iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Financial Distress Still Plagues American Families, Despite Increase In Jobs

Financial Distress Households

First Posted: 02/16/2012 5:21 pm Updated: 02/16/2012 9:24 pm

Seth was in his 20s on spring break in Florida when he fell into a debt trap. Alongside the cocktails on the beach and wet T-shirt contests were credit card companies, enticing young spenders with free food and apparel in exchange for signing up for a credit card.

"Credit cards started coming in the mail and I started using them," recalls Seth, who requested his last name be witheld for privacy reasons. "When I hit the limits I got credit increases very easily." When his credit maxed out on one card, he simply transferred his balance onto a new card with zero percent interest, allowing his debt to snowball until he owed $40,000.

With limited income, a dismal credit score and his spending spiraling out of control, Seth fell into financial distress, as did many other Americans swept up in the credit boom at the time.

Today, though he's gotten better at managing his money, Seth still can't get a credit card. And he's not alone. Despite a slowly improving job market, financial distress still plagues American families, according to the results of the latest Consumer Distress Index, released Wednesday. The index has shown alarming signs of Americans in crisis for 13 consecutive quarters, or 39 months.

Measured by non-profit credit counseling agency CredAbility, the index takes into account five indicators of financial well-being including housing prices, employment rates, credit, budgeting and net worth. All indicators are evaluated on a 100-point scale and a score that falls under 70 is considered failing.

Mark Cole, chief operating officer of CredAbility, said that even though the most recent index score rose to 67.6 from last quarter's score of 66.7, the results are in keeping with a trend in which positive results on one or two indicators are offset by two negative scores. In this latest index, falling net worth and shrinking budgets are what kept the average American household in distress.

Seth has improved his financial situation over the last five years. He's on stable footing when it comes to employment (he started his own business and is now self-employed) and has improved his credit.

That said, he has not since been approved for traditional credit cards. A stable retirement fund is a long way away.

Are you in financial distress? Email us at money@huffingtonpost.com and tell us about how you're coping.

CredAbility's Cole said he is particularly concerned about the latter issue, citing that a generation of Americans is heading into retirement without defined pension plans.

"The net worth number is the ticking time bomb," Cole said. "People have not saved nearly enough money for their retirement," he said, adding that this indicator has not scored well in the 31 years that CredAbility has been looking at this figure.

Budget and spending is another category Cole worries about. Like Seth, many American families are spending less, which puts the national recovery at risk.

"I don't find many people who feel safe and good about their jobs," Cole said. When stagnant wages and job insecurity meet rising gas and food prices, he added, discretionary spending is eaten up.

Cole pointed out that the states that contribute the most to the nation's economy -- California, Texas, Florida, Illinois -- are the ones seeing failing Consumer Distress Index scores.

"We've got to get growth in those states," he said.

Georgia, where Seth lives, is the 11th largest state in terms of gross domestic product. The state's unemployment rate is 9.7 percent.

While Seth was able to pull himself out of distress, those around him have not found such success.

"With my circle of friends I would say over a third of them are at a point where I was five years ago," he said. "More are having problems than are not."

FOLLOW HUFFPOST BUSINESS

Seth was in his 20s on spring break in Florida when he fell into a debt trap. Alongside the cocktails on the beach and wet T-shirt contests were credit card companies, enticing young spenders with fre...
Seth was in his 20s on spring break in Florida when he fell into a debt trap. Alongside the cocktails on the beach and wet T-shirt contests were credit card companies, enticing young spenders with fre...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 439
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
frank1946
Tell the Truth
11:10 PM on 02/20/2012
Occupy VISA/Mastercard would make the whole Movement Respectable !

Loan Sharks in suits.

Usury, excessive fees and interest which cannot logically be repaid by the borrower.
10:40 PM on 02/20/2012
Credit card companies love targeting college students. They "sell" them on credit cards telling them that it's a great way to build your credit. They're also an ideal target because it's probably their first time using 'credit' and first time being independent. As broke college students, they're enticed with "free money, aka available credit".
09:51 PM on 02/20/2012
I know I'm becoming a relic, seemingly all too soon. There's so much of the 21st century that I seem to have difficulty dealing with. In contrast to Seth's story; I was aided through college by the G.I. bill. I was extreemely poor then. I had to budget my finances & when I shopped for food I had to plan my meal expenditures down to the precise penny. I worked some @ a mexican restaraunt, doing dishes & waiting tables for additional money. I didn't play @ a vacation spot during summer "vacation", I worked as a guide/driver for a whitewater boating co. of western Colo.
I bought my first car for $75 in high school. A '40 model. The 1st time @ driving across town it burned 2 qts. oil in 20 miles. Insurance was $75/yr., liability for a teenager. Have always loved "old" cars. My wife's "newer" one lost the fuel pump. Over $400 and a day later (w/in tank pump); repaired. I've changed many ("old" kind) for < $30 & 30 mins.. Progress? My parents tought me thrift & financial responsibility. Concepts our political "leaders" seemingly cannot grasp.
I've never abided spend, spend, spend. If you don't spend what you don't have, you can probably keep your financial house in order. Oh so many victims of commercialized media. Who says you need an extravogent lifestyle to be happy?
photo
liberalbug
do you want fries with that?
09:03 PM on 02/20/2012
Seth is not a very sympathetic protagonist for this story. Just sayin'--bars and wet t-shirt contests, 40K of debt. Get bent.
07:16 PM on 02/20/2012
Seth racked up $40K in credit card debt. Not to pay for a life-saving medical procedure. Not to start his own business. Not to keep a roof over his kids' heads. Not to file a patent for his Better Mousetrap. But to party. Leave aside the obvious "grasshopper vs. ant" debate. Few here will debate (although there are some) that Seth got exactly what he deserved.

More interesting is the author's takeaway: poor Seth; Seth cannot get a credit card; Seth was "financially distressed". Given the absence of detail as to how, exactly, New Seth got himself out, we can infer that likely (a) Seth filed for bankruptcy, or (b) Seth's creditors wrote off his debts in whole or in part.

In either of those likely scenarios, Seth's creditors took a hefty loss. And Seth's creditors do not like losses. So they jack up the interest rates on the ants of the world. Thanks, Seth, you freeloading deadbeat.
11:43 PM on 02/23/2012
fyi i payed back every penny and then some, but its funny you think banks take hits, lol
07:04 PM on 02/20/2012
Blaming banks for Seth's credit problems is like blaming the TV informercial for my buying spree. Please, people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JoeBlough
The Horror. . .The Horror. . .
06:51 PM on 02/20/2012
Strangers will never take you by the hand and lead you to financial safety. You have to educate yiourself before you are taken advantage of. You are responsible for yourself.
05:15 PM on 02/20/2012
The conservative plague!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:33 PM on 02/20/2012
Seth is the liberal plague!
03:36 PM on 02/20/2012
Duh. "Seth" is/was a college student. Doesn't this imply that he understands some basic math? Or is this just another in a very long line of persons who just don't "get it." Or, is this another facet of persons who "want to get it" but can't. So they spend money they don't have?
Lets party like its 1999.
What is it these people don't seem to understand.
If you spend more than you make, you are in trouble.
You loose.
Its that simple.
GuiltyUndertaker
no se mata la justicia!
03:45 PM on 02/20/2012
"You loose"? Are you a college student?

It's telling people what they want to hear -- like taxes are the reason the economy is a wreck. They should know better, but they don't.
01:50 PM on 02/21/2012
Thank you for your reply Guilty. No, I'm not a college student. Anymore. Just a working, family man, trying to keep my head above water.
Indeed, I do believe that using credit not-wisely, is dangerous.
Money is a tool. Like all "tools" it needs to be used and used properly.

Banks and credit card companies rely on people "hearing" what they (banks/CC co's) WANT them to hear.
Using credit is not the same as your wife/gf asking "does this dress make my ass look big?"
Of course, if you want to maintain good relations, you ( I, at least) will reply in the positive, "no honey, that dress looks great."
The bank or credit card co. says "come in, sign up, use our card and henceforth your life will be great." That is what THEY want you to hear.
As a consumer, what you need to hear, loud and clear, is "I have to pay 21% interest on the balance, plus any other additional fees?"

The basic math part is, if you use credit cards and don't zero the balance due, each and every month....YOU LOOSE.
Just the way the banks and credit card companies want it.

FYI. There is now a movement among the banks and credit card companies to eliminate the zero balance no interest rule.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
El Chingaso
Fighting for mental superiority...
02:24 PM on 02/20/2012
When you smoke the credit card companies' dope -- and dwell in their fantasies -- you get everything you deserve, plus interest & late fees.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Fattonecat
whoops !!
02:02 PM on 02/20/2012
loan sharks
GuiltyUndertaker
no se mata la justicia!
03:27 PM on 02/20/2012
Yes the only difference is they don't break your legs if you don't pay. What they do is much worse.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptainObvvious
Calling me a liberal is a compliment!
01:18 PM on 02/20/2012
Seth can't get credit because Seth was irresponsible with nobody to blame but himself. He got credit cards, saw it as free money and went to town, now he's paying for it.

I got my first credit card when I was 17 (11 years ago) and I have never missed a payment, been late for a payment or paid a dime in interest, I always pay off my card completely every single month. I use my card for 100% of my purchases and my current balance is 0% and I collectively have $40,000 is unsecured credit limits. I have an almost 800 credit score as does my wife.

There are many things above our control. I sympathize with the people who are losing their homes and think the banks should help as they tanked the market leaving their customers stranded... I am a liberal who believes in this President's economic ideas... But we can't absolve people of personal responsibility, Seth is a dummy and made his own mess.
photo
fried52
"Just the Facts Ma'am Just the Facts"
02:19 PM on 02/20/2012
While I want to sympathize with Seth because I know what the banks and CC companies are capable of, I can't help but agree with you. You pretty much nailed it. Nice post.
GuiltyUndertaker
no se mata la justicia!
03:18 PM on 02/20/2012
If regulations of banking were in place, Seth wouldn't have had the chance to make a mess of his life.

When I was Seth's age, getting a credit card was difficult. The CC companies wanted to make sure they could have a reasonable expectation of payment. You had to have a certain annual income (which almost no one my age I knew had) to get one. Delayed gratification really was not that bad.

Sure, I balme Seth for being a fool. I also blame deregulation for allowing it to happen. As the saying goes, an ounce of prevention...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptainObvvious
Calling me a liberal is a compliment!
03:32 PM on 02/20/2012
The banks are responsible in that they made a terrible bet... However the fault rests squarely in Seth.

The mortgage crisis is different. People were told they could afford homes by supposed trustworthy experts who said an interest only loan was a great plan because in 5 years they can refinance and get a fixed rate and everything is going to be OK... Then through their own greed they destroyed the economy and got bailed out... Now they don't want to help their victims.

This kid got a credit card and racked up $40,000... He KNEW he would never be able to pay that back but did it anyway... There is nobody to blame but him. When I got my first credit card it had a $300 limit which I couldn't afford... I was responsible with it and I have a great credit rating.

The bank didn't make him spend $40k and juggle money between cards.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tosc
12:34 PM on 02/20/2012
job availability may be on a slight rise, but what is not being discussed or highlighted is that those employment opportunities pay less by the hour than previously, many have far less health insurance coverage or have higher copays. Retirements or pensions are all but an extinct employee bonus. There is having a "job" and being employed in the profession of your study and interest. I would contend that many of the "newly employed" took a " job" to maintain some kind of income and are not fully employed in their profession of study or interest. WE as an employed nation have taken two steps backward to the advantage of the big business. Just look at their profit margins for the tell tale signs of my theory.
photo
xpt2wndj
socialism sucks
08:46 AM on 02/20/2012
Under Obama we are looking more like Greece every day. Dim is as Dim does.
photo
MaxHeadroom
My Karma ran over my dogma.
11:40 AM on 02/20/2012
The only thing you know about "Greece" are what those stains are on the front of your shirt from eating to many fried pork rinds that cause people to dumb down. You ignorance about international and domestic economics is only surpassed by your ability to be so clueless on a public forum as you just demonstrated.

Thanks for the laugh.
05:13 PM on 02/20/2012
And you have absolutely nothing but insults, and cannot prove that the poster is not correct. The poster is absolutely correct, but fails to put Bush, Clinton, Bush 1, in that mix of bad presidents, with bad administrations, and an ignorant congress and senate that puts the icing on the cake.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptainObvvious
Calling me a liberal is a compliment!
01:13 PM on 02/20/2012
How are those austerity measures working in Europe? They're slashing pending to try and fix the economy and it is blowing up in their face... Proving that the GOP's method is a failure.

Of all the economically distressed countries the ones doing the best are the ones who didn't give in to austerity measures.

We're nothing like Greece.
05:15 PM on 02/20/2012
Right now! We are on our way though. Germany for many years starting in the mid 90s started to make austerity cuts, and it hurt for a while, drove their markets down. But they hit the ground running, and look at them now!
09:05 PM on 02/19/2012
What exactly did Seth buy and who forced him to do it. Don't blame the credit card company. Blame Seth who seems irresponsible. Can't he control his impulses and refrain from buying everything he wants?

Or is he entitled to everything he wants?
GuiltyUndertaker
no se mata la justicia!
03:21 PM on 02/20/2012
As I said earlier, and ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. When I was in my 20s the only credit card I had was from an oil company. I didn't make enough money to get a bank CC. Why is it different today? Deregulation, perhaps? Just as you don't let children near a bottle of ammonia, you don't let Seth near easy credit.
05:17 PM on 02/20/2012
So the ounce of prevention could have been the parents teaching financial responsiblity, or the schools? Schools wouldn't have a clue about financial education. This is not the fault of the bank, nor regulation.