iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

California Dream Act: 'As An Undocumented Immigrant, It's Unfair That My Hard Work Might Not Lead To College'

Layouth

  First Posted: 02/11/2012 2:51 pm Updated: 02/11/2012 8:08 pm

This is a teen-written article from our friends at L.A. Youth, a nonprofit organization that helps teens advocate for themselves through journalism, literacy and civic engagement.

We’re running this story anonymously to protect the identity of the writer, who is an undocumented immigrant.

I’ve always worked hard in school because I want to go to college and be successful. But because I’m not a citizen, my hard work could be for nothing. My parents don’t have the money to pay for college and I can’t get federal financial aid because I don’t have a Social Security number. In October, Governor Jerry Brown signed the California Dream Act, which will allow undocumented students like me to get financial help to attend public colleges in California. This made me feel hopeful for my future. However, the state Dream Act doesn’t provide a path to citizenship. Even if I graduate from college, would I have to work in a low-wage job? Will my status prevent me from obtaining my dream job as a journalist?

I think it’s really unfair that I can’t get the same opportunities as a citizen. I grew up here like any other student. Some people say that undocumented immigrants are criminals because they came here illegally. But I don’t consider myself a criminal because it wasn’t my choice to come here. My parents brought me here because they believed they could provide a better education and a better life for me and my sister.

When I was two, my parents left my older sister and me with my grandma and came to the United States. They were trying to give us a better life than what they had in Mexico. We were living in a small one-room house and my sister and I were sharing a bed with our parents. Their plan was to live in the United States for a few years and then return to Mexico once they made enough to buy a house in Mexico, pay for our education and open a business. But they stayed because they weren’t able to make enough money. We were brought to the United States right before I turned three and my sister was five because my mother missed us and she couldn’t bear being apart from us. Three years later my little sister was born here and a few years after that my brother was born.

Once I was here for a few years I forgot about Mexico and the United States became my home. I liked McDonald's for the toys in the happy meals. One of my favorite things to do was watch cartoons, like Ren & Stimpy, Looney Toons and Animaniacs. I didn’t know English but the TV shows were helping me learn it.

When we were young my mother would tell us to do well in school so we wouldn’t end up like her and my father. I don’t think they understood that attending college was hard if you’re undocumented. They worked as street vendors. They’d wake up at 3 a.m. to prepare the champurrado, a drink like hot chocolate. They’d leave the house at six a.m., carrying the champurrado and heavy pots full of tamales. They’d get home at 10 a.m., rest, and then prepare for the next day. They always seemed busy buying ingredients and making the tamales. But they still dedicated time to my sister and me. They’d wake us up and get us ready for school. My mom would take us to school with her cart full of tamales.


FOLLOW HUFFPOST HIGH SCHOOL

This is a teen-written article from our friends at L.A. Youth, a nonprofit organization that helps teens advocate for themselves through journalism, literacy and civic engagement. We’re running ...
This is a teen-written article from our friends at L.A. Youth, a nonprofit organization that helps teens advocate for themselves through journalism, literacy and civic engagement. We’re running ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 491
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
diverjay
The Depth of Liberal Hypocrisy is Beyond Fathom.
11:22 AM on 04/19/2012
First, to the teen who wrote this story, job well done!

As for the person who is the subject, there are no shortcuts to citizenship. If you want it, go back to Mexico, stay with some relatives, and immigrate legally just like everyone else has to do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:55 AM on 04/19/2012
Interesting that the choice of going to a private university, something out of the reach for many of us, seems to be the objective. The rest of the article in the link:

"My sister... chose Northland College, a small private school in Wisconsin.­.. They offered her $14,000 in scholarshi­ps to help her pay the tuition and housing costs, which were about $32,000 a year...My parents had to pay $1,000 every month but it was difficult.­.. At the end of my sister’s first year of school, they owed $7,000... My sister had to return home without getting her report card since my parents didn’t pay the bill."
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:53 AM on 04/19/2012
My kids had their academic scholarships "re-allocated" to fund two programs including the full 4 yr scholarship for students that are the first in their family to attend college. In addition, both kids were awarded Federal Pell Grants but one of the two universities withheld the funding to pay for other students to meet the "Texas 2015: Closing the Gaps" quota. Both were awarded $5500 a year. One at one univ got he full amount, the other at a diff univ only got $590 of that fed fund.

In order to pay for the state universities, I left my home and family, moved across the country to a higher paying job and the girls took out private academic scholarships that the universities could not touch.

In exchange, the universities have an extremely low graduation rate and failure rate midway through the program. A total waste of money. TWU is the worst.
01:35 PM on 03/31/2012
Sorry to tell you sweetie, anything pass post secondary education is a privelege, not a right See the UN Universal Human Rights (1948). It as privelge even for American citizens. The DREAM Act is proven to cause an infrastrutural nightmare.

If California's version of the DREAM Act is any indication of the outcome of it on a grander national scale, then we are truly screwed. My brother in law an Mexican American Citizen graduates from high school in May but due to limited resources and classroom overcrowding, he will not be able to get into school until next Fall... and even if he feels that kinship towards you, this is most certainly not his dream.

He can only enroll in two class when he is allowed to enroll but full time is four classes and even with the limited and highly need funding he will receive, he will still need to take out a loan. For a four year degree in California, he will be in six figure debt by graduation. All because funding had to make room for the Dream act? So again whose dream are we facilatating?
07:53 PM on 03/18/2012
I invite you to read "La visita de Dermot"
Nearly everyone today has a pretty good idea of what being an illegal immigrant is like for adults. We are constantly being bombarded with stories about men and women who have risked it all to come to America. But seldom do we ever get any real feedback on how it feels to be an illegal immigrant from a child’s perspective illegal immigrant children are being left out in the cold. No one seems to care that they miss abuelo and abuela, or the friends they had to leave behind. How many people have actually stopped and asked an illegal immigrant child what their dreams are for the future? Don’t you think its high time we get a close-up view of what illegal immigrant life is truly like from a child’s point of view? After five years, the book written in Spanish “La visita de Dermot” was born and published at amazon.com
They are four teenage boys. Coming from Chile, Peru, Mexico and Colombia, they wander with innocence through a world of displacement and illegality, a phenomenon so current to our times, that brings them great pain and uncertainty. They share their parents’ hardships, including the lack of work, work permit and the never-ending struggle to find a way to become legal U. S. residents. They live in a melting pot of mostly Hispanic and North American cultures while experiencing the storminess their uprooting generates.

Livia Cleary
02:24 AM on 02/23/2012
Want citizenship? Join the military. They pay for education too. Go ahead and show your patriotism.
01:45 AM on 02/23/2012
There’s nothing at all unfair about a sovereign nation determining that those who broke the law to come here and continue to break the law by staying are ineligible for benefits and privileges available to others. This kid *didn’t* grow up like any other student. He grew up in a country that owes him nothing, with people who have so little respect for us that they refused to follow the laws regarding entering the country.

And it’s a shame about the Dream Act. Because that’s all we citizens of the US are concerned about – providing the resources for somebody else’s kid to go to college. How is it possible that *this* kind of statement never appears in the mainstream news? All I hear is that immigrants just want to become citizens because they love the US. Yet here is one who, when given the opportunity to speak on a national stage, says nothing about our great nation, the benefits of being raised here, the privilege of being a part of the best country on Earth. There’s no gratitude for all he gained by growing up here, no recognition of the millions who would happily take his place, do it the legal way, and appreciate the opportunities that *are* available. No, all he wants to do is complain that we’re not doing enough for him. We’re not ponying up the dough for him to go to school. That sure makes me want to petition the government on his behalf. @@
12:12 AM on 02/23/2012
Hard to believe there are no colleges in Mexico or his national country.
06:27 PM on 02/20/2012
Its really unfair that as an American citizen I can't enroll in classes that illegal immigrants are in. Last semester I tried to bump into a full class and watched a guy from South Korea proposition 2 guys from China to marry his 'aunt', who is also here illegally. It was an interesting discussion. 16 people petitioned to get into the class including me; didn't get in.
My ancestors served in the military from the Civil War to the first Gulf War. Sorry you don't think its fair that you can't cut in on the legacy they left for their posterity. Be sure you know, you are wrong, this policy is wrong and there is a hard reckoning coming soon. Globalization is industrial feudalism and I'm not the 1% thats eating everyone's lunch.
unique
Animal lover forever
05:56 PM on 02/20/2012
We need to get rid of the Statue of Liberty,
"Give me your tired, your poor," etc.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
shankapotomus
11:58 AM on 02/14/2012
Just tell a democrat and they will be happy to take our money and pay for you education.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PivotalForce
Once a Marine, always a Marine
04:38 PM on 02/18/2012
I'm a Democrat, and I'm not for that at all. In fact, I'm disturbed that illegals are taking spots in the classroom that U.S. citizens could use. Illegals do not qualify for Federal funds to pay for college, but states can do what they want, and private schools can offer scholarships to whomever they please.

Getting a degree will frustrate them even more, because it's illegal to hire someone who doesn't have a green card or a valid social security number. So they'll be working the same low-wage, paid under the table jobs they could have gotten with just a high school diploma.
10:38 AM on 02/14/2012
Become a citizen. Its that simple.
04:53 PM on 03/29/2012
A lot of immigrants tried that route. They lost a lot of hard earned money just to have their petition denied.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:42 AM on 04/19/2012
Then your issue is with the state dept process.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reformtxcs
01:39 AM on 02/14/2012
The problem with making allowances here, and giving aid there is that as a country we are rewarding criminal behavior, even if it is to the child of the criminal who brought them here illegally. It's absolutely NO different than a child whose mother/father robbed a bank of hundreds of thousands of dollars and the house is repossessed in order to repay the bank for the theft. The child of the bank robber is left homeless of no fault of their own, but CRIME should not pay and should not be rewarded regardless of how far down the family tree the person could potentially profit or gain (monetarily or otherwise).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:48 PM on 02/13/2012
Well it doesn't look like our immigration laws are going to be enforced anytime soon so I'm sure you can do what my daughter did an many more deserving American citizens did, get a student loan and pay for college. What an idea, you can actually pay for your education just like actual citizens have to do.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reformtxcs
01:36 AM on 02/14/2012
They get free scholarships....nothing to repay.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PivotalForce
Once a Marine, always a Marine
04:40 PM on 02/18/2012
Not with federal dollars, although states and private universities can dole out cash as they see fit.
08:09 PM on 02/13/2012
BTW I paid my own way through college. From 6 years old I went without snacks & put my milk money and 10 cent/week allowance in the bank. From 13 I started working and put that money in the bank to pay for school. When I made it to college I bought only 2nd hand clothes on 1/2 price day at the Salvation Army, often ate only bread & water, never went to movies, restaurants, etc. I was a citizen but I didn`t ask anyone to pay my bills. I paid my own bills as I should have, and I had a great time because I had the dignity of knowing I wasn`t mooching off anyone. I worked and paid my own way.