iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Stuart Chaifetz, Father, Puts Wire On Son With Autism, Records Verbal Abuse From Teachers (VIDEO)

The Huffington Post  |  By Posted: 04/24/2012 10:41 am Updated: 04/26/2012 4:02 am

Stuart Chaifetz

When Stuart Chaifetz sent his 10-year-old son to New Jersey's Horace Mann Elementary School wearing a hidden audio recorder, he couldn't have predicted what he would uncover.

The move came in reaction to accusations from the school that his son Akian was having "violent outbursts," including hitting his teacher and teacher's aide -- claims that Chaifetz claims are against his son's "sweet and non-violent" nature.

Akian, who has Autism, returned with a tape containing hours of apparent verbal and emotional abuse from his classroom aide and teacher -- whom Chaifetz identifies as "Jodi" and "Kelly" -- a recording which his father later published on YouTube.

The Feb. 17 recording started with Akian's aide and the teacher, whom Collingswood Patch provides evidence may be Jodi Sgouros and Kelly Altenburg, respectively, based on a previously published online staff directory.

The two engage in inappropriate conversations, like joking about their alcohol abuse and sex lives in front of their students -- all of whom have behavioral conditions and, according to Chaifetz, communication difficulties that prevent them from relaying the conversations to their parents.

"You would never get away with talking about your alcohol abuse the night before if this was a mainstream class," Chaifetz says in the YouTube video. "And that's the point, isn't it? They knew none of those boys could go home and tell their parents that the person who ran that class was under the influence of alcohol and was throwing up."

As the tape continues, the teacher and teacher's aide's behavior turns from inappropriate to cruel.

"Who are you talking to, nobody?" Kelly asked Akian, who sometimes talks to himself. "Knock it off," Jodi chimed in.

According to the video, Akian became upset, and starting crying.

"Go ahead and scream because guess what? You're going to get nothing until your mouth is shut," the classroom official is heard saying. "Shut your mouth."

Due to his son's anxiety, Chaifetz, who is divorced from his wife, has to reassure Akian that he will return to his care after the boy spends time with his mother.

"It's not a big deal," he said, describing the reassurance ritual in the video.

When Akian asked his teacher for the same reassurance, however, she answered "no," sending him into an emotional panic. The teacher's aide, too, responded cruelly.

"Oh Akian, you are a bastard," Jodi said, according to the audio recording.

Chaifetz said that the classroom aide was fired after he presented the recording to school district officials, but that the teacher remains employed in a different classroom.

Susan Bastnagel, Cherry Hill Public School District spokesperson declined to comment on the teacher's continued employment, but told The Huffington Post that the incident is a "personnel matter that the district took seriously and handled appropriately."

“That my son's teacher was not fired and still works in the school district is an outrage I am not willing to allow to pass in silence,” Chaifetz said in an email to The Huffington Post.

“She betrayed my son and caused him great pain. If some union rule or HR regulation has allowed her to keep her job, then the law needs to be changed so that the next time a teacher bullies a child, especially one with special needs, they will be immediately fired. For me to do nothing would mean I was treating my son with as much disrespect as they had," he added.

An online petition on Change.org and a Facebook page calling for the teacher's termination have already received attention.

Akian's troubling experience is not unique, nor is his father's method of exposing believed wrongdoing in the classroom.

"I have also been stunned by how many emails I have received from people with special needs who were bullied by teachers when they were in school, and from parents who have a situation that mirrors what I went through," Chaifetz told The Huffington Post. "These parents are desperate to find out what is happening to their child and have asked for help on how to wire them."

This was the case for parents of a special needs student at Miami Trace Middle School in Ohio, who sent their daughter to school with a hidden tape recorder last fall after the girl repeatedly complained about teacher bullying.

The revelation was shocking: the educators on the recording called the child lazy and dumb, and forced her to run on a treadmill with increasing speed.

"Don't you want to do something about that belly," former teaching aide Kelley Chaffins says in the recording. "Well, evidently you don't because you don't do anything at home. You sit at home and watch TV."

The girl and her father spoke to Ann Curry on NBC's "TODAY" last November and, in a tearful interview, the concerned dad recounted how the abuse had affected his daughter.

"She got to where she didn't want to go to school," he said. "She was ... starting to harm herself to keep from going to school and we knew we had to do something at that point."

Chaffins was later forced to resign from her position.

Other bullying incidents have also been exposed by hidden cameras. After Julio Artuz, a 15-year-old at Bankbridge Regional School in New Jersey asked his teacher to stop calling him "special," the teacher told him, "…I will kick your a-- from here to kingdom-come until I'm 80 years old."

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article named Jodi Rosenfeld as the possible "Jodi" referred to in the video. Stuart Chaifetz has since confirmed that this is not the teacher he refers to, according to Collingswood Patch. Language has also been altered to better reflect the sourcing of information by Patch about the teachers' possible identities.

FOLLOW EDUCATION

 
 
  • Comments
  • 4,979
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (121 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Mathew Sewell
05:20 AM on 02/06/2013
I am a corrections officer. If someone did this to my child they would answer to me, in person. Woe unto them.
05:13 AM on 10/01/2012
i will not feel sorry for special needs teachers.thats why the children are in the class they have special needs maybe you need to find a different job.these children are human beings and you should treat them with respect.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
2tru4u2c
Politically correct is neither!!
04:18 AM on 10/01/2012
Sticks and stones may break my bones...

But Smith & Wesson will bring a quick ending to this bulling
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Your name here
When nothing goes right, Go Left.
11:55 AM on 12/09/2012
Stupid comment.
11:55 AM on 08/29/2012
I am a parent. I am a mother. I will give you 1,000,001 reasons to get through this. You are a beautiful human being. You are entitled to have a fullfilling and rewarding life. Don't let those bullies take that from you. YOU have that power. Remember, everything is temporary, you can get through these moments in time. My heart breaks for all that you are going through now, I do believe it will only make you stronger as you get older.Sadly, nobody deserves to to acquire his strengths by being pushed down this path. I am one of many random strangers out in the world who shares her heart with you. Please be strong. I am certain you have so much to bring to this world. When you are grown and successful, personally and professionally, it is very likely that the various horrible bullies who have hurt you, are not leading a very rewarding or successful life of their own. One day you may suprise yourself by pitying these people instead of hating them. Don't let them win. YOU ARE WORTH IT!
09:45 AM on 07/29/2012
This was a beautiful video by a wonderful dad. I cry because this whole school year (kindergarten) I wondered if my grandchild's teacher liked him. I say this because I got this weird feeling whenever I picked him up that she didn't seem to like him. I know he can be a handful but he so adorable and sweet at the same time. Maybe it is hard for teachers to have to handle children with special needs like this little boy or my grandson, but once you get past that and focus on his or her accomplishments, teachers can take pride that they were a part of these accomplishments. But if I ever do find out that this teacher said anything inappropriate to my grandson or any other student you can bet I will not be so nice as this dad was.
10:58 AM on 07/27/2012
These don't sound like trained teachers. I've worked with disabled kids and I can't imagine anyone wanting to work in that field who could have so little obvious training and so little empathy for their students. If they didn't have the wherewithal to handle the job appropriately they should both have quit, and if they didn't quit, they should have at least been fired. Mr. Chaifetz is absolutely right. Every day as a teacher is a choice, and every successive day this teacher remains employed is a slap in the face to Akian, his father, and every taxpayer whose money was used to allow this to happen and then to cover it up.
10:12 AM on 07/27/2012
My daughter's son is autistic and she needs to place him in a therapuetic residentral facility, but because of these kinds of carrying ons she is fearful her child might be abused. This is something no parent wants to see or hear about their child, just because he can't speak on his own people tend to take advantage of children who can't speak of the ugly things teachers and aids do, this puts a very dim light on the school system. Yes, granted children can work your nerves, I taught in the school system for 32 + years in early childhood education and believe me even with normal children, a teacher must practice tremendous self control and discipline when it comes to children and please be careful what comes out your mouth. This is another reason why teachers are not respected in this country, because of those who mess it up for those teachers who are doing a good job. Let's focus on those good teachers who have a passion for what they are doing, teaching children regardless of their disabilities.
08:56 AM on 07/27/2012
The teacher won't be fired because the union will protect her. That's all teacher unions do - protect useless, incompetent and abusive teachers in exchange for their union dues which they give to the Democrats.
dancingbones
Teach, lead by example, example, exampl
08:30 PM on 08/03/2012
You are really wrong. They mostly protect teachers from incompetent board members and religious-based community bigots, as well as from burnt-out, over-promoted administrators. Teaching is terribly stressful and difficult, as well as rewarding. Yes; some teachers are worthless or worse and should be dismissed, but the vast majority are truly dedicated and caring people, so your hatred and union nonsense shows you know nothing about education. I was a teacher (non-union) and administrator for 40 years so I have some idea what I am talking about. Listen to Rush much?
08:24 AM on 07/27/2012
Since I can remember, bullying has been tolerated in schools and workplaces. Bullied kids are 'mysteriously' placed in class after class with their tormentors as winking teachers, counselors, and on up look on. They aren't even pretending to look the other way, and that goes double for the workplace. If I never see that avid look of enjoyment from the misery of another on another teacher, manager, or HR-oid again it will be too soon. There are just too many that can't treat their fellow species members decently. There is true evil in this world and we need a reset button.
01:48 AM on 03/20/2013
You said it Kerri! Fanned and faved!
04:47 AM on 07/27/2012
bottom line is the child was acting poorly and his behavior was poor. perhaps if he was better parented this wouldn't have happened. I commend the teacher for at least trying to discipline the child since he wasn't getting it at home.
photo
caroleann926
Less exploitation and more empowerment to women
01:19 PM on 07/28/2012
The child is autistic. Have you any idea how difficult life is for a child like that trying to cope with life? How old are you, anyway to make a dumb remark like that? A teacher and an aide calling the child a b*stard...how unkind and unprofessional they were and you dare to put the blame on the victim. You need to grow up and do a little reading on the life of an autistic kid.
08:39 PM on 07/28/2012
The child was acting poorly??? Why do you think this child is in a special class? Do you think autistic children act this way because they want to? This little guy is just trying to make his way in a world where he has to deal with people like you......I am so ashamed of what you said. Perhaps some day you will walk in this parent's shoes......you will be singing a different tune. Hopefully, you will never become a parent.......we can tell you wouldn't be able to parent properly and lovingly.
11:39 PM on 07/23/2012
Hey this was New Jersey. I guess the teachers were getting their cues from the Governor Chris Christe!
11:36 PM on 07/03/2012
Here is my opinion...I think that the child was treated unfairly, according to the clips presented. I do however not know the entire back story, as well as anyone else watching the video. However, the teachers in this classroom are not just teacher’s, they're special need student teacher’s and aids...they are supposed to uphold a higher respect, and moral ground towards these children. This is NOT a group of unruly high school students, it’s a classroom full of children with learning disabilities. It was unacceptable, and I just wish that the union's didn’t stand up for people like this...but again, I don't know the whole story, I’m not a politician who knows every statue, and as such, my comments’ are only based on the article. . . .
03:30 PM on 06/26/2012
Hey, folks, the article says the student was wearing an AUDIO recorder, not a video recorder. The dad played the recording in a youtube video he made later. In spite of the fact that it apparently was illegal to secretly tape a teacher in the State of New Jersey, in this case, I'm glad the dad made the recording. In the state I live in, the teachers' union would provide an attorney for the teacher if he/she belonged to the union. It's covered by insurance paid for by union dues, to insure due process. It doesn't mean the teacher would automatically get to keep her job. Whether the aide was similarly protected depends on the union she may or may not have belonged to and whether she was still on probationary employment status. The whole thing is not as simplistic as some readers would like to have it be. Sometimes it's teachers who are on the receiving end of abuse by students or administrators. Parents and administrators should make it a practice to visit classrooms unexpectedly once in a while.
11:37 PM on 05/16/2012
The father should be arrested for federal and state wiretapping laws .
06:29 PM on 05/17/2012
You sound stupid haha failure. The father was 100% right on this case.
02:46 PM on 05/18/2012
You're joking right? No way you can be that stupid.
11:44 PM on 05/18/2012
Read the law in the state he lives in.New JerseyIt is a crime to purposely intercept any wire, electronic, or oral communication. It is also a crime to disclose or use the contents of any wire, electronic, or oral communication, knowing or having reason to know that the information was obtained unlawfully. N.J. Stat. § 2A:156A-3. However, if the contents of the communication have “become public knowledge or public information,” then the disclosure is not a crime N.J. Stat. § 2A:156A-3.The statute makes an exception and allows interception if the person intercepting is a party to the communication, or if one party has given prior consent, unless such communication is intercepted for the purpose of committing any criminal or tortious act. N.J. Stat. § 2A:156A-4. The fact that one subscriber to a particular telephone has consented does not authorize interception of conversations by other parties who use that telephone. N.J. Stat. § 2A:156A-4.Civil liability for unlawful interception or disclosure can be imposed for the greater of actual damages, $100 per day of violation $1,000, and can include punitive damages, attorney fees, and litigation costs. N.J. Stat. § 2A:156A-24.
03:30 AM on 05/14/2012
Mr Chaifetz you are a legend! Good on you!

As a teacher and a father (and a human) I'm disgusted by this story. No wonder our profession lacks respect when a**holes like this are in the classroom!