Who had whom in a headlock is the focus of a dispute between a Baltimore chef and a diner.

The parties in the argument are Kevin Perry, the chef and co-owner at Liv2Eat, a restaurant in the Riverside neighborhood of South Baltimore, and Wesley Doyle, 42, of Baltimore, who was dining at Liv2Eat on Friday with his wife and their two children.

Perry, who is 34 and lives in Annapolis, and Doyle have filed criminal complaints, each charging the other with second-degree assault. Perry also charged Doyle with reckless endangerment and affray, which is similar to disturbing the peace. All are misdemeanors. A trial is scheduled for April 23 in Baltimore City District Court.

Both sides' accounts of the events leading up to the disputed headlock are similar.

They both acknowledge that the Doyle family wasn't having a good time at Liv2Eat on Friday night, and both agree that there were two confrontations about slow service between Doyle's wife, Claire Mullins, and Perry's wife, Cecilia Benalcazar, who is the restaurant's co-owner and manager.

Both sides also agree that the second time Mullins approached Benalcazar to complain, she was headed with her family toward the restaurant's exit, which is within earshot of Liv2Eat's open kitchen.

That's when, both sides agree, Perry told Mullins in not-so-nice terms to leave his restaurant. Both sides say that Perry shouted obscenities at Mullins.

It's what happened next that's in dispute.

According to an account circulated via email by Mullins and later posted on a neighborhood listserv, when her husband "intervened in an attempt to get [Perry] to settle down ... [Perry] jumped out of the kitchen and attacked Wes, in front of our kids and a restaurant full of patrons, putting Wes in a headlock."

Benalcazar disputed Mullins' version of events, saying Doyle walked into the kitchen and went after her husband, putting Perry in a headlock.

"Their account is completely false," Mullins said. "My husband was attacked in a restaurant that we went to with our children."

A police report from that night indicates that Doyle told the responding officer "that after a dispute over food the cook ... grabbed [Doyle] in a head lock. Several customers broke up [the] fight. Neither individual was hurt."

Benalcazar said the story will be told more fully next month.

"Both our sides will be heard in court," she said in an email to The Baltimore Sun. "It is very easy to believe everything you hear but rumors run [rampant], as they usually do."


twitter.com/gorelickingood ___

Also on HuffPost:

Loading Slideshow...
  • Sophie Guite

    Sophie Guite, 19, of Winterport, Maine, was arrested for spousal abuse after allegedly hitting her husband with a spatula.

  • Joel Parrish

    Parrish was accused in June, 2013 of beating another man with his own prosthetic leg, according to an arrest report filed by the <a href="http://p2c.cityofmyrtlebeach.com/p2c/QuickResults.aspx?case=13012274" target="_hplink">Myrtle Beach Police Department.</a>

  • iAssault

    A NYC firefighter allegedly <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/28/eric-bischoff-beat-wife-ipad-nyc_n_2781184.html?1362068369" target="_hplink">beat his wife over the head with an iPad </a>after an argument regarding a photograph she'd posted online.

  • Joel Perez

    Police say they saw Joel Perez hit his brother with a cremation urn in Lorain, Ohio. It knocked out his brother and broke the urn, sending human ashes flying, officials with the Lorain County Sheriff said.

  • Lynn Benson

    Lynn Benson allegedly drove a bulldozer through his place of employment.

  • Lois Goodman

    Lois Goodman, a professional tennis referee, has been accused of murdering her 80-year-old husband with a coffee mug. (AP Photo/Nick Ut)

  • Man Robs Ice Cream Shop With Submachine Gun

    A suspect allegedly robbed a Naples, Florida Italian ice shop with a submachine gun on Aug. 23, according to police. He is still on the loose.

  • Sarah Howell

    Sarah Howell, of Killeen, Tex., beat her boyfriend with a stripper pole and poured cooking oil on him.

  • Chris Meusburger

    Chris Meusburger brandished a sword and threatened to "seriously hurt" an elderly woman after she criticized the way he treated a book she had lent him.

  • Mangos Stop Robbery

    Otilia Martins, 80, helped thwart a robbery at her son-in-law's market by chucking mangos at the thieves.

  • Gardener Harry Cook

    Gardener Harry Cook who defiantly stopped a man in a van from stealing his potted plants and flowers. Brave Harry Cook, 67, calmly stood in front of their getaway van before ordering them to "put the blooming things back." Incredibly, the cowardly thieves agreed to replace the plants and unloaded the van before speeding off empty handed. Harry, a retired JCB driver, was in his potting shed in his back garden of his home in Loughborough, Leics, when he caught the raiders red-handed at 4pm on July 8.

  • Jason Dornhoff

    Jason Dornhoff was arrested after <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/11/jason-dornhoff-wrote-bomb-threat-job-application_n_1665954.html" target="_hplink">he wrote a bomb threat on the back of a job application,</a> police said. Cops searched his truck, but found no explosives.

  • Michael Conley

    Former Elvis impersonator Michael Conley blamed his diabetes for starting a standoff with Florida police, in which he threatened to use a weapon of mass destruction against them. He allegedly held up a vial of what he called Ricin -- a highly potent toxin -- as he barricaded himself in a motel in February, 2012. He was arrested about four hours later. Read more <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/02/29/wmd-suspect-diabetes_n_1310202.html" target="_hplink">here.</a>

  • Bug Spray Bandit

    Investigators in California are trying to track down a man who robbed a bank armed with pesticide. The suspect appeared to be carrying a black semi-automatic handgun and a plastic container of pesticide when he held up the Pacific Western Bank in Rancho Santa Fe on Nov. 4, 2011. <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/11/08/bank-robbery-pesticide_n_1082447.html" target="_hplink">Read more.</a>

  • Konstantine Myakush

    Konstantine Myakush was struck in the neck with an errant arrow in a Moscow park on April 30, 2012. Myakush -- who was out with his two daughters -- miraculously survived the brush with death and is expected to make a full recovery. Doctors said he was fortunate because the arrow didn't strike a major artery.

  • Clara Ann Blocker

    In April 2012, Clara Ann Blocker, of Oklahoma City, was sentenced to life in prison for beating a dwarf to death with a crystal ball. Blocker, 41, was drinking with Erik Scott Saxton on September 16, 2010, when the two got into an argument. Blocker grabbed a nearby crystal ball to bludgeon Saxton in the head before also beating him with a DVD player. Though Blocker initially claimed she never would have hurt the 4-foot 5-inch Saxton, "because he's a little person," she ultimately pleaded guilty to his murder.

  • Dildo

    On April 25, 2012, Lisa Anderson violated the penal law. When police showed up at Anderson's apartment in Watertown, New York, on complaint of an "unwanted person" in the home, Anderson allegedly threw a pink dildo at the face of Officer Jonathan Pitts. The sex toy hit him in the forehead. Anderson was arraigned the same day on a charge of misdemeanor harassment and ultimately released.

  • Deadly Booby Traps

    On April 16, 2012, a U.S. Forest Service Officer came across something that most people only encounter in cartoons: booby traps. The traps were located along a popular hiking trail in South Fork Canyon, Utah. They were elaborate set-ups, including concealed pits of spikes and a tripwire-activated swinging ball of spiked sticks surrounding a 20-pound rock. The officer found the traps before they claimed any victims, but hiker Emily Hammerstad noted that such traps "would kill people, easily." Benjamin Rutkowski, 19, and Kai Christensen, 21, ultimately admitted to setting the traps, and were charged with reckless endangerment. Had anyone been hurt, they would have been charged with felonies.

  • Peter Andrew Levay

    Peter Andrew Levay, 42, is charged with beating his neighbor to death with an electric guitar. On the morning of April 22, police in Austin, Texas were notified shortly after Levay allegedly told his roommate, Lavern Fisher, that he thought he killed the man who lived above them. Officials say they found the man, 64-year-old Maurice Leray Eckert, dead from "blunt trauma to the head." Eckert's wallet and blood-stained clothes were recovered from Levay's closet. Fisher said his roommate's motive was likely related to the victim's conduct not long before the incident took place. The three men had been drinking together, Fisher said, when Eckert "started making sexual advances toward me and [Levay], and they became violent."

  • Spatula

    Investigators believe that Utah woman Angeles Cadillo-Castro used a spatula to murder her five-year-old stepdaughter. The young girl was found beaten to death in July 2010 in Cadillo-Castro's South Salt Lake apartment. As part of a plea deal, the 31-year-old woman pleaded guilty and received a sentence of five years to life sentence in May 2011. <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/a_mason/7251819/" target="_hplink">flickr: Andrew Mason</a>

  • Medieval-Style Mace

    Roberto Vazquez's weapon of choice wouldn't be that unusual . . . if he were living in the Middle Ages. Police say the 37-year-old New Jersey man attacked Matthew Pinto, an employee of Atlantic City Electric, with a "mace-like weapon" on February 8, 2012. Vazquez had previously had his electricity disconnected after he failed to pay his bills, but he had managed to reconnect his power by cutting a lock and manipulating the meter. Pinto had arrived to disconnect the power once again when Vazquez allegedly beat the employee over the head with a weapon made up of a 16-inch wooden handle and two spiked metal spheres. Pinto was knocked unconscious, and after waking up, bleeding from the head, in Vazquez's home, he drove to a police precinct to get help. Vazquez now faces a range of charges including attempted murder, aggravated assault, tampering with evidence, obstruction of justice and weapons charges.

  • Tom Guzzi

    Tom Guzzi, a legally blind 71-year-old, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/16/tom-guzzi-fights-robbers-kitchen-pot_n_1676159.html?1342726649" target="_hplink">defended his Pittsburgh home</a> from a pair of alleged armed robbers by using a kitchen pot.

  • Garden Gnome

    Frederick Gilliard, 76, killed his wife with a Easter End head-shaped garden gnome and an 8-inch carving knife.

  • Ana Trujillo

    Ana Trujillo, 44, allegedly told Houston police that she fatally stabbed her boyfriend with a stiletto high heel in self defense on June 9, 2013.