iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Obama Seeks To Confront Oil Market Manipulation

By JIM KUHNHENN 04/17/12 08:49 PM ET AP

Obama Oil Plan

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama pushed Congress Tuesday to give oil market regulators more muscle to deter price manipulation by speculators, the latest White House response to determined Republican attacks on administration energy policies amid high gas prices at the pump.

Obama wants Congress to strengthen federal supervision of oil markets, increase penalties for market manipulation and empower regulators to increase the amount of money energy traders are required to put behind their transactions.

"We can't afford a situation where some speculators can reap millions while millions of American families get the short end of the stick," Obama said at the White House.

The plan is more likely to draw sharp election-year distinctions with Republicans than have an immediate effect on prices at the pump. The measures seek to boost spending for Wall Street enforcement at a time when congressional Republicans are seeking to limit the reach of federal financial regulations.

The president's $52 million proposal comes as Republicans have been hammering Obama on his energy policies, recognizing the political cost of high gas prices on the president. Obama's plan would turn the tables on Republicans by taking aim at Wall Street's role in the oil price chain.

Obama was joined during his Rose Garden remarks by Attorney General Eric Holder, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chairman Gary Gensler, and Federal Trade Commission Chairman Jon Leibowitz.

The president didn't shy away from casting the issue in partisan terms, drawing attention to Republican opposition to a plan to end tax breaks for oil and gas companies.

"So here's a chance to make amends," he said.

Even before the White House announced Obama's plans, House Speaker John Boehner called it a political ploy and criticized the president for not using authority he already has to deal with such problems.

"The president has all the tools available to him if he believes that the oil market is being manipulated," Boehner told reporters Tuesday. "Where's his Federal Trade Commission? Where is the SEC? He's got agencies there. So instead of just another political gimmick, why doesn't he put his administration to work to get to the bottom of it?"

Boehner used the acronym for the Securities and Exchange Commission, whose duties include regulating markets.

Senior administration officials who put together the proposal stopped short of blaming market manipulation for rising gas prices, but said they wanted to curtail the ability of speculators to take unlawful advantage of oil price volatility.

"The price is affected by a variety of factors," said Brian Deese, the director of the White House's National Economic Council. "Obviously, instability in the Middle East as well as growth projections across the globe are affecting global oil markets all the time."

Meanwhile, the average price of a gas at the pump has dropped slightly but is still higher than it was at this time last year.

"None of these steps by themselves will bring gas prices down overnight," Obama said. "But it will prevent market manipulation and make sure we're looking out for American consumers."

Democrats promptly tested Republican support. House Democrats tried to attach an amendment to an unrelated hunting bill Tuesday that would have provided the CFTC with a version of the manipulation-fighting resources Obama sought.

It was defeated 261-160 with all but one Republican and 25 Democrats voting against it.

At issue is the increasing role of investment in oil futures contracts by pension funds, mutual funds, hedge funds, exchange traded funds and other investors. Much of that money is betting that oil prices will rise. Analysts say it is possible that such speculation has somewhat inflated the price of oil.

At the same time, investors can also bet that prices will go down – indeed, speculators have been credited for low natural gas prices. Studies of the effects of speculation on oil markets indicate that it probably increases volatility, but doesn't have a major effect on average prices.

Citing such evidence, Charles T. Drevna, president of the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers, said refiners count on the financial markets to hedge against higher crude oil costs. He urged Obama to instead focus on transporting oil from Canada through the Keystone XL pipeline that Obama has blocked.

Obama's plan this time calls on Congress to:

_ Increase six-fold the surveillance and enforcement staff of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission to better deter oil market manipulation.

_ Increase spending on technology to provide better oversight and surveillance of energy markets.

_ Increase civil and criminal penalties against firms that engage in market manipulation from $1 million to $10 million.

_ Give the Commodity Futures Trading Commission authority to increase the amount of money that a trader must put up to back a trading position. The administration officials said such authority could help limit disruptions in energy markets.

The White House effort comes as Republicans have talked of limiting the reach of a financial regulation overhaul that Congress passed in 2010 over their objections. Though the House Republican budget, which calls for sharp reductions in government programs, does not specify reduction in spending by the trading commission, the administration officials said that if the cuts were applied the commission would lose more than five times what it spends on regulating energy markets.

The debate will pit Republicans who blame high gasoline prices on Obama who, in turn, blames Republicans for coddling Wall Street.

___

Associated Press writer Alan Fram contributed to this report.

Follow Jim Kuhnhenn at Jkuhnhenn(at)twitter.com

Also on HuffPost:

FOLLOW POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama pushed Congress Tuesday to give oil market regulators more muscle to deter price manipulation by speculators, the latest White House response to determined Re...
WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama pushed Congress Tuesday to give oil market regulators more muscle to deter price manipulation by speculators, the latest White House response to determined Re...
Filed by Nick Wing  | 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7,373
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (148 total)
photo
dvtaz
Conservative to the core. Make my day!
09:18 AM on 04/20/2012
How can we believe anything this President says. Obama says "the problem is we use more than 20 percent of the world's oil and we only have 2 percent of the world's proven oil reserves."
The president's own administration has released a report which reveals that the United States has 26 percent of the world's technically recoverable conventional oil resources, and that's not including our enormous oil shale, tight oil and heavy oil resources. President Obama's claims ... are shall I say, less than honest. We need to stop relying on foreign oil.
11:13 PM on 04/19/2012
Wait, is this the same person who made millions from selling his book? I'll almost bet that when he is back to the regular world, if there is one, he'll be charging hundreds of thousands of dollars for one of his on going speeches! I agree with a certain extent about the speculators, however, they are not the major reason why oil prices are as high as they are. Drilling for oil should have started many years ago, not drill with your mouth with excuses which will never reduce the price we all are paying.
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:13 PM on 04/19/2012
WoW! - Obama reads the teleprompter and 2 days later - VOILA! THe price of gas is now forecast to go down ... Who says Obama isn't da Man? LOL. But wait, there's more ...Of course, the speculators aren't just hanging out at gas stations. Those evil-doers are all around us. How can stock prices be going up when demand is falling? It must be the evil speculators.Precious metals prices are higher, too. Gold is up 6% so far in 2012. And the evil speculators have pushed silver prices 10% higher in the past four months.

But the worst part is those little demons haven't been confined to just the financial markets. They're everywhere.

My health insurance premium is 15% higher today than it was last year – even though I haven't been to the doctor in the past 12 months. My water bill is 12% higher this year, too – even though my usage is down.

The local dog groomer charges $7 more to clip Fido's nails. My wife's hairdresser hiked prices by 10% last month. And just last night, I shelled out $85 for a sushi dinner for two that didn't even include alcohol.

Those evil speculators are pushing up the prices of everything... (since most liberals have no sense of humor, this tirade is about as foolish as Obama's speech calling for more regulation of oil and gas regulators)
02:45 AM on 04/23/2012
no, try thinking for a change. those people are raising prices because inflation has risen primarily due to high energy prices. you are correct that if they are raising prices it is largely because of speculation but it is oil speculation. the price of oil and gas affects almost all aspects of our economy and that is what you are seeing. think.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kyle10
those who sharpen perception tend to be antisocial
06:45 PM on 04/19/2012
Confronting the Master of Petroleum? Good, Mr. President. Godspeed.

But, good lord, watch your back with this mob.
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:21 PM on 04/19/2012
What frightens me more than what Obama says (fortunately he seldom DOES what he says), is that there are so many liberals who believe what he is saying ... I trade stock options. It's pure speculation - I'm buying or selling an "option" on a stock to buy or sell at a fixed (guaranteed) price at a specific point in time in the future. It is PURE SPECULATION and IT HAS ZERO EFFECT ON HOW THE STOCK ACTUALLY PERFORMS. Anyone with any sophistication , and I know many libs. are smart financially including you Kyle10, understands that. If speculation worked, why is the price of natural gas at a 10 year low? Certainly there are speculators in that market as well. Seriously Kyle, think about it and I think you see how foolish Obama looks to those who understand financial markets. However to a very large part of society, that believes OWS and that wall street is evil, they want to bring down with Capitalism (and replace with ??) , and Evil Big Oil - it's politics and plays well. Don't be a dope.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kyle10
those who sharpen perception tend to be antisocial
01:19 AM on 04/20/2012
Appreciate the pedantic lecture, prof. I spent eight years working at a major brokerage firm. You know where you can put your arrogance.

Culturally, your post is rife with gross, simplistic bias. Few actually demonize capitalism, in reality. It is unmitigated corporatism and unchecked greed that are the issues. That subtlety seems lost on you.
08:52 AM on 04/19/2012
You can rationalize this any way you want, it just comes down to one thing, when the 1% of this country push the rest over the brink with their greediness there will be no help from your political allies whose heads will be on the chopping block when the government can no longer control the population. All your laws meant to protect your greedy ways will be obsolite and anarchy will rain down on this country with a vengence. Tread lightly you are about to wake a sleeping giant from which there will be no turning back. America as you know it will never be the same.
12:58 AM on 04/19/2012
Sooooooo, why didn't he do this 3 yrs ago? Not close enough to election season!
11:10 PM on 04/18/2012
Has there every been someone who is so far over his head for a job? I mean, every word out of his mouth is some political plow that is so transparent it is becoming comical. What an embarrassment. Just two weeks ago, everyone in his cabinet and all the cronie supposed news outlets went on and on about how the president had absolutely no control over the price of oil.
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:31 PM on 04/19/2012
and this has what to do with speculators?
08:06 PM on 04/18/2012
Obama surely thinks we the people are ignorant, copy and paste this to your browser, for the real truth http://digg.com/news/politics/15_times_obama_and_top_dems_blame_bush_for_gas_prices
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:33 PM on 04/19/2012
blaming Bush is news? I'm surprised even liberal journalism publishes such nonsense because we all know IT NOT NEW NEWS - IT's WHAT OBAMA HAS BEEN DOING FOR 3.5 years ... BORING.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mediamarv
1-2-3 Is this thing working?
11:56 AM on 04/18/2012
I think I've found someone manipulating the oil market.

Drilling on Public Federally Owned land is down 14% from last year; clearly someone is blocking this drilling to decrease supply, increase imports, and raise prices.

What punishment should the person responsible get for this crime?

OH, you meant "manipulation of the oil market is criminal; except when I DO IT"? Yeah, sorry, I keep forgetting that rule.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
dadw5boys
Disabled Vietnam Vet
01:38 PM on 04/18/2012
Wake up ! Oil Comoanys are in the Oil, Gas and Chemical SHORTAGE BUSINESS !
Oil Production is at an all thime high SO ARE EXPORTS OF OIL FROM THE USA !!!!!!
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:35 PM on 04/19/2012
the amount of oil we export in minuscule compared to how much we import (50%). Those exports are all based on economics, politics, and prior agreements with foreign partners.
11:55 AM on 04/18/2012
This move by Obama is a blatantly obvious political maneuver, but it has no teeth. This follows another just as obvious politically-driven announcement about the Keystone pipeline. The enormous amount of ignorance lodged within liberal minds no longer amazes me. I read a post that boldly claimed that Obama has promised to approve the Keystone pipeline in his second term. Of course, the poster failed to comprehend that Obama was talking about work on the southern section of the Keystone pipeline running from Cushing, Oklahoma to Port Arthur, Texas. However, the pipeline segment from Canada down to Cushing...the one that will actually deliver oil to the refineries, is the one Obama blocked and continues to block.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
creativ786
independent of the left a centrist for life
12:16 PM on 04/18/2012
Uh O forgot to mention that there where new laws passed after last years rise, however the limited restrictions did much of nothing. They did increase margin requirements .. however the geo politicl state of the world any time war clouds and saber rattling occurs the price goes up in anticipation of some contraction in supply.. For a academic , not to understand cause and effect. It is sad really..
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
dadw5boys
Disabled Vietnam Vet
01:40 PM on 04/18/2012
Come on ! The Keystone Pipeline HAS TO GO TO TEXAS !
Why ? The Oil Companys have an EXPORT TAX FREE TRADE ZONE THERE !!!!

That is heavy Oil it will be used for Plastics NOT GAS !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
muck-raker
give me liberty or give me death
11:30 AM on 04/18/2012
this is for the people here saying the MARKET can not be manipulated...the story:
Johann HariHow Goldman Sachs gambled on starving the world’s poor – and won
Posted by Johann – July 2, 2010

By now, you probably think your opinion of Goldman Sachs and its swarm of Wall Street allies has rock-bottomed at raw loathing. You’re wrong. There’s more. It turns out the most destructive of all their recent acts has barely been discussed at all. Here’s the rest. This is the story of how some of the richest people in the world – Goldman, Deutsche Bank, the traders at Merrill Lynch, and more – have caused the starvation of some of the poorest people in the world, just so they could make a fatter profit.

http://johannhari.com/2010/07/02/how-goldman-sachs-gambling-on-starving-the-worlds-poor-and-won/
yesiamaconservative
waiting for an intelligent reply ...
09:41 PM on 04/19/2012
Speculation doesn't manipulate - supply and demand does - I "speculate" with stock options ... PURE speculation based on my "guess" what a stock will do. If I'm right I win big (much bigger than if I owned the stock) and if I'm wrong I lose the entire amount I speculated.

Risk - Reward - but I know that doesn't play in your "Rule of Fairness - Rule 1 - everyone gets a trophy" view of life ...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Penelope Pitstop
Glamour Gal of the Gas Pedal
11:05 AM on 04/18/2012
he really doesn't know how our system of government works does he, he's got the ftc and the sec why doesn't he use them? he's also got holder...why doesn't he ask him to look into it that's what he's there for isn't it?

sometimes this president really surprises me
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mytradingrobot
10:56 AM on 04/18/2012
Waging war on oil speculators is pure political crap. All you have to do is the simple math to see that "speculators" have no power over the global market. Sovereign governments maybe, but not the evil "speculator" that Obama rails against.

The NYMEX/CME contract limit for trading/speculating on oil is 3000 contracts total. The March 2012 oil futures contract traded an average of 600,000 + contracts each day. I would love to see how a max position size of 3000 contracts can manipulate price when it is only 1/2% of the average daily volume. For a whole month, 12mil contracts trade.

So it is possible to manipulate price with only 3000 contracts out of 12mil total traded in a month? Even if 20 people "colluded" together, the impact is negligible over the course of a month. Could they influence it for 1 day - probably. But then they have no more ammo the next day and are done.