iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Susana Martinez, New Mexico Governor, Asks Federal Officials To Stop Horse Slaughterhouse

First Posted: 04/13/2012 3:11 pm Updated: 04/13/2012 5:17 pm

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (AP) — New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez said Friday she is asking federal officials not to allow a southeastern New Mexico company to open the nation's first slaughterhouse for horses since 2007.

Martinez plans to send a letter to the U.S. Department of Agriculture asking it deny a Roswell meat company's request for inspections that would allow it to operate.

"Despite the federal government's decision to legalize horse slaughter for human consumption, I believe creating a horse slaughtering industry in New Mexico is wrong and I am strongly opposed," Martinez said in a statement.

Valley Meat Co. has filed an application with the U.S. Department of Agriculture for its 7,300-square-foot plant outside of town. Documents obtained by the Humane Society of the United States and Front Range Equine Rescue show that horses would be "custom slaughtered" and processed for human consumption at the plant, the Albuquerque Journal reported (http://bit.ly/IlnrcB ).

Valley Meat didn't immediately returns calls from the Associated Press on Friday.

USDA spokesman Aaron Lavallee said in a statement that there are no facilities approved for horse slaughter in the United States.

"One establishment, located in New Mexico, recently applied for a grant of inspection exclusively for equine and USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service is reviewing the application," Lavallee said.

Horse slaughter has effectively been blocked since Congress withheld funds for USDA inspections of horse meat plants in 2006. But a recently passed agriculture bill provides the money.

The last horse slaughterhouse closed in Illinois in 2007. Since Congress renewed inspection funding, several plants are under consideration, including one in Missouri that would process up to 200 animals a day.

More than 100,000 American horses are shipped out of the country to plants in Canada and Mexico for slaughter each year, and their meat is bound for markets in Europe and Asia, according to the Humane Society. Although there are reports of Americans dining on horse meat a recently as the 1940s, the practice is virtually non-existent in this country.

A spokesman for New Mexico Attorney General Gary King said his office so far has found no legal basis for stopping the plant, but a lawyer has been assigned to continue looking into the matter.

"A horse slaughtering plant in Roswell is a terrible idea. Such a practice, while not illegal, is certainly abhorrent to public sentiment, and I strongly suggest it be abandoned," King, a Democrat, said in a written statement.

"Horses are different and should be treated differently," he said.

The Humane Society, Front Range Equine Rescue and other groups are pushing the federal government to ban the export of American horses for the foreign meat market and to formally prohibit the slaughter of horses for human consumption in the United States.

"Horse slaughter for food is a national disgrace, given the iconic nature of American horses and the especially brutal methods used to kill them," Front Range Equine Rescue said in a statement.

Pro-slaughter activists say the horse slaughter ban had unintended consequences, including an increase in neglect and the abandonment of the animals.

Details about the extent of the proposed horse slaughtering operation were unavailable, but the application obtained by the groups says the plant would only handle horses, not cattle or chickens. The plant would operate eight hours a day year-round, according to the application.

Front Range's lawyer, Bruce Wagman, said Valley Meat first filed an application for USDA inspections in December, and then a second application in March.

The groups said it has obtained email correspondence showing that company representatives have been talking for months to officials from the Denver office of the Food Safety and Inspection Service, which inspects animals and meats in American slaughterhouses.

According to Front Range, one January email from an FSIS official said, "Public wants assurances there is no way for horse meat to get into their beef products."

The USDA said FSIS regulations prohibit horse slaughter or other preparation of horse products in the same establishment in which cattle, sheep, swine or goats are slaughtered or their products are prepared.

Critics also contend former companion, working, racing and wild horses should not be used as human food because drugs routinely given to such horses are potentially dangerous to people.

Elisabeth Jennings, executive director of Animal Protection of New Mexico, said residents of a state with roots in cowboy culture "have a deep and enduring appreciation for horses, especially given their important role in our state's rural way of life."

"It is an affront to our citizens to suggest bringing the cruel, dangerous and polluting enterprise of horse slaughter to New Mexico as we celebrate our state's centennial," she said.

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST GREEN

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (AP) — New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez said Friday she is asking federal officials not to allow a southeastern New Mexico company to open the nation's first slaughterhouse for hors...
ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. (AP) — New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez said Friday she is asking federal officials not to allow a southeastern New Mexico company to open the nation's first slaughterhouse for hors...
Filed by James Gerken  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 328
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
10:12 PM on 06/02/2012
We must close this predatory industry. Hopefully, we are one step closer. Viande Richelieu, the company that operates two of Canada’s four equine slaughterhouses, appears to be backing away from accepting Thoroughbreds for slaughter after their unusual move of returning slaughter-bound former racehorses Canuki and Cactus Cafe.

The two Thoroughbreds left Beulah Park’s barn area May 1 after their owner, Barbara Price, allegedly sold them to trainer Mark Wedig. Ohio stewards investigating the horses’ whereabouts ruled Price off for a year and fined her $1,000 for impeding the investigation and providing false information. About three weeks later, Wedig presented Canuki and Cactus Cafe to West Virginia state veterinarian John Day in connection with Mountaineer Park officials’ inquiry into the horses’ whereabouts.

According to a May 24 e-mail from Richlieu administrative technician Geneve Ethier to Mindy Lovell, a Canadian farm owner whom Ohio stewards authorized to contact Richelieu on their behalf, the Canuki and Cactus Cafe case “did occur major problems to us and a lot of time, efforts, and money consuming. So to avoid that in the future, the plant advises all his suppliers to not BUY those thoroughbred[s] and overall not have them ship to us. . . . For us, thoroughbred[s] are definitely banned from our premises.”

http://www.drf.com/news/canadian-slaughterhouse-firm-no-longer-accepting-thoroughbreds
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
06:07 PM on 05/08/2012
Why am I not surprised that horse meat is shipped to Asia?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PiedType
Old editors never die, they just revert to type
07:03 PM on 04/16/2012
Horse meat is not something Americans want. Slaughtering American horses for export is nothing but greed. I suggest the owners of the potential slaughterhouse find some other way to make money.
photo
bad spelling grammar
Help save Big Cats from extinction!
12:58 PM on 04/16/2012
Another step backwards for America, this country is literaly heading back in time with these insane new laws
01:23 AM on 04/16/2012
Who determines which animal has more of a right to live. Stop killing cows, chickens, fish and rabbits. They shoot horses after racing injuries and the poor animal just gets buried or cremated. Why don't they outlaw that practice too?
04:54 PM on 04/15/2012
I love horses. I grew up around them and formed relationships with the ones I knew. I couldn't imagine eating any horse, ever. Having said that, I couldn't eat (or personally slaughter) ANY animal I had a relationship with. That goes for my 4 pet goats and 24 chickens who give me eggs every day. The only way I can kill an animal is for quality of life issues. If it was a matter of survival (me or them) in an extreme situation, then maybe. I do eat meat and I've seen Food, Inc. I DO NOT like the slaughter process. I'm torn and feel 100% hypocritical. It's totally an ignorance is "bliss" situation.
unique
Animal lover forever
04:41 PM on 04/15/2012
Please someone tell me what the rich will not do for money?
Kudos to Gov. Martinez. She should run for president.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patianneb
toothed night fury
01:37 PM on 04/15/2012
God bless the Governor.
photo
Artemesian
Spiritual Messenger of the Earth
07:54 AM on 04/15/2012
I believe the entire subject of horse slaughter has been revived because the economy is so bad, and/or the unscrupulous want to take advantage of the situation. I associate eating horsemeat with bad times and the Great Depression, and after the wars in Europe because people had no money and had to eat it out of desperation. On the plus side, meat was scarce so any animal eaten was used to its fullest and not wasted. In modern times we are too wasteful with food.

I don't think times are so tough that we have to resort to jobs we find morally objectionable, do we?

Times and cultures change and evolve. Horsemeat is generally taboo in a lot of countries, you can find it in Europe but I believe it is generally frowned upon in modern times, or a delicacy considered by some. I believe in France they have their own butcher shops for cheval and it is not sold in the regular butcher shops. Sounds a little 'taboo' to me, but I may be wrong. Horses are not currently raised for food and don't come under the bare minimum food regulations and protections that other animals used for food do. Until that changes, horsemeat is not only inhumane but unsafe. That's the major answer to the question "why cattle and not horses" that I can see. Horses are considered companion animals by most Western countries, and also in the Middle East they have been praised throughout history.
(continued)
photo
Artemesian
Spiritual Messenger of the Earth
08:30 AM on 04/15/2012
I don't have a problem with people who eat meat or ethical hunters because if you look at the food chain of carnivores, omnivores and hervbivores, and humans are no different than any other omnivore (even tho we like to think we are better). It's the indifference and the inhumanity of slaughterhouses that I have a problem with. They are hellish places; but the reason they exist is because so many animals need to be processed for our ever-growing population's food consumption. The more people, the more animals raised, the more land taken up, the more water used, and the more waste disposal for communities and water supplies.

So, the question of why cattle and not horses is obvious - we don't need them because in today's world we have other food sources, if we don't like that we can all stop eating cattle.

Humanity is supposed to the capacity for kindness and empathy if we choose to use those qualities in the way people treat other living things and each other. Slaughterhouses for horses are exceptionally cruel, and horses are sensitive and aware creatures. Plant owners could take the steps to make slaughterhouses and the conditions under which farm animals are raised much more humane according to Dr. Temple Grandin, but are too cheap and greedy to do it.

Once you figure out that everything revolves around money and nothing else, it makes people's motiviations and the world a whole lot easier to figure out!
11:38 AM on 04/15/2012
Very well said. Another thing - since horses are not raised by anyone like farmers/ranchers raise food animals, the killer buyers - as we call them - must acquire them one by one or at best a few at the time. Many horses are stolen, especially in the area of a slaughter plant. Killers watch the For Sale ads and misrepresent themselves to sellers who would never knowingly sell their horse into slaughter. Many people are naive enough to believe their good horse will find a good home at the local auction. Wrong! The good - fat, healthy, sound, young - horses are the very ones the killers go after. You can't sell old, crippled, sick horses for human consumption, The slaughter plants refuse them.

I lived in Dallas, TX right between both Beltex and Dallas Crown when they were still operating. As I have repeatedly told people, it's a nightmare for horse owners - fear of their horses being stolen, fear that if you sell your horse it will be to a killer in disguise, fear that if you allow your horse out of your own hands, he/she will end up in the slaughter pipeline one way or the other. NO horse owner wants this!
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:42 AM on 04/15/2012
Martinez has some hidden agenda. She is not doing this out of humane motives. How does she feel about eating beef?
Watch how cows are often treated at slaughter houses if you have the scruples: http://humanesociety.org/news/news/2008/01/undercover_investigation_013008.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Duke T Draz
Conservative Independent Female.
04:24 AM on 04/15/2012
Her motives are not important at this point. Those things need to be stopped any way anyone can. Those things need to be slaughtered themselves and processed and then flushed into the sewage system! Stop them any way you can!
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
11:43 PM on 04/15/2012
You can't defeat them if you don't know who you are fighting.
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:08 AM on 04/15/2012
Just had to jump on this one - journalists help propagate the misnomer "America(n)" when referring to the US, -More than 100,000 American horses are shipped out of the country to plants in Canada and Mexico for slaughter each year - Mexico and Canada are America. So "American horses" are shipped to America?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Duke T Draz
Conservative Independent Female.
04:25 AM on 04/15/2012
Why would anyone ship anything to Mexico or Canada? They could drive.
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
11:08 AM on 04/15/2012
Only if you have cravings for bullets (in Mexico). Sure drive several hours for a burger.
11:42 AM on 04/15/2012
Horses are shipped across these borders in large trailers for slaughter.
11:41 AM on 04/15/2012
They mean the United States of America, as you well know. Canada is part of North America, but does not have "America" in the countries NAME. Neither does Mexico as a country in Central America.

And, your point is........?
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
02:51 PM on 04/16/2012
forget it you missed it.
12:11 AM on 04/15/2012
I made a comment yesterday, but it seems to have disappeared...

My biggest concern is the long distance shipping of these poor creatures. Especially to the plants in Mexico! Have you ever driven on the highway past one of these packed trucks? It is sickening!

There will always be somebody that will try a make a buck off of cheap horse meat. Hard to imagine, but there are people out there that buy up unwanted horses (usually at auctions) and haul them away. So, off they go, for thousands of miles in cramped trailers.

In the heat. With no water. For hours at a time. You will never see a packed trailer with horses pulled over somewhere so they can get out and have a drink and stretch their legs. And roll. And run around for a few minutes.

Nope, because that just doesn't happen. They just keep going down the highway to the slaughterhouse. Gotta get across the border. Gotta make a living.

So New Mexico, keep it out of your backyard. Because, if you don't see it, it's not there. And then you've done your job. Good for you! Just watch out for those trucks going across the border. And whatever you do, don't look at the eyes peering out through the cracks of the trailer. Because as far as you are concerned, you've fixed that problem!
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:11 AM on 04/15/2012
Not sure how they are shipped -but horse meat is not cheap. In places like Mexico and France it is preferred over beef. Although as with any commodity, I'm sure there are operators with no scruples.
11:50 AM on 04/15/2012
There were the exact same shipping conditions when the domestic plants were open. These trucks are owned by AMERICANS and are transporting horses just like they always have. It's against the law, but since when did the USDA ever enforce it's own laws? The distances within the US are vast, and we only had THREE slaughter plants - one in DeKalb, IL and two in TX - Ft. Worth and Kaufman. But those were within 60 miles of each other, so, from a distance standpoint, they only counted as one. There are many places closer to Mexico and Canada than that! Also, ALL the big commercial plants in Mexico, ALL plants in Canada and ALL our domestic plants were owned by the same Belgian/Dutch companies and ran under the very same European Union rules. All the same. All horrible.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddeanfountain
I think micro-bios are overrated!
10:34 PM on 04/14/2012
What, did I read that correctly! A republican governor that has the nerve to request that the life of lowly farm animals be spared denying the republican's desire to control this nation through their control and expansion of capitalism. Hey I thought creating jobs was your priority but I guess that only applies if it infringes on what others consider to be morally objectionable.
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:11 AM on 04/15/2012
There must be other than humane reasons for her move.
11:57 AM on 04/15/2012
Slaughter plants provide VERY few jobs for Americans. Most use Hispanics - preferably undocumented so they will have no recourse for being under paid, no benefits, dangerous working conditions, etc. It's a documented fact that crime increases dramatically in areas where there are horse slaughter plants. Documented environmental damage because horses have twice as much blood as cattle and there is a great deal of waste because horse blood and by-products are contaminated by banned chemicals. So ALL this must be disposed of in a way that will not damage the environment - which doesn't seem possible when you look at the records of all the horse slaughter plants.

Horse slaughter is an extremely poor way to provide minimally paying, dangerous, dehumanizing high turnover jobs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddeanfountain
I think micro-bios are overrated!
03:02 AM on 04/16/2012
"Documented environmental damage because horses have twice as much blood as cattle and there is a great deal of waste because horse blood and by-products are contaminated by banned chemicals."

Twice as much blood huh. All mammals contain 7 to 10% blood as a portion to their body mass. A 1000lb horse has now greater amount of blood than a 1000lb cow! Did you miss that in biology class? Only animals that were administered banned chemicals which in the case of the links you provided, appear to be primarily thoroughbreds and I seriously doubt a horse owner would pay thousands and thousands of dollars for a thoroughbred to simply send it to slaughter. I get the distinct impression your arguments have nothing to do with any safety factor but rather you're simply hung up on the idea of eating a "noble" beast so you would deny others as well! Have you ever eaten anything that didn't come in a plastic wrapped package purchased from your grocer's meat department?
photo
freedom1947
San Juan River Fishin'
05:04 PM on 04/14/2012
That's only the second thing that martinez has given me hope for in New Mexico. The first has to do with thieving politicians. To bad the rest of america finds the need to cover things up.
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:13 AM on 04/15/2012
The rest of america covers things up? Do you think there is no political agenda behind her decision? This woman is not what I consider humane.
photo
freedom1947
San Juan River Fishin'
03:55 PM on 04/15/2012
Only two items on my plate about her. The rest including my med cannabis is off limits.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
see-ellen2001
04:52 PM on 04/14/2012
Some animals are more equal than others....fries with that hamburger?
photo
niko73
Dem belly full but we hungry
08:57 PM on 04/14/2012
Strange, isn't it? I would think 1 horse soul = 1 cow soul, but reading these comments, I am obviously mistaken.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddeanfountain
I think micro-bios are overrated!
10:44 PM on 04/14/2012
Next thing you know they'll be denying egg production because colored eggs are tied to the man made ritualistic Easter celebration and don't get me started on rabbit production! The only thing that makes horse a more noble animal than any other animal are the fools that place this animal on some kind of imaginary animal social ladder. I think they should all be forced to witness the slaughter of any animal they consume at dinner time and see if they feel the same afterwards.
photo
Razpooten
Nil homini certum est
03:14 AM on 04/15/2012
Yes, same soul, just leaner.