iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Texas School District Embarks On Widespread iPad Program To Close Digital Divide

Ipad

By CHRISTOPHER SHERMAN   02/27/12 08:11 PM ET  AP

McALLEN, Texas -- A Texas school district is trying to close its digital divide by distributing thousands of Apple tablet computers in a move that could make it the largest iPads program for students in the nation.

McAllen Independent School District in the southern part of the state began distributing 6,800 devices this week – mostly the iPad tablet computers, but also hundreds of iPod Touch devices for its youngest students.

By this time next year, the district says every one of its more than 25,000 students in grades K-12 will receive an iPad or iPod Touch. The district believes it's the largest to try for complete coverage and while Apple would not confirm that, other districts the company noted as having made large investments have not made ones as big as McAllen's.

Educational use of the tablet computers is so new that there's little evidence available on their impact. Superintendent James Ponce said the district wanted to change the classroom culture, making it more interactive and creative and decided Apple's devices – even at $500 retail for an iPad2 – were the best investment.

"We're just choosing to invest differently going forward," Ponce said.

The district's typical classroom is outfitted with three computers for students and one for the teacher. Going forward those technology investments will be supplanted by the iPads. For now, McAllen's iPads don't carry its textbooks, but eventually they will and at much lower cost than the hard copies that can cost $200 apiece.

A small group of teachers in the district began preparing more than a year ago on incorporating the devices into their lessons. Recently, more instructors have started studying the devices. Teachers already training will see their students receive the first wave of devices.

About two-thirds of McAllen students were characterized as economically disadvantaged in 2010, the most recent data available according to the district. The median household income in McAllen, a city on the U.S.-Mexico border near the southern tip of Texas, was about $41,000 in 2010.

School board president Sam Saldivar Jr. said the $20.5 million investment in the technology aims at "equity."

"We know that when they do achieve and are successful they are going to be generationally impacting their families and this community," Saldivar said.

Stacey Banks, a social studies teacher at McAllen Memorial High School, helped the district shape its program. She said textbooks for her class were 12 years old and she hadn't used them in the past five years, choosing to cobble together her own lessons instead with hopes of collaborating with colleagues to build electronic textbooks.

"It's given us a great opportunity to hone our skills as teachers and change our paradigm a little bit about what our classrooms look like and how we approach learning," Banks said of the iPads program. "That excitement has definitely migrated to the kids."

Sophomores in her class pulled up art images Monday on their iPads. Banks asked them to find out how changes taking place during the Renaissance were demonstrated in art from the period.

"It's actually a really good technology," said 15-year-old Christian Hernandez, gently polishing the screen with the cuff of his sweatshirt.

He had never used an iPad before last week when he and other students got a sneak preview. After spending some time with it over the weekend, Hernandez was using the note-taking application and others with ease.

The district installed tracking software on the iPads so they won't go missing and their Internet connections will still be through the school district's filter, meaning students won't be able to access any sites that they'd be restricted from in school. Parents have to pay a $40 refundable deposit in two payments and can receive help with paying.

Zeeland Public Schools in Michigan gave 1,800 iPads to all of its high school students last fall and hopes to eventually cover every student in grades 3-12. Chicago Public Schools bought about 10,000 iPads and some individual schools in the district have bought more using discretionary funds, but it's far from districtwide.

Hundreds of other districts are experimenting with iPads in individual schools or grades.

Carmen Garcia, director of instructional technology for the McAllen district in Texas, said past technology investments only benefited the students when they were at school. But with the iPads, students and their families will be able to use the technology at home, too.

"It's about transforming learning," Garcia said. "It's really not about the device."

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST EDUCATION

McALLEN, Texas -- A Texas school district is trying to close its digital divide by distributing thousands of Apple tablet computers in a move that could make it the largest iPads program for students ...
McALLEN, Texas -- A Texas school district is trying to close its digital divide by distributing thousands of Apple tablet computers in a move that could make it the largest iPads program for students ...
Filed by Emmeline Zhao  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:55 PM on 05/13/2013
All I know is I am a sophmore at McAllen and we use the ipads mostly to keep us entertained with facebook and skype while the boring teacher teaches the class from her desk never getting up to have interaction with us. Most of my teachers are basically lazy and are just counting the days for summer they teach only with power points or handouts and these are Pre AP classes so if Im getting a poor education I can just imagine the other 'regular' classes. IPADS are not used for teaching merely just for keeping us quiet! Sorry Im throwing my school under the bus but Im tired of these teachers I actually want to learn but all three highschools are the same.
06:51 PM on 01/29/2013
Congratulations, Texas, on blowing a bunch of money! You must just be rolling in dough, huh? Don't need to even consider less expensive alternatives that can give you the same exact results (or better), eh?

iPads are a major waste of money. They cost twice as much as alternatives (Chromebooks, ultrabooks, netbooks, Android tablets, etc. etc.), and yet they have even more limitations and problems:

1) They limit access to great, free educational resources online since many (if not most) of them use Flash.
2) They don't give students the real-world computer skills they need. There is not a single job posting on Monster that cares whether you know how to use an iPad (UNLESS you are going to program apps -- which means you need to use a real computer!) There are many postings for jobs requiring skills like MS Office, Windows proficiency, and keyboarding.
3) Colleges, as well, advise their students NOT to use tablets instead of computers, because of the above reasons.

For more details about the limitations, problems, and cost-inefficiency of iPads, go to my EdTechExpert website or see my videos "Just Say NO to iPads for Education" (the newest is Part 5: Apple Products Break Budgets)
04:31 PM on 03/12/2012
Ipads are for consuming, not creating - creating is the only way we learn. This is the 21st century, and ipads in schools are strictly 20th century, epitomizing the passive consumption of information. When you spend $500 a pop, and they last how long, and e-textbooks are never going to be deeply discounted (this simply doesn't happen in education) you'd never make that money back. How many textbooks do you print, anyway, to equal the environmental cost of one electronic gadget, with its rare earth minerals? To do anything but read or surf, ipads are not as good as a basic computer, and a lot more expensive than a basic e-reader. As one commenter here demonstrates, you can't type accurately on a keypad. When the teacher tries to present material, like this art lesson, how many kids are surfing? You are introducing distraction. Before this it was "interactive white boards," same hype and lack of scrutiny, and I have no doubt it was something else before that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:42 AM on 02/29/2012
Texas? Who knew? This, my friends , is potentially the salvation of our schools. We can save a fortune in text books and supplies while providing relevant instruction that provides efficient practices for student and teachers, which can be monitored by parents and principals to provide access to how students and teachers performance. This will be somewhat more objective in all evaluations as itnprovides insight to the efforts in class and provides evidence and rational for grading stake holders. aDA fraud will no longer be so easy to perpetrate, and the need for office techs should be less immense. All this saves mine and engages buy in from students and parents while making teachers less vulner able to reprisals and unfair evaluations. The money saved is reason enough but we get so much from usingniPads with a centralized platform we should not wait for these knuckleheads to realize this is the ticket. It's alo environmentally sound.
06:47 PM on 01/29/2013
Yes, you can "save a fortune" by buying devices that are twice as expensive as the alternatives which do the same thing (or more.)

This is the kind of fallacious logic I hear over and over again.

Sure, we should be going digital and not spending so much on textbooks. Guess what -- you don't need an iPad to do that. You can use Kindles, Android tablets, ultrabooks, Chromebooks, netbooks, etc. etc.

So all that happens is the schools are wasting money, and then complaining that their budgets are tight and that they don't have money for teachers, after-school programs, etc.

It's a completely negligent and irresponsible use of taxpayer dollars.

See my EdTechExpert website or "Just Say NO to iPads for Education" videos for more details...
05:58 PM on 02/28/2012
Money down a hole. These are 2 year devices at best. What to do wen the batteries start to go? Send in 25000 devices for battery upgrades? What to do when its too old for updates? You can get laptops that are lower cost, can be self serviced, and have a useful life of 4 to 6 years, and are far easier to manage in an enterprise environment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smithrd4
06:39 PM on 02/28/2012
I agree. I would have went for the cheaper netbooks myself. They also do more than iPads.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:46 AM on 02/29/2012
I believe they lastnlonger than if iPad or moodles are enhanced to endur rough use and given regular maitence. With textbooks about $100 a pop in high schools where students have 5 -7 classes a term as well as novels and consumable texts, need resources and research, the 2 year wholesale price of thisnis still less than the morbid expenses for our traditional approach. Tabllets are going to get kids into themlearningnprocess and all all stakeholders to monitor the learning process.
photo
mikey09
Living off the grid.
05:08 PM on 02/28/2012
Not a bad idea, hope it works well. The tracking device doesn't mean it won't go missing from the student, just that they can track it if it does, but I would bet a far share will end up in gone, wonder if they are pre-programmed to not work if taken out of the general area of the school, town?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:49 AM on 02/29/2012
They will make thes limited in what they can access so theft will be less likely. You can see a theif by the way with free. Low jck programs by apple. But the school units will probably be easy to distinquished. I agree they will still be stolen and get broken, but you'd be surprised how zealously young people protect gadgets.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mjeffn
Freedom's just another word 4 nothing left to lose
03:47 PM on 02/28/2012
Texas, where parents give their guns and teachers give them iPads. You be the judge.
photo
mikey09
Living off the grid.
05:09 PM on 02/28/2012
Teachers are parents too, so are the teachers giving their own kids guns and ipads?
photo
KarmaPatrol
Riverboat Gambler, satellite whisperer. Independe
03:08 PM on 02/28/2012
Technology is great for 'at risk' students but an iPad is hardly a way to teach them technology. Powerpoint and those projector screens enabled with touch control for student presentations of applied math, plus a good old fashioned algebra book, would be better.. IMO. What good is surfing for Amazon items they can't afford. Surfing is not teaching technology ! ! !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:50 AM on 02/29/2012
You don't have an iPad, do you?
photo
KarmaPatrol
Riverboat Gambler, satellite whisperer. Independe
12:14 PM on 02/29/2012
I use iPad and other Macs at home,but work (large municipalities, defense contracting) requires PC-based systems since the cost per desktop is initially less. Simple economics. For presentations I use Powerpoint for Mac. I also have a PC laptop at home but I leave it in the foyer as a decoy for robbers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
XV8 Crisis Suit
02:22 PM on 02/28/2012
Shouldn't such a expensive and sweeping reform have a little bit of evidence behind it before they do it? Right now there's no evidence that this will help students, so shouldn't they be a bit more cautious first?
12:02 PM on 02/29/2012
They don't care whether is works or not. There is a big push right now in education reform for corporate take over of the education system and push out the teachers union. Bringing Apple in is a huge first step. It seems to be the red states that have taken the lead in on-line education than any other state, no surprise.
02:16 PM on 02/28/2012
What parents don't understand is that children are going to be taught the dependability on technology. Before anybody thinks I am a caveman living in the dark ages, let me explain that I do understand the importance of teaching technology to children but not at this young of an age. When these kids grow to be in high school or college and the plug is pulled from them, they are going to be lost without their Google glasses and e-books. Were Konrad Zuse, John Atanasoff, Clifford Berry, Bill Gates, or Steve Jobs taught with electronic tablets? How about Newton and Einstein? Yet these are the people who launched us into the Nuclear Age.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
mjeffn
Freedom's just another word 4 nothing left to lose
03:48 PM on 02/28/2012
Most of Texas agrees with you. That's why parents down there give their kids guns instead.
photo
mikey09
Living off the grid.
05:11 PM on 02/28/2012
Your fixated on Texas and guns, but according to the daily beast, Texas had less guns per capita than Kentucky which was number one in citizens owning guns. And like I said, according to your thinking the Texas parent teachers are giving guns to their kids too.
01:58 PM on 02/28/2012
While Amazon and Barnes and Noble are fighting the tablet wars "out there", Apple is gaining territory by taking over the young people. This generation of Apple iPad users will buy nothing but Apple software and hardware.

Awesome marketing ploy and parents are falling for it by raising the "It's 2012 flag". I know this is the wave of the future but this kids don't know how to apply basic math proficiently yet. These kids haven't read Shakespeare yet. No wonder these kids are no longer using logic and speech to debate their differences, instead, they use guns when bullied.
thatswatshesaid
free chill pills for all
01:47 PM on 02/28/2012
Ipad is a terrible choice. First, if you are going to go with an electronic textbook, then why spend the extra money on Apple, get a droid. Second, Ipads are for consuming information, not creating information. You need a computer for that. Third, Apple is a closed Ecosystem, this district is now married to Apple for life and will pay for that priviledge dearly over time. There is very little collaberation between students that is possible on the Ipad, where with laptops and sketch devices, the collaborative learning process is greatly enriched. Great idea, poor platform.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:57 AM on 02/29/2012
iPad is the best choice because it offers tbe best array of art and music apps. It is well made and began investing in development years ago while android was cheating out weak imitations. The people at Apple have given free units to school to improve the device and modify it to educational use. With this said, Apple has been outted for abuse of Cinese workers they've outsourcespd iPad assembly to. I love my iPad but I will never buy a new one again. I will not give Apple my $ or microsoft a cent . Moodle is a small company founded by educators who devoted themekves to the promise of technology in classroom years before thier were tablets. Their device is only used by schools and offers a unified platform dpso data is universal and acessable. They deserve the contracts.
thatswatshesaid
free chill pills for all
01:49 PM on 02/29/2012
Interesting comments. I sell technology to education and most of my customers who have gone with Ipad (not MAC, but Ipad) have been very disappointed. Why? Because it's not a computer. Apps are great for consuming info, but educators want students to create information, this can't be done on an Ipad effectively. Apple is probably being unfairly singled out for the labor issues, just based on their size. Inexpensive laptops are far more of a learning device than any of the ipad or droid tablets, I don't see that changing for the next several years, but Apple is certainly finding a ton of districts willing to take the plunge w/o really knowing what they're getting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drama Llama
10:06 AM on 02/28/2012
It will all go this way anyway.. Digital delivery of textbooks is just smarter.. Content can be updated easier.. Costs of the books is driven down because they do not have to be physically "made" . Homework can be delivered electronically.. podcasts teachers post.. I mean it is 2012... Not to mention a lot of these kids do not have access to any computing devices at home.
01:30 PM on 02/28/2012
"Costs of the books is driven down because they do not have to be physically 'made' " That's what was said when the first e-readers came out in the 90's. However, have you seen the cost of e-books on Amazon or anywhere else? They are $1, $2 off the cover price of a printed book. The demand will not drive the price down. If a math text book is $120, I can assure you that the e-version will not be much cheaper.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drama Llama
03:10 PM on 02/28/2012
kno.com has already got lots of ebook rentals for 40% to 50% off the cost of buying them and saving 15% off a Harry Potter Kindle book may seem trivial but saving 15% off of say a 1 billion dollar a year schoolbook budget for a large state like Texas or California is a lot of cash.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JohnTheMac
Now, why don't you go home and get your shine box?
09:14 PM on 02/28/2012
textbooks will be $14.99 at iTunes textbook store.
It won't be just an 'e-version' either.
photo
mikey09
Living off the grid.
05:14 PM on 02/28/2012
Maybe the costs will be lower, who knows what the companies will charge for the e-books, but when you drop a book or the car runs over it, you can still use it, not so much with electronic devices.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drama Llama
05:15 PM on 02/28/2012
LOL very true.. Not that teenagers would ever do that.. I wonder what Apple gives as an academic price point.. God knows they give no break to anyone else
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
11:58 AM on 02/29/2012
I am guessing with tax breaks and wholesale contracts 150- 250 each with high memory and heavy duty construction and battery .
10:04 AM on 02/28/2012
Great idea, very innovative. This will make a huge impact on their education. This will lead to the end of textbooks in school in the distant future.
01:44 PM on 02/28/2012
How's this "innovative"? How will this "make a huge impact on their education"? The experts are saying, "Educational use of the tablet computers is so new that there's little evidence available on their impact."

It sounds like a great marketing move by Apple to take over the educational division. It isn't that I like in 1700's with clay tablets and a stylus but all I see students doing (even in the photo above) with the iPad is dragging their fingers for drawing pictures and playing games.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
12:00 PM on 02/29/2012
If you could see what teachers do, you'd get it . I researched this and went to conferences, it's no joke. Text books are like coities to kids, they are obsolete. This makes incredible sense.
10:01 AM on 02/28/2012
What good will it do?

They're all tied to distorted Texas School Board approved reference material.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BlairCase
10:26 AM on 02/28/2012
What distortions are you referring to? Nearly all the proposed changes to the Texas school curriculum that generated so much controversy were voted down. For example, there was a proposal to remove Thomas Jefferson from the social studies list of world philosophers. (Most scholars, by the way, agree that Jefferson doesn't belong on the list.) However, the Texas Board of Education voted down the proposal. There was never a proposal to remove Jefferson from Texas history textbooks, which continue to reocognize his importantes as a revolutionary leader and statesman.
01:45 PM on 02/28/2012
I don't know about "distorted Texas School Board" but you are in the right to question what good will it do. The experts say, "Educational use of the tablet computers is so new that there's little evidence available on their impact."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
XV8 Crisis Suit
02:14 PM on 02/28/2012
Exactly. We ought to wade our feet into these waters, not dive right in.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ariel Bonzai
Naked is the best disguise.
12:05 PM on 02/29/2012
How do we know either way unless we try!? You remind me of Olatos allegory of the cave. Everyone is afraid to move into the light. Ohhhhhnooooo don't go there, who knows what waits for outside tbe darkness of our cave? Let's stay here and be ignorant. Safe is orry.ntheres good reason to give it a shot. One us that we are doing so badly it is unlikely to get worse. Another is, this costs less$ . Most of all engaged students are successful.