Huffpost Politics

Republican Debate: GOP Candidates Face Off In Arizona (LIVE UPDATES)

Posted: Updated:

Republican presidential candidates Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum are looking to make a splash in Wednesday night's primary debate in Arizona.

The forum comes with the Grand Canyon State primary and Michigan primary less than one week away. Romney and Santorum are looking to build momentum in the upcoming contests ahead of Super Tuesday.

Newt Gingrich and Ron Paul will also take part in the event on Wednesday night.

(From delegates to Twitter followers, click here for a rundown on who's running ahead in the race for the Republican presidential nomination.)

Below, a live blog of the latest developments to unfold in Arizona.

live blog

Oldest Newest
@ samsteinhp : Santorum on Fox says Romney is right that the state mandate is lawful. still argues that it's the wrong approach

Share this:

Think Progress' Igor Volsky tweets this quote from Rick Santorum, who went into the spin room himself after the debate: "You've got to ask Congressman Paul and Governor Romney what they've got going together"

Paul and Romney do like each other on a personal level. But their political alliance has become one of the defining features of this GOP primary.

-- Sam Stein

Share this:
@ ZekeJMiller : Jan Brewer on who won debate: I think Mitt Romney had a great night

Share this:

“I always say if you want to know what foreign policy position to take, find out what Joe Biden’s position is and take the opposite opinion and you’ll be right 100 percent of the time,” Rick Santorum said during CNN’s Republican debate in Mesa, Ariz., on Wednesday night.

That’s not quite true. In fact, two of the most consequential laws passed during the Bush administration in the wake of 9/11 featured yes votes from both Biden and Santorum.

Both voted on the Authorization for the Use of Military Force, passed unanimoiusly, in the wake of the 9/11 attacks. A month later, in October 2001, both voted for the Patriot Act, passed by a 98-1 vote.

Of course, those votes came during the days when a bipartisan atmosphere prevailed in Congress as lawmakers rallied around President George W. Bush’s launch of the so-called war on terror in reaction to Al Qaeda’s attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.

But their unity was not limited to the early days of the post-9/11 era. In early 1995, for example, both men supported the Jerusalem Embassy Act of 1995, passed 93-5, resolving to move the U.S. Embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. That bill was left unsigned by then-President Bill Clinton, and despite becoming law, never led to the embassy’s move.

On the 2012 campaign trail, both Santorum and Newt Gingrich have stated that they will move the embassy to Jerusalem as a first move as president.

-- Mike Sacks

Share this:
@ ariannahuff : Judging by tonight's debate, you'd think the economy was a-okay.

Share this:
@ samsteinhp : Bob Dole prepared stm: "I've watched a lot of debates in my years. I've seldom seen a candidate shine like Mitt Romney shined tonight" #sure

Share this:
@ thegarance : Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer says debate was so "fabulous" that she's "even more confused" abt who to back. #CNNdebate

Share this:
@ aterkel : Donald Trump on Romney: "He'll protect us against OPEC." Whew. #cnndebate

Share this:
@ SarahPalinUSA : Newt's message on energy development was spot-on. Drill now and stop bowing to foreign regimes begging them to do...

Share this:
@ HuffPostPol : Big obstacle for Mitt Romney: His likability problem not solved by talking #CNNdebate

Share this:
@ zachdcarter : No tax policy questions on day Romney, Obama release new tax proposals. #CNNDebate

Share this:

The audience at the GOP debates has become perhaps as famous and newsworthy as the candidates themselves. In September, some audience members booed a gay soldier who asked a question about Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Then there were the times they cheered the death penalty and Newt Gingrich slamming moderator Juan Williams for asking about charges of racial insensitivity.

During Wednesday's debate in Mesa, Ariz., the audience booed moderator John King's question about contraception -- a topic much in the news lately -- and Rep. Ron Paul (R-Texas) for urging caution when dealing with Iran.

"Since the birth control is the latest hot topic, which candidate believes in birth control -- and if not, why?" asked King.

The question is was not crazy. Santorum has said that he personally does not believe in using birth control -- although he would not outlaw it for everyone -- and he doesn't think that health insurance should cover it.

Paul faced some boos when he said there was "no evidence" that Iran has a nuclear weapon.

Rick Santorum also faced a few boos after he defended supporting earmarks while in Congress.

-- Amanda Terkel

Share this:

The biggest obstacle between Mitt Romney and the White House has long been his inability to connect with regular voters, to get people -- even his supporters -- to like him as a person.

In wrapping up Wednesday's debate, Romney gave a glimpse of the aloof affect that can lead to that disconnect. CNN's John King asked each candidate to lay out what the greatest misconception about each was. When Romney's turn came, he reverted to his stump speech. King tried to stop him and remind him that there was an actual question on the table.

"You get to ask the questions you want. I get to give the answers I want," Romney told King, deploying the entitlement-tinged phrases "I get" and "I want" in the same sentence, coming off, for lack of a better description, as a class-A jerk.

"Fair enough," said King.

-- Ryan Grim

Share this:
@ samsteinhp : Romney actually directly lobbied the dreaded Arlen Specter for federal money

Share this:
@ piersmorgan : My verdict: 1) @newtgingrich 2) @MittRomney 3) @RonPaul 4) @RickSantorum #CNNdebate

Share this:

When Mitt Romney mentioned early in the debate the quagmire in Syria, where disparate opposition forces are engaged in a complex and sectarian-fueled battled against a brutal and increasingly violent regime, his analysis was skin-deep: "Syria is in flux." When John King brought the issue up again, later on, Romney ended up being the only candidate to seriously and substantive engage the question, arguing that President Barack Obama needs to take advantage of a rare moment to force out an Iranian ally, by joining with local Allawites, and friendly Saudis and Turks, to abandon Syrian President Bashar Assad and funnel weapons to the opposition. (Nevermind that Hillary Clinton is in Tunisia this week to meet with a "Friends of Syria" group, including Saudi Arabia and Turkey, to find a way to do just that.)

The other candidates were far less inclined to answer the question, in all likelihood because there is no easy answer. Rick Santorum accused Obama of failing to directly confront Syria from day one, faulting him for opening an embassy once again, and then for closing it only when it became too dangerous to operate (embassy staff have always insisted they were most effective in helping the opposition while in the country), but offered little concrete suggestions for ways to move forward. Newt Gingrich suggested that the U.S. should have its "allies covertly destroy the Assad regime," adding: "There are plenty of Arab-speaking groups that would be quite happy" to do that. Who, precisely, he did not specify, but presumably he does not mean these guys.

-- Joshua Hersh

Share this:
@ DanAmira : "Fair enough" is what John King says whenever he is publicly emasculated

Share this:
@ fivethirtyeight : Santorum dropped quite a bit on Intrade during the debate. Now just 6.8% chance of winning GOP nomination, started at 11%

Share this:

Former Gov. Mitt Romney spent much of the middle of Wednesday's night GOP debate criticizing former Sen. Rick Santorum on two fronts: being a prodigious spender of federal funds and for supporting former Sen. Arlen Specter, a Pennsylvania Democrat-turned-Republican-turned-Democrat who has, for conservatives, come to resemble the worst of GOP moderation.

It was an effective dual-barrel attack, one that put Santorum squarely on the defensive and with little support inside the debate hall. Had he had his wits about him, he could have pointed to an October 2005 press release, in which Romney not only publicly acknowledged he was lobbying the federal government for money on home heating assistance, but was turning to Specter to get him the dough.

“As a state, Massachusetts and its people have led the way in pursuing energy efficient programs for our homes and businesses,” said Romney. “This year, it’s especially important for consumers to know that winter doesn't have to burn a hole in their wallet. Families can save hundreds of dollars by following some common sense tips.”


Low-income residents in Massachusetts are expected to be particularly affected by increases in energy costs this winter. With heating prices on the rise, Romney and Governor Granholm of Michigan have led an effort among the nation’s governors to obtain approximately .3 billion in emergency federal fuel assistance funding through the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP).

Yesterday, Romney met with Senator Arlen Specter, Chairman of a key Senate Appropriations subcommittee, to lobby for the additional funding.

(emphasis ours)

Specter, at the time, was chairman of the Appropriations subcommittee, which oversaw LIHEAP funding. So the fact that Romney would come to him with palms open makes sense. But it doesn't particularly help his position with respect to the 2012 Republican primary. In a Telegram and Gazette article from that same time, Romney's spokeswoman Julie Teer offered the following summary of that Specter-Romney meeting.

"The governor feels that Mr. Specter will have a sympathetic ear since he also represents a state in the Northeast," Ms. Teer said. "Gov. Romney would like as much federal assistance as we can get but he recognizes that it may be a difficult process."

-- Sam Stein

Share this:
@ maggiepolitico : Santo to CNN:"I think this was a pretty favorable Romney crowd"

Share this:
@ HuffPostHill : TONIGHT'S WINNER: No one. TONIGHT'S LOSER: Grimace from McDonaldland, who had to die to make Newt Gingrich's tie.

Share this:
@ howardfineman : Problem is that santo's nice summation about principle wasnt backed up by the substance of the debate .

Share this:

The Republican candidates have not addressed unemployment so far in the CNN debate. The unemployment rates in the next two states to vote -- Arizona and Michigan -- are 8.7 percent and 9.3 percent, respectively.

-- Arthur Delaney

Share this:

A little earlier in the debate, Mitt Romney took credit for balancing the Massachusetts state budget all four years he was governor. Rick Santorum took issue with the credit-claiming, noting that former Democratic Gov. Michael Dukakis also balanced the state's budget for a full decade.

It doesn't actually take much political prowess to balance a budget as a governor, since most states are required by their constitutions to to balance their budgets every fiscal year.

According to the official Massachusetts budgetary process, "State finance law (Chapter 29 of the Massachusetts General Laws) requires the Legislature and the Governor to approve a balanced budget for each fiscal year. In other words, the Commonwealth cannot spend more than it receives in revenue. Further, during the fiscal year, the Governor may approve no supplementary appropriation bills that would result in an unbalanced budget."

The federal government, by contrast, has the power to both print money and run deficits.

A more important test of a governor's budgetary prowess is what they accomplish with their legally mandated balanced budgets. And Romney's balanced budgets in Massachusetts accompanied an underwhelming record on jobs. As The Washington Post has reported, Romney's Massachusetts was one of just a handful that never fully recovered the jobs it lost in the 2001 recession, alongside rust belt states of Ohio and Michigan. Only one state posted a bigger drop in the labor force than Massachusetts during Romney's tenure as governor: Hurricane Katrina-ravaged Louisiana.

-- Zach Carter

Share this:
@ howardfineman : This debate has been a slow-motion meat grinder for Santorum. He sounded like a deal-cutting pol, and not a nominee let alone a president.

Share this:
@ HuffingtonPost : Ron Paul: 'Perpetuation of the myth by the media that I can't win' is biggest misconception about me #CNNdebate

Share this:
@ Bthypin : Did anyone else catch that "Frothy Santorum: Lube and Fecal Matter" sign during the cutaway to commercial? Classic

Share this:

Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, best known for his controversial and inflammatory policies toward undocumented immigrants, was in the audience for Wednesday night's debate in Mesa, Ariz.

Debate moderator John King gave Arpaio a shout-out, saying the sheriff told him recently that it's "political garbage, if you will, to not arrest illegals already in this country."

During tonight's debate, the group Citizens for a Better Arizona is airing an ad calling for Arpaio's resignation.


Watch a Huffington Post interview with Randy Parraz, president of Citizens for a Better Arizona.

-- Amanda Terkel

Share this:
Rick Santorum made it clear during the debate Wednesday night that he opposed the Title X family federal planning fund and would defund Planned Parenthood as president. He would, however, spend an equal amount of government money on "Title XX," a federal abstinence program

to "counterbalance" family planning.

"I said we're going to create something called Title XX, which will provide programs that actually work in keeping children from being sexually active instead of facilitating children being sexually

active," he said.

Ron Paul made the point that spending government money on an abstinence program is no more of a conservative position than spending money on a family planning program.

"John, this demonstrates the problem I'm talking about," Paul said. "It's not a program of the federal government to get involved in our lives this way ... The government shouldn't be spending money on abstinence -- I don't see that in the Constitution any place."

Mitt Romney then pointed out that Santorum actually voted for bills that included Title XX funding. Santorum admitted that this was the case, even though he personally opposes contraception and family planning.

"I think I was making it clear that while I have a personal moral objection to it, even though I don't support it, that I voted for bills that included it," he said, drawing heavy boos from the crowd.

-- Laura Bassett

Share this:
@ daveweigel : Santorum's history with schooling his kids is a little more interesting than he says

Share this:

Around the Web

2012 Primary Debate Schedule « 2012 Election Central

Live from S.C.: The Republican debate

Republican Party presidential debates, 2012 - Wikipedia, the free ...

Republican Debate – GOP Debate 2011 - CNBC

Romney, Gingrich at GOP debate: We'd go to war to keep Iran from ...

Saturday Night Live - GOP Debate Cold Opening - Video - http ...

Republican Presidential Debate at the Reagan Library - September ...

GOP Debate

Republican Debate: Where and when you can find it - Election 2012 ...

CNN Arizona Republican debate – live

Republican Debate in Arizona 2012: LIVE COVERAGE

Arizona Republican Debate Live Blog

Tonight's GOP debate: Why are viewers suffering fatigue? Policy vs. personality

LIVE Blog: Republican Debate in Arizona