RICHMOND, Va. — RICHMOND, Va. (AP) — The families of victims and survivors of the 2007 massacre at Virginia Tech call campus safety measures instituted at colleges and universities nationwide a "living legacy" that won't be diminished by a court decision involving two who were killed.
The VTV Family Outreach Foundation said the changes sparked by the deadliest mass shooting in modern U.S. history remain strong despite a Virginia Supreme Court ruling Thursday that tossed a jury's wrongful death finding against the state stemming from two students' deaths during the rampage.
Justices concluded that Tech administrators did not have a duty to warn students that a gunman remained at large after he had killed two people in a dormitory and that they had no way to anticipate he would go on to kill 30 more and himself.
The court ruled in the case of two students whose families argued that they might have survived the rampage if the administrators alerted the campus earlier to the gunman's initial shootings at a dormitory. Instead, Erin Nicole Peterson, Julia Kathleen Pryde and 28 other people were killed nearly three hours later in Norris Hall, a classroom building.
But the justices agreed with the state — that there was no way to anticipate the deadly intentions of student Seung-Hui Cho.
"Thus, as a matter of law, the commonwealth did not have a duty to protect students against third party criminal acts," the court wrote.
Since the shootings, U.S. campuses have instituted warning systems across different platforms — cellphone alerts, warning sirens — and have been proactive in working to prevent a repeat of what happened in Blacksburg, Va. Advocates and family members of victims said the ruling won't change that.
"Improvements to how colleges and universities across the country, post April 16, 2007, handle threat assessment and emergency response spurred by the tragedy have fundamentally improved campus safety," the VTV Family Outreach Foundation said in a statement. "This is their living legacy."
The foundation and its 32 National Campus Safety Initiative — named for the number of victims at Tech — works to promote efforts to make college campuses safer.
"The April 16, 2007, tragedy forever changed campus safety," said S. Daniel Carter, director of the initiative. "This court ruling does nothing to diminish that."
In Thursday's ruling, the justices reversed the jury's findings and issued a final ruling, meaning there is no avenue for appeal.
The state attorney general's office said the court "found what we have said all along to be true."
Spokesman Brian Gottstein wrote in an email: "The commonwealth and its officials at Virginia Tech were not negligent on April 16, 2007. Cho was the lone person responsible for this tragedy."
The case was the lone pending legal action stemming from the massacre, Gottstein said.
The appeal attorney representing the parents of Peterson, 18, and Pryde, 23, said justices applied a stricter standard than the trial judge. The public perception of the university's actions could be a different matter, attorney L. Steven Emmert said.
"Now in the court of public opinion, the university may suffer — that's quite possible, but that's not the court's to deal with," he said. "Courts will decide legal rights."
The trial in the case was held in March 2012 in Montgomery County, near the Tech campus. Jurors found that the state should have issued more timely campus warnings after Cho shot two in the dormitory. The jury awarded the families $4 million each. The trial judge later reduced the award to $100,000 each, the state cap on damages.
The trial focused on the time between the dorm shootings, shortly after 7 a.m., and the killings at Norris Hall, shortly before 10 a.m. A campus-wide email at 9:50 a.m. warned of a gunman on campus and advised students to remain inside. By then, Cho had chained the Norris Hall doors and killed the victims.
The Petersons and the Prydes are the only families of Tech victims who did not join in an $11 million settlement. Their attorneys have shielded the families from the media, but they have said they were intent on holding university officials accountable for their actions on April 16, 2007.
The state argued that law enforcement officials believed the first shootings were targeted, the result of a domestic dispute, and they concluded the larger campus was not at risk. The justices concluded that university officials acted properly.
The state was the only defendant at trial. In a statement, Tech President Charles Steger, who has announced his retirement, extended his gratitude to state attorneys who argued the appeal. Virginia Tech's statement said the ruling "can never reverse the loss of lives nor the pain experienced by so many families and friends of victims of one person."
Andrew Goddard, whose son Colin was wounded at Tech, said he found the ruling upsetting, and he wondered whether universities would see an opening to relax safety measures.
"I think it certainly takes the pressure off universities," he wrote in an email to The Associated Press. "I would hope that all future freshman orientations clearly spell out that, despite all the policy changes and advanced notification systems, the university actually has no 'duty' to use them. Let's see how parents react to that."
Steve Szkotak can be reached on Twitter at http://twitter.com/sszkotakap .
Also on HuffPost:
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/12/oikos-university-shooting-one-goh_n_1419649.html">One Goh, Man Charged In Shooting Spree At Oikos University, Apologizes During TV Interview</a> PHOTO: A memorial at the entrance of Oikos University is shown in Oakland, Calif., Monday, April 23, 2012. Some students and staff members have arrived to resume class at Oikus University, the small California Christian college where seven people were shot to death. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)
Amy Bishop - University of Alabama
FILE - This Feb. 13, 2010, file booking photo provided by the Huntsville, Ala., Police Department shows college professor Amy Bishop, sentenced to life in prison for capital murder in the Feb. 12, 2010 shooting deaths of three faculty members at the University of Alabama in Huntsville. Court documents filed by Bishops lawyer in Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham, Mass., Monday, Oct. 1, 2012 say she wants to go on trial in the 1986 death of her brother in Massachusetts. The district attorney decided not to move forward with the murder indictment against Bishop because in that case after she received the life sentence in the Alabama case. (AP Photo/Huntsville Police Department, File)
Texas A&M Shooting: Gunman, Officer And Civilian Dead In College Station Shooting
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/13/texas-am-shooting-college-station_n_1773387.html">Texas A&M Shooting: Gunman, Officer And Civilian Dead In College Station Shooting</a> In this Aug. 13, 2012 photo provided by Rigo Cisneros, an officer takes cover, center, behind a vehicle during a shooting at a house in College Station, Texas, near Texas A&M University. Brazos County constable Brian Bachmann, a veteran of 19 years, was making what was supposed to be a routine house call to serve an eviction notice at the property when the recipient, Thomas Alton Caffall, opened fire and shots were exchanged. Bachmann, Caffall and another man were killed by the gunfire. (AP Photo/Rigo Cisneros)
CASPER COLLEGE SHOOTING
Police investigate a homicide at Casper College on Friday morning, Nov. 30, 2012, in Casper, Wyo. At least one person was killed and another was wounded Friday in an attack at Casper College, a community college in central Wyoming. (AP Photo/Casper Star-Tribune, Alan Rogers)
Hampton University Shooting: Former Student Shot Two, Turned Gun On Himself
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/04/26/hampton-university-shooti_n_191574.html">AP:</a> A former Hampton University student armed with three guns followed a pizza delivery man into the student's former dorm early Sunday, shot the delivery man and a dorm monitor, then turned the gun on himself, university officials said. All three survived. No current students were injured and both victims and the alleged shooter were expected to recover. Officials could offer no motive for the shooting.
USC Halloween Shooting
<a href="http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/11/01/us-usa-university-shooting-idUSBRE8A01E920121101">Reuters</a>: A gunman opened fire outside a large Halloween party at the University of Southern California and wounded four people in the second major shooting incident involving the urban Los Angeles institution this year, police said. PHOTO: University students walk to classes as Los Angeles police officers investigate a shooting that occurred Wed. night at a halloween party on the University of Southern California Campus in Los Angeles on Thursday, Nov. 1, 2012. Los Angeles police say two men apprehended after a Halloween shooting on the USC campus are still being interviewed and three of the four people wounded have been released from the hospital. (AP Photo/Nick Ut)
On Feb. 1, 2012, a <a href="http://www.wmctv.com/story/16660276/man-critically-wounded-in-shooing-at-lane-college">21-year-old man was shot in the head</a> on the Lane College campus in Jackson, TN. He was not a student, but was shot in a parking lot in front of the school gymnasium around 6 p.m. that evening.
Hazard Shooting: 2 Killed At Community College Shooting In Kentucky
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/15/hazard-college-shooting_n_2483771.html?utm_hp_ref=college">Hazard Shooting: 2 Killed At Community College Shooting In Kentucky</a>: Members of the Perry County Sheriff Office respond to the scene at Hazard Community College on Tuesday night, Jan. 15, 2013, after a shooting at the school in Hazard, Ky. Authorities say two people were shot and killed and a teen was wounded in the parking lot of the eastern Kentucky community college. (AP Photo/The Ashland Daily Independent, Joshua Ball)
Stevens Institute of Business and Arts in St. Louis
Police respond to the report of a shooting at Stevens Institute of Business and Arts on Washington Avenue in St. Louis on Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2013. A part-time student strode into the office of a longtime administrator at the school and shot the man in the chest, creating panic in the school before turning the gun on himself, police said. (AP Photo/St. Louis Post-Dispatch, David Carson)
Shooting Near UCF
A double shooting <a href="http://knightnews.com/2013/01/suspect-named-in-double-shooting-at-campus-crossing-near-ucf/">took place near</a> the University of Central Florida campus at the Campus Crossing Apartment complex in January 2013.
Pennsylvania College of Technology
In early January, <a href="http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2013/01/person_shot_to_death_near_penn.html">PennLive.com reported</a> the Pennsylvania College of Technology issued an email alert after an individual was shot to death close to campus.
Lone Star College - North Harris Campus
Multiple people were <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/22/lone-star-college-shooting_n_2527806.html" target="_blank">injured on Jan. 22, 2013 in a shooting</a> on the Lone Star College North Harris campus in Texas.
Morehouse College Student Shot After Basketball Game
<a href="http://www.accessnorthga.com/detail.php?n=257892">The AP reported on Feb. 2, 2013</a>: <blockquote>A Morehouse College student has been hospitalized after being shot over a pick-up basketball game. Morehouse Spokeswoman Elise Durham said the shooting happened at Samuel A. Archer Hall. Police spokesman John Chafee says officers responded to a report of a shooting on the campus and turned the investigation over to Morehouse campus police. Durham says four shots were fired and the unidentified student is in stable condition at Grady Memorial Hospital. </blockquote> Two of the people suspected in the shooting are believed to be students at the Atlanta University Center, according to the AP.
Indian River State College - Feb. 7
On Feb. 7, a student was shot in the parking lot of a training complex near the main campus of Indian River State College in Fort Pierce, Fla. <a href="http://www.wptv.com/dpp/news/region_st_lucie_county/fort_pierce/indian-river-state-college-police-training-facility-shooting-reported#ixzz2KKMG1ISy">WPTV reports</a>: <blockquote>A female student at Indian River State College was shot and injured as a gunman and police traded fire Thursday in the parking lot of the college’s campus, a college spokeswoman said. The student was injured as police converged on the armed man in the parking lot of the Treasure Coast Public Safety Complex on the college’s campus at 4600 Kirby Loop Road in Fort Pierce.</blockquote>
Florida Atlantic University - Feb. 8
WPTV <a href="http://www.wptv.com/dpp/news/region_s_palm_beach_county/boca_raton/fau-shooting-report-florida-atlantic-university-shooting-reported-on-school-campus#ixzz2KKGIzlWw">reported one person was shot</a> at Florida Atlantic University on Feb. 8, prompting an evacuation of the campus.
University of Maryland murder-suicide near campus
Police said Dayvon Green<a href="http://collegepark.patch.com/articles/umd-wasn-t-aware-of-shooter-s-mental-illness"> lit a fire in the basement </a>of a house he shared with two roommates. When the roommates came outside, he shot at both them before killing himself. One roommate died, the other survived, and it was later found out that Green had a mental disorder.
Coastal Carolina University
A shooting took place at a university residence hall at Coastal Carolina University on Feb. 26, <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/26/coastal-carolina-shooting_n_2769939.html">Reuters reported</a>. One person <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/27/coastal-carolina-shooting_n_2770909.html?utm_hp_ref=college">was killed</a>.
New River Community College
<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/04/12/new-river-valley-mall-shooting_n_3071919.html?utm_hp_ref=college&ir=College" target="_blank">The Associated Press reported</a> on April 12: <blockquote>CHRISTIANSBURG, Va. -- A man shot two women at a mall branch of a community college in Virginia Friday before he was subdued by police, a city official said. One of the victims was airlifted to a hospital and the other was taken by ambulance for treatment, said Christianburg city spokeswoman Becky Wilbur. Their conditions and identities were not immediately available.</blockquote>
Elizabeth City State University (2)
Student shot near dorm at Elizabeth City State University, <a href="http://www.fox43tv.com/dpps/news/local/shooting-locks-down-ecsu_5958042" target="_blank">WAVY reported</a> on April 13, 2013: <blockquote>A shooting at Elizabeth City State University Saturday night put the campus on lock down. At a news conference today, the ECSU Police Chief Sam Beamon confirmed he spoke with a 23-year-old named Jake (we will not release his last name) and he is back on campus and was shot once in the right thigh. Beamon confirms Jake was shot outside Butler Hall, a university dormitory hall, late Saturday night.</blockquote> This was the second shooting on the ECSU campus within a week.