iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

In Super Tuesday's Shadow, Ohio's Poorest Struggle To Rise

Posted: 03/06/12 06:40 AM ET  |  Updated: 03/06/12 05:46 PM ET

YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio -- Exit the Madison Avenue Expressway onto Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, just beyond a road sign advertising the Museum of Industry and Labor, and an elegant, pre-war building, red brick and multi-gabled, rises on your right. Built in 1931 and the former home of the West Federal YMCA branch, it is now owned by the Rescue Mission of Mahoning Valley, which houses dozens of this town's homeless residents.

Cleavon McClendon, who recently lost his job working at a Bob Evans restaurant, is among them.

"I lost Bob Evans due to Sundays," says McClendon, 36. "Sundays are their best days, busiest days, and they needed me there on Sundays as much as possible, but I couldn't be there because I don't have transportation and the bus don't run on Sundays. The bus don't run on Sundays, period."

Unable to pay his bills, he then lost his apartment and soon washed up at the side door of the mission. It was not his first time here, and his story is not unusual in a city, and a region, struggling to re-invent itself after the steel industry largely vanished.

As Republican presidential candidates jockey to win the vote in the Buckeye State and elsewhere as part of today's Super Tuesday primaries, the message will, as a matter of political expedience, be carefully tuned to middle-class voters -- and it's little wonder. Ohio lost nearly 34 percent of its high-wage manufacturing jobs between 2001 and 2010, according to one analysis published last spring. More than two-thirds of the state's 88 counties saw losses of such jobs at rates of 20 percent or higher. And as a state endowed with 66 delegates, the allegiance of middle-class voters here is required for anyone hoping to capture the White House in November.

Cleavon McClendon says he lost his job at a
Bob Evans restaurant because the bus doesn't
run on Sundays. (Photo by Tom Zeller Jr.)

But for McClendon and other unskilled workers subsisting at the bottom of the economic ladder -- and for those activists and community leaders who strive to better the lot of the worst off -- such statistics can seem hopelessly distant. A more telling metric, they say, would be a Brookings Institution figure published in November, which found the Youngstown metropolitan area to have one of the highest rates of concentrated poverty in the nation. Among core cities, it ranked number one.

With campaign chatter now focused on issues like separation of church and state and the proper place for contraception, the realities of life for the poorest Americans, and the cost to them and society as they continue to founder, hasn't yet been a significant part of the presidential candidates' — or the White House's — stump speeches.

In response to a query on the topic from The Huffington Post on Monday, R.C. Hammond, lead spokesman for Newt Gingrich's campaign, said the problem was partly a function of onerous regulations and stifling tax codes inhibiting businesses from taking root and flourishing. That, in turn, limits good jobs and real opportunities for those at the lowest end of the ladder. "There's a lot of working poor in the United States," Hammond said. "But having everyone working is not enough. People need to be working at jobs that support their families and their dreams."

Representatives of Rick Santorum's campaign did not respond to requests for comment, but Jesse Benton, a spokesman for the Ron Paul campaign, blamed the nation's growing poverty rates in the United States on inflation. "The Federal Reserve is systematically debasing the dollar and squeezing the lower middle class, the poor and Americans on fixed incomes," Benton said. "Unless we sure up our monetary system, we will see more and of our people slip into poverty."

Andrea Saul, a campaign spokeswoman for Mitt Romney, blamed rising poverty rates on the White House. "Under this President, Americans have seen more job losses and more economic devastation than under any President in modern history," Saul said. "The only real solution to the economic crisis is to get Barack Obama out of the White House, undo the damage he has done, and replace him with a true leader."

Representatives of the White House and President Obama's re-election campaign declined to discuss the issue on the record, though a campaign spokesman pointed to the extension of unemployment benefits and investments in job training and homelessness prevention as evidence of the president's commitment to addressing poverty.

For residents of Youngstown's many decaying neighborhoods, however, hard times are measured in decades, and even some of the city's most dedicated boosters concede that lifting the city's poorest out of their plight will continue to be an uphill battle. For the most part, they remain ignored and, as such, invisible.

"It's out of sight, out of mind," says Jim Echement, a former business executive who is the director of development at the faith-based Rescue Mission. Echement has high praise for Youngstown's recent efforts to turn itself around, but he says the poverty he sees at the mission is too-often unnoticed. "People think, 'Well, somebody else will take care of that' -- and I speak from personal experience," he says. "I had no idea this place was here at all until one night a homeless guy showed up at our church, looking for help in one of the elite suburbs. The pastor said we should take him to the mission, so we dropped this fellow off. It was the first time I'd ever been here.

"It's kind of an indictment," Echement adds. "Why didn't I know about this before? I didn't care. That's the way that it was."

BOUNCING BACK

In a huge yellow font, set against a black background, the cover of the August 2009 issue of Entrepreneur Magazine declared it had compiled a list of the 10 best cities in which to start a business. "Youngstown, Ohio, Anyone?" was the underline. Inside, the magazine profiled one of several budding technology companies being nurtured at the Youngstown Business Incubator, a campus of four previously empty buildings in the heart of downtown.

Jim Cossler, the founder of the incubator, says the success of his enterprise is a bellwether of more good things to come.

"From the perspective of someone who has lived here almost all his life," he says "I've never been more optimistic about the community."

FOLLOW BUSINESS

YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio -- Exit the Madison Avenue Expressway onto Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, just beyond a road sign advertising the Museum of Industry and Labor, and an elegant, pre-war building, re...
YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio -- Exit the Madison Avenue Expressway onto Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, just beyond a road sign advertising the Museum of Industry and Labor, and an elegant, pre-war building, re...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 2,926
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (51 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
02:39 AM on 11/18/2012
Surely there are punters out there that will pick up the slack outside economic bus hours in smaller cheaper vehicles

family vans often seat 8

11 happens too

cant see the point of a metro that isnt 24/7
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
02:12 AM on 11/18/2012
just sayin

but ohio I think is flat

amazing how far & easily you can go on a good bike on the flat

30km ph/20mph w/ same exertion as walking

They can be had very cheaply if not free if u put time in

Worked well for me

solved my problem when in a similar situation & made me fit.

not preaching

just sharing

if u have some cash

some states allow powered bikes of limited power w/o any on road costs

a big item

even if u have a junker car

u still get fired if it breaks & u dont have a plan b to get to work
conservo
Tea Partier, Atheist, Libertarian, Objectivist
10:14 PM on 03/19/2012
"Cleavon McClendon lost his job because the bus doesn't run on Sundays".
Well then, perhaps he should have did like I used to do EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK, which is walk or ride my bicycle 5 miles to work at my $3.25 per hour job. I don't know...it worked for me. Something tells me that wasn't the real reason that he lost his job, though.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
exmate
Life is about playing a poor hand well.
03:06 PM on 03/19/2012
Good thing that Romney's safety net is there to catch them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Patient Zero
That is not a picture of me.
10:37 AM on 03/19/2012
I know how to solve this problem! Let's talk about birth control!
12:04 AM on 03/08/2012
I appreciate this article in elaborating on the plight of the homeless, but it fails to make the connection between homelessness and the economies of scale that produce poverty in the wake of destructive laissez-faire capitalization -- not real community interdependent capitalism where people are not treated as chattel to be cast off as just a means of making profits.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:52 PM on 03/19/2012
You mean how Youngstown's steel mills are closed while the nation imports steel for bridges and proposed pipelines, the sheet metal for cars that aren't made in America down to the man n the article; no doubt his vacant job was taken by an illegal immigrant.
Somewhere, sometime, Anerican will need to be for Americans.
10:48 AM on 03/07/2012
As a past small business owner I always find myself confused with the GOP blaming federal regulations for stifling business, especially small businesses of fewer than say 10 employees. My struggle was always with state and city regulations and taxes, not the federal government.

As to the federal side, ADA if looked at in a positive way, makes your business more accessible to the handicapped. OSHA requirements keep the workplace safer for employees and customers, which seems like an obvious and desirable goal. As for “Obmacare,” if you have a larger enough business where you need to worry about it, wouldn’t you want to provide a good benefit package to attract the best employees? To top if off, many of the expenses incurred by federal regulations are even tax deductable.

I challenge the GOP & TP candidates to specifically name regulations they would propose doing away with. Not generalities, but name them specifically.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SirReal1
08:12 PM on 03/08/2012
"I challenge the GOP & TP candidates to specifically name regulations they would propose doing away with. Not generalities, but name them specifically."

And?

Crickets!
06:00 AM on 12/16/2012
Nobody has ever shown a workplace safety benefit to having OHSA, so get rid of it.
09:22 AM on 12/16/2012
That conclusion can only be reached by ignoring the entire history of safety in the workplace, all accident statistics before and after OSHA was established, and perhaps spending little actual time in say a "blue collar" workplace. Granted it doesn't probably do much to protect Wall Street workers from papercuts, but the janitorial staff id safer.
01:27 AM on 03/07/2012
I just tried to post a prayer for my country twice and the moderators keep blocking it. If I cant post a prayer for the unification and love for this country and its people then no matter how much of a liberal I am i will no longer come to this site. YOU hear that mr. moderator I did not say anything offensive nor did I try to convert others to my beliefs, I just wanted to express love for the people of this country and hopes that we all could get along. If that gets banned then I think my time coming to this site is over, its a shame you let people spew racism, and hate and then block sincere love for all shame on you good bye
10:38 PM on 03/07/2012
And you can do all of that without a profession of faith or proselytizing. Your god has seen the poverty for several years now; are you saying suffering people get help with prayer from believers because god himself is not moved with compassion of his own nature?
11:16 AM on 03/08/2012
I have seen prayer work first hand, notice those who are born with less are more likely to have faith, youd think it would be the other way around, but we know how we make it. trust me I have seen things you would not believe. but thats not the point. I just wanted to show love,
01:20 AM on 03/07/2012
Dear LORD, My GOD, you have been really good to me, and have helped me through some difficult times, and even the times when my mistakes could have been disastrous, you saved me. Now LORD I am asking something bigger than big, Please bless this country. Please bring the people together. we have a liberal movement and a conservative movement, we need a love movement. So I am asking you to please bring us together in your love, let us do for each other despite what those in the nations capitol are doing. It seems to me, we have some leader who just want to help the rich, and potray the poor as lazy. If I am wrong please forgive me and lead me to truth. but when I hear people say there are people buying vacations to Hawaii with their foodstamps, I feel they are trying to get votes by stewing peoples fear and anger. Please forgive me if im wrong, either way please bless us all. the only thing that seems to trickle down is low wage job crumbs off a rich mans plate, prepared by his starving servant. Lead us all to truth and show us how to get along and how to love one another. As always I thank you for all thing GOD, please bring about a love movement
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
moonlightnmagnolia
If you die in an elevator, be sure to push the Up
02:12 AM on 03/07/2012
Nice! Thank-you...Amen.
10:57 PM on 03/07/2012
Conservative Christians have been loving us far too long now. Fantasies and delusions to hide an avariciousness while fleecing the poor are becoming a thing of the past. Caring takes our own sacrifice for one another, not that of a past Rabi who offered an example that most do not manifest in their own reality, but willingly take the fruit of obfuscation by hiding behind religious zealotry.
11:13 AM on 03/08/2012
look im a libaral christian, my prayer was not about condeming or judging those who dont have faith, if you dont thats good for you. I do and prayer is my way of expressing love for all. If you dont believe good for you, but why do you wish for me to cease. will my prayer some how hurt you or anyone else. lets not forget about all the science behind prayer and faith, how people who are sick heal faster when they pray. or that a high percentage of recovering addicts are more successful when they have a faith. look up the stats and then come back and tell me I shouldnt pray for that which I love my country
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sisa
09:50 PM on 03/06/2012
Is they key issue abortion, abortion, abortion, or is it contraception, contraception, contraception or maybe it's gays sex, gay sex, gay sex.
09:27 PM on 03/06/2012
Personal instability has long term effects.
Folks wind up at the margins.
They fall off the edge easily.
No support,no family,no resources.
This guy should have been helped at an earlier time.
Its all so sad.
Trapped in a living nightmare as the pols spout nonsense.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
randinoel
God is the only way to ever-lasting life.
08:59 PM on 03/06/2012
i hear him with the Sunday thing. I was born and raised in NJ, which has exzcellent transportation, however I had spent 8 months in P.A and remember their terrible bus systems. I feel for those who DO have bus issues. Every city should cater to working ppl. Everyone needs to get to work, one way or another.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
AprilPA
Truth has a liberal bias
10:07 PM on 03/06/2012
It's about to get worse in PA with the bus systems. Here in Pittsburgh they're talking about ending service at 10 PM and drastically cutting service on weekends . Think of how many people are going to have to quit their maintenance jobs, you know cleaning offices for rich people, because they can't get a ride to and from work.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Namaste MF
08:18 PM on 03/06/2012
SHAME ON BOB EVANS! That is sick if it's true!
photo
7dr361
USAF VETERAN Older Than Dirt
08:17 PM on 03/06/2012
No more republicans with the same mind as GWB...........
photo
7dr361
USAF VETERAN Older Than Dirt
08:14 PM on 03/06/2012
come on mods I have two remarks need posted..................
photo
unclogum
Micro-bio is classified
09:14 PM on 03/06/2012
that Obama is the best and not to settle for anyone else?.