WICHITA, Kan. (AP) — A federal judge ruled Tuesday that the Kansas State Fair can require an animal-rights group to shield people walking by its booth from easily seeing images depicting animal slaughter.
U.S. District Judge J. Thomas Marten rejected a request from People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals to block the restrictions on its booth for the fair, which starts Friday. The judge determined the fair is a "limited public forum," because exhibitors have to apply for a booth and pay a fee — unlike a public square, for example, where anybody has the right to protest or speak.
PETA plans to show a 13-minute video, "Glass Walls," which depicts animals being slaughtered and instances of abuse at factory farms. It filed a lawsuit last week asking the court to immediately block the fair's requirements that it shield people from the video.
In rejecting the group's request for that restraining order, Marten said restrictions imposed by fair officials were minimal and did not constitute any significant infringement on PETA's free speech rights. However, Marten declined to dismiss PETA's lawsuit, as the state had requested.
Marten noted fair officials are not preventing PETA from showing its undercover video. Instead, he said, this could be as simple as turning a TV screen away from the public flow down the aisle.
"It is simply a matter of whether you can have it shoved in your face, or whether you take a step or two in another direction," Marten said.
The judge was clearly uncomfortable with his ruling, telling lawyers at a hearing that it ran counter to his own personal feelings and saying that he would not have a problem taking his own children by the video. But he said he believed the fair board acted responsibly. He invited PETA to appeal to the 10th Circuit for an immediate ruling that would provide more guidance.
It is unclear whether PETA intends to further pursue the issue. PETA's attorney, Bill Raney, said following the hearing that no decision had been made yet about whether to appeal the judge's ruling or even whether to proceed with the lawsuit, which names the Kansas Fair Board, the state and the fair's general manager, Denny Stoecklein, as defendants.
"We are disappointed," Raney said. "We think the fair is a designated public forum."
PETA later issued a written statement saying it was considering an appeal.
"The Kansas State Fair's requirement that PETA hide its video from fairgoers is like the Wizard of Oz telling Dorothy that she can't look behind the curtain," PETA said. "We believe the First Amendment means that we can show our video without limitation to reveal what the animal agriculture industry wishes no one would see — that animals confined in filth on factory farms are routinely beaten and kicked by workers and have their throats cut open while they're still conscious at the slaughterhouse."
Kansas Deputy Attorney General Jeff Chanay said the state was pleased with the court's ruling.
"We are thankful for the opportunity to present our position in court," Chanay said.
During the hearing, the state tried to distinguish the fair from a traditional public forum by portraying it as "Kansas' largest classroom."
If the fair were equated to a public forum, that would destroy the atmosphere of the event, argued Stephen McAllister, one of the attorneys representing the state. One group might want to show dead soldiers to protest wars, another might want to show aborted fetuses to protest abortion, another might want to include nudity in a booth. The state has a compelling interest in controlling what is presented to children in this setting, McAllister said.
"It is not about trying to restrict the message; it is trying to see the environment is appropriate," McAllister said.
But Raney argued that in its own commercial exhibitor materials, the fair has called the event a "public forum of limited duration." Therefore, Raney said, the fair is subject to the same rules as any other public forum.
"The First Amendment is not so easily evaded," Raney argued. "You can silence someone indirectly."
Also on HuffPost:
Fake snow falls as Kobe Kaige, Penthouse's former 'Pet of the Year' poses nude for a PETA anti-fur ad campaign in Melbourne in May 2008
PETA animal rights activists demonstrate naked and speared with banderillas against the EU cash support for bullfights in front of the EU Parliament's Headquarters in Brussels on October 9, 2008. AFP PHOTO JOHN THYS (Photo credit should read JOHN THYS/AFP/Getty Images)
Dutch model Natasja Vermeer (R) is pictured by Italian photographer Angelo Gigli while posing naked for animal rights campaign organized by The People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, in downtown Rome, 10 December 2007. The campain titled, 'Be an angel for the animals, don't wear the fur.' is the latest anti-fur advert for animal rights group PETA. AFP PHOTO / Filippo MONTEFORTE (Photo credit should read FILIPPO MONTEFORTE/AFP/Getty Images)
In October 2007, actress Sophie Monk lies nearly nude in a bed of crimson chilli peppers for a PETA pro-vegetarian campaign: "Spice Up Your Life - Go Vegetarian"
Naked Australian model and singer Imogen
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA: Naked Australian model and singer Imogen Bailey holds Reggie the rabbit during filming for an anti-fur campaign ad sponsored by the environmental group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) in Sydney, 25 March 2004. PETA is protesting the commercial use of rabbits - which are found in plague proportions across much of Australia - by the fur and felt industries. AFP PHOTO/Torsten BLACKWOOD (Photo credit should read TORSTEN BLACKWOOD/AFP/Getty Images)
Two nude Peta girls shower on a sidewalk
Two nude Peta girls shower on a sidewalk in Holllywood, California on March 22, 2011 in celebration of World Water Day to expose meat's alleged devastating impact on the planet. AFP PHOTO / GABRIEL BOUYS (Photo credit should read GABRIEL BOUYS/AFP/Getty Images)
Barcelona, SPAIN: About one hundred members of the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) and Anima Naturalis, lies down naked silently protest naked in Catalunya square, in center of Barcelona, 21 January 2007. AFP PHOTO/LLUIS GENE. (Photo credit should read LLUIS GENE/AFP/Getty Images)
All Dogs Go To Heaven
Italian television presenter Tamara Ecclestone poses with her dog Buster in a new poster ad for PETA that urges, 'Be an Angel for Animals. Animals Deserve Respect, Patience, and Understanding'.
Adam And Eve
Models Patrick Ribbsaeter and Avi Siwa hold a banner encouraging the closure of all zoos, promoted by the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) at a studio in Bangkok in December 2006
Alicia Meyer Bares All In Lettuce
Alicia Meyer wears labels referring to cuts of meat in a photo shoot for PETA's pro-vegetarian ad campaign in August 2009
Playboy Bunnies For PETA
Playboy models Victoria Eisermann and Monica Harris pose in a bathtub to highlight the U.K.'s water consumption, during PETA World Water Day in London in March 2011
Tony Gonzalez and October
Atlanta Falcons' Tony Gonzalez and his wife October pose nude for PETA's anti-fur campaign in November 2009
Model Becomes Tiger
Malaysian model Amber Chia with body painted tiger stripes poses with a tag line for PETA Asia near Kuala Lumpur in October 2009
Pamela Anderson In China
Pamela Anderson poses topless in PETA's 'Give Fur the Cold Shoulder' anti-fur campaign. In Chinese, the ad reads "Cold shoulders are nothing compared to the pain they feel. Please don't wear fur"
Two half naked women, from the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) painted with Canadian flags, protest against seal slaughter outside the Canada Trade Office in Taipei on March 23, 2011. The protesters said the European Union and the US have banned seal products for years and hope Taiwan can do the same too. AFP PHOTO / Sam YEH (Photo credit should read SAM YEH/AFP/Getty Images)
Two members of the group People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) stage a 'naked' protest outside the venue of the G20 summit in Seoul on November 9, 2010. AFP PHOTO/HOANG DINH Nam (Photo credit should read HOANG DINH NAM/AFP/Getty Images)
Animal Activists Encourage Vegetarianism
LONDON - AUGUST 17: Shoppers stop to look at a naked PETA member lying wrapped in cellophane and bloodied on large trays for Pro-Vegetarian demonstration in Covent Garden on August 17, 2006 in London, England. PETA EUROPE aims to demonstrate to shoppers that all animals are made of flesh and bone and feel pain and that eating meat is literally eating a corpse. (Photo by Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images)
PETA's Banned Superbowl Ad