iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Middle East Christians Keep Wary Eye On Arab Spring

Christianity Middle East

First Posted: 02/ 1/2012 6:57 pm Updated: 02/ 1/2012 6:57 pm

By Oren Dorell and Sarah Lynch
USA Today

CAIRO (RNS) From her home, Samia Ramsis holds a key chain bearing the face of the Virgin Mary as visitors outside come to look upon the spot where Egypt's Coptic Christians believe Mary, Joseph and the infant Jesus found refuge after fleeing Bethlehem.

Once crowded with Christians, Cairo's Coptic quarter where she lives with her husband, Mounir, and two children is now home to fewer than 50 Christian families.

"We know many Christians have left," said Mounir Ramsis, speaking not only about this quarter but about all of Egypt. "But we love this country and will stay until death."

The Arab Spring uprisings that toppled secular dictatorships have unleashed long-suppressed freedoms that have allowed Islamic parties to gain a share of political power they have been denied for decades. Their rise is creating near-panic among ancient Christian communities that dot the Muslim world and predate Islam by centuries.

In Tunisia, where the regime of President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali was ousted last year after 32 years in power, the dominant political party, Ennahda, has worried some of Tunis' 22,000 Catholics by vowing to tilt the country's yet-to-be-written constitution toward Shariah, or Islamic law.

In Libya, Christians are uneasy as the powerful head of the Tripoli Military Council, Abdul Hakim Belhaj, who once led an Islamic militia with links to al-Qaida, has said he plans to run for office in elections scheduled for April.

In Afghanistan, no new building permits have been issued for churches, and the last church open to the public was demolished over the summer. In Iraq, the Christian community has decreased by two-thirds since 2003 amid bombings of churches and assassinations of priests.

And Christians in Syria, where Muslims have risen up against President Bashar Assad, have been subjected to murder, rape and kidnappings in Damascus and rebellious towns, according to Christian rights groups, including Open Doors, which helps Christians facing persecution.

Many had hoped for better in an Arab movement that proponents said was about replacing tyrannies with democracies.

"The outlook is grim," said John Eibner, CEO of the California-based human rights group Christian Solidarity International.

"If the current trajectory continues, it's reasonable to think that within a generation these (Christian) communities will not look like functioning communities," Eibner said. "They'll look more like the once-flourishing Jewish communities" across the Arab world that are all but gone.

Nowhere is the irony more profound than in Egypt, where an estimated 8 million Christians live with more than 70 million Muslims.

Christians demonstrated alongside Muslims early last year to oust Hosni Mubarak. Before Mubarak's overthrow, Christians had suffered from years of church burnings and murders at the hands of radical Muslims who want an Islamic state free of religious minorities. After the ouster, the military regime that has been running the country has refused to make any arrests in attacks on Christians.

Mina Bouls, 25, a Copt who fled to Philadelphia, recalls cowering with his mother in 1997 as a mob stoned the family home and chanted anti-Christian slogans. But the difference then was that Mubarak ordered the military to protect Christian communities and jailed extremists, Bouls said.

In October, Copts organized a protest in downtown Cairo over the authorities' failure to investigate attacks, including the bombing of a church in Alexandria on New Year's Day 2011 that killed 20 people. The military attacked the demonstrators and 17 Christians were run down and killed by military vehicles, according to Human Rights Watch.

Bouls wants to bring his family to the U.S. because he says he is petrified by the new society forming in Egypt. The first free elections in decades held in the past two months handed power not to moderates but to members of the Muslim Brotherhood and radical Salafi candidates, who combined took nearly 70 percent of seats.

"If people try to rule the country with the Quran, with Shariah law, that means they look to us as second-class people," Bouls said.

Christianity has existed in Egypt since the second century. The Muslim Brotherhood, a political movement that seeks a nation run according to Quranic law, has said Egypt would respect the rights of religious minorities.

The Salafis, Muslim fundamentalists who want a complete application of Shariah law that generally denies equal rights to women and religious minorities, also say Copts are safe in Egypt.

"Even if there are Salafi leaders who proclaim Copts to be heretics, this does not mean that (the Copts) must be subjected to any religious or (legal) sanctions," said Emad Abdel-Ghafour, head of the al-Nour party that won 25 percent so far in parliamentary elections.

Abanob Magdi lives near Egypt's largest pyramid and says he is not optimistic about what lies ahead.

"I saw on TV the other day a Salafi saying that if they get in power, beaches will be divided for men and women and women will have to be veiled," Magdi said as he walked through Coptic Cairo with friends.

Christians account for 4 percent of the people of the Middle East and North Africa. Despite being the birthplace of Christianity, the region now has the fewest number of Christians (13 million) and the smallest share of its population that is Christian of any other major geographic region, according to the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life.

The future of minorities in the emerging democracies of the Middle East "is a huge issue most vividly seen in Egypt and the Copts," said California Rep. Howard Berman, ranking Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee. "It's on our agenda as we figure out how to help these countries," and their treatment of Christians and other minorities is a "red line" that will affect future aid.

(Oren Dorell and Sarah Lynch write for USA Today.)

FOLLOW HUFFPOST RELIGION

By Oren Dorell and Sarah Lynch USA Today CAIRO (RNS) From her home, Samia Ramsis holds a key chain bearing the face of the Virgin Mary as visitors outside come to look upon the spot where Egypt's ...
By Oren Dorell and Sarah Lynch USA Today CAIRO (RNS) From her home, Samia Ramsis holds a key chain bearing the face of the Virgin Mary as visitors outside come to look upon the spot where Egypt's ...
Filed by Jahnabi Barooah  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
04:59 PM on 02/05/2012
A sad irony is that during the centuries when Europe executed people who didn't conform exactly to the Catholic Church's teachings, Muslims allowed Jews and Christians to practice freely.
09:50 AM on 02/25/2012
actually that is not entirely true. Christians and Jews had to pay a tax to worship if they would not convert. Also in Egypt and under sharia law- Christians cannot build new churches, and they must ask permission to repair existing ones
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thecla
Normal People Are Boring
01:38 PM on 02/05/2012
Let's understand this: Shariah law is NOT Democracy! It is Theocracy. Ask Iran. Ask Pakistan.
It would be a shame if the Near/Mid East go through this "Arab Spring" (a title I despise) only to end up in a perpetual "Arab Winter" (creepy . . . ), as countries such as Egypt and Tunisia begin to understand the (potential -- let's hope) theocratic monster they have unleashed.
Iran, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Afghanistan, Pakistan -- these are not happy places. I urge Muslims all over the world to ask themselves these questions: What has an Islamic Republic really done for its citizens economically? How much "freedom" within the practice of Islam actually exists in an Islamic Republic?
You best take a serious look around at the reality of what an Islamic Republic actually IS, Egypt, et al.! Is that what you really fought for? Is that what your family and friends really died for?
Theocracy is theocracy and Shariah law is totalitarian theocracy. Period. There is no ambiguity here.
Every culture, every language, has this saying: "Be careful what you wish, my dear, for you will surely get it."
09:01 AM on 02/04/2012
I think they should domwhat they think is right to them as relegion is is always ampersonal decision.
http://www.austinwoodfloorcontractors.com/Wood-Floor-Refinishing.html
www.txwoodfloorcontractors.com
www.woodflooringlifestyles.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joan E Freyer
12:57 PM on 02/02/2012
The dhimmi system in Sharia Law requires the sub citizen (described by some Islamic writers as being a sub species) to wear inferior clothes to show they are inferior, not ride superior elephants or camels or horses which today might mean not ride expensive cars, not wear their religious symbols openly, not celebrate their religion openly, and not enjoy anything deemed too superior to what Muslims enjoy.

The dhimmi's churches and temples can be burned down at any time by any Muslim, and then those churches or temples CANNOT be repaired or rebuilt.

A dhimmi do not have even 1/2 rights in Sharia courts of law, cannot dispute or defend themselves in anyway whatsoever, A Muslim can legally get away with murder of a dhimmi and not even have to pay a blood debt.

A dhimmi must pay jizya and pilgrim taxes and when paying the jizya tax must endure 'rites of humiliation to feel himself subdued' such as being shaken, shoved, spat on, or walloped by a slipper.

A dhimmi has no say in the running of the government of the land. He is a cash cow to be taxed to the profit of the Muslims.

The minorites who are still alive will not be for much longer when the Arab Spring turns to Arab Winter. Read the real history of Islam rather than chide people have have read the whole and uncensored history of Islam including Islamc slavery of dhimmi and non Muslims.


JEF
09:41 AM on 02/02/2012
First of all I am married to a Tunisian and there are NOT 22,000 Catholics in Tunisia. Enaadtha did not say they were going to implement sharia law. Egyptian Muslim brother hood never said they were going to implement sharia law. Hypothetically speaking even if they did decide to in the end it is THEIR right to do so. Americans would never tolerate any Muslim coming to the states telling them to adhere to the sharia law and the West should stay out of their way of governing as well. With respect to this article, I have many Christian Arab friends. The Christian Palestinians for example blame the Israeli's and Americans for their suffering NOT the Islamic world. The Quran clearly states there is no compulsion in religion so an idea of forced conversion is a fabrication. Christian Arabs enjoyed prosperous lives under the ruling Khaliphates in the past so this again is another fabrication. The idea that Christians are not given rights is another fabrication. In Islam there is a special set of laws for Non Muslims 1 prime example would be Christian men are allotted 1 wife and 1 wife only. Therefore they would have their own set of laws for marriages and divorce. I wish the west educated themselves more on Islam and the middle east. P.s. next time you write an article about Arab Christians try to use pictures of Actual Arab's. Eritrea isn't an Arab country!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:19 AM on 02/02/2012
According to wiki on Tunisia "The Christian community, composed of foreign residents and a small group of native-born citizens of European or Arab descent, numbers 25,000 and is dispersed throughout the country.[1] There are an estimated 22,000 Catholics.[1]".
Anecdotal evidence does not defeat facts, and notice that most of what you wrote is anecdotal ("I have some friends who prove my point"), uses false comparisons (the connection between the time of the Caliphate and today), and fails to consider the difference between what one is "ought" to do and what one "will" do. The Quran or Bible or Torah can say what they like, and they can be interpreted to mean anything. An example from my religion, Jews aren't allowed to force conversions on others. Yet, under the Maccabis, there is clear evidence that they did force conversions, but gave the people the choice to leave instead (making the conversion a "choice" and sidestepping the Law).
And Eritrea, while not Arab, is a semetic nation whose people and history is intimately connected to Arabs historically, culturally, linguistically, and genetically. So I understand why you're upset, but its not the worst mistake in the world.
11:37 AM on 02/02/2012
You are right on the fact that what Muslim's should do and what they do is a reality. Good point. Not he worst mistake in the world sure yet... Most American's do not know the difference between Eritreans and Arabs when you're speaking about Arab Christians one would think you would actually show Arab Christians. Not Pilgrims. Lastly about the whole Catholic thing. Wiki is not exactly the kind of source one would take to since I could go right now and change the numbers. I am sure you could agree with me when I tell you there are people who believe and practice a religion and than there are the pseudo members. In name only. The Jewish population (Cohen's) Which Israel wishes their return as they are one of the 12 tribes mostly on the Island of Djerba enjoy a very good life in Tunis. Most tend to be anti Israel go figure that one. The Christians on the other hand that are there mostly from Europe are not citizens. Law was put into place there so that non Tunisians would not buy up all the land like they did during the French colonization making it impossible for the Tunisian citizens to own. Any way long story short I will further investigate the validity of my statement of non Christians living there but I know for sure Christians and Jews are very well treated in Tunisia.
09:38 AM on 02/02/2012
Very interesting article. Obviously the former leaders were protecting the religious minorities because the minorities (Christians) are majorities in the West. However, after Arab protests against Western intervention in the Middle East, the new rulers have little regard for the West's opinion, and don't care if the West is angered over the treatment of minorities.

Still, the West said that they supported democracy in the region, and democracy means that the Muslim majority will rule. Democracy in such diverse countries (ethnically, religiously, etc.) will undoubtedly be full of obstacles- even more so perhaps than what is to be expected from the "bloody" period preceding a new democracy.
09:49 AM on 02/04/2012
Correction" The reason why former leaders like Mubarak were protecting minorities was because they were given billions of dollars in aid.
10:53 AM on 02/04/2012
Well, yeah... ;)

And much of that was to deter Egypt from going to war with Israel, and the largest Jewish community outside of Israel is in the US (with a powerful lobby).
photo
Veritas is Pro Life
Follower of Christ, Family Man and Marine
09:33 AM on 02/02/2012
I have read similar accounts of the tough times that Christians are facing in these countries "liberated" by the Arab Spring... we need to pressure the governments of these countries to protect their minorities or not receive US funds and we need to find "moderate" Islamists who can engage the more radical ones, in an attempt to work with them...Veritas.
CognitoErgoSum
CogitoErgoSum was taken when I signed up.
10:05 PM on 02/02/2012
The pressure you describe would be seen as foreign intervention and a challenge to their national sovereignty. Rights for minorities cannot be imposed from outside the society of the presence of the minorities will be seen as the reason for the imposition and resented. If religious minorities want rights, they will have to wge a hearts-and-minds campaign like the civil rights leaders everywhere else have done.
02:22 AM on 02/02/2012
There is more outrage in the Middle East and the wider Muslim world over a cartoon than when Christians are kidnapped, bombed and raped. A Saudi-style Islamic state or one similar to Iran are just as bad as life under the Caliphs. Whether Muslims want to accept it or not, the Dhimmi system and Sharia do not provide equal rights for non-Muslims as many Muslims enjoy religious freedom in democratic societies in the West and beyond.
09:34 AM on 02/02/2012
Eh, sort of. Any "rights" that are lost under an Islamic system are not significant when compared to those "enjoyed" in Western societies. Muslims, and most religious people, don't enjoy very much freedom of expression in the West, and are widely subjected to discrimination and violence.
12:07 PM on 02/02/2012
Muslims, and most religious people, don't enjoy very much freedom of expression in the West,
-------------------------------
Please tell us why you have come to this conclusion. I see Muslims every day freely expressing their views.