If you've ever seen the popsicle commercial created by the Corn Refiners Association, you know that most frozen treats are loaded with high fructose corn syrup -- which we all know by now isn't a great thing. Thankfully, that doesn't mean we have to stop eating popsicles -- there are a ton of all-natural popsicles on the market, and of course we're going to find the best ones for you.

We gathered the most appealing varieties of all-natural popsicles and conducted a blind taste test of 14 brands and flavors. Some are sweetened with cane syrup and others use good old sugar, but you won't find any corn syrup in these (or artificial sweeteners). We ended up discovering some pretty amazing flavors that we may not have tried on our own -- we hope we'll help you discover your own new favorite.

Check out the slideshow below to see how the popsicles ranked.

As always, this taste test was in no way influenced or sponsored by the brands included.

Loading Slideshow...
  • #1: Edy's Mango Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "There are actual mango fibers in this." "Yum! Tastes like fresh mango." "Wow, perfectly creamy texture. Great!" "Like frozen pureed mango. Delightful." <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, sugar, mango, lemon juice concentrate, natural flavor, guar gum, carob bean gum.

  • #2: 365 Coconut Frozen Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "So creamy! Absolutely delicious." "Great take on coconut -- but you must like coconut to like this!" "Creamy and milky." "Almost a chewy texture." "Sugar + sunscreen." <b>Ingredients:</b> Nonfat milk, cane sugar, coconut flakes, coconut cream, maltodextrin, whey (milk), natural stabilizers, guar gum, xanthan gum, dextrose.

  • #3: 365 Caribbean Mix Frozen Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "Nice complexity." "Lots of mixed fruits going on here -- I'd prefer if there was less going on." "Pleasant tropical taste." <b>Ingredients:</b> Strawberries, pineapple, mango, passion fruit, coconut flakes, water, cane sugar, natural stabilizers (guar gum, carob gum, carrageenan gum), citric acid.

  • #4: 365 Mango Frozen Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "This tastes like fresh mango." "Lovely mango. A tad too sweet but I love this." "Perfect mango flavor." "Would be great with a sprinkle of salt." "A slightly antiseptic aftertaste." <b>Ingredients:</b> Mango, water, cane sugar, natural stabilizers (guar gum, carob bean gum, carrageenan), citric acid.

  • #5: Trader Joe's Caribbean Fruit Floes

    <b>Comments:</b> "Is there passion fruit in here?" "A little syrupy -- and I can't detect what flavor this is." "Fresh tasting but not too sweet." "Give me the whole box of these!" <b>Ingredients:</b> Strawberries, pineapple, mango, passion fruit, coconut flakes, water, fructose, sucrose, citric acid, stabilizers (guar gum, carob gum, carrageenan gum), citric acid.

  • #6: 365 Strawberry Frozen Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "Love the chunks, but it's a little on the icy side." "Great berry taste." "Tastes like there's real fruit in here, but it's a little icy." "Very fruity, but a bit too sweet." "A little too sugary." <b>Ingredients:</b>Strawberries, water, cane sugar, natural stabilizers (guar gum, carob gum, carrageenan gum), citric acid.

  • #7: Trader Joe's Strawberry Fruit Floes

    <b>Comments:</b> "A weak fruit flavor." "Great texture, good flavor." "Needs a lot more flavor, but it's pleasant enough." "Just tastes like sugar." <b>Ingredients:</b> Strawberries, water, fructose, sucrose, natural stabilizers (guar gum, carob gum, carrageenan gum), citric acid

  • #8: Ciao Bella Sorbet Bars: Blood Orange

    <b>Comments:</b> "Creamy but a little bitter." "Refreshing, and not too sweet." "Perfectly tart, and not too sweet. Delicious." "Lovely and fresh tasting." "Tastes like frozen orange juice." "There are no words for how much I hate this. Like children's Tylenol and wet dog." <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, blood orange juice concentrate, organic evaporated cane juice, tapioca syrup, orange juice concentrate, pectin, natural coloring, orange oil, lemon juice concentrate.

  • #9: Edy's Pineapple Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "Love this, but it doesn't taste like real pineapple." "Just falls a little flat." "So icy. It tastes like bad pineapple hard candy." "Odd chemical flavor." "Odd fake pineapple flavor." <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, sugar, pineapple, citric acid, modified corn starch, guar gum, carob bean gum, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), natural flavor, annatto color, turmeric extract color.

  • #10: Trader Joe's Coconut Water Fruit Floes

    <b>Comments:</b> "Less creamy than I'd hope for coconut to be." "Icy, with coconut shavings." "Coconutty, fresh and amazing." "Pina colada on a stick!" <b>Ingredients:</b> Coconut water, cane sugar, coconut cream, coconut flakes, maltodextrin, stabilizers (guar gum, xanthan gum, detrose), citric acid.

  • #11: Edy's Tangerine Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "Bright!</b> "Way too watery and the orange tastes medicinal." "So icy. This hurts my teeth." "Violently orange. Blech." "I know this is fake orange and I should hate it, but I love it." <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, sugar, tangerine juice concentrate, orange pulp, citric acid, annatto color, tangerine oil, natural flavor, guar gum, carob bean gum, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), turmeric color extract.

  • #12: Edy's Strawberry Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "Too weak, not enough flavor." "I like the chunks of fruit but it needs a more powerful taste." "I think this is strawberry? A lot of chunks but very watery." "Love these." <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, strawberries, sugar, carob bean gum, guar gum, citric acid, color (beet juice extract, turmeric color), natural flavors, ascorbic acid (vitamin C).

  • #13: 365 Lime Frozen Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "So refreshing, but a little too tart for a whole bar." "Tart but nice." "Lime popsicles are the best, and this is a good one." "Tastes a little artificial." "Tastes like Citronella." <b>Ingredients:</b> Lime juice, water, natural stabilizers (guar gum, carob gum, carrageenan gum), citric acid.

  • #14: Edy's Grape Fruit Bars

    <b>Comments:</b> "I'm not a fan of grape juice, but I like this better than I thought I would. It tastes like real grape juice." "Awful concord grape medicine flavor." "Tastes like frozen grape juice from concentrate." "Gross. Why does anyone make grape-flavored anything?" <b>Ingredients:</b> Water, concord grape, sugar, grape juice concentrate, malic acid, natural flavor, guar gum, ascorbic acid (vitamin C), carob bean gum.