iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Loren Berlin
GET UPDATES FROM Loren:

Cleveland Foreclosure Crisis Gives Refugees A Fresh Start

Posted: 04/19/2012 8:33 am Updated: 04/19/2012 1:11 pm

Cleveland Foreclosure
Ruk and Leela Rai, Bhutanese refugees, in their Cleveland apartment. The couple and their son, Anish, are moving into a previously vacant home as part of a program created by two Cleveland nonprofits to redeploy abandoned properties as refugee housing.

CLEVELAND -- Three-year-old Anish Rai can’t figure out how to work the screen door at his new home. He tugs once, but it doesn’t open. He tugs again, staring at the closed door until his mother shows him how to press down on the square lever. He has never seen a handle like this. A refugee from the Himalayan nation of Bhutan, he spent much of his early life in a bamboo hut in a camp in the lush forests of southern Nepal.

But now the Rais, who arrived here two years ago as part of a United Nations refugee resettlement program, are preparing to move into a three-bedroom house with yellow siding and grey shutters on a quiet suburban street. They are renting it thanks to a new collaboration between a pair of Cleveland nonprofits that aims to address two vexing problems: the flood of vacant homes languishing in the wake of the foreclosure crisis -- an inventory estimated at about ten million properties nationwide -- and the need for decent, affordable housing for refugees arriving in America.

The Cleveland program is part of an emerging national effort that is seeking to find a silver lining in the foreclosure wave that has pockmarked communities with abandoned properties. Across the country, nonprofit organizations are purchasing, repairing and redeploying vacant homes in a bid to provide needy families with housing, while revitalizing struggling communities.

In New Orleans, the group Youth Rebuilding New Orleans employs local high school students to repair distressed properties. The homes are sold to teachers at 80 percent of the market value in exchange for a three-year commitment to continue teaching in New Orleans schools. Though the organization began in response to Hurricane Katrina, it has expanded because of the glut of foreclosed homes stemming from the national housing crisis, said executive director William Stoudt.

In North Carolina, the nonprofit Purple Heart Homes is converting foreclosed properties into affordable housing for disabled veterans and their caregivers. In the Minneapolis-St. Paul area, the Twin Cities Community Land Bank is transforming vacant properties into environmentally sustainable homes for low-income families. And in Baltimore, St. Ambrose Housing Aid Center, a nonprofit that has long purchased and rehabbed homes before selling them to low-income families, has in recent years expanded those efforts, acquiring properties abandoned by speculators.

“These initiatives stabilize the market by reducing the supply of homes and supporting the values of the surrounding homes that are still occupied,” said P.J. McCarthy, who directs the sale of homes to nonprofits for Fannie Mae, the giant, government-controlled mortgage lender, whose books are now choked with distressed real estate. "They get vacant homes back into use, reducing blight in the neighborhood."

Here in Cleveland, the International Services Center, a nonprofit that has resettled close to 13,000 refugees over the last half century, stumbled on the idea of making use of foreclosed homes last summer, as it grappled with a stark shortage of available housing. Caseworkers were having difficulty finding acceptable homes for newly arrived families because landlords were reluctant to rent to refugees.

“The challenge is to find a landlord and then explain that their future tenant is arriving in the United States and has no employment, no immediate future employment, and no credit history, but to please give them a place to live,” said Karin Wishner, ISC’s executive director. “That leaves few landlords to work with, and then the question is if they have openings when we need them."

The organization soon settled on a novel idea: It would become the landlord. But it had little budget to start buying homes, necessitating a fortuitous conversation with the Cuyahoga Land Bank, a nonprofit established by county officials to manage the flood of empty homes. The organization takes ownership of more than ninety vacant properties each month and then decides what to do with them.

“We knew the Land Bank had hundreds of homes in their inventory, vacant homes, abandoned homes, foreclosed homes,” said Wishner. The two organizations soon decided to designate a handful of properties as refugee housing, in order to match ISC’s need for housing with the Land Bank’s mission to improve the state of vacant homes.

“Here are these people struggling to find this housing and behold, we have it,” said Gus Frangos, the executive director of the Land Bank. “It’s logical. I’ve got to do something with these properties. I can’t hold them forever.”

Wishner culled the Land Bank’s database of available homes and identified several promising prospects. She visited each one to assess its viability. She had very specific criteria -- something near a bus line since most refugees don’t have cars, with a bedroom on the first floor in case the occupants were elderly or ill and couldn’t handle stairs, a yard for children or gardening and proximity to other refugees for support and community.

She found all of these attributes in the little yellow house on Hopkins Avenue.

The house had previously belonged to Theresa Palmer-Ross, a mother of four who bought it 10 years ago for $81,000. It was the first home she had ever owned. She chose it for its proximity to quality schools, she said.

But five years after she bought it, Palmer-Ross lost her $12-an-hour job at a local manufacturing plant when the company shifted its operations to Mexico.

Shortly thereafter, she fell off a ladder while cleaning the gutter and developed a blood clot. Her condition required her to go to a doctor three times a day for monitoring and treatment. The constant medical visits made it difficult for her to find work.

Then the roof caved in on her garage. When the city required her to replace it, she realized she could no longer afford the home.

In 2010 she filed for bankruptcy. Later that year her lender, First Federal Lakewood, foreclosed on the property, which was by then worth less than $27,000.

The following June, First Federal Lakewood sold the home to the Land Bank for $1 through a partnership in which the community bank essentially donates select properties to the International Services Center.

By the time the Land Bank and ISC selected the Hopkins Avenue home as the pilot project for the refugee housing program, the property had been vacant for more than a year. It needed approximately $40,000 worth of repairs. The two organizations agreed to split the rehabilitation costs, with the Land Bank covering them initially and ISC repaying its portion to the Land Bank via a $20,000 mortgage.

This was the origin of the program that has created a new opportunity for the Rai family. They plan to move into the Hopkins Avenue home later this month.

For Ruk Rai, the move will complete a wrenching journey that began more than two decades ago, when he was in his late teens. His family fled Bhutan due to political persecution, he said. Leaving behind their cattle, sheep, and two-story stone house in their village, the Rai family crossed through India in a cramped truck, arriving at the Sanischare refugee camp in Nepal in the early 1990s.

Life in Sanischare was difficult, according to Rai, who spent nearly twenty years in the encampment.

“Not good environment,” Rai, 40, explained in the broken English he began learning after arriving in America two years ago. “A lot of people. We live in small hut with plastic roof. Not good water. Dirty water, not like here. Many people die from water and other things."

In the refugee camp, Rai and his six siblings -- none of whom had previously received a formal education -- attended the camp’s free school, where Rai eventually earned a tenth grade education. There he met Leela, now 30, whose family had also fled political persecution in Bhutan and was living in a neighboring camp. They fell in love and were married in 2006 in a series of small ceremonies held in the camps. About two years later, Anish was born.

They longed to leave Sansichare. “The future is not good, we think, in refugee camp,” said Rai. “If you live inside the camp, no good education, no freedom to leave, everything is limited."

In November 2007, the United Nations began resettling refugees out of Sansichare and the six surrounding camps. The Rais applied for resettlement. After a three-year wait, they were approved to move to Cleveland.

One evening in May 2010 an ISC caseworker, accompanied by a translator, met the Rais at the airport. She drove them to a one-bedroom basement apartment the agency had secured for the family. So began the Rai family’s life in America.

In the subsequent months, the Rais attended ISC classes on subjects ranging from English to employer expectations.

“We try to orient the families to the American workplace,” said Wishner. “We go over the importance of being on time, to be careful when you take your breaks but also to take breaks, that you shouldn’t show your paycheck to everybody, the acceptable and unacceptable excuses for being late to work, what is considered sexual harassment."

Through the ISC classes, the Rais also learned how to write a check, how to use a bank account, how to create a budget, how to differentiate between junk and important mail, how to interpret American traffic lights, how to use public transportation, how to pay rent and bills and how to operate a stove. They learned how to interview for jobs and volunteered in ISC’s market garden, where Ruk Rai grew vegetables.

Eventually, Leela and Ruk found jobs. She works the night shift, fifty hours a week, at a factory that manufactures airplane parts, earning $9.75 an hour. Ruk works second shift, forty hours a week, at another plant, earning $9.50 an hour. Ruk’s aunt, who was resettled to Cleveland after the Rais, babysits Anish. Leela and Ruk both take the bus to and from work, and have saved nearly $6,000 to purchase a used car in the coming months. They have squirreled away another $2,000 in savings. They occasionally send money back to family members, who are still in the refugee camps, though a handful of Leela’s relatives are slated to resettle to Cleveland this year.

Last month Wishner took the Rais on a tour of the home. She showed Ruk the small strip of grass out back where he could plant celery, tomatoes, hot peppers and flowers for traditional Bhutanese ceremonies. She explained that Anish could have his own bedroom instead of sharing with his parents. She told them about the other Bhutanese family that lived down the block.

In an upstairs bedroom, Leela pointed to a sunny corner where she could fashion a traditional Buddhist shrine.

The Rais will rent the home from ISC for about $550 per month, plus utilities, while the organization assesses how to proceed with the new program.

“It’s an iterative process,” said Wishner. “We want something that the family can afford but doesn’t cripple our budget, so we’ll see how this goes, see what works and what doesn’t, and build from there."

She is confident enough in the idea behind the program that she has already begun conversations with the Land Bank about selecting the next home.

Staff at the Land Bank portray the project as an injection of faith in Cleveland’s future.

“We’re talking about people who have been oppressed or are escaping a war or some sort of cataclysm, and they want to come here, to Cleveland,” said Frangos, the Land Bank’s executive director. “They view a home and a job as paradise, something they’ve never had access to. So these are the folks that become integral, contributing, sustaining members of our community.”

Frangos said the refugee program is one of many he is looking to build in Cleveland to leverage the city’s stock of vacant homes. “I want to take this to the next level. I want to do fifty of these with refugees. And then I want to do fifty of these with veterans. And fifty of these with people with disabilities.”

In the meantime, the Rais have plans of their own.

“Study more for Anish,” said Ruk when asked how he thinks the new home will change his life. “Not like us. He work a good job like doctor, engineer.”

Leela nodded her head in agreement, then added, “I want Anish becomes a big, great person.”

1  of  13
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
The Rai family, political refugees from Bhutan, are preparing to move into this 3-bedroom home in suburban Cleveland.
RATE IT!   |  
VOTE
CURRENT TOP 5 PICK YOUR OWN TOP 5
USERS WHO VOTED
NEW! CREATE YOUR OWN SLIDESHOW
FOLLOW BUSINESS

CLEVELAND -- Three-year-old Anish Rai can’t figure out how to work the screen door at his new home. He tugs once, but it doesn’t open. He tugs again, staring at the closed door until his mother sh...
CLEVELAND -- Three-year-old Anish Rai can’t figure out how to work the screen door at his new home. He tugs once, but it doesn’t open. He tugs again, staring at the closed door until his mother sh...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 86
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
11:10 AM on 09/20/2012
I thought there were no jobs in Cleveland?
These people are more American than most anymore.

Eventually, Leela and Ruk found jobs. She works the night shift, fifty hours a week, at a factory that manufactures airplane parts, earning $9.75 an hour. Ruk works second shift, forty hours a week, at another plant, earning $9.50 an hour. Ruk’s aunt, who was resettled to Cleveland after the Rais, babysits Anish. Leela and Ruk both take the bus to and from work, and have saved nearly $6,000 to purchase a used car in the coming months. They have squirreled away another $2,000 in savings. They occasionally send money back to family members, who are still in the refugee camps, though a handful of Leela’s relatives are slated to resettle to Cleveland this year.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:45 AM on 07/24/2012
I know of an HPD coop in NYC that allows Chinese immigrants to put their names on the waiting list before they even leave China. The Chinese have flooded the waiting list and no one else can get an apartment,thus the place is becoming Chinese. Management and local politicians sit back and let it happen.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
elgeeezer
Got my head fixed with ObamaCare
07:21 PM on 06/12/2012
Nice story. Just the kind I enjoy reading.
12:56 PM on 06/09/2012
But you can't buy land in their countries, and I wonder how many poor homeless Americans are reading this news and fighting the desire to sock up any stuck up Asian they come across.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NickandMurcia Sapoznick
People are the money and we are purposely divided
11:43 AM on 05/22/2012
So is the happy part of the story that the previous owner lives in Nepal, nice story of unethical gentrification. Go read the jungle by Upton Sinclair.
07:25 AM on 05/16/2012
Another government program to help the poor and the community that works. But again a reaction to the programs caused by the 99 percenmt. Hard working people deserve a chance but what happens if these ytwo get hurt or sick? Do they now have health insurance to allow them to help pay the mortgage? Will they qualify for food stamps if they loser jobs? Will they have a way to work if the bus line shuts down? Do you not see this whole story of success by hardworking people is not possible without the involvemenmt of those others with a sense of community . Unfortunately conservatives who are never willing to extend a helping hand to those who look different, talk different, or worship different will see this story as proof of only the discipline of hard work and ignore the role of government and the community in providing the opportunity. Think about it republicans.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fireart
I got mine the hard way.
07:06 PM on 07/23/2012
I hope you feel better now that you havespilled your vinom over a feel good story.
03:23 AM on 04/23/2012
Great that they're helping refugees, but what about the already homeless in the US.. the numbers are phenomenal... and what about the woman who owned that home.. where did she end up? Sorry... but look to your own... there are so many homeless people in the US already...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fireart
I got mine the hard way.
07:07 PM on 07/23/2012
Why are we taking a man out of a grass hut and putting them in clothes and a house in cleveland.
04:26 PM on 04/20/2012
I think that it is nice to help the refugees and give then a fresh start. But I know a couple here in Northern California (Sunnyvale) living in their van and his Wife is handicapped and she can hardly walked. The Social Services told them that they couldn't help them because they haven't been homeless for TWO YEARS.. The nonprofit organizations has just turn there backs and told they they couldn't help them. Will it looks like if you are American born here in the United States you are screw. There are a few Veterans living in the streets here and they don't drinks or use drugs? There is something wrong with this picture????
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BinghamLofts
04:21 PM on 04/20/2012
these are the neighbors we need not the 8th generation americans living in govt housing still collecting public assistance.
09:59 PM on 04/19/2012
I think this is a wonderful story about people...refugees..that are hard working and willing to do whatever it takes to make a better life for their children. It should not be held against them that they were not born here. America is a country built of people whose parents, grandparents, etc most likely came from another country originally. No one should say that certain people deserve this opportunity more than others. There are programs available to help people of all circumstances.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rtx47
06:07 PM on 04/19/2012
Refugees in our small city in upstate NY have revitalized our dangerous and delapitated inner city by cleaning and fixing the area and making the homes habitable and the neighborhoods drug-free. And they did not even receive govt subsidies to achieve these results.
makemesmile
it makes you wonder
02:25 AM on 05/23/2012
It's my understanding that refugees do receive monetary help from the USA.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
fireart
I got mine the hard way.
07:12 PM on 07/23/2012
Green card, cash alounce and all the freebies.
06:01 PM on 04/19/2012
within 2 years of arriving in the country, not speaking English, they now both work full time jobs and have saved $8,000
They are headed in the right direction and deserive credit, congratulations and well wishes
06:26 PM on 04/19/2012
I agree!!! What a testimony to overcoming dire circumstances. The article points out that these individuals were in camps for 20 years. Let's be mindful of what a refugee truly is...a victim of persecution. Some of the most deplorable conditions in America are still better than a refugee's best day warehoused in a camp!!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
elgeeezer
Got my head fixed with ObamaCare
07:25 PM on 06/12/2012
Wish I could save $8,000 over 2 years. That's $77/wk. I'd starve.
06:18 PM on 04/19/2012
You can help those people and equally should. I suggest you gather your network of friends and start making a difference.
07:09 AM on 04/20/2012
As a disabled Veteran I spend most of my day working to help people caught up in this countries worst housing crisis since the Depression but thanks for the advice.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BinghamLofts
04:24 PM on 04/20/2012
you can do your part and help them too.
04:33 PM on 04/19/2012
So....what happened to Theresa? I love this story, except that it shows a family benefiting from the misery of another family. It doesn't have to be this way. There are enough houses, empty, that Theresa could still be in this home and the new family in another home. It really comes down to our obsession with only helping people who strike the perfect balance of needy and worthy. Hardworking immigrants win out over single mom of 'too many kids'.
When do we stop judging and just get down to meeting people's needs?
12:00 AM on 04/20/2012
Quite the contrary..... The story is about a home that had fallen into foreclosure, was vacant and falling further into decline. The misery of the former tenant, while sad and unfortunate, has nothing to do with the need to return the property back to practical use. And as for "judging" it seems as though there is an undertone of bias in your comment. This isn't a case of rock, paper, scissors...refugees win and single moms lose.
04:17 PM on 04/19/2012
I'm all for helping out the refugees, but what about the people who were foreclosed upon? why didn't they get to stay in these homes and work out a deal?