Huffpost San Francisco

Binh Thai Luc Pleads Not Guilty: Accused San Francisco Mass-Murderer Enters Plea

Posted: Updated:
BINH THAI LUC PLEA
AP

SAN FRANCISCO -- The suspect in the gruesome slayings of five people inside a San Francisco home pleaded not guilty to murder charges Thursday.

Binh Thai Luc, 35, entered his plea to five counts of murder, plus special circumstances of committing multiple murders, robbery, burglary and lying in wait. Luc faces the death penalty if convicted.

Luc appeared nervous and shook his head several times during the 20-minute hearing in San Francisco Superior Court.

"It's a very emotional thing," said Luc's attorney Mark Goldrosen, who gently placed his hand on Luc's back to calm him midway through the hearing. `It is a very difficult thing to stand up there for that long and listen to all the charges."

The rail-thin and boyish-looking Luc shuffled in and out of court, his hands handcuffed in front of him and shackled around the waist.

Goldrosen said Luc was a construction worker and a member of a plumber's union before his arrest.

Judge Samuel Feng reluctantly set bail at $25 million after initially ordering Luc held without the possibility of bail.

But to hold Luc without bail would require prosecutors to disclose enough evidence to convince the judge that Luc likely committed the murders. Prosecutor Sharon Woo said she was unwilling to do that because the investigation was still in the early stages.

"I'm still not comfortable," the judge said in ordering the $25 million bail. Federal immigration authorities also placed a "hold" on Luc because he faces deportation if convicted. He would be placed in federal custody in the event he posts bail.

Goldrosen said Luc, who was born in Vietnam, was a legal U.S. resident before his arrest. Goldrosen took over the case after another judge barred the public defender's office from representing Luc. Judge Lucy Kelly McCabe said the public defender's office had a conflict because it previously represented Luc's brother in an unrelated case. Prosecutors say Luc's brother Brian Luc may be a witness in the murder case.

Prosecutors and police have released little information about the case, including any discussion about the murder weapon. Luc is charged only with using a "blunt instrument" to kill Yuan Ji "Vincent" Lei, 32; Lei's parents, Hua Shun Lei, 65, and Wan Yi Xi, 62; sister Ying Xue Lei, 37; and his girlfriend Chia Huei Chu, 30. The bodies were found on March 23 by a relative at the family's home in the city's residential Ingleside District.

Authorities have not discussed a possible motive, but said they believe the victims were targeted.

Around the Web

Binh Thai Luc Pleads Not Guilty To Howth Street Mass Murder: SFist

Binh Thai Luc Pleads Not Guilty to All Charges of Murdering ...

Suspect In SF Ingleside Home Massacre Pleads Not Guilty « CBS ...

Man pleads not guilty in mass slaying at SF home | www.ktvu.com

Binh Thai Luc Held on $25 Million Bail | NBC Bay Area

Man pleads not guilty in slayings of 5 at CA home

Man Pleads Not Guilty in Slayings of 5 at CA Home - ABC News

Man pleads not guilty in slayings of 5 at CA home | Wichita Eagle

Brian Luc pleads not guilty to drug charges | UTSanDiego.com

Suspect in San Francisco mass killing pleads not guilty - latimes.com