PHILADELPHIA -- PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Police must get a warrant before using GPS to track a suspect's vehicle, a federal appeals court has ruled, throwing out a cache of evidence against three brothers charged in a wave of pharmacy burglaries and going beyond a Supreme Court ruling that left open the question of whether judges have to approve of the high-tech surveillance.
State police investigating the pharmacy burglaries were making progress in 2010 when they found tools, gloves and a ski mask in a search of suspect Harry Katzin's van.
The electrician said they were merely tools of his trade, and police let him go. But police, working with the FBI, soon put a GPS device under his bumper and closed in on the van after another burglary. They found Katzin and his two brothers inside, along with a large stash of pills, cash and other store property.
Three years later, the evidence has been tossed out after the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court called the GPS tracking an illegal search. The Katzins, who have pleaded not guilty, are free on bail.
The Supreme Court ruled in January 2012 that GPS tracking amounts to a police search, but left open the question of whether such searches require warrants. The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court said they do, unless there's an imminent danger.
Judge Joseph A. Greenaway wrote in a 2-1 opinion for the court last month that a GPS tracker is different than human surveillance because "it creates a continuous police presence" meant to discover future evidence.
"This case in our view is very significant," said lawyer Catherine Crump, who argued on behalf of the American Civil Liberties Union. "Where people go can reveal a great deal about them, from who their friends are, to what their daily routine is ...to what doctors they visit. All of that information, especially when considered together, contains a detailed portrait of someone's life."
The Justice Department is weighing an appeal, according to Assistant U.S. Attorney Robert Zauzmer. He had argued that police acted in good faith before the ruling from the Supreme Court. And one of the three judges agreed the evidence should not be suppressed for that reason.
The Katzins — Harry, Michael and Mark — allegedly sold prescription drugs from the house they lived in across from a public school. A police raid turned up $28,000 worth of OxyContin, Xanax, Ritalin, morphine and amphetamines at the house, Zauzmer wrote last year in opposing bail, when he called the evidence "overwhelming."
One law enforcement expert agreed, but said that evidence found during the investigation before the GPS was attached should have been used as probable cause to get a warrant.
"The rule of thumb is, if you have time to get a warrant, get a warrant," said Vernon Herron, a former Maryland State Police commander who now works as a senior policy analyst at the Center for Health and Homeland Security, part of the University of Maryland.
Police used GPS devices during his tenure, but they could only dream of the technology available today, when police can follow someone's every move from a laptop, Herron said.
U.S. District Judge Gene Pratter first ordered the evidence in the Katzins' case suppressed last year, writing that the GPS device recorded information "that investigators could have observed by conducting physical surveillance."
But police surveillance is costly, and therefore subject to built-in limitations, Crump said. Cheap GPS devices, on the other hand, present no such barrier.
"When we started out, the Supreme Court hadn't weighed in... and the majority of the law was actually contrary to our position," said Mark Katzin's lawyer, Rocco Cipparone, who argued the defense case. "My hope is that the government won't (appeal)."
Also on HuffPost:
Bill de Blasio, New York
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio sits on stage during the swearing in ceremony for New York City's 42nd police commissioner William Bratton at One Police Plaza on January 2, 2014 in New York City. (Photo by Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
Eric Garcetti, Los Angeles (D)
Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti speaks in front of city hall after being sworn in, Sunday, June 30, 2013, in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill)
Rahm Emanuel, Chicago (D)
Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel speaks to members of the Safe Passage program during a training session at Chicago State University in Chicago, Wednesday, Aug. 21, 2013. (AP Photo/Scott Eisen)
Annise Parker, Houston (D)
President Barack Obama, right, meets with Houston Mayor Annise Parker during his arrival at Ellington Airport, Friday, March, 9, 2012, in Houston. (AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais)
Michael Nutter, Philadelphia (D)
Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter speaks about ways to reduce US murder and gun violence rates and other issues affecting urban communities at the National Press Club in Washington, DC, September 26, 2013. (SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images)
Greg Stanton, Phoenix (D)
Phoenix Mayor Greg Stanton speaks at a press conference to introduce Brittney Griner (not pictured) of the Phoenix Mercury at U.S. Airways Center on April 20, 2013 in Phoenix, Arizona. (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)
Julian Castro, San Antonio (D)
San Antonio, Texas Mayor Julian Castro testifies on Capitol Hill in Washington, Tuesday, Feb. 5, 2013, before the House Judiciary Committee hearing on America's Immigration System: Opportunities for Legal Immigration and Enforcement of Laws against Illegal Immigration. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh)
Todd Gloria, San Diego (D)
Interim San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria leaves City Hall Friday Aug. 30, 2013, after inspecting his new office in San Diego. Gloria assumed the role at 5 p.m. PDT, when Bob Filner's resignation took effect. Filner resigned amid numerous complaints of sexual harassment.(AP Photo/Elliot Spagat)
Mike Rawlings, Dallas (D)
U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius, right, with Dallas Mayor Mike Rawlings, left, discusses the implementation of the federal health care overhaul in Dallas, Texas, on Thursday, September 26, 2013. (AP Photo/Nomaan Merchant)
Chuck Reed, San Jose (D)
This April 22, 2011 file photo shows San Jose Mayor Chuck Reed speaking during the 8th Annual CEO Summit at IBM offices in San Jose, Calif. (AP Photo/Paul Sakuma, File)
Lee Leffingwell, Austin (D)
Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius, left, leads a meeting with Austin, Texas, Mayor Lee Leffingwell, second from left, and City Manager Marc Ott, right, and others at City Hall in Austin, Texas, on Thursday, Aug. 8, 2013. (AP Photo/Austin American-Statesman, Jay Janner)
Alvin Brown, Jacksonville (D)
Jacksonville mayor Alvin Brown speaks to the media during the Road to Daytona Fueled By Sunoco Tour stop at City Hall on February 12, 2013 in Jacksonville, Florida. (Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images for NASCAR)
Greg Ballard, Indianapolis (R)
Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard talks the plans for the city to bid for the NFL football's 2018 Super Bowl as Allison Melangton, left, chair the 2018 Super Bowl Bid Committee, watches during an announcement in front of the downtown skyline in Indianapolis, Friday, Aug. 30, 2013. (AP Photo/Michael Conroy)
Ed Lee, San Francisco (D)
San Francisco Mayor Ed Lee speaks to reporters during a news conference after Asiana Flight 214 crashed at San Francisco International Airport in San Francisco, Saturday, July 6, 2013. (AP Photo/Darryl Bush)
Michael Coleman, Columbus (D)
Mayor Michael Coleman of Columbus, Ohio speaks to members of the media outside the West Wing during a news briefing after a meeting with President Barack Obama at the White House December 12, 2012 in Washington, D.C. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Betsy Price, Fort Worth (R)
Fort Worth Mayor Betsy Price looks on during a press conference before the start of the 2013 Mayor's Cup on July 26, 2013 at Texas Motor Speedway in Fort Worth, Texas. (Photo by Cooper Neill/Getty Images for Texas Motor Speedway)
Mike Duggan, Detroit (D)
Mike Duggan celebrates his election as the new mayor of Detroit at a victory party at the Renaissance Center November 5, 2013 in Detroit, Michigan. (Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images)
Patsy Kinsey, Charlotte (D)
John Cook, El Paso (D)
El Paso Mayor John Cook, right, presents a report that says Ft. Bliss has a $6 billion dollar economic impact from automatic budget cuts during a news conference Friday, March 8, 2013 in El Paso, Texas. (AP Photo/Juan Carlos Llorca)
A.C. Wharton, Memphis (D)
Memphis Mayor AC Wharton encourages Memphians to sign up for the Affordable Care Act during a rally at the Central Library in Memphis, Tenn. Monday, Sept. 30, 2013. (AP Photo/The Commercial Appeal, Jim Weber)