Huffpost Parents

Baby Name Contest Hoax: Belly Ballot Not Actually Paying Woman $5,000 For Naming Rights

Posted: Updated:
Natasha Hill
Natasha Hill

Last week, the story of a "mom" who had agreed to let the Internet choose her baby's name for $5,000 went viral. The tale garnered interest in part because it seemed unbelievable. It turns out, it was.

Belly Ballot, a website that allows friends and family members of expectant parents to vote for their favorite baby names, contacted The Huffington Post about its contest offering one expectant mother $5,000 to let online voters choose her new baby's name. Lacey Moler, the site's co-founder, put us in touch with the "winner" -- a woman allegedly named Natasha Hill, who was later revealed to be an actress named Natasha Lloyd.

Lloyd, who claimed to be three months pregnant, told The Huffington Post last week that she wasn't worried about strangers choosing a bizarre name for her baby. "I think people will do the right thing and vote for something unique and nice," she said over the phone.

She explained that she would use the prize money to pay off her credit-card debt and to start her child's college fund.

The story was picked up by several news outlets -- Today Moms, the Daily Mail, the New York Daily News -- and even spoofed on "Saturday Night Live."

Los Angeles website LAist then uncovered clues that the story might be a hoax.

First, the contest winner's photo is strikingly similar to the headshot of an actress LAist found on IMDB (you can see the comparison on LAist). The woman who claimed to have won the contest identified herself as "Natasha Hill," and the actress's name is Natasha Lloyd. The birthday listed on Hill's Facebook page, which has since been taken down, was the same as Lloyd's birthday.

Belly Ballot's Moler then confessed to Today Moms that story was in fact a hoax. “We came up with the idea for the contest and we knew it would be controversial ... But we’re a startup and we wanted to control the situation,” Moler told Today's Jacoba Urist.

Moler admitted that after receiving zero applications for the contest, Belly Ballot decided to hire an actress to play the winner. Llyod confirmed that she pretend to be Natasha Hill, but wouldn't give Urist any more details about her contract with Belly Ballot.

The Huffington Post reached out to Belly Ballot Monday morning and has yet to hear back.

Related on HuffPost:

10 Weirdest Baby Name Stories
Share this
Current Slide

Suggest a correction

Around the Web

$5000 online baby-name contest revealed as hoax

Baby-Naming Hoax Tricks TV News

Is The Story Of The Mom Who Agreed To Let The Internet Name Her Baby For ...

Baby Naming Contest Elaborate Hoax, NBC Blog Learns