of the University of British Columbia, who studies how babies perceive language, found that if a mother spoke two languages while pregnant, her infant could <a href="http://www.livescience.com/13016-bilingual-babies-brain-language-learning.html" target="_hplink">recognize the difference</a> between the two. And they don't even have to be spoken out loud. Werker's research found that infants four to six months old can <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/11/health/views/11klass.html" target="_hplink">visually discriminate two languages</a> when watching muted videos of someone speaking both.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST PARENTS

WASHINGTON &mdash; Babies don't learn to talk just from hearing sounds. New research suggests they're lip-readers too. It happens during that magical stage when a baby's babbling gradually changes fr...
WASHINGTON &mdash; Babies don't learn to talk just from hearing sounds. New research suggests they're lip-readers too. It happens during that magical stage when a baby's babbling gradually changes fr...
Filed by Jessica Samakow  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 35
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
05:29 PM on 01/20/2012
What about blind people ? How did they learn to talk ?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brianna Cole
Which one wins? The one you feed.
12:11 PM on 01/23/2012
Obviously by listening. They aren't afforded all of the benefits of people with sight I suppose. The article said nothing about *not* being able to speak if you couldn't read the lips.
photo
LivelyLexie
Don't panic.
10:00 AM on 02/01/2012
Wondering the same thing, and if they learn to speak later.
photo
phoebequeen
I blame the dog
08:25 PM on 01/18/2012
Not sure I agree with this. When my son was a baby and wouldn't stop screaming and go to sleep, I would tell him,"Shut the f&ck Up!!! and go the hell to sleep!!!," he never seemed to understand. Hmmm.... strange.
06:32 PM on 01/18/2012
I have a niece who is almost 5. She learned to talk at an early age, and I think it is mainly from 1. Being talked to all the time, and 2. Being read to all the time. At her age, she has an amazingly large vocabulary, always wants to know the meaning of a new word, and can spell words pretty closely to how they're spelled. Every time I see her she has learned more words and I am constantly amazed.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
alsm9
Bombshell
04:05 PM on 01/18/2012
This is exactly the conversation me and my Dad had a couple of months ago. My nephew is 11 months now but we notice at around 5-6mths that he wouldn't look us in the eye for very long when we talked to him. He was watching our lips move as we spoke. My Dad said he believed he was reading lips. :)
01:04 PM on 01/18/2012
my younger brother just had his first child (i dont have any yet), i did not know this. this is great to know.
10:03 AM on 01/18/2012
Well, now we know why plopping our kids down in front of the tv does NOT help their language skills, the mouths are not moving appropriately. Sit and play with your children, look at them when you are talking to them, and they will develop.
08:47 AM on 01/18/2012
What parent didn't already know this? If you spend ANY time at all talking to a baby, you can see them watch your mouth as you're talking to them. Soon, the baby will start moving his/her mouth in the same way as you and try to make the sounds you're making. Why did this need researchers to "study" this? It's not a new phenomenon; it's been happening since language began, I have no doubt..
08:13 AM on 01/18/2012
I don't know if parenting is the correct venue to raise this question. I am an empty-nester,
senior with a guinea pig. I don't expect him to speak but I would like him to squeek more.
He looks at me intensly like the babies mentioned in this article. I have him in the
kitchen under a table in the corner. His eyes follow me around as I move around the
kithcen. But lets get back to squeeking.
His fav food is his apple. I tease him by holding it outside the cage. That doesnt
make his squeek. I put it in the cage and then take it out, all the time laughting.
That doesn't do the trick either.
The only time he squeeks is when I take him out of the cage..
I think he is "saying" I want to get back in my cage. I sit him on a towel
on my lab and tell him how pretty he is (he is multicolored) or how the kids are
waiting for him outside. I put him ouside about 30 minutes a day. And here comes
the kids, all screaming, "Louie (his name) is outside!"
If any of you commentators have any suggestion as to how to make him
squeek please e mail me at richardff572@aol.com. Thanks
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marianproletarian
04:59 PM on 01/18/2012
Love it. Maybe Louie is lonely and needs a friend to squeek to.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
keedyk87
07:51 AM on 01/18/2012
They can also naturally think before knowing any words. Words are a way of expressing thoughts , not thinking itself!
06:57 AM on 01/18/2012
I wonder how much grant money they got for this study! ANY MOM can tell you that this is how babies learn to talk!

Definitely not a "hands on" dad -------> "Babies are so hard to study that this is "a fairly heroic data set," says Duke University cognitive neuroscientist Greg Appelbaum, who found the research so compelling that he wants to know more."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
keedyk87
07:53 AM on 01/18/2012
I know, but because they have College degrees given to them by mainly those with a few degrees of intelligence we are supposed to emulate them.
BloodGlutton
I'm not likely to even read your angry response.
11:28 AM on 01/18/2012
You two are questioning the necessity of this study without even remotely considering the help it could offer to those with brain injuries? Wow - guess you're both right - we've learned everything about the human body we need to - time to quit and only study those things the two of you consider worthy. Sheesh.
06:22 PM on 01/17/2012
Any first-year linguistics student can tell you that! Who's funding these quacks and why won't they give ME any money? I'm a philologist, too, damn it!
05:12 PM on 01/17/2012
I teach parenting classes to teen moms and I always encourage them to look directly at their babies when they are talking with them. You can almost see the little wheels spinning in a baby's brain while they decipher the words. Babies are amazing!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sulk
04:15 PM on 01/17/2012
The pediatrician was examining a newborn for the first time. He said, My what a beautiful baby. The mother said, Oh you say that about all the babies. The doctor said, No, I just say that about the babies that are truly beautiful. The mother said, Well, what do you say about the babies that are, you know, not quite so beautiful? The doctor said, Ahh, the baby looks just like you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marianproletarian
02:46 PM on 01/17/2012
Lots of face-to-face time communicating with and engaging your infant is a good way to get an early talker, which makes for far fewer tantrums/fussy moments.
01:57 PM on 01/18/2012
I agree. I once thought teaching sign language from the beginning was an intriguing way to help eliminate frustration tantrums - until a friend of mine tried this, and it has been disasterous. The poor child is always angry, now at two and a half years old, her vocabulary is scant - save screaming NO!!!, and becomes especially livid when someone does not sign with her, or does not do it to her standard of perfection. Sadly, no one wants to be around the poor child.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marianproletarian
02:18 PM on 01/18/2012
That's sad. I think it's a myth that babies don't talk until close to a year, anyway. They are talking. They may make up their own language, but they are talking. My son spoke really early on, starting at 5 months with mimicking how I would say "hiiii kitty.." every time the cat jumped on his changing table, he's say "iyyyy yeeyeeee!" At 8 months he could not say feet, so he called his feet and shoes "doots," so he could tell us when he wanted his shoes on or off. He called his grandma "Baba," breastfeeding "ish," his lovely blanket "Ishy," etc. His use of these words was not very overt in the begninng, so we had to really be paying attention to realize he'd made up a word, but it worked out well. At 5 people are still amazed at how well he speaks and what big words he uses. Language has always been his strong point, so I'm not insinuating other children who are not verbal are not being paid enough attention to, but I do believe many don't realize their babies can communicate verbally early on because they aren't looking for it.
photo
phoebequeen
I blame the dog
08:27 PM on 01/18/2012
Maybe she can be friends with Coco the chimp?
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]