iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Bosnian War: Sarajevo Marks The Conflict's 20th Anniversary

By AIDA CERKEZ 04/ 6/12 02:11 PM ET AP

SARAJEVO, Bosnia-Herzegovina — Bosnians walked silently and sobbed on Sarajevo's main street, leaving flowers and gifts on 11,541 red chairs arranged in seemingly endless rows – the number represents the men, women and children killed in a siege that ended up being the longest of a city in modern history.

Sarajevo marked the 20th anniversary of the start of the Bosnian war Friday. Exhibitions, concerts and performances were held, but the impact of the empty chairs reduced many to tears.

"It's as if the whole tragedy materialized, became visible," said Asja Rasavac, who covered her face with an umbrella, embarrassed for not being able to control the tears. "One cannot even describe the feeling. It's not hatred. It's not anger. It's just endless sadness."

Hundreds of the chairs were small, representing the slain children. On some, passers-by left teddy bears, little plastic cars, other toys or candy.

"The amount of the chairs really hit me, especially the little ones," said Ana Macanovic, who placed white roses on seven chairs – each for a member of her family killed by mortar shells during the siege.

Of the tens of thousands of passers-by, hardly anyone spoke a word. Many just walked and sobbed, overwhelmed by the length of the red river of empty chairs.

"This city needs to stop for a moment and pay tribute to its killed citizens," said Haris Pasovic, organizer of the "Sarajevo Red Line."

The Serb siege of Sarajevo went on longer than the World War II 900-day siege of Leningrad, now St. Petersburg. Its 380,000 people were left without food, electricity, water or heating for 46 months, hiding from the 330 shells a day that smashed into the city.

On the fateful day of April 6, 1992, around 40,000 people from all over the country – Muslim Bosniaks, Christian Orthodox Serbs and Catholic Croats – poured into a square further down the red street to demand peace from their quarreling nationalist politicians.

The European Community had recognized the former Yugoslav republic of Bosnia as an independent state after most of its people voted for independence. But the vote went down along ethnic lines, with Bosniaks and Croats voting for independence, and Bosnian Serbs preferring to stay with Serb-dominated Yugoslavia.

The ethnic unity being displayed on the Sarajevo square irritated Serb nationalists, who then shot into the crowd from a nearby hotel, killing five people and igniting the 1992-1995 war. The Serb nationalists, helped by neighboring Serbia, laid siege to Sarajevo and within a few months occupied 70 percent of Bosnia, expelling all non-Serbs from territory they controlled.

Bosniaks and Croats – who started off as allies – then turned against each other, so all three groups ended up fighting a war that took more than 100,000 lives, made half of the population homeless and left the once-ethnically mixed country devastated and divided into mono-ethnic enclaves.

Gianni Spanghero, 56, watched the reports on TV at his home in Gorizia, Italy, and says he couldn't really understand this was going on so close to Italy back then. He has never been in Sarajevo before and for Easter holidays decided to visit the city during the commemoration with his 15-year-old daughter Francesca.

"I read about it in the newspapers. It is so impressive. It is as if the city is talking to it's dead and saying: 'we miss you,' he said.

"I'm shocked. This is sad. Very sad," Francesca said as she fought back tears.

Shop windows displayed photographs made during the war, showing the daily suffering of the residents.

Bosnia's foreign minister, Zlatko Lagumdzija also could not control his tears.

"We owe it to the people that are not here, that we have a future here," he said. "Most of us have someone missing here."

While remembering the dead, many also cannot forget feeling that the international community had let them down during the war. All the world did was condemn the horrors in Bosnia and send food packages. What Sarajevo residents really wanted was an end to the death and destruction, the restoration of electricity, water and heating, a halt to the shelling and sniping every day.

"Those chairs are for the international community," former Bosnian vice president Ejup Ganic said. "The international community that did not help us during the war ... it is a picture of the world somehow at that time. But life goes on. We have peace without justice."

A 1995 peace agreement brokered by the U.S. ended the shooting, but its compromises left the nation ethnically divided into two ministates – one for Serbs, the other shared by Bosniaks and Croats – linked by a central government.

Ethnic mistrust is keeping the groups in Bosnia separated. Children in school are learning three different versions of history, calling their common language by three different names – Serbian, Bosnian and Croatian – and are growing isolated from each other in monoethnic enclaves.

Bosnia's leaders are still arguing about the future of the country: should it be unified or should it remain divided.

A new generation, children who were born after the war, had only one message for them on Friday.

At the end of the ceremony, they lined up among the red chairs and sang John Lennon's legendary song: "All we are saying is give peace a chance."

1  of  7
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
Red chairs are displayed along a main street in Sarajevo as the city marks the 20th anniversary of the start of the Bosnian war on Friday, April 6, 2012. City officials have lined up 11,541 red chairs arranged in 825 rows along the main street that now looks like a red river representing the 11,541 Sarajevans who were killed during the siege. (AP Photo/Amel Emric)
FOLLOW WORLD

SARAJEVO, Bosnia-Herzegovina — Bosnians walked silently and sobbed on Sarajevo's main street, leaving flowers and gifts on 11,541 red chairs arranged in seemingly endless rows – the number...
SARAJEVO, Bosnia-Herzegovina — Bosnians walked silently and sobbed on Sarajevo's main street, leaving flowers and gifts on 11,541 red chairs arranged in seemingly endless rows – the number...
Filed by Jade Walker  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 222
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:50 AM on 04/08/2012
It is good to remember however I get the sense that Bosnia is milking this conflict for every penny it can get.Western Europe witnessed the most devastating and genocidal war known to mankind during the second world war (1939-1945).But 20 years later they were well on their way to self reliance.Japan victim of two nuclear bombs was already busy cornering the car market i mean, compare this with Bosnia where are they? They are still whining about this war and are still desperate and impoverished and your life is not certain if you walk the streets.Now why is that? Serbia is doing much better then Bosnia so is Croatia.It's just a backward savage place still after 20 years.
05:56 PM on 04/08/2012
BTW there is no other explanation for this it's a conclusion that cannot be escaped by anyone. The only difference between Bosnia and Croatia or Serbia is the fact that Bosnia is Muslim.That is the only thing that separates them from those two powers.
Yet there GDP is less then half that of Croatia or Serbia.And that while the altter Serbia got a savage pounding the late 90's that pretty much destroyed their infrastructure.
05:40 PM on 05/08/2012
I fail to see how one is able to compare post WW2 Japan and post-war Bosnia. While it is true that Japan was in ruins and is now an economic giant, much of their success is due to the United States pouring millions and billions of dollars into the restoration of Japan. We wanted an ally in the Pacific, and rebuilt the entire country in the hopes that it would not fall to Communism. In Bosnia, we did no such thing.

Compare post WW1 Germany, and Germany after WW2. After the first World War, Germany's economy was in ruins, yet nobody did anything to help them. They did eventually manage to pull themselves out of their depression (which was arguable many times worse than anything we experienced in the United States), but at the cost of allowing the Nazi's to take power. After World War 2 however, we (and the rest of the Western European powers) took an active roll in rebuilding Germany, also allowing it to become an economic powerhouse. Had we done the same in Bosnia, I'm sure that they would be in much better condition.

This is not to say that they have no responsibility for their current condition, but rather one cannot compare arbitrary historical events without considering the different factors that contributed to them. Also, while milking a situation for attention is never "good", especially on the 20th anniversary of the event in question, I would give genocide victims a break.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
athiesttoo
reorganization: creating an illusion of progress
10:16 AM on 04/07/2012
and now it's Syria. Wonder how many chairs they'll have before it's over/
?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Celebrindan
M=1∞/R=dM>1
09:46 AM on 04/07/2012
Twenty years ago it was Sarajevo, today it's Homs.

We've learned nothing.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:58 AM on 04/07/2012
SOME OF US LEARNED, who is WE?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Celebrindan
M=1∞/R=dM>1
07:27 PM on 04/07/2012
'We' on this most interesting planet, is the less interesting and extremely destructive fungus, known as mankind.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
09:11 AM on 04/07/2012
Bosnian war? Bosnian genocide is more accurate.
mortonrchrd
How you gonna get down that hill
08:32 AM on 04/07/2012
The Handschar division , or 13th mountain Waffen SS, were Bosnian Muslims who fought for Hitler in WWII. The division was created by Hitler at the urging of Gestapo chief Heinrich Himmler. Recruiting was done by the Mufti of Jerusalem Mohammed al Husseini. At least 5,000 Serb partisans were killed by them in 43 & 44.
Bill Clinton killed 5,000 civilians and just over 1,000 soldiers in the 1999 Kosovo war.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
09:26 AM on 04/07/2012
As Jew and supporter of Israel, I am well aware of the Mufti's actions and those Bosnians who fought for Hitler. Nevertheless, this does not justify the slaughter of Bosnians twenty years ago. Taking your supposed logic to its natural conclusion, we could then justify the killings of this generation of Germans for what their grandfathers did during the Holocaust. Genocide is wrong. Period.
09:48 AM on 04/07/2012
Genocide is wrong indeed. But all 3 sides did it to each other...the picture portrayed around the world is unilaterally one sided. I believe that is what he was trying to portray.
mortonrchrd
How you gonna get down that hill
10:00 AM on 04/07/2012
I'm just trying to offer a bit of historical perspective, BahtHarim. My comment was more directed towards the average American who has some interest in these events, but lacks time to do a bit of historical research....As you indicate, you are already aware of these facts.
The 100 thousand deaths in the Bosnian war are tragic... Are they more tragic than the 500 thousand Serbs butchered at Jasenovac Concentration camp ? I say butchered because the method of killing was using knives.
I encourage anyone to google or wiki the facts I've posted. If I'm misled, I will admit it.
03:11 AM on 04/07/2012
This was a sad event in our history,however.
One thing I think has always been complete BS is this lame platitude that we are doomed to repeat history if we do not learn from it. I honestly think the world would be a much better place if we stopped reminding ourselves of these horrid times like this article and back to the Nazis. I do not think we need to make an anniversary out of people being killed, tortured, and or slaughtered. Maybe if the world forgets what WAR is, maybe we can come together as the human race finally. The whole thing with keeping up with our disgusting history as so called Man-Kind hasn't worked so far. We keep repeating history and it gets worse every year. I am 45 yrs old and have watched the world flush itself down the toilet in my lifetime, Then I am expected to try and teach my children there is some hope for us!?!?!?!
02:56 AM on 04/07/2012
I played basketball in high school with a Bosnian refugee. He told us a stories about seeing people killed on a daily basis.

One time he was standing on a sidewalk with a group of friends- just like we did everyday in high school in the US- when sniper fire erupted and his best friend, who was standing right next to him, was shot in the head, dying instantly. He told the story in such a detached, matter-of-fact fashion, it's stuck with me 15 years later.

I can't help but look at Germany, France, and England and wonder why they didn't do something to stop this tragedy and look at us and wonder why we didn't do more.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
jsanti7
Sin's a Good Mans Brother I Know Both
02:40 AM on 04/07/2012
Another tragic chapter in a region that has had conflict for generations ... may the next chapters not be so bloody and cruel on all sides involved.
02:31 AM on 04/07/2012
I am confused. Which is better between strongman Tito era and the current seemingly forever-split and bitter situation?
photo
southingtonian
"I'm a Capricorn and you can't make me do sh*t.."
01:15 AM on 04/07/2012
If I had had any power to stop this, it would have ended the day it began. An incredible (and I use that in its literal meaning) departure from the images of Sarajevo during the Winter Olympics of just 10 years prior. It is as though groups of us periodically lose all cerebral function.
08:51 PM on 04/06/2012
Twenty years later and this is still heart-breaking.

Every morning and every evening I heard the news from Sarajevo reported by NPR, mostly by NPR's Sylvia Poggioli. I remember her first-hand eye-witness descriptions of Sniper Alley. I remember the destruction of the Mostar Bridge, the Stari Most. The war introduced me and perhaps most others to the phrase "ethnic cleansing," and taught us to expect that the news of massacres was incomplete, and massacres were more common than we knew.

But it was the seige of Sarajevo that burned into the memory.

And I remember the disbelief and horror that the international community really did know all about what was happening in Bosnia, and was NOT willing to do anything to stop it.

The international community really is not much better today.
pixie66
per aspera ad astra
09:31 PM on 04/06/2012
Well since we learned that famous Sarajevo market shooting was a scam, and that there are people supposedly murdered in Srebrenica still alivce and well and even living in the US, and more imprortantly that Taliban (and S. Arabia) was helping the muslims I have trouble swallowing that maudlin setiment. Muslims won this war on the back of one-sided CNN reporting... BTW international "community" was TOO involved in the conflict. Firstly by helping the Croats start the bloody war. Than negotiating with the communist dictator Milosevic for YEARS... What planet do you live ON? Or should I say "pink cloud?"
10:47 PM on 04/06/2012
You tend to label just one side, the Serbs, as aggressors, while the truth is far from that. All three nations lived in Bosnia and Herzegovina and the decision to declare independence could not be made without the consensus of all three nations living in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Muslims and Croats did that backed by US, Germany and Vatican contrary to the will of Serbs living there and thus initiated War (igniting flame was killing of a best man at the Serbian wedding in Sarajevo). Later, each of the three sides led the War against remaining two, so it is not just all black and white in this conflict, like you try to present here through your ignorant and rather shallow view of War.
As all the birds know by now, there is nor there ever was, honesty and will to help in the US and NATO actions, just interests, like those, just recently, expressed and enforced in Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Yemen and so on and so on, and situations where US and NATO did nothing like in Darfur, Kongo, Rwanda, East Timor and so on, so on.
Actually, the Croatian forces destroyed (during the fierce fight with Muslims), the Stari most (Old Bridge) in Mostar, and the fact is that now, twenty years after the conflict, there are no more Serbs in Sarajevo, whereas they formed a substantial part of population of the city before the Civil War.
Indeed, siege of Sarajevo, burned into the memory.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:51 PM on 04/06/2012
From this we learn that it can happen anywhere.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
07:31 PM on 04/06/2012
Who would have ever guessed that the city in which the event that led to World War I (the assassination of Archduke Ferdinand) would later see the worst genocide in Europe since the Third Reich?
pixie66
per aspera ad astra
09:32 PM on 04/06/2012
Anyone with any knowledge...And it wasn't genocide, it was a civil war. All three parties involved commited atrocities. Go educate yourself.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
09:14 AM on 04/07/2012
The Bosnians did not have concentration camps in which they imprisoned Serbs and Croats. Bosnian men were slaughtered wholesale. This was absolutely a genocidal war against the Bosnians. YOU need to educate YOURSELF.
BahtHarim
בת ההרים
09:36 PM on 04/06/2012
Do you know what is the definition of genocide? Typical for average, ignorant, american mind who, I bet, can not even find Bosnia on the map. You should not comment on matters that you have no knowledge (other than that provided to you by brainwashing media in US) or valid information whatsoever about conflict in former Yugoslavia, nor about history of that region. The final result is that now, there is no more Serbs in Sarajevo, it was once multicultural town, and now it is only a muslim town.
pixie66
per aspera ad astra
10:32 PM on 04/06/2012
Well, firstry you are a bigot, since you called me "an IGNIORANT and average american" You know nothing about me. I have a degre in political science and I STUDIED the conflict in the former YU.
Secondly, the "brainwashing media" in the US supported the muslim cause as well as the croat cause.
Thirdly, the DEFINITION of genocide is the systematic extermination of the people (not just the men of fighting age). And the International Court has ruled that there wasn't a genocide although what was done in Croatia is definitely "ethnic cleansing".
Lastly, you came here to wage some virtual war in lack of the real one you seem to miss.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
10:49 PM on 04/06/2012
Not only CAN I find Bosnia on a map, I can find every other country. As for questioning whether or not genocide took place, did you even read the article?
photo
climbing panda
there's a log in my cabin
07:19 PM on 04/06/2012
was this the war where america sacrificed blood and treasure to stop the genocide of muslims?
08:54 PM on 04/06/2012
Actually no. This was the war when the US and NATO had countless opportunities to stop the genocide of Muslims, but stood by and allowed it to happen.

You are thinking of the later conflict in Kosovo, when the US did at long last use its military might to take the fight to the aggressors, the Serbs, who promptly lost their taste for genocide. Pity that NATO and the US hadn't tried that a few years sooner.
pixie66
per aspera ad astra
09:51 PM on 04/06/2012
Of please and no one commited atrocities against the Serbs?Go google "Oluja..." That's just wishful thinking...Regarding Kosova, there's an ongoing investigation into organ trafficking of saughtered serbs which ended up in foreign coutries trafficked by Albanian mafia. give me a breat...Anyone can google albanian organ trafficking...
A lot of muslims and chatolics from the former YU spreading propaganda...20 years later.
10:05 PM on 04/06/2012
Again, do you know the definition of genocide? The proper way is to educate yourself, before permitting yourself to even think of discussing serious issues. It was, in fact (contrary to that what media in US say) the civil war in former Yugoslavia and Bosnia Herzegovina, with casualties and atrocities committed on both sides.
Kosovo was and still is a part of Serbia, sovereign country (majority of the countries in the UN still think so), and the real truth is that US armed and trained rebells and paramilitary formations in Kosovo, and initiated conflict solely because of US interests, just like US armed and trained Bin Laden in Afghanistan in the eighties, Nguyen Van Thieu in Vietnam, rebels in Lybia, now Syria and so many, many others that the list would be too long to stand here. Anyway, Kosovo is currently NATO occupied land, with absolute majority of serbian population banished and expelled from the territory and a lot of serbian orthodox churches and monasteries, far older than US, destroyed. Kosovo is the region with substantial mineral resources and now, after conflict, there stands Camp Bondsteel, second largest US military base in Europe.