iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Elite Soccer Players Score Higher On Cognitive Test

Posted: 04/ 6/2012 8:23 am

Soccer Smarts

The trope of the dumb jock is regularly eviscerated by reports of such brainy top-performers as the Knicks' Harvard grad, Jeremy Lin, or the Oakland A's Craig Breslow, a Yale graduate who was accepted to NYU's prestigious medical school. But now there's actually proof that athletes are exercising their neurologic pathways along with their muscles: a study from the Karolinska Institute found that elite soccer players demonstrated above-average cognitive abilities.

The particular area of thinking at which soccer players excel is executive function -- a term that includes creative problem solving, multi-tasking, inhibition and working memory. That last one, working memory, refers to the ability to recall previously stored information on the spot and use it to problem solve. Many of these are skills that can be seen on the field: employing strategy in the midst of a game (creativity, working memory), executing a play while also surveying the field (multi-tasking) and following the rules of the game (inhibition). Indeed, as CNN reported, previous research has attributed heightened cognitive abilities to athletes:

The phenomenon has not been studied in detail before with regard to professional athletes. But previous research showed expert sports players have enhanced abilities in things like evaluating probabilities, recognizing patterns and using information from peripheral vision.

Researchers administered an established cognitive function exam (for which there is a national average) to 57 male and 26 female soccer players from Sweden's three top ranked national divisions. They then compared the players' results to the average score from a 2007 nation-wide sample. Not only did the elite players' score above average for executive function, their cognitive scores went up as their playing scores did: in other words, the more skilled a player was on the field, the higher they tested for executive function. That's important because it implies an actual association between soccer skill and cognitive ability, rather than the influence of a tertiary factor.

Still there remains a "chicken-and-egg" question: are brainy soccer players born or made? Do people with elevated executive function reach elite levels of soccer playing? Or does all that game-time experience and scrimmaging result in improved thought patterns? The researchers hedged a bit: "The study cannot answer the question whether the difference in executive functions mirrors practice or genes. There is probably both an inherited component and a component that is trained," they said in a statement.

FOLLOW HEALTHY LIVING

Filed by Meredith Melnick  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onionboy
Blessed are the Cheese Makers
03:59 PM on 04/09/2012
I've read this about other athletes too. Soccer is kind of 'top-down' sport. I remember reading something about this with regard to NBA (possibly NCAA too...can't recall) point-guards too, not shooting guards, but guys with a lot of assists. I don't know about IQ, but they tended to do very well outside of basketball compared to their peers. That seems to share a similar feature with soccer players...the need to see the big picture, know where everyone is and/or is likely to be in the next few seconds.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
montanasian
Still trying to make it up the learning curve.
11:28 AM on 04/08/2012
I wonder what sports have what IQ attributed to them? And there is IQ of the fans; that could be skewed to the left a little.
10:47 PM on 04/06/2012
Makes sense , as soccer players really need to plan a few steps ahead of actual game situations, and must innovate on the fly. Since the game has few stops, it probably only adds to this ability.
09:38 PM on 04/06/2012
The number of participants stated in the article appears to be incorrect. The paper reads as follows: "The participants in the first (cross-sectional) part of the study included 57 male (n = 31) and female (n = 26) players ." Seems clear that there are 57 total players involved, 31 males and 26 females.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bradlinsky
Concept Other Than Self
08:49 AM on 04/06/2012
This makes absolute, perfect sense! I tell my girls - I coach U10 and U14 competitive soccer - that soccer isn't in the body/legs it is in the head, and heart. Most people can reach a level at which they can compete physically, generally. However, only a few excel at the mental aspect. I put it this way: there are many people who know how to play soccer, but there aren't many SOCCER PLAYERS.

As to the chicken-egg scenario from the article: Which comes first, the ability to understand the game, or can anyone learn with the proper coaching? I believe if one applies themselves then they can learn to be a soccer player and develop their cognitive abilities beyond the norm. Some have a higher aptitude for it, sure, like in anything. Just like some girls are physically more "gifted" naturally.

The *problem* is, at least from what I've seen in the US, is that most coaches at most ages concentrate way too much on foot skills, dribbling and all that stuff, and not NEARLY enough on how to really play this beautiful game.
02:39 PM on 04/09/2012
If US coaches spend too much time on footskills, it's most likely because players don't spend enough time doing it on their own. I understand what you're saying, but players cannot execute in the game if they don't have basic skills. That's the reason the US is behind.

This study on brain development is very encouraging.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bradlinsky
Concept Other Than Self
09:26 AM on 04/10/2012
Yes, excellent point. Many have pointed out that soccer in this country is more of a "suburban" sport that costs money and necessitates a lot of travel. Granted. And, other than Hispanic kids and a few others, most kids in this country aren't playing pick-up soccer games and shooting for the stars like they do for basketball, football, etc. Not a lot of kids hang out with their families watching soccer on television, either. So their whole understanding of the game, especially all the nuances, is very limited.

Luckily around here - Northern VA - there are plenty of 'foot skills' clinics and that sort of thing. But the kids have to practice on their own! As a coach, however, I do not want to 'train'. I want to coach. And with such limited time I want to concentrate on the things you (should) do the most in every game: control the ball, look up, pass and run.