iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

New Mexico Slaughterhouse Owner Plans To Process Horses For Meat, Send To Mexico

04/14/12 02:27 PM ET AP

ROSWELL, N.M. -- The owner of a New Mexico slaughterhouse is defending his plan to become the first plant in the nation since 2007 to handle horses after an outcry from politicians and animal activists.

In interviews with the Roswell Daily Record and the Albuquerque Journal on Friday, Valley Meat Co. owner Rick De Los Santos said he's trying to revive his failing business and that what he's proposing is legal.

The horses he plans to process are being slaughtered anyway in Mexico and his operation would be overseen by the U.S. Department of Agriculture and meet much higher standards, he said.

The company's application for federal inspections at the plant just outside Roswell triggered an outcry when it became public Friday, with New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez calling on the USDA to deny his application.

If his application to the USDA is approved, De Los Santos said horse meat will be exported to Mexico and be for Mexican consumption. He said the exportation of horse carcasses might be a better option than exporting live horses to Mexico, which involves holding the horses at the border. De Los Santos also said horse slaughter methods in Mexico may be less humane than in the U.S.

"There's no regulation as to how they (slaughter horses) in Mexico," De Los Santos told the Daily Record. "It's nowhere close to the USDA standards."

Horse slaughter has effectively been blocked since Congress withheld funds for USDA inspections of horse meat plants in 2006. But a recently passed agriculture bill provides the money.

De Los Santos said the official number for live American horses exported to other countries for slaughter is 100,000; but the figure may be closer to 130,000.

"All I'm saying is we can take some of those and slaughter them here," De Los Santos told the Journal.

The company, which has a 7,290 square-foot plant on a 10-acre site, has been slaughtering cattle for about 20 years, but has recently been unable to continue doing business because the cost of cattle has risen dramatically with the recession.

The company that once had 40 to 45 employees is currently not operating. Slaughtering horses, De Los Santos said, might be the only way to save his company. He laid off his last 10 employees three weeks ago.

"All we're doing is trying to make a living," he said. "My whole life is invested in this business." He said he was unaware until recently that, if approved, his company would be the only slaughterhouse in the U.S. to slaughter equines.

The USDA is reviewing Valley Meat's application for a grant of inspection, which would put federal inspectors in the plant to oversee the processing. The agency said Friday that it had earlier rejected three horse-processing applications because the plants would also process cattle. The USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service bars the processing of horses with any other animal.

If he receives USDA approval, De Los Santos told the Journal that he planned to slaughter 20 to 25 horses per day to start "which is not a whole lot, compared to what's available."

The meat from his plant would be exported by an El Paso partner, whom he declined to name, into Mexico. "Everyone who's ever eaten tacos in Mexico, I guarantee you they've eaten horse meat down there," he said. "It would never be my intention to sell it in the U.S."

Valley Meat's application to the USDA was disclosed this week by Front Range Equine Rescue, which obtained USDA documents and emails through a federal records request.

Gov. Martinez, a Republican, and Attorney General Gary King and State Land Commissioner Ray Powell, both Democrats, voiced opposition to the horse slaughtering plan Friday.

King called the prospect of a horse slaughtering operation in the Roswell area "a terrible idea" while Powell, a veterinarian, said: "New Mexico can do much better by these intelligent and gentle creatures."

Martinez's office said the governor plans to send a letter to the USDA urging the federal agency not to allow the horse slaughtering operation, and she will seek the support of New Mexico's delegation in Washington, D.C.

"A horse's companionship is a way of life for many people across New Mexico. We rely on them for work and bond with them through their loyalty," Martinez said. "Despite the federal government's decision to legalize horse slaughter for human consumption, I believe creating a horse slaughter industry in New Mexico is wrong and I am strongly opposed."

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW FOOD

ROSWELL, N.M. -- The owner of a New Mexico slaughterhouse is defending his plan to become the first plant in the nation since 2007 to handle horses after an outcry from politicians and animal activist...
ROSWELL, N.M. -- The owner of a New Mexico slaughterhouse is defending his plan to become the first plant in the nation since 2007 to handle horses after an outcry from politicians and animal activist...
Filed by Carey Polis  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 462
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
01:05 PM on 03/16/2013
This is outrageous. The horse represents America in so many ways. Horses should be protected . The inhumane operations of slaughterhouses is enough to make one throw up. I hope States in act laws that forbid horses to be taken across state lines for slaughter like we did in Calif. several years ago.
01:01 PM on 03/16/2013
This is outrageous . I can not belive the DEPT. of AG. supporting such evil stuff all for greed of the owners of the slaughter house. IT should be stopped and states should forbid horses to be sold across state lines to be slaughtered. Horses helped to discover this great nation of ours and need to be protected. I would never spend a nickle in New Mexico if this is allowed . It needs to be stopped.
12:42 PM on 05/28/2012
I wish people would read what is really going on before they start spotting off about something they no nothing about. If you read the studies on unwanted horses they have been turned loose left to starve and tortured because there is no plce for them. If you do the research there are to many horses in the US. I have horses and I love and care for mine probably better than most but I have owned horses that were of no use to anyone they would get someone killed and they came to me this way well I say ley them feed someone instead of kill some one read your facts do there search before you can not be blind to both sides or closed minded. No one is telling you to slaught your horse this is an a personnel right to do as they see fit with their own property.
11:49 AM on 08/02/2012
AMEN!! At least being slaughtered would be much better than starving to death on the plains! I wish people really knew what the cost has been to horse owners after the slaughter houses were closed. Hay prices have doubled because we have to feed all the horses that are now not being slaughtered and it is causing horse owners who used to afford their horses give them up because they cannot afford to feed them anymore . . . So if you ask me closing the slighter houses has worked backwards and we are not just putting ourselves in a bind. If this man can employ and make a living slaughtering horses then good for him. I love horses and I would never want to slaughter them but I know it has to be done, just like dogs and cats, they get put down too no one cries to stop that because they know it is not best for the animals.
01:44 PM on 09/05/2012
Part 1-
The idea that horse slaughter prevents abuse/neglect is a myth propagated by Sue Wallis/Big Ag/pro slaughter people. The largest horse slaughter neglect case in TX took place right outside of Kaufman, TX when Dallas Crowne Slaughterhouse was opened. The horses were owned by a VET. In addition, I am in El Paso, and we have a Killer auction 15 min from here monthly. Plus, if you put a free horse ad on CL you'll have 5 or 6 kiler buyers show up the same day to take the horse. Yet we have people with starving horses in their back yard. Of course we also have dumped or starving dogs, and that's with having an animal control in town that will take any and every pet for free. Some people are just irresponsible.
In addition, when reports of abandoned horses began surfacing, they were investigated. Some, like in KY were found to have owners who just turn them out yearly on the stripmines to graze. The majority were abandoned by killer buyers after the horses were rejected at the border. See report here-http://www.harnesslink.com/www/Article.cgi?ID=94627&fb_comment_id=fbc_10150453189172875_20359683_10150453956727875#f35f2cd2ef9015c
It is also legal to shoot and eat your own horse. So for those who say, It's too expensive to humanely euth, and dispose of a horse, well, there you go. Horses can also be composted. It comes down to being responsible.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dbrett480
06:09 PM on 05/08/2012
It sounds gross, but I've eaten in Mexico so I'm sure some horse, cat, and dog have been thrown in.
07:25 PM on 04/17/2012
This just in, Cows think you are all hypocrites!
06:29 PM on 04/17/2012
... anything for a capitalist buck ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greggied
Prying open my third eye
05:25 PM on 04/17/2012
Oops! I meant " I guess THEY should eat horses if they want to"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greggied
Prying open my third eye
05:23 PM on 04/17/2012
So what? If people eat cows, pigs, chickens, turkeys, ducks, deer, etc., I guess than should eat horses if they want to. Millions of starving people in the world, and this is the cause people get behind.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:41 PM on 04/17/2012
For all of you saying that horses are being abandoned, dogs and cats are being abandoned also. Should we slaughter them and export their meat? Provide a reliable market for the puppy mills? Irresponsible breeding is the problem. Hopefully with the downturn in the economy, people will breed in lesser numbers and breed superior animals that grow up to be trained and marketable to responsible horse owners.
photo
Artemesian
Spiritual Messenger of the Earth
01:12 PM on 04/17/2012
The majority of Americans find eating horsemeat replusive, but yet we still hypocritically sell it to foreign countries. Here's a thought - if European and Asian cultures want it, they can raise their own. It'll be a lot safer for them also, as they'll know where their meat comes from and how it was handled, and not the mystery, adulterated meat America would be selling them. It's not a large market for the US anyway, so not a lot of jobs to be created either.

I'm being a little facetious here of course - but the point is that we can't evade the real logic behind the reviving of this ugly practice - making a buck. American business will sell out their own grandmothers to make a buck.
10:50 AM on 04/17/2012
A solution to reducing the number of horses slaughtered would be to enact a ban on slaughter and the transport to slaughter. Enact an export fee of around 1500.00 on any horse leaving the country. This would make it unprofitable to export to slaughter. Distribute the money collected to each State Veterinarian office to be used for gelding clinics, hay banks, care of seized horses, and euth clinics.
To bring a horse into our country from Mexico costs approx 1500-1600.00. It is only fair we charge the same to export them. It shouldn't affect those with high dollar horses who sell to people out of the country. If you are paying 30,000 for a show horse, another 1500 won't kill the deal. And if you are looking for a 2000.00 horse, you can find a lot of those to choose from in your own country.
Remove the Ag exemption from horse breeders.
Require all horse horses to pay a breeding tax on any foal born, in the amount of around 500.00. (Again with proceeds to teh State Vets office). Well bred foals will recoup that price when sold. Horse owners breeding an animal purely because it has a uterus, will be forced to stop.
12:14 PM on 04/17/2012
Responsible breeding is the answer! I love the idea of a 500 foal fee...I say make it a grand! and in reply to spottednikes..I lived out west and worked closely with the AQHA for years...the AQHA makes a nominal amount of money from the registration of horses..but in the long run back yard breeders hurt the breed, as the big money comes from performance animals who compete in shows/competitions. Not sure what logic is behind the theory that vets profits fom slaughterhouses due to drugs...slaughtered horses are put down with a bolt gun, no drugs are used as they would affect the meat. A bullet might be legal, not sure where you buy them for cheap...but it is illegal to bury horses on your own property in most places due to groundwater restrictions, so even if you put one down that way..you still have to pay a rendering plant to come and haul of the carcass...
10:58 AM on 09/05/2012
Amen! This is the most intelligent comment I've seen yet!! Will you run for Congress?
photo
cicchino21
Come Together
10:17 AM on 04/17/2012
I really don't see what the big problem is with slaughtering our own horses, that would otherwise go to another country to get slaughtered and eaten anyway. I love horses, and grew up on a horse farm, but I still understand that some countries see horse meat as no worse than beef. Why not provide some American jobs, by humanely providing a staple meat for other countries? No one is being forced to eat it here, and it seems like a lot of jobs and money going to other countries, when we are sending upwards of 130,000 horses to foreign slaughterhouse's.
photo
Artemesian
Spiritual Messenger of the Earth
12:57 PM on 04/17/2012
It isn't a staple meat, #1 - it's a delicacy. It won't provide that many jobs for the US. Slaughtering a horse is not humane. We have the answers to a horse "overpopulation" without having to send them off to be destroyed or to a rendering plant like an inanimate resource - we can own them responsibly and not overbreed them.

I think the second half of the ban on US slaughter of horses bill would have been to ban the shipment of them to Canada and Mexico also, but that part of the bill is still languishing in Congress somewhere, I believe.
photo
cicchino21
Come Together
10:40 PM on 04/17/2012
I understand it is a sensitive matter, for some people. I agree that responsible ownership would be a better solution for overpopulation, but that will likely never fully be the case. Some people look at horses as intelligent beings, a friend, a pet, or just an animal. We keep dogs and cats as pets, but some people in China or the Philippines consider it a traditional meat, like having ham on Easter. Some people also keep pigs as pets, but we still have bacon or 'the other white meat' in the supermarket. It just depends on where you are in the world. I don't think a lot of Americans consider what their meat was before it was all wrapped up in that pretty package. Animals slaughtered in our government monitored facilities are much more likely to see a humane death, than those in foreign countries, like Mexico. As long as we continue to send so many horses to foreign slaughterhouses, I don't see the problem with creating American jobs from the process, however few. I'm sorry, I guess my point of view is that of a true carnivore. I can't say I'm ready to eat a horse, but I love beef, moose, deer, pork, wild turkey, and bison meat. As long as the animal isn't near extinction, I don't see the problem with eating it.
photo
Artemesian
Spiritual Messenger of the Earth
07:43 AM on 04/17/2012
"Obama basically voted back in funding for horse slaughter plants. But to be fair, it was attached to another bill, and was on a deadline to get the bill passed. It was thrown into the bill at the last minute by the Big Ag groups."

This pretty much explains it all, spottednike, thank you - this is the same thing that happened with taking wolves off the endangered list too - an 11th hour rider to the budget. Money talks!

Wild and Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act of 1971 was signed into law by Richard Nixon, so you can see that animal welfare and protection is bipartisan - and as the years go by certain special interest group keep trying to chip away at it, and the Endangered Species Act too.
06:05 AM on 04/17/2012
Professional horse lady here..before you bash it, do some research. After the two US slaughter houses were closed, untold millions of horses out west were left to starve to death/be killed by predators by thoughthless owners who could no longer afford to feed them as the economy got worse..both the AQHA and most equine vet organizations endorse this,,yes, it is the lesser of two evils. If we really want to improve the lot of horses, we need to make lwas and regulations for back yard breeders who are responsible for creating theses animals because foals are cute..but they grow up and it cost alot of money for their care, proper up keep and even euthansia.
10:42 AM on 04/17/2012
Millions of horses were not left to starve. There are only an estimated 9 million horses in the US. Approx 1% are slaughtered each yr. There have been some cases of horses dumped by irresponsible owners, that comitted a criminal act rather than put their own horse down. A bullet is cheap and legal. There were stories that papers published citing abandoned horses, yet they were found to be false. In one case (in KY I IRC) horses were reported abandoned by an old strip mine. Later it was found out that the owners turn them loose to graze there every year, and they aren't abandoned.
However Killer buyers have dumped over 5000 horses just outside of the Mexican Border in the desert to starve after they were rejected at the border.
The AQHA supports slaughter because they WANT people to breed horses to increase their registrations/profit. The AVMA supports it, because they are in be with drug companies. There is a group called Vets For Equine Welfare, made up of veterinarians against slaughter.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:44 PM on 04/17/2012
The people who abandoned their horses are criminals.
07:40 PM on 04/16/2012
I thought Congress passed a law (back during G.W. days) prohibiting the processing of horse for human consumption????
10:16 PM on 04/16/2012
I honestly don't know about that, but sometime around Thanksgiving Obama made it legal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EllyB
left of center
07:53 AM on 04/17/2012
Rightfully so. I am a horse owner, a responsible horse owner. I own two lovely geldings and I have ensured their futures by having them trained (humanely) and budgeting for preventive care (vet, farrier, dentist). I am not a wealthy person and have sacrificed a lot of time and $ for these two lovely guys. I have plans in place for their continued care if something should happen to me. It sounds excessive, but I know that if I sold either of them, they could end up on a truck headed for Mexico or Canada for slaughter. There are many, many people who have horses and breed horses for reasons known only to them. Often they cannot afford to feed them much less train them. After suffering at the hands of such owners, you would have them put on a truck with hundreds of other animals and sent to Mexico for a most inhumane end? Obama did the right thing.
01:38 AM on 04/17/2012
There has been a state law in TX since 1949 banning the sale of horse meat. That is what shut down the 2 horse SH in TX. Illinois voted to ban the sale of horsemeat a few yrs ago. About a yr before that, Congress defunded inspectors for horse slaughter plants, so they shut down for a short while, then just hired their own. Obama basically voted back in funding for horse slaughter plants. But to be fair, it was attached to another bill, and was on a deadline to get the bill passed. It was thrown into the bill at the last minute by the Big Ag groups.