More

HuffPost Social Reading

Rahm Emanuel: Chicago Coal Plants Must Clean Up, Activists Call For Their Closure

Chicago Coal Plants Rahm Emanuel

First Posted: 02/22/2012 2:54 pm Updated: 02/22/2012 2:54 pm

Mayor Rahm Emanuel has put Chicago's two coal power plants on warning: Either present a plan to clean up their pollution or risk being shut down by the city within the next two years.

Various politicians, community groups and others have been pushing for more than a year to shut down the Crawford and Fisk plants -- owned and operated by Midwest Generation -- because they say the plants come with serious health consequences for the Little Village and Pilsen communities located nearby them.

As the Associated Press reports, Alderman Danny Solis (25th) and Dr. Ravi Shah of the Doctor's Council of the Service Employees International Union of Illinois on Wednesday are among those who have spoken out against the plants. According to Shah, the coal-fired power plants such as theirs are the largest generators of the greenhouse gases associated with respiratory problems.

Solis told the Chicago Tribune that he is "hopeful … that they negotiate a compromise by the end of the month."

Meanwhile, Jennifer Hoyle, a spokeswoman for the mayor, said that Emanuel has urged Midwest Generation to "clean up the two plants, either by installing the necessary infrastructure to dramatically reduce the pollution they emit or by converting to a clean fuel." If an agreement is not reached, the mayor will reportedly join the call for the plants' shutdown, according to the Tribune.

Fisk and Crawford are the subject of the ambitious Chicago Clean Power Ordinance, introduced in 2010 by Ald. Joe Moore (49th), that would implement new, strict regulations. The plants also became an issue during the 25th Ward aldermanic race last winter, after Solis, the incumbent alderman, was called out by his opponent Cuahutémoc Morfin by his initial reluctance to support the ordinance that would limit the plants' dangerous emissions of soot and carbon dioxide.

The mayor's call for the plants to clean up their act comes a week after the Chicago Clean Power Coalition demonstrated inside City Council chambers, urging Emanuel to "finish the work he has begun, and to not delay any further."

Both plants were built more than 100 years ago and generate emissions that would violate the federal Clean Air Act of 1977 -- except that both were grandfathered in under that law.

Late last month, the plants were identified by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency as the city's biggest industrial sources of pollution, the Tribune reports. In 2010, the two plants reportedly pumped 4.2 million metric tons of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, according to the EPA.

FOLLOW HUFFPOST CHICAGO

Mayor Rahm Emanuel has put Chicago's two coal power plants on warning: Either present a plan to clean up their pollution or risk being shut down by the city within the next two years. Various polit...
Mayor Rahm Emanuel has put Chicago's two coal power plants on warning: Either present a plan to clean up their pollution or risk being shut down by the city within the next two years. Various polit...
Filed by Joseph Erbentraut  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 152
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:46 PM on 02/24/2012
Fire up Zion the big mothballed nuke plant on Lake Michigan. Be up and running in a year.
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
10:02 PM on 02/25/2012
It's being broken up into pieces and hauled off to Utah so I think a year might be optimistic.
09:06 PM on 02/23/2012
It's the Chicago Way.

Rahm's just looking for shakedown money.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alvdh1
11:13 AM on 02/24/2012
Hogwash
01:34 PM on 02/23/2012
These plants are dirty and should be shut down. Let's build another nuke west of town as a replacement because it doesn't produce CO2 and runs 24/7.
photo
Romano54
honor does not have a price
10:04 PM on 02/23/2012
What makes you think "west of town" wants nukes? Cooling towers would look good as part of the skyline. There is plenty of land from the Olympic bid that went south.
01:24 PM on 02/24/2012
Siting new nuclear power plants is virtually impossible these days. It's one reason why the only two nuclear plants permitted in the last 30 years in the US are on a site where where two older plants currently exist (Vogtle).
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
10:03 PM on 02/25/2012
Difficult, yes.

We agree here.

I don't know about virtually impossible, but I am not aware of any new sites in the pipeline currently.
photo
Son of Liberty 1765
Exposing Government Lies.
11:51 AM on 02/23/2012
THey are grandfathered. I would fight Rahm and the leftist ruse makers at the SEIU. What is going to replace these plants? A wind farm on top of Emanuel's roof? The green canard is in full tilt now. These people are despicable. Over 100 years and now all of a sudden people are going to drop like flies if these plants stay open? riiiiiight. : i
01:42 PM on 02/23/2012
you ought to look at that asthma rates, and cancer rates in the neighborhoods they are located in, versus national and citywide averages. As a resident of the area, no people are just going to start dropping like flies, they already have been unnecessary sickness and death due to the plants and the smelter for years and years now.
photo
Son of Liberty 1765
Exposing Government Lies.
02:41 PM on 02/23/2012
THe entire Chicago area has higher rates. It is a city. You have far more emissions from cars and buildings than the plants. Lets ban cars and shutter buildings while we are at it.
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
10:05 PM on 02/25/2012
According to the Clean Air Task Force, 13,200 Americans die every year from inhaling microparticulate matter from coal burning, which leads to various bad health effects. We know that older plants also have less in the way of emission controls, both for MP matter and for other emissions.

This is great news for Chicago.
11:10 AM on 02/23/2012
quote -- " Both plants were built more than 100 years ago and generate emissions that would violate the federal Clean Air Act of 1977 -- except that both were grandfathered in under that law."
---------------------------------------------------------

It is time to transition to safe, clean alternative energy. Wind, solar, wave energy, geothermal and second generation biofuels made from algae, cellulose and waste are the future.
01:25 PM on 02/23/2012
Are any of those practical for Chicago?
01:30 PM on 02/24/2012
Exelon has a 10 MW solar park located on a brownfield site in West Pullman. Are you suggesting they aren't making any money with this, and are doing it purely as a public service?

http://www.exeloncorp.com/powerplants/exeloncitysolar/Pages/Profile.aspx

Do a search for wind power in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Minnesota, and beyond and you will find much the same. And the most affordable way to replace a power plant, just don't use the energy (let efficiency, retrofits, and conservation do all the heavy lifting).
10:44 PM on 02/25/2012
Nope
photo
Romano54
honor does not have a price
10:06 PM on 02/23/2012
How about geothermal and wave action? Those are clean options,
10:43 PM on 02/25/2012
Do you know of any geothermal hot spots in Chicago? Wave power isn't even close to being able to supply a city the size of Chicago. Solar and wind suffer from the storage problem. The only solution is a combination of nuclear power and natural gas.
10:33 AM on 02/23/2012
Those are some really old power plants.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thstolbe
09:56 AM on 02/23/2012
fu rahm.he's more corrupt than daly!
photo
mikey09
Living off the grid.
09:54 AM on 02/23/2012
Is there another power source ready to take over for these two plants?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TMS3100
Tea Party has run off with his light saber.
10:03 AM on 02/23/2012
If these plants are such the danger, then close the plants right now. Let the people of Chicago sit in the dark.
01:43 PM on 02/23/2012
the plants dont provide any energy to chicago, btw.
photo
Romano54
honor does not have a price
10:32 AM on 02/23/2012
Let Com Ed take over supplying power and raise rate. The mayor already gave them the fast track to screw consumers in exchange for their support.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DemFem
02:11 AM on 02/23/2012
All I can say is YAY!!!
12:27 AM on 02/23/2012
Some people still want to call Chicago / Detroit West a "world class city"....

Does a "world class city" lose about 7% of its population in a 10 year period as Detroit West did from 2000 to 2010?

NOPE... World Class Cities move up in population, not down. Detroit West made a mistake with daley. Emanuel isn't any better but the media and the Libs talk about the "great job" he is doing? Where are the results? What has he done?

Detroit West is sinking. Everyone knows it. Closing a power plant is the first step. Soon, Detroit West will be bulldozing three-quarters of the south and west sides because the houses are falling down.
photo
BVictor1
Chicago, My kind of town...
01:36 AM on 02/23/2012
World Class doesn't have anything to do about fluctuating population.

In terms of global or world cities, Chicago is ranked as an alpha city.

Detroit's west side? Really? How imbec!!ic.

They want to close it because it's not up to standards.

So it's the south and west sides that';; get bulldozed huh? Keeping the pristine 'white' north side in tact?

Seriously, what's the use of conservative$ in the world other than to pollute the air as much as a coal burning plant?
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
01:38 AM on 02/23/2012
Do you have a point?

Any point at all?
photo
BVictor1
Chicago, My kind of town...
01:49 AM on 02/23/2012
Other than to annoy, no...
08:53 AM on 02/23/2012
Detroit West is in decline. Is that understandable for a Lib?
12:22 AM on 02/23/2012
Another bad move by Chicago/Detroit West.

The economy in Detroit West is terrible. Power rates are skyrocketing, businesses are leaving, people are leaving at a rate of one person every 10 minutes, taxes were increased, jobs have decreased, oppertunity is leaving, roads and bridges are crumbling, welfare is up, unemployment is really up, property tax bases are plummeting, values are decreasing but the good news is.... is......is....

Isn't life under Lib Rule fun???? (Sarcasm)
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
01:37 AM on 02/23/2012
These plants had decades to clean up.

They are without a doubt contributing to deaths from pollution.

It's good that they are going.
photo
Son of Liberty 1765
Exposing Government Lies.
11:52 AM on 02/23/2012
Really? They have been running for 100 years, but all of a sudden they are responsible for deaths. Such a leftist canard.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
07:28 PM on 02/23/2012
Now if we could also get RID OF NUCLEAR!
04:29 AM on 02/23/2012
Who cares about coal or any other fossil fuel. They are already obsolete. Coal causes $500 billion dollars in damage to human health every year. All fossil based energy should be abandoned as soon as possible, and it happened yesterday, it wouldn't be soon enough.

Coal sucks and it's no longer needed. Grid Parity is here.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_parity
"Grid parity is the point at which alternative means of generating electricity produces power at a levelized cost that is equal to or less than the price of purchasing power from the grid. Reaching grid parity is considered to be an important point in the development of new sources of power, the point at which it becomes a contender for widespread development without subsidy support."

"...the suggestion that solar has already reached grid parity in a wide variety of locations. The European Photovoltaic Industry Association (EPIA) defines the moment at which the value of PV electricity equals the cost of traditional grid power as dynamic grid parity. However, this report was based on the prediction that prices would fall 36 to 51% over 10 years, a decrease that actually took place during the year the report was authored. The line was claimed to have been crossed in Australia in September 2011, and module prices have continued to fall since then."
photo
Romano54
honor does not have a price
10:33 AM on 02/23/2012
Clean, safe nuclear energy! Put up a couple cooling towers in Pilsen.
photo
Son of Liberty 1765
Exposing Government Lies.
11:53 AM on 02/23/2012
Yea, let's put solar on all of the roofs in Chicago and when the snow comes they will cave in because the structures were not designed for them.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jimmy Seidita
11:21 PM on 02/22/2012
Instead of Crawford and Fisk, these plants ought to be called Freddy and Jason, because they just won't die. It looked like their days were numbered beginning in 1977, when the EPA found that coal could be burned less lethally, and grandfathered these plants (for a brief period, they mistakenly thought at the time) while directing all new plants to use cleaner technology. The plants were already regarded as dinosaurs in 1999 when Com Ed unloaded them on Midwest Gen.

Since then, state regulators and the City Council have dithered while the neighbors and health professionals beg for relief. Midwest Gen, which could never have run such dirty plants in their home turf of California, figures they'll keep squeezing one more dollar out of the plants as long as the City lets them get away with it. The power is sold to customers outside the region, and will have no impact on our rates when the plants are closed.

The continuing operation of these filthy plants was a conspicuous black eye for the Daley Administration and always undercut its green cred. The other smokestacks in Chicago cleaned up decades ago. Mayor Emanuel please please please put these awful relics out of our misery.
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
11:28 PM on 02/22/2012
Hopefully Rahm can kill them.
11:20 PM on 02/22/2012
Bravo, Mayor, now what about solar and wind turbines that make the scrapers sing with the frequencies of life, no tri blades, bladless wind machine of whimsy and energy. The windy city?
Now for the wonder of it all, solar on anything, even stuff that moves and coal will no longer produce the mercury killing us down below.
To show support for clean air, the G8 will be in Chicago on 15 to 22 May 2012, supposed to be some sort of fight? A question what if we all, world wide wore the same colors while the world leaders discuss our future we will be reminding them world wide, we spend the money we are the labor, we are the people.
Green, Red, Orange, White, Blue, Yellow, and on the seventh day, Purple for our passion, we the 99% world wide, we don't need no riot police this time we do it so peacefully the cops will quit.
Got Sulfur?
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
10:53 PM on 02/22/2012
'Both plants were built more than 100 years ago and generate emissions that would violate the federal Clean Air Act of 1977 -- except that both were grandfathered in under that law.'

These plant operators had decades to build new plants or come into compliance. Meanwhile, they have been belching a disproportionate share of coal pollution into the environment. Older plants like these have much higher environmental impacts, and among these impacts is that 13,200 Americans die every year from coal-generated microparticulate matter.

I hope they are shut, and soon.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CaptD
Freedom From Nuclear Fascism...
09:11 PM on 02/22/2012
I wish Rahm would also tell the Nuclear Operators to clean up their reactors, each of which is a Trillion Dollar Eco-Disaster waiting to happen because Nature can destroy any land based nuclear reactor, any place anytime 24/7/365! (Ask The Japanese!)

How would the USA pay for a Trillion Dollar Eco-Disaster if Nature caused a meltdown?
photo
maslin
At 6 bn km, it's mostly small stuff.
10:30 PM on 02/22/2012
Hi CaptD,

I was pretty sure you'd be here defending coal plants, and look! Here you are, trying to change the subject.

Reactors are clean, and no American civilian has ever been harmed by emissions from nuclear power in its 40+ year history.

By way of contrast, roughly 35 Americans died today thanks to one form of coal pollution alone. The same number will die tomorrow. Emissions from coal power are worst from the oldest plants - like these.

Do you defend these plants?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nick Hatch
I'm So Meta Even This Acronym
11:03 PM on 02/22/2012
Not only does CaptD show up here to defend coal plants, s/he uses the exact same cut/paste phrase as always. I'm quite certain s/he is a cleverbot program. Seriously.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jimmy Seidita
11:28 PM on 02/22/2012
You're both right, in that we don't need any more coal plants or nuke plants. A combination of wind, solar and investments in efficiency is the only sensible way to meet our new energy needs in the near and medium term.

The numbers are in and are essentially irrefutable. From a cost and reliability perspective, wind, solar and efficiency win hands down. The only case for more coal or nukes is as government-imposed welfare to prop up dying and uncompetitive (not to mention dangerous) technologies.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
ChiGuy
Just an earthbound misfit, I
12:20 AM on 02/23/2012
Emanuel is mayor of Chicago. There are no nuclear reactors/plants in Chicago.
photo
Son of Liberty 1765
Exposing Government Lies.
11:53 AM on 02/23/2012
just the radioactive leftists.