In what seemed an attempt to hype up a nascent, and perhaps nonexistent, quarterback controversy on the Washington Redskins, Skip Bayless of ESPN made himself the story during an episode of "First Take" on Monday morning. Perhaps best known for lauding Tim Tebow and tearing down LeBron James, Bayless contended that it is human nature for white fans to support a white athlete over a black athlete if given a choice.
"I'm going to throw it out there. You also have the black-white dynamic and the majority of Redskins fans are white. And it’s just human nature, if you’re white to root for the white guy," Bayless contended. "It just happens in sports. Just like the black community will root for the black quarterback. I'm for the black guy. I'm just saying, I don't like the dynamic for RG3. It could stunt his growth in the NFL."
Bayless made this claim about human nature to bolster his argument that Robert Griffin III, the reigning Heisman Trophy winner and the No. 2 overall selection in the 2012 NFL Draft, is in a precarious position in Washington due to the presence of fellow rookie QB Kirk Cousins, a fourth-round pick out of Michigan State. While attempting to make the case (which he has been doing for months) that the Redskins erred in drafting Cousins, who is white, because it puts unnecessary pressure on Griffin III, who is black, to flourish quickly, Bayless cited race as factor in determining fan opinion. This discussion came two days after Griffin delivered a lackluster effort in a preseason game against the Chicago Bears.
In its recap of that Bears' preseason win over the Redskins that also featured a strong performance by Cousins, NFL.com added "Cue the quarterback controversy jokes!" This remark was followed by a parenthetical explanation, "(Seriously, Cousins could pass Rex Grossman on the depth chart.)" Likewise, SB Nation made sure to flatly say "No, there isn't a quarterback controversy" while praising Cousins' relief efforts in that game.
"I think it’s safe to say that everyone wants to see RGIII flourish," Sarah Kogod wrote in the D.C. Sports Blog at the Washington Post after Bayless' performance on Monday morning. "Nobody is rooting against him because they’d rather see a white guy lead the team. And if they are, well that’s racism, not human nature."
Bayless' "First Take" foil, Stephen A. Smith, seemed to make an attempt to keep the conversation on the relative merits of the two quarterbacks after his partner's tangent, stating his opinion that any quarterback competition would only help the franchise. After getting Bayless to admit that he does think that Cousins is performing better right now, Smith added his own twist by seeming to transfer the racial rooting motivations that Bayless ascribed to the fan base to people within the organization. According to Smith, a failure to succeed with Griffin would cement a disconcerting "pattern" of African-American quarterbacks failing in D.C.
"You look at the Redskins and you look at Mike Shanahan. We haven't gone there. I'm going to go there. I don't know how it worked out with Jason Campbell, we just know it didn't work out. It didn't work out with Donovan McNabb and I don't like how the situation was handled. And now you've got RG3. So if it doesn't work out with RG3 either, Mike Shanahan, I guess all that I would try to say to you, as a brother, what's up? I would have a problem. Because I'm like 'wait a minute here!' There's just a little pattern going on here that I wouldn't like."
Since Bayless does proclaim his support for Griffin by saying "I'm for the black guy," he does allow for the possibility that not all people make rooting decisions based on the race of a player. Does he only think that Redskins fans let their allegiances be swayed this way? Does he really think that Cousins is better, even if only right now, and that Redskins fans will be swayed by the preseason productivity of each player? Or did Bayless only "throw it out there" in order to generate controversy?
Also on HuffPost:
Scott Van Pelt
Scott Van Pelt attends the Tim Tebow Foundation Celebrity Golf Classic Gala at TPC Sawgrass on April 13, 2012 in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida.
Steven A. Smith
Former ESPN radio's Steven A. Smith attends ESPN the Magazine's 7th Annual Pre-Draft Party at Espace on April 21, 2010 in New York City.
ESPN Anchor Stuart Scott arriving at the ESPN The Magazine's After Dark Party in the Metropolitan Big Room at Generations Hall on February 15, 2008 in New Orleans, Louisiana.
Buchigross has been an anchor for ESPN since 1996, working on <em>SportsCenter</em>, as well as an NHL column for ESPN.com.
Former Cold Pizza host Skip Bayless on the ESPN set in Miami, Florida on February 1, 2007.
ESPN personality Chris Berman speaks onstage during The 2011 ESPY Awards at Nokia Theatre L.A. Live on July 13, 2011 in Los Angeles, California.
Berthiaume is an anchor for<em> SportsCenter</em> and also hosts ESPN's <em>Baseball Tonight</em>.
Cohn regularly anchors ESPN's <em>SportsCenter</em>. She has been in that role since 1992, and also added play-by-play for WNBA telecasts to her repertoire in 2005.
Sports writer Bill Simmons speaks at the 2010 New Yorker Festival at DGA Theater on October 2, 2010 in New York City.
ESPN Anchor and Host Bob Ley arrives to the 2005 IRTS Foundation Awards at the Waldorf Astoria on October 6, 2005 in New York City.
Schefter is the NFL Insider for ESPN, and appeared frequently on ESPN's <em>Around the Horn</em>.
Sideline reporter Chris Mortensen on ESPN Monday Night Football September 11, 2006 in Washington.
Kenny Mayne of ESPN asks a question during the GMC Defensive Player of the Year award news conference prior to Super Bowl XLII at the Phoenix Convention Center on January 31, 2008 in Phoenix, Arizona.
Jay Crawford and Skip Bayless during a broadcast of ESPN's Cold Pizza from the Super Bowl XL Media Center at the Renaissance Center in Detroit, Michigan on January 30, 2006.
Ravech has worked for ESPN since 1993, and he appears mostly on <em>SportsCenter</em>, as well as <em>Baseball Tonight</em>.
Reali is the host of <em>Around the Horn</em> on ESPN, and previously worked on <em>Pardon the Interruption</em> in October 2001.
Mike Greenberg & Mike Golic
Golic joined ESPN in 1995 as an analyst for <em>Sunday NFL Countdown</em>, and is currently a co-host of <em>Mike and Mike in the Morning </em>with Mike Greenberg. Greenberg occasionally hosts <em>SportsCenter</em> in addition to his radio show.
Anderson has hosted <em>SportsCenter</em> since June 1999.
Colin Cowherd of ESPN Radio hosts The Herd from the Super Bowl XL Media Center at the Renaissance Center in Detroit, Michigan on January 30, 2006.
Hockey Analyst Barry Melrose speaks on set during a NHL Network broadcats during the 2012 NHL All-Star Game Player Media Availability at the Westin Ottawa on January 27, 2012 in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Journalist Hannah Storm attends the 34th Annual AWRT Gracie Awards Gala at The New York Marriott Marquis on June 3, 2009 in New York City.
ESPN broadcaster Dick Vitale does a live broadcast before a game between the North Carolina Tar Heels and the North Carolina State Wolfpack at the Dean Smith Center on January 26, 2012 in Chapel Hill, North Carolina.