Huffpost Politics

Florida Governor Rick Scott Using Bad Estimates -- Again (UPDATED)

Posted: Updated:
Print Article
MIAMI, FL - AUGUST 20: Florida Governor Rick Scott speaks with the media after holding a Florida Cabinet at the Miami-Dade College Wolfson Campus Auditorium on August 20, 2013 in Miami, Florida. The governor released a press release yesterday indicating he has privacy concerns surrounding the Obama Administrations use of taxpayer-funded organizers called 'Navigators' to sign up Floridians on federal health exchanges. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images) | Getty

A kerfluffle last January over the use of inaccurate estimates apparently hasn't stopped Florida Governor Rick Scott (R) from doing it again.

A state-wide sales tax holiday proposal has been stalled after it was discovered Scott decided not to use recent estimates he'd been given in favor of old, inflated savings calculations.

Scott claimed in a statement that a 15-day tax holiday on hurricane readiness supplies would save Floridians $20 million. But according to the Florida Current, that number was gleaned from an estimate made all the way back in 2007 -- and Scott had been given a new, updated -- and less generous -- estimate by the state's Office of Economic and Demographic Research at a meeting in November.

The updated estimate Scott was given but chose not to use or promote was much, much lower. Reports the Current:

At their Nov. 20 meeting, the economists estimated a 12-day hurricane preparedness sales tax holiday would save shoppers between $1.2 million and $12.9 million. A midrange estimate put the savings at $3.8 million. Even using the highest estimate and accounting for the three extra days in Scott’s plan, there’s a discrepancy between Scott’s numbers and the up-to-date estimate. ...It’s unclear why Scott used an old estimate to push for the 15-day sales tax holiday.

According to the Current, Scott used other numbers given during the November meeting to promote a sales tax reduction on commercial properties. Read the full story at

While it's expected the hurricane tax break will be only temporarily derailed, it's not the first time the governor has used bad estimates despite the advice of staff. A year ago, email records obtained by WUSF showed that Scott continued to use inaccurate cost estimates for the expansion of Medicaid in the state despite messages from Florida's chief economist warning Scott's staff that the figures were wrong.

UPDATE: 3:00 p.m.: The Florida Current has updated their article from early this morning with comment from Scott's press secretary, Jackie Schutz, who also contacted The Huffington Post.

Schutz said Scott used the older number because the 2007 analysis included additional items that are not part of the current proposal. The Current notes, however, that the items listed in the administration's January press release are the same as those listed on documents for the analysts' November estimate. The administration updated the online version of the press release on Thursday.

The full list of items that Scott would include has been posted on his budget website.

Around the Web

Scott-O-Meter: Create over 700,000 jobs | PolitiFact Florida

Gov. Rick Scott says rail would have cost state taxpayers $1 billion ...

Florida Morning: Scott's hurricane sales tax estimate uses 2007 ...

Rick Scott Outed In Florida For Inaccurate Medicaid Numbers - Forbes

Rick Scott Not Favored By Florida Voters For A Second Term: Poll

Senate Panel Backs Hurricane-Tax Holiday « CBS Miami

Gov. Scott seeks 2-week hurricane supply tax holiday - WSVN-TV ...

Rick Scott meets $500 million tax-cut goal, revives hurricane tax ...

Florida Senate panel backs hurricane-tax holiday - Jacksonville ...

Rick Scott's hurricane supply sales tax holiday idea gains steam ...

Rick Scott Calls for Hurricane Supplies Sales Tax Holiday

Support Soars for Rick Scott's Sales-Tax Break on Hurricane Items

Gov. Scott's inflated hurricane preparedness sales tax holiday numbers put ...

Scott Proposes Hurricane Holiday; Tops $500 Million In Tax, Fee Cuts

Another sales-tax holiday, this one for appliances, is floated