Huffpost Green

Bill McKibben And Ezra Levant Debate Keystone XL Pipeline Pros And Cons

Posted: Updated:

Should the Keystone XL pipeline project be permitted in the U.S.?

The proposed pipeline -- which would travel from Alberta's tar sands oil deposits to Gulf Coast refineries in the U.S. -- has drawn strong responses from individuals on both sides of a growing debate.

Supporters contend that the pipeline will create thousands of jobs and lower gas prices in the U.S. Opponents claim that the pipeline will carry oil which will contribute to climate change and a spill along the pipeline route could impact a large drinking and irrigation water source in Nebraska.

President Obama rejected TransCanada's permit for the Keystone XL in January, but his decision still leaves an opportunity for the company to reapply for permission to build the international pipeline.

In the first installment of our Change My Mind debate series, we challenge two leading voices in the debate to defend their views on the Keystone XL project.

Speaking against the Keystone XL is author and environmentalist Bill McKibben. He is the co-founder of and a leading voice in last year's Tar Sands Action protests against the Keystone XL.

His challenger is Canadian lawyer and author Ezra Levant. A columnist for Sun Media newspapers and a conservative commentator on the Sun News Network, Levant is also the author of 2010's "Ethical Oil: The Case for Canada's Oil Sands."

Join the debate below, and see if Bill or Ezra change your mind.


Pre-debate poll:

Tell us your opinion before the debate starts to set the starting line

The Keystone XL pipeline project should be permitted in the U.S.

Agree - Thanks for voting! Please proceed to read the debate below

Please vote to proceed to the debate


Who makes the better argument?



Did one of the arguments change your mind?

The Keystone XL pipeline project should be permitted in the U.S.


Agree - Thanks for voting again! Here are the results:



moreless AgreeDisagreeUndecided

"Agree""Disagree"Neither argumenthas changed the most minds

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Kentucky Rep. Blasts Feds for Slow Review of Keystone XL

Keystone: How Bill McKibben Turned a Pipeline into an Environmental Rallying Point

Bill Clinton Says Keystone XL Should Be Built on New Route

Keystone XL pipeline may raise U.S. gas prices

Speakers' Spotlight | Ezra Levant: Award-Winning Author ...

Keep convicted jihadist from returning home to Canada, right-wing commentator ...

Bill McKibben: Beyond Keystone

Keystone: the pipeline to higher gas prices

Activists assault new Keystone XL pipeline bill

McKibben: There's no time to wait on climate change

From Our Partners