More

HuffPost Social Reading

Kaitlyn Shorrock, New Haven Teach For America Teacher, Hits Stride And May Leave Town

  Melissa Bailey First Posted: 02/21/2012 11:38 am Updated: 02/21/2012 11:38 am

Teach For America Teachers
Wexler/Grant School teacher Kaitlyn Shorrock, a Teach For America corps member, gives a 7th grader a parting instruction as he leaves class Thursday.

This piece comes to us courtesy of New Haven Independent.

A year and a half after students welcomed the Teach For America recruit with a flash flood in her classroom, Kaitlyn Shorrock is emerging as a model teacher -- and weighing whether to continue her job at one of the city's most challenging schools.

Shorrock, who's 24, is one 30 TFA corps members in New Haven's public schools. Since the fall of 2010, the California native has been teaching middle-school science at Wexler/Grant School in Dixwell.

As the school goes through a "turnaround" focused on improving school climate, she has served as a standard-bearer to other teachers in her demanding-but-friendly classroom management style.

After putting in hours of class prep work on nights and weekends for 18 months, the energetic teacher is finding herself at a crossroads. Come June, she will complete her two-year commitment with TFA, a leading national not-for-profit focused on luring talented young people into urban classrooms and narrowing the racial achievement gap.

TFA takes recruits like Shorrock straight from college or graduate school. In lieu of a standard teaching certification, they attend a five-week summer TFA training course to prepare for the classroom—then take classes during the school year to earn their Connecticut certification. They commit to teaching for two years; they have access to one-one-one coaching and teaching support during that time.

Principal Sabrina Breland said of all the TFA recruits she has come across, Shorrock is "one of the best I've ever seen."

Shorrock "is a great role model, especially for the young teachers," said Breland.

When middle school teachers are struggling in managing student behavior, Breland said, she sends them to Shorrock "to look at how she's doing things."

As her two years wind down, Shorrock said, she hasn't decided whether to stay on with the students she's learned to love—or head back to California to her family.

Young teachers like Shorrock have been enlisted in New Haven's school reform drive, which calls for overhauling low-performing schools into turnarounds, where principals have the power to replace veteran staff. The city's long-running partnership with TFA, which began in 2006, is now targeting vacancies at turnarounds, where young teachers can infuse new energy into long-failing schools.

Shorrock's story highlights one drawback: These bright, hardworking teachers often pack their bags after two years.

FLASH FLOOD

Her voyage to Wexler-Grant began in the spring of 2010, when she was a senior at the University of California Santa Barbara. The environmental science major had already racked up some experience as an educator at a campus aquarium. She led field trips for students in grades K through 12, and rose to become head aquarist.

In the spring, as California's economy suffered, she sent out a flurry of applications to a variety of jobs across the country—including SeaWorld and TFA.

When she got a call back from TFA, she started studying the nation's achievement gap. She decided that "this is what I need to do." She'd be "doing the same thing" as at SeaWorld, "but making a difference in a field where they need us."

She applied to TFA at a time of rapid expansion due to a $50 million federal grant. The organization grew from 8,200 corps members in 2010-11 to 9,300 this year in 43 regions across the country.

As she ranked her most-preferred regions, Shorrock included Connecticut because it has a good aquarium (where she now volunteers). She graduated from college in mid-June. Within six days, flew to New Haven for induction into TFA.

She got hired by Breland, who had just taken over as principal of Wexler/Grant, a K-8 school serving 400 kids at 55 Foote St. Shorrock landed a job teaching science in the fifth to eighth grades.

After five weeks of training, she walked in the door of Wexler/Grant in the fall of 2010 as a brand new teacher. She quickly learned what she was up against.

One eighth-grade class informed her their last science teacher, also a TFA corps member, didn't survive one year. "How long are you going to stay?" the kids asked her.

It was a tough class. Shorrock admitted feeling "frightened, intimidated." During the first week, one kid pretended to trip in the science lab and pulled the cord to the safety shower, sending buckets of "brown, copper water" onto the floor.

"It just poured out," she recalled. An alarm started blaring. Within a couple of minutes, the room was flooded two inches deep.

Shorrock recalled watching, stunned, as her students darted out into the hallway in search of dry land.

"You can't let them see you cry," Shorrock recalled telling herself.

She took off her shoes, which were ruined in the flood, walked barefoot into the library, and taught her next class.

Shorrock laughed as she recounted the story in her classroom Thursday at the end of the school day. Then she wiped away a couple of tears.

"It's funny now," she said.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

This piece comes to us courtesy of New Haven Independent. A year and a half after students welcomed the Teach For America recruit with a flash flood in her classroom, Kaitlyn Shorrock is emerging a...
This piece comes to us courtesy of New Haven Independent. A year and a half after students welcomed the Teach For America recruit with a flash flood in her classroom, Kaitlyn Shorrock is emerging a...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 299
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:52 PM on 03/22/2012
Emotionally abused to teach your horrible children....poor teachers...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Morrison
Proud Dad, Engineer, Aspring Geophysicist
03:35 AM on 02/23/2012
Good work, Kaitlyn!

My daughter was a TFA corps member in Harlem for four years. Gosh, has she got some stories.

The kids could be rough, but her worst problems came from the principal, who made no secret of her disdain for TFA and her belief that whites shouldn't be teaching in her school.

Yeah, I guess racism works both ways.
09:35 AM on 02/23/2012
I hope your daughter has some respect for the people who have chosen to make this their life's work. This has been my issue with TFA…they teach for a short time and then all of a sudden are consultants who show little regard for the teachers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Morrison
Proud Dad, Engineer, Aspring Geophysicist
08:46 PM on 02/23/2012
She works at a non-profit that ensures that high school students who need computers for their education have them...As well as the training they need.

If not for her very snarky, racist principal, I think she would have stayed indefinitely. As it was, the principal made her life pretty difficult.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jp90
05:05 PM on 02/22/2012
You know, I admire this young lady for what she has been able to do in 2 years. Like folks have said here-she seems to be a natural at the job as well as hard-working. But I'm seeing the same thing here as we've all seen with these "great" new teachers (remember the Freedom Writers movie?) who have been lauded in books and movies. They don't stay. They may make a difference for a few years, then when the money comes calling in the way of speaking engagements/books/movies, they leave. This TFA teacher is essentially doing the same thing. It's hard to stay. But it does a disservice to the community and future students to dive bomb the profession, then leave for greener pastures.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:16 PM on 02/22/2012
She was a blessing for that school during the time that she was there and hopefully others learned from her example. BUT she is entitled to live her life and no one has a right to impose their priorities on to her life.

Her family is in California. Home is where the heart is and if she wants to go home or explore some place else, God speed. She's only one person. Her decision won't save or sink the entire school system.

Maybe she can write a book and inspire many...
09:47 PM on 02/22/2012
About what? This is about the kids, not her.
VA Jill
Retired RN, Army mom. Bring the troops home!
03:05 PM on 02/22/2012
Time to grow up, Teach. We all have to learn to live on our own, away from our families.
12:56 PM on 02/22/2012
It's too bad the writer didn't ask her if she planned to stay in teaching period. Or if this way of life is sustainable.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TINA ANDRES
How did this happen?
02:33 PM on 02/22/2012
Your wording is interesting because I do think that some of these TFA teachers probably consider this something like a Peace Corps position where they will pour in their heart and soul for a few years but never intend to make it their life's work. She is obviously a natural born teacher but it will be for her to decide if she wants to continue at this type of pace for an entire career (or life) and possibly never even earn enough money to own her own home. The bigger part of this story is that fact that I'm sure she is 1 in 100. The other 99/100th are spending two years as novice teachers and then leaving. It takes about five years to really get into a stride and become effective. I have supervised nearly 50 students teachers in my career and there are only two that I sent off to their own classrooms who were actually ready to be decent teachers their first year. It is all trial and error, lots more error than anything else in the first 3-5 years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ifquilt
04:38 PM on 02/22/2012
Well said, if she doesn't want to do it I say:
Run, little lady run! Before you sell your soul to the benefits devil.
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
06:24 PM on 02/22/2012
She's not obviously a natural born teacher, she's great at making her kids look like bad people for her glory. The amount of deficit language she uses to talk about her students sickens me as a teacher in South Central Los Angeles.
The fact that she has no problem leaving after just two years means she was never any good. Good teachers stay for the long haul. Glory hounds put down their kids and get themselves in the paper to pad their law school applications.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
refuse2fail
05:33 PM on 02/22/2012
EXCELLENT POINT!
12:39 PM on 02/22/2012
If she stays on she will be a real and professional teacher. If she walks, your child's wellbeing were just her hobby...something she can move beyond, put on her resume, and say to her friends...look at what a nice person I am to give up to years of my life to help the disadvantaged.

When teacher as hobbyists leave, there are abandonment issues left in their wake. These are the damages professional teachers spend valuable time mopping up and repairing our kids from.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
03:04 AM on 02/22/2012
One of the many problems with TFA is that the "teachers" they produce are often not in it for the teaching. They have other career aspirations but want the experience on their resumes. They always leave. Many of them do put in a lot of extra hours but they are young--they don't have families and they are running a sprint, not a marathon like real teachers. Many teachers put in 10-hour days--I did for the first eight years I taught until I realized that the work only multiplied to fill as much time as I would allow. TFA and the KIPP schools are often held up as models because they begin the day early, end it late, work on weekends, in other words, they are taking the place of parents who are unwilling or unable to do their job as a parent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Snow Horton
11:31 AM on 02/22/2012
No the biggest problem with TFA is that they don't offer the good packages that they used to. If you want the best people, you have to offer something. It used to be great for helping to pay off college, but these days, not so much. So they want to send you to the dumps of society, with kids who act like these kids do, and offer nothing in return. They used to pay off some student loans, but now they just make your payments for 2 years...that is hardly the same thing. Once they changed their payments they started to get real garbage. I can't feel sorry for them.
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
06:44 PM on 02/22/2012
No, the program is terrible, no matter what they offer the tourists that call themselves teachers.
03:40 AM on 03/16/2012
TFA still pays down some of your loans. You get approx. $5k each year you teach in "education grants" that you can use to either fund grad school or pay your existing loans. They also pay the interest on your federal loans while you're in the program. And you get "transitional funds" to help you move. My allotment was almost $5k. Some partner colleges also offer reduced tuition or special scholarships for TFA members who are looking at grad school. So...I don't know where you're getting your info, but it's incorrect. The effectiveness of the TFA program may be...debatable, but you're completely wrong in your assessment of the benefit package.
01:41 AM on 02/22/2012
i guess this article does get me thinking about why it is the teachers leave. bright students, or so it is said - what is a bright student, anyway? aren't we all bright students in a way? i would prefer to use 'passionate, caring teacher' - why do they want to leave? someone mentioned something about the administration. should teachers really have to put up with bad or even corrupt administration? can anything be done about it?
01:43 AM on 02/22/2012
i meant 'bright teachers' not 'bright students.' should have previewed it before posting! : )
photo
nypoet22
Psychology Ph.D., Civics Teacher, Songwriter
02:00 AM on 02/22/2012
1. working conditions (including administration)
2. test pressure
3. money
4. threat of layoffs
5. burnout

http://www.takepart.com/article/2011/08/09/five-reasons-teacher-turnover-rise
02:45 AM on 02/22/2012
could teachers come together and unite forces to fight for the students? inter-disciplinary learning! creativity! relevant curriculum fueled by the interests of the students! application! community involvement! and more!
09:44 AM on 02/22/2012
welcome to the great american government failure ...piublic education.
01:36 AM on 02/22/2012
just read the rest of the article. someone mentioned that teachers leaving after 2 years was not news. article is okay if you are interested only in knowing this fact.
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
06:30 PM on 02/22/2012
TFA teachers leaving after 2 year is not only NOT news, its par for the course. TFA people don't care about the kids they teach, they use them to look good for grad school apps.
That actually should be the story- why keep a program going that is expensive, has not resulted in the positive changes that they claim will occur, and puts non-teachers who don't care about kids in classrooms for short periods of time and abandon them as part of the plan?
TFA is a crime.
10:45 PM on 02/22/2012
No....sitting back and watching schools fail in the name of "respecting teachers" is a crime.

These schools in low-income neighborhoods are one big collective crime. TFA attempts to be a band-aid on a much larger problem. People attack TFA because they feel theatened.

The problem is poor teaching, poor administration, and doing the same thing over and over expecting different results.

Simply put, our schools of education do NOT prepare teachers to deal with the realities that exist in our low-income communities.

The other problem is pay....teaching needs to be a selective profession. But you can't be selective when you're paying $37k per year. At the same time, we shouldn't give big bonuses to teachers just for showing up.
04:03 AM on 03/16/2012
I may share some of your sentiments about the (questionable) effectiveness of TFA, but I think it's incredibly hyperbolic to declare that TFA teachers just "don't care about the kids they teach" and are only using the program to pad their resume.

Here's the thing: I'm a public policy major and a TFA member. I give a flip about what goes on in those classrooms and in the homes and neighborhoods of those children. So much so that I'm devoting my life to the pursuit of education equity. This doesn't mean I see myself in a classroom all my life. I chose to apply to TFA because I want to write education policy that isn't an affront to common sense. And, frankly, I don't think I can do that until I spend some time in a classroom.

So, yes, this means that I HAVE already planned my retreat from teaching--because I want to use what I learn during that time to work toward solutions on a bigger scale.

Quick!! Bring out the tar and feathers!! Burn me in effigy!! I'm a horrible person who hates children!!

Do you see why your generalization doesn't work? Is TFA a strategic move for me? Yes. But, ultimately, I want my life to serve those kids. And I want to see real, institutional change happen before I die. I know, I know: I'm awful.
01:34 AM on 02/22/2012
no offence, but after reading the first page of this article i felt a little bit miffed. i didn't want to hear about how the water 'ruined' her shoes - rather, i would like to hear more about the students. i understand that the article is about this teacher and Teach for America, but i would rather hear more about what the students have done on the first page of the article. i don't even really want to hear about Teach for America, its title and how 'bright' students go for it. i want to hear about the results in the students, what is happening there. is this about tooting a horn or really getting at what should be talked about - the students and how (what is being done in the classrooms) they are being provided with the best possible education?
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
06:35 PM on 02/22/2012
GREAT post. You seem to have the problems with TFA right on the head
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Laura Hayes
12:09 AM on 02/22/2012
Of course, TFA is a student loan payoff program and resume builder. The real star teachers are the veterans who guided her and who will STAY
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ifquilt
04:49 PM on 02/22/2012
Those star teachers will go without recognition.
11:55 PM on 02/21/2012
TFA is not a perfect organization....but the people attacking it need to take a step back.

Why do a majority of ALL teachers (not just TFA) leave within 5 years? People attack TFA teachers for not staying....but neither do a majority of new teachers.

I'll tell you why: many of these inner city schools are run by incompetent administrators. On top of that, the schools are ill-equipped to meet the needs of struggling students.

If a student falls behind in most schools, there really is ZERO PLAN about what to do with those kids other than to have them repeat the grade.
photo
MardiGrasGirl
At 65, you'd better not give me a d*mn voucher!
04:07 AM on 02/22/2012
You just described New Orleans to a tee.
10:28 AM on 02/22/2012
Learning starts at home. Ingraining the idea that education and learning is important.

Did you ever wonder why 1st generation immigrants or their children will often do so well? Its b/c the parentS emphasize education and EXPECT their children to take advantage of the public education they are receiving and to make the most of it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ifquilt
04:50 PM on 02/22/2012
EXACTLY RIGHT!
10:35 PM on 02/22/2012
All I can say is that most of my students' parents think learning is important....but may have a hard time supporting their kids because they're single, etc.
09:00 PM on 02/21/2012
What a great story. Whether she stays or goes, there will be students that at some point in their life will look back, as we all do on the one or group of teachers that enriched our lives. For her, those 2 years will serve her well no matter the course her life may take. She did what many no longer do, she went out of her comfort zone.
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
08:41 PM on 02/21/2012
Huffpo: just a little error in your article. TFA doesn't stand for "Teach for America" it stands for "Teach For A bit"
09:46 AM on 02/22/2012
tfa becuase grf (government run faliure)
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
10:08 AM on 02/22/2012
blah blah blah, more republican talking point garbage. We're talking about a polcy here, not being mindless partsan drones. Save the hackery ofr others
photo
David Flint
just ignore him.
04:56 PM on 02/22/2012
Would you prefer privatizing education? Could your parents afford to send you to a private k-12 school? Most can't, and if we "got government out of education" everybody but the rich would be uneducated. This obsession with the idea that everything the government does is a failure is silly, especially over the internet, which was developed by..... the government.