Huffpost Politics

Arizona Bill Could Outlaw Online Impersonation, Twitter Parody Accounts

Posted: Updated:
ARIZONA BILL HB 2004
A bill proposed by Arizona Republican State Representative Michelle Ugenti could outlaw the creation of Twitter parody accounts. | Twitter

Are you a fan of @KimJongNumberUn, @AngiesRightLeg or @ThePresObama? Well, a new bill in Arizona could make the creation of some Twitter parody accounts a felony offense.

If passed, House Bill 2004 -- which was proposed by Arizona Republican State Representative Michelle Ugenti -- would make it a crime to impersonate someone online without their permission and with the intent to "harm, defraud, intimidate, or threaten" anyone.

In addition, the bill would make it a misdemeanor to send an email, text message or instant message impersonating someone else without their permission and with the intent to cause "harm."

According to The Arizona Republic, Ugenti modeled the Arizona billon a similar law in Texas that was passed in 2009. As recently as October, a woman was jailed in the Lone Star state after allegedly pretending to be a doctor in an elaborate scheme to convince her friend to engage in a relationship with her.

New York, California and Washington have enacted similar laws, as well. In New York, where the law banning online impersonation has been in effect since 2008, the language is vague and subject to broad interpretation.

Of course, Arizona's proposed bill isn't specifically trying to shut down those Twitter parody accounts. It seeks to outlaw harmful online impersonation, which can be a dangerous crime that can get people killed. For example, Megan Meier, a 13-year-old girl, committed suicide in 2006 after a Missouri woman, her daughter and a family friend set up a fake MySpace account pretending to be a 16-year-old boy in order to fool and bully Meier.

But critics of the bill say that if the "intent to harm" phrase is interpreted broadly, it could provoke a controversy involving the First Amendment.

"The problem with this, and other online impersonation bills, is the potential that they could be used to go after parody or social commentary activities," an attorney from the San Francisco-based nonprofit Electronic Frontier Foundation told The Arizona Republic.

Twitter already has its own rules regarding parody accounts, stating users cannot take a person's real name without a qualifier like "not" or "fake" in front of it. For example, @FakePresidentObama would be OK; @PresidentObama would not. Even with a qualifier, however, Twitter can shut down a parody account if it is misleading or deceiving.

Ugenti did not immediately return a request for comment.

(h/t Daily Dot)

Close
What Not To Post On Twitter: 11 Things Your Tweeps Don't Need To Know(CLONED)
of
Share
Tweet
Advertisement
Share this
close
Current Slide


Also on HuffPost:

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

Michelle Ugenti's Absurd Revenge Legislation, HB 2004 - Phoenix ...

Arizona bill would outlaw posing as others on Facebook or Twitter

Arizona set to make online impersonation a felony

How To Create A Fake Twitter Account: Author Hoaxes And Microblogging

Fake John le Carré Twitter Account Fakes JK Rowling's Fake Twitter Death

Sorry, Philip Roth Is Not on Twitter

Newtown School Shooting Spurs Fake Adam Lanza Accounts and Other Social ...

 
Register To Vote