Huffpost Los Angeles

PetSmart Sued For Puppy's Death After English Bulldog Was Allegedly Strangled (PHOTOS)

Posted: Updated:
PUP
Rita the puppy. | Veronica Espinoza/John Benitez

Rita, the adorable four-month-old English bulldog puppy depicted above, was allegedly strangled to death while in the care of PetSmart's groomers, the LA Weekly first reported.

The owners of the pup, Veronica Espinoza and John Benitez, filed a lawsuit against the store Monday. The owners' attorney, Jill Ryther, gave The Huffington Post an account of what happened on the tragic day of the doggie's death.

Rita's owners dropped her off on May 12, 2011 at 8 a.m. at the PetSmart in Downey, Calif. Two hours later, they received a call from the store saying that Rita was throwing up blood and that they needed to take her to a veterinarian right away. Espinoza and Benitez rushed over and took Rita to the vet, where she died 45 minutes later.

Ryther said that the necropsy results suggested that the dog had been strangled. "The report said that because her lungs had been filled with blood, she wasn’t able to breath," explained Ryther. "Her trachea was pushed up four or six inches, possibly from trying to revive her."

She continued, "It looked like someone had tried to do CPR on her after she stopped breathing. There were marks on her neck looking like she'd been strangled."

Owner Benitez recounted to HuffPost, "We were all going through a rough time when we got Rita, and when we would come home to her, she made us laugh. She was such a perfect puppy." He continued, "The way she died and the way they handled the situation, it was just so horrible. It made the situation so much worse."

In regards to the cause of Rita's strangulation, Ryther said, "I have no idea whether it was intentional or the dog was left unattended and somehow was hung. I really don't know."

After Rita's death, PetSmart sent Espinioza and Benitez a check for $2,000 and offered to replace the puppy in exchange for them agreeing not to sue, according to Ryther. The owners did not agree and, instead, contacted Ryther.

On June 6, 2011, Ryther sent a letter to PetSmart clarifying that her clients do not accept the check. The letter added, "The tragic death of Rita cannot be cured simply by you replacing her with a new puppy."

Because the store ignored the letter, Ryther said, she filed the lawsuit. Ryther and her clients are seeking damages in excess of $25,000, which includes pain and suffering, medical expenses, punitive damages and lost wages. Ryther said that, because the owners are "really traumatized," they've missed a number of days of work.

In response to the lawsuit, PetSmart released the following statement to HuffPost:

The death of Rita, an English Bulldog puppy, is a tragic loss. Many of us at PetSmart are pet parents, and no words can express our deep sorrow for this family’s loss.


We take very seriously the trust placed in us by pet parents who each day leave their pets in our care. Nothing is more important than looking after the safety and well-being of pets as if they were our own.


The facts as represented in the recently distributed press release by an attorney are not what we believe to be true relative to this unfortunate situation. As a practice, however, PetSmart does not comment on pending litigation.

PetSmart has been sued in the past by a man who slipped on dog feces in the store; by a family whose dog was killed by a PetSmart employee's dog at the store; by a woman alleging a sick hamster from PetSmart led to her husband's death; by a woman alleging a sick cockatiel from PetSmart led to her father's death; and others.

Benitez recalled the day Rita died to HuffPost: "I took the day off because it was her first time being groomed, and we were so excited. I played with her all morning. It was such a good day." After Rita died, he said, "I feel so bad, like I took her to her death."

Check out pictures of the puppy, Rita, here:

of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide

Around the Web

PetSmart Sued for Hamster Blamed in Deaths of Three People | Fox ...

Man Sues Petsmart For $1 Million After Stepping In Dog Poop - The ...

PetSmart sued for $1 million over slippery feces - Daily Press

The Hamster Did It: PetSmart Sued Over Diseased Hamster in ...

News, PetSmart Sued for Hamster Blamed in Deaths of Three People ...

Peninsula man sues pet shop after slipping on dog feces ...

Ex-employee sues PetSmart for sexual harassment | San Francisco ...

A dog eats dog world: Petsmart sues over noncompete.

PetSmart, former manager sued for sexual harassment, wrongful ...

PetSmart News and Video - FOX Business Topics - FOXBusiness.com

PetSmart settles dog poop lawsuit | WAVY.com | Newport News, Va.

Consumer complaints about PetSmart

PetSmart Dog Bite Lawsuit - PritzkerOlsen, PA

Dog owner sues PetSmart after grooming incident - Roanoke.com

Puppy Strangled at PetSmart, L.A. Lawsuit Alleges: PHOTOS - Los ...

Dog owner sues PetSmart after grooming incident - Topix