This disputed call at second base was so close that instant replay might not have helped clarify matters after umpire Bill Miller called Dodgers pinch-runner Dee Gordon out trying to swipe the bag.

With one out in the top of the ninth and Atlanta clinging to a 4-3 lead, the Dodgers sent Gordon to pinch-run for A.J. Ellis, who had gotten aboard with a walk. To the surprise of few, Gordon tried to steal second. He slid head first as Braves catcher Gerald Laird's throw bounced into Andrelton Simmons' glove. As Simmons grabbed the ball, he had his mitt near Gordon's backside and may have touched his jersey. Simmons then tagged Gordon again near his foot. That tap on the lower leg came after he appeared to have touched the base.

"Out!" was the call from Miller. Gordon disagreed.


(GIF via BuzzFeed Sports)

Gordon looked visibly shocked -- and may have created a new Internet meme -- after he got up and found out what had been called.


Dodgers manager Don Mattingly never left the dugout to argue. The Braves went on to win 4-3.

"I'm just as surprised as you are... I thought I was safe," Gordon said after the loss, via Jesse Sanchez of MLB.com.

Also on HuffPost:

Loading Slideshow...
  • Manny Machado's Amazing Play Against Yankees

  • Ben Revere's Unbelievable Catch

  • Puig Ropes It In

  • McLouth Hustles

  • Rivera's Last Out

  • Big Play From Soriano

  • Trumbo Flashes The Leather

  • Santana Comes Down With It

  • Cowgill's Big Catch

  • Strasburg Gets 500

  • Desmond Reaches 20/20 Mark

  • Span Holds On

  • Kelly's Diving Tag

  • Zimmerman's Ridiculous Play

  • Rios Gets The Cycle

  • Duda's Big Bomb

  • Choo Delivers A Walk-Off

  • Twins Turn Two

  • Davis Crushes No. 53

  • Pirates Cut Down Schierholtz

  • Hundley's Big Shot

  • Davis Crushes A Grand Slam

  • Harper Homers At First Two At-Bats - 4/1/13

  • Estrada's Incredible Double Play

  • Upton's Grand Slam - 5/17/13

  • Juan Perez makes a perfect throw to nab Logan Forsythe

  • Heartwarming Moment With Todd Frazier And Bat Boy

  • Escobar

  • Ciriaco's Wild Double Play

  • Miguel Cabrera Launches HR Into Stingray Tank

  • Markakis Robs Beltre Of Homer

  • David Wright flashes leather

  • David Lough's sliding catch

  • Chris Stewart turns great double play

  • Werth transfixed by 57 mph pitch

  • Puig's CANNON throw to third

  • Rays pull off hidden ball trick

  • Jeter homers on first pitch he sees

  • Yunel Escobar Goes Behind The Back

  • Tim Lincecum Throws No-No

  • David Ortiz breaks Harold Baines' record for hits by a DH

  • Dbacks outfielders trade brilliant catches

  • Terdoslavich's over the shoulder catch

  • Huff's sick glove toss

  • Yasiel Puig's Incredible Start

  • Kershaw Goes Long

  • Homer Bailey tosses second career no hitter

  • Bryce Harper homers in first AB back from DL

  • Ludwick's diving grab

  • Pedro Alvarez HR clears PNC Park

  • Mike Trout's Diving Catch