Prior to an interview, job seekers may fret about whether their analytical skills are up to par or whether their experience is extensive enough, but when it comes to landing certain positions, new research shows that considerable weight is put on whether the interviewer would like to have a beer with the interviewee.
Having the same tastes, experiences and leisure pursuits as the interviewer -- as well as good "emotional spark" with him or her -- is just as important, if not more, than actual job skills, according a new study by Northwestern University management and organizations professor Lauren Rivera.
"I had one interview, who was the head of recruiting with an investment bank, who started off the interview saying, 'You're just hiring yourself,'" Rivera told The Huffington Post.
The study, titled "Hiring as Cultural Matching: The Case of Elite Professional Service Firms," will be published in the December issue of the American Sociological Review.
By speaking with representatives from 120 prestigious law firms, management consulting firms and investment banks throughout the course of two years, Rivera found many people are looking for a good "cultural fit." In other words, they want to find people with similar profiles to themselves outside of work. In fact, more than half of the study's participants rated "fit" as the most important criteria in hiring -- even more so than analytical thinking and communication.
While these tendencies don't mean that employers hire unqualified candidates, Rivera said the research suggests that once job candidates have met a certain threshold in terms of their job skills, their interpersonal connection and fit with the interviewer become the deciding factors in whether they make it to the next round.
A company representative who defined his firm as "boring" didn't want to hire candidates with too many interests outside of work, while another interviewer thought that a squash player wouldn't match well with her company's more "rough and tumble" image.
"A lot of this job is attitude, not aptitude...fit is really important," one study participant told Rivera, according to the study. "You know, you will see more of your co-workers than your wife, your kids, your friends, and even your family. So you can be the smartest guy ever, but I don't care. I need to be comfortable working everyday with you, then getting stuck in an airport with you, and then going for a beer after. You need chemistry."
At the same time, when firms didn't specify how to measure merit, individuals conducting interviews tended to fall back on their own identities and used them as templates of success. For example, non-athletes tended to highlight the value of non-athletic pursuits in candidates, while peer interviewers who played Division 1 sports in college were more impressed by those who did the same.
"It's this idea that merit looks like me," Rivera told HuffPost.
Bruce Barry, a professor of management and sociology at Vanderbilt University, said that the findings illustrate the tried and true psychological tenet of like-attracts-like, but that it's hard to say whether they would translate to companies outside of this specific and elite context. For example, he said, one would hope that skill set would be far more important in other settings, such as medicine.
However, he noted the study does highlight what previous studies have shown: People over-rely on interviews in determining whether a candidate is right for the job.
"Interviews are not that reliable," Barry told HuffPost. "There are better ways, behavioral testing and performance testing, that are more reliable than just the gut feeling people get. But we do know from a lot of research from HR selection that people think they're good at this and like to use their own judgment to make these choices."
Barry went on to argue that it's reasonable to break a tie between candidates by going for the person who seems to get along better with the rest of the group, but that the dark side of favoring candidates based on similarity is that it's the same premise that has fostered decades of discrimination against those who are different from a firm's existing base.
"There's certainly a danger in treating cultural similarity as somehow a proxy," Barry said.
Rivera echoed his sentiment, noting that a lack of diversity can be detrimental to creativity and decision-making in the workplace, among other things.
While gender and race were not the key characteristics of similarities that drove hiring decisions in this study, the extracurricular activities that were often favored were stereotypical of white males from privilege. The candidates came from such similar educational backgrounds, though, that even the non-white and female candidates shared interest in these same activities, which suggests there's a strong socioeconomic dimension to what they had in common.
Steve Kane, a human resources consultant, suggested that candidates should stay true to themselves during interviews.
"People shouldn’t try and doctor what they do in the hopes that they will put down the right activities, like playing squash or sailing," Kane told HuffPost.
In the end, he noted, it's interpersonal skills with potential clients that should matter more than a direct connection with the interviewer.
"In professional services, everybody's role is to go get business," Kane said. "They look for somebody who would be interesting to talk to, and that's the key. Can this person engage with others?"
At the same time, Kane argued that it's still not a bad idea to capitalize on any similarities one might have with an interviewer.
"The employment situation is not significantly different from any other selection situation. You want that other person to feel that they have something in common with you," Kane said. "Think of it as a date. If someone says I happen to like opera, and you also like opera, you ought to mention that."
Also on HuffPost:
Median Salary: $62,174 Oh, accountants. When was a movie ever made that didn’t show them as nerdy and uninteresting? Well, accountants, you can stick this in your pocket protector – you are among the most underrated jobs! “In fact, it’s a very solid, secure profession,” Lee said. “Accountants are needed whether the economy is good or bad.” And, let’s face it, the most recent downturn and subsequent scrutiny on accounting highlighted the need for accountants even more. <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list at CNBC</a>
5. Market Research Analyst
Median Salary: $61,236 “This is one where we’ve become such an incredible consumer nation and market research has really elevated it to where there isn’t a product or service that doesn’t require market research,” Lee said. “And yet most people don’t think of market research as a profession. They might think of going into marketing but that’s different from market research.” <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list at CNBC</a>
Median Salary: $73,285 When was the last time you heard a kid say, “I want to be a biologist when I grow up!” Right. Well, maybe they should. “There’s a lot of demand,” Lee said. “Biologists have a lot of things going for them. They’re needed by the whole military complex, with biological weapons. At the same time, they have mapped the human genome – so, there’s biological science in health care.” “The need for biologists is very large. And yet biology is a field that has not attracted huge numbers of new graduates,” Lee said. <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list at CNBC</a>
Median Salary: $82,190 “With the amount of work and school being so high, the perception is that, ‘If I’m going to do that, I should just be a person doctor!’” Lee said. In fact, there’s a real shortage of veterinarians, he said. Plus, you get to manage your own schedule, and you don’t have to worry about health-care regulations! What’s more, Lee said, Look at the baby boom generation: “They are at the wealthiest stage of their lives, and they all have pets!” Boom! Demand. <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list at CNBC</a>
2. Civil Engineer
Median Salary: $78,133 The only time civil engineers really get respect seems to be on the History Channel. And this area of engineering, which is on the lower end of the engineering pay scale, tends to not be that popular. But right now, Lee said, there is huge demand for rebuilding bridges, roads, and other infrastructure, all of which require civil engineers. “At long last, we seem to be moving forward with infrastructure improvement in the country,” Lee said, adding that there are actually shortages of engineers right now. <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list at CNBC</a>
1. Computer Systems Analyst
Median Salary: $78,148 These are the guys who study an organization’s computer systems and procedures and make recommendations for how to better organize, manage, and upgrade technology. These guys aren’t usually the heroes in the movie – if they’re even in the movie – but if you’ve ever used a computer at your job you know this is one of the most necessary, and underrated, jobs. “It’s a terrific job,” Lee said. “Demand is extremely high. Pay is strong. And you get to work pretty autonomously.” According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, this profession is expected to grow 22 percent in the next decade. Computer systems analysts, we salute you. Your job is underrated! <a href="http://www.cnbc.com/id/49184854?__source=huffpost|underratedjobs|&par=huffpost" target="_hplink">See the full list At CNBC</a>