More

Microsoft 'Avoid Ghetto' App Sparks Controversy (VIDEO)

First Posted: 01/19/12 06:53 PM ET Updated: 01/19/12 11:53 PM ET

These days it seems like there's an app for everything. But one app has stirred mixed emotions in its attempt to help make pedestrians' lives a little bit easier.

Microsoft is being slammed for its new feature that some have dubbed the "avoid ghetto" app, although it still does not have an official name. The app is meant to help anyone traveling on foot avoid bad weather, tough terrain and unsafe neighborhoods, NPR reports. It uses a combination of information from maps, weather reports, crime statistics and demographics to give users a comprehensive route recommendation. But while some say it is an innocent GPS system that features important information, others criticize it for reinforcing negative assumptions about certain neighborhoods and the people that live there.

According to the company's "Pedestrian Route Production" patent the app is simply a device pedestrians can use to determine the most effective route to their final destination.

"As a pedestrian travels, various difficulties can be encountered, such as traveling through an unsafe neighborhood or being in an open area that is subject to harsh temperatures," Microsoft states in its patent. "A route can be developed for a person taking into account factors that specifically affect a pedestrian. Moreover, the route can alter as a situation of a user changes; for instance, if a user wants to add a stop along a route."

But as Sarah Chinn, author of "Technology and the Logic of American Racism," told NPR, despite appealing to an understandable desire to feel safe, the app could reinforce stereotypical views of certain races and socio-economic classes.

"In much of dominant American culture," she told the news outlet. "There's an assumption that criminality and being poor and not white go hand in hand."

Others said the app isn't targeting anyone in particular because of its use of crime statistics.

"I don't think anybody from any particular race is being singled out because they are using crime data to come up with these figures," said Loop21.com editor Maurice Garland, who also wrote a humorous piece on the subject for the website. "If you don't want to end up in those places, I don't see anything wrong with somebody trying to help you out."

According to the 2010 FBI crime report, whites were arrested more often for violent crimes that year than any other race, NPR reports. But Dallas NAACP president, Juanita Wallace, told CBS Dallas that the app is discriminatory because most people assume African Americans commit more crimes.

"It's almost like gerrymandering," she said. "It's stereotyping for sure and without a doubt; I can't emphasize enough, it's discriminatory."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BLACK VOICES

These days it seems like there's an app for everything. But one app has stirred mixed emotions in its attempt to help make pedestrians' lives a little bit easier. Microsoft is being slammed for its...
These days it seems like there's an app for everything. But one app has stirred mixed emotions in its attempt to help make pedestrians' lives a little bit easier. Microsoft is being slammed for its...
Filed by Danielle Cadet  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 453
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (13 total)
10:16 AM on 03/14/2012
Oh, and I'm Puerto Rican coming from a Puerto Rican neighborhood. YES I avoid that neighborhood because there is alot of crime over there, though not all Puerto Ricans are violent criminals. For the most part I can survive, but I'd rather not risk it anymore. I'd say THIS will make community leaders and business owners get together to fix up their neighborhoods. Can't sit around waiting for the government nor the police(who are already absent in these neighborhoods that they don't patrol) I'd say bring it on. I can't wait to get it.
10:13 AM on 03/14/2012
there's already an app for this though. that Zillow thing where it shows the property value, automatically leads you to believe the lowest priced real estate is in a high crime area because of property value
10:07 AM on 03/14/2012
maybe this app will make people clean up their acts...seems only logical to me
10:00 AM on 03/14/2012
I just downloaded it and it told me to get out of Hartford. it's not different then the app for letting you know where the pedophiles or sex offenders are...if you're offended it's because you just might live in that area or have some business in it.
photo
Dahveed1
Rational discussion is the basis of a democracy.
07:42 AM on 01/28/2012
This is ridiculous. This app is going to help visitors stay out of dangerous neighborhoods. It sounds like a good thing to me. Its only based on crime reports, so its going to keep you out of bad areas regardless of race. Crime reports a public information, so I hope other developers create similar apps for other phone OSs.
10:40 AM on 03/14/2012
there's Zillow, and the Sex Offenders list too..this is nothing new, I don't see sex offenders being offended!!!
08:24 PM on 01/26/2012
It's sad that people are leaping to conclusions about what this App could mean. If it takes into account strictly crime statistics then how does this become an issue of race? If your afraid that your neighborhood will suffer because of this as of yet nonexistent app, get off your butt and do something about your neighborhood! I think it is pathetic that so many people whip out the race card because they are to lazy to take responsibility for their neighborhoods and what goes on in them.
10:02 AM on 03/14/2012
Exactly. I'd be happy as hell to get that app if it guides me away from being shot at.
09:42 AM on 01/26/2012
It is not called the "Ghetto app" by Microsoft. Users came up with that name. As much as some people would like, they cannot and have no right to determine what people think.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Layla Portier
The world is a vampire...
10:45 PM on 01/25/2012
I don't find the app racist. The app is basing it's directions off crime statistics, not the community's racial breakdown. On the contrary, I think it's racist to assume that the areas with high crime rates are going to be populated by minorities.
10:03 AM on 03/14/2012
you do know there are high crime areas that are predominately white right?
09:28 PM on 01/23/2012
If a neighborhood is offended because of this app TOO BAD TOO SAD, you have made it what it is so get some pride (get off your a--) and clean up your neighborhood and stop thinking everyone "OWES" you!!!!!!!!!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NerdyStudent
Sorry, your micro-bio doesn't meet our standards
01:26 AM on 01/23/2012
As someone who lives in North St. Louis City, owns a business there, and also loves to develop/utilize his WP7 handset, I couldn't care less.
photo
JasonMcl
8(Na) + 8(Na) = BACHMAN
04:19 PM on 01/22/2012
I would like to see an "Avoid Country Clubs" feature on navigation apps. Lest my delicate nose catch a whiff of the infectious air of superiority that seems to float around those unsavory places.

I dare say I would be most put out were I to catch an airborne case of the snoots from some bypassing fellow wearing a white shirt, white shorts with a pink sweater tied around his waist.
09:31 PM on 01/23/2012
Jason, you just made yourself the snob by your comments..... do you not enjoy having a nice place to go and enjoy good friends and good food? and no I do not belong to a country club nor do I enjoy the trashed neighborhoods!
photo
JasonMcl
8(Na) + 8(Na) = BACHMAN
08:07 AM on 01/24/2012
I think you missed the point.
10:04 AM on 03/14/2012
he was being sarcastic....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John Crane
12:51 PM on 01/22/2012
Contrary to the lady from NAACP, North Dallas is totally different from South Dallas, which hasn't changed one bit from the 70's. Driving through North Dallas on the Central Expressway, the road on which I used to commute, I scarcely recognize anything for all the change and spectacular growth. Dallas is definitely growing and expanding, but it is not evenly spread throughout the city, and all of this BEFORE and regardless of any Microsoft app.

Back in the 70's a lady was driving in downtown Houston, made a wrong turn and got lost. She ended up raped and murdered. This app could have saved her life.

I lived in Chicago for a year. I went to visit a business establishment in North Chicago. I had to drive around looking for a parking place. I found out later that the store I wanted to visit was in a very nice area, but it was also a block away from Cabrini Green, one of the most dangerous parts of the city. Not being from the area, I didn't know that. Thanks to a guide book, I was able to avoid the area and stay safe. Another time, I took a wrong turn and wound up somewhere on Chicago's west side. It was night. Until I was able to navigate out of the area, I was literally in fear for my life. I wished I had some kind of a guide to get the hell out of that area.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
authorized-user
No right way to do a wrong thing
11:56 AM on 01/22/2012
the "avoid ghetto" app,---Baltimore?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GaryNOVA
Fear My Micro-bio!!!!!!!!
07:21 PM on 01/22/2012
yah basically
10:34 AM on 01/22/2012
Unfortunately and sadly, statistics are compelling and everyone – and I mean everyone, even if it’s not spoken about in polite company – is well aware of them. In the U.S., whites outnumber blacks by roughly 258 million to 38 million, or about 7 to 1. Meanwhile, a Dept. of Justice report on homocides from 1974 and 2004 showed that 52.2% of killers were black and 45.8% of killers were white, an almost 1 to 1 ratio. The unfortunate but rational assumption to make is that any random black male on the street is 7 times more likely to murder you than any random white male on the street. (Remember the famous observation by Jesse Jackson on this topic?) Significantly, for those who cry "racist," the “Avoid Ghetto†app may be more useful to black people since blacks murder blacks at a higher rate than whites murder whites. Nobody wants to be murdered, of course, black or white. If it means avoiding certain neighborhoods, then that’s what you do.
01:00 PM on 01/22/2012
If you've ever taken a class in any university's Stats department, you would understand the "magic" of statistics, and the fact that you can create your own narrative with Stats and it doesn't always represent the real world, particularly when only viewed alone.

For example: When looking at the numbers alone it might appear that blacks commit more crimes (not true) than whites. But without taking into account social stigmas, created by a number a sources (mainly media), and the result of those stigmas being implicit racism, outright racism and also institutionalized racism, you wont begin to see the actual story. If you have two parts of town, East and West, both have equal crime committed but the police force is dedicated overwhelmingly to the West, you will then have more arrested and jailed on the West (and as a result, the stats to backup your reasoning for police force to continue to go BACK to the West...and the cycle continues).

To get around this reasoning and the magic of stats (sometimes, not always magic) you have to look at things from an historical perspective. Blacks are no more violent than whites when looked at over recorded history.
06:51 AM on 01/22/2012
Who needs an app?

If the street sign says "Martin Luther King Dr." then lock the doors and HIT IT!

There are still some simple truths in America.
01:12 PM on 01/22/2012
I see no mention of the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr., or streets name after him, in this article

I note, also, that I once worked very happily at a store on a MLK-namesaked street, and served customers from various ethnic groups without once encountering violent crime.

So your "simple truths" are really reflections of something quite simple about YOU (which I need not say).
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GaryNOVA
Fear My Micro-bio!!!!!!!!
07:23 PM on 01/22/2012
either that or it's a Chris Rock joke. lighten up.