Huffpost Entertainment

'Sound Of Music' Review: What Worked And What Didn't

Posted: Updated:
THE SOUND OF MUSIC LIVE! -- Pictured: (l-r) Carrie Underwood as Maria, Sophia Ann Caruso as Brigitta -- (Photo by: Will Hart/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images) | NBC via Getty Images

NEW YORK (AP) — Whew, that was nerve-wracking, right? All those kids and staircases, pillow fights, candles and dancing. But somehow the cast and crew of NBC's three-hour live telecast of "The Sound of Music" pulled it off Thursday night with only a trodden-on dress, some inconsistent sound levels and a flubbed few words.

This was the first time in more than a half-century since a broadcast network dared to mount a full-scale musical for live TV and there seemed to be danger everywhere, making it impossible to stop watching in case one of the von Trapp kids tumbled into a fountain or a camera accidentally exploded. But it was all whiskers on kittens and warm woolen mittens, for the most part.

The only real problem was the real reason most people tuned in: Carrie Underwood, an "American Idol" winner and country music star, sang well as Maria but her acting inexperience was laid bare. She had zero chemistry with her love interest and lacked any intensity or shading. Deer in headlights have emoted more. How do you solve a problem like Maria, indeed.

Underwood was done no favors by being surrounded by some Broadway veterans — Christian Borle, Laura Benanti and Audra McDonald, especially — who thrive under the lights and pressure. This is what these Tony Award winners do for a living and it showed. Underwood would never have gotten through the audition process if this was a regular Broadway musical. Her co-stars overpowered her at every turn. It was like watching a Nissan Sentra try to drag race with a pack of Bugatti Veyrons.

Full credit goes to Underwood for trying, though. She was not just dancing and singing live in front of millions in a medium she is a novice at, but she also was stepping into the role made famous by Julie Andrews in the 1965 film. As if that wasn't enough, it was also only a few hours after the death of Nelson Mandela. Theater lovers mocked her on Twitter but the only reason we got to see this Rodgers and Hammerstein masterpiece on TV was Underwood. No one is about to build a live network musical around a Broadway star, alas.

Viewers who tuned in hoping to catch the film version may have been surprised at what was broadcast from a Long Island soundstage. This show was based on the stage original, penned as a vehicle for Mary Martin, not the Andrews film. It includes several songs that were left out of the movie — "No Way to Stop It" and "How Can Love Survive" — and is darker, with more Nazis. Both have the timeless tunes "My Favorite Things," ''Do-Re-Mi," ''Sixteen Going on Seventeen," ''The Sound of Music" and "Climb Every Mountain."

The directors — Tony-nominated director and choreographer Rob Ashford and Emmy-nominated "Saturday Night Live" and "30 Rock" director-producer Beth McCarthy-Miller — used all six sets efficiently and the dozen cameras worked hard, catching close-ups as well as sweeping shots. But it was often strangely lifeless, with the crack and zing of being live rarely transmitting through the screen.

It was supposed to be spectacular, appointment TV in this era of DVRs and binge watching. It's unclear if this was the breakthrough that will start a whole new musical revolution. What it really turned out to be was an advertisement for Broadway (smart shows currently running like "Wicked" and "Rogers + Hammerstein's Cinderella" bought commercials) and the skills that veterans of the stage can bring.

Borle was arch and wonderfully slimy as Max, Benanti was glamorously witty as Elsa, and McDonald was a majestic Mother Abbess. Michael Campayno as Rolf was a natural though he's still in drama school and Ariane Rinehart was a winning Liesl. Stephen Moyer, who is primarily known for his work on HBO's "True Blood," was a particularly stern Captain and more than a few people watching would probably have liked him to ditch the nun drop-out and stay with Benanti.

But Carrie Underwood was the star and she gets her man in the end. And, ultimately, it was Underwood who got us to even tune in on Thursday. Yet it was Borle, Benanti and McDonald who showed the world how to hold a moonbeam in your hand.


Follow Mark Kennedy on Twitter at

Around the Web

“The Sound of Music Live” TV review on NBC | Variety

The Sound of Music Live!: TV Review - The Hollywood Reporter

'The Sound of Music Live!' review: NBC does its best to top 1965 ...

'Sound of Music Live!' Review: The Hills Are Barely Alive

'The Sound Of Music Live' Review — Carrie Underwood SO GOOD ...

TV Review: Broadway Wins in Live 'Sound of Music' - ABC News

'The Sound of Music Live!' Review, Recap: Top 10 Highlights | HEAVY

Review: Audra McDonald overshadows Carrie Underwood in ...

'The Sound of Music Live' Review: NBC Remake Critics, Reception ...

'The Sound of Music Live!' Review - : Pop Of Culture

The Harsh 'Sound of Music'

'The Sound of Music Live!' review: NBC does its best to top 1965 classic with ...

Carrie Underwood 'Sound of Music' review: She sings well but falls short as ...

The Sound Of Music Live!

Review Roundup - NBC's SOUND OF MUSIC LIVE! All the Reviews!

'The Sound of Music': Carrie Underwood on tonight's live show and hate tweets ...

'The Sound Of Music': Miranda Lambert & More React On Twitter

Review: NBC's 'The Sound of Music Live': An impossible climb after all

Review: Audra McDonald overshadows Carrie Underwood in 'Sound of Music Live'

Carrie Underwood & 'The Sound of Music Live': What Reviewers Say