Huffpost Media

Egyptian Judge Dismisses Videos In Trial Of Al Jazeera Journalists

Posted: Updated:
FAHMY AL JAZEERA
Al-Jazeera English producer Baher Mohamed, center left, bureau chief Mohammed Fahmy, center, and correspondent Peter Greste, second right, appear in court along with several other defendants during their trial on terror charges, in Cairo, Egypt, Monday, March 31, 2014. Two Al-Jazeera journalists on trial in Egypt have directly asked with the judge to release them. Australian Peter Greste and Canadian-Egyptian Mohammed Fahmy are among three journalists and 17 others who are facing terrorism-rela | ASSOCIATED PRESS

CAIRO (AP) — Egyptian prosecutors presented their first evidence Thursday to back up charges that three journalists from the Al-Jazeera satellite news network and their co-defendants participated in terrorism, playing to the court an assortment of videos found in their possession. They included news clips about an animal hospital with donkeys and horses, and another about Christian life in Egypt.

Defense lawyers — and even the judge — dismissed the videos as irrelevant, while defendants shouted from the dock that the trial was "a complete joke" and "an embarrassment to Egypt."

The three journalists, award-winning Australian correspondent Peter Greste, Canadian-Egyptian acting bureau chief Mohammed Fahmy and Egyptian Baher Mohammed, are accused of being part of a terrorist group and airing falsified footage intended to damage Egyptian national security. Egyptian authorities accuse Qatari-owned Al-Jazeera of providing a platform for the Muslim Brotherhood, which the government has branded a terrorist organization.

Al-Jazeera denies the claim, and the defendants deny being members of the Brotherhood, saying they were simply doing their job reporting on Egypt's political turmoil.

The case is part an unprecedented crackdown on the Brotherhood since the military's ouster in July of Islamist President Mohammed Morsi, who was a veteran figure from the group. Hundreds of Morsi supporters have been killed in crackdowns on protests and more than 16,000 have been arrested. The three journalists, who work for Al-Jazeera's English-language channel, were arrested Dec. 29 when police raided a Cairo hotel room they were using as an office.

"This is a politicized trial and a politicized judge," Fahmy shouted from the courtroom cage where defendants are traditionally held during trials. He said prosecutors had told him privately that he and his co-defendants "are paying the price" for tensions between Egypt and Qatar.

"I want to get out of this place! ... I am going to expose all of this!" he shouted. "There are crimes against humanity taking place. Nothing is right in this system."

Besides the three journalists, 17 others are charged in the case, mostly students not connected to Al-Jazeera. Only five of the students are present for the trial, with the rest on trial in absentia.

In previous sessions, prosecutors have said they would present video from the defendants showing they intended to harm national security. The prosecution has said it will present further video evidence including Al-Jazeera coverage of the crackdown on Islamists that it claims was falsified to destabilize Egypt and fuel support of the Brotherhood by showing Egypt as thrown into "civil war."

Thursday's was the first session in which any video was shown — but none of it appeared to have any connection to terrorism, and none was Al-Jazeera footage. Prosecutors said the material was found on the journalists' or students' flash drives and computers.

The videos included clips from Greste's BBC news documentary on Somalia called "Land of Bandits," for which he won a 2011 Peabody Award, and clips from a Kenya press conference. Before joining Al-Jazeera, Greste worked for the BBC in London, Bosnia, Kenya and South Africa.

Other footage, from the Sky News Arabia network, included short news reports on an animal hospital in southern Egypt with pictures of horses and donkeys and on a Christian Mass in Egypt in 2012.

"This clearly does not contain anything supporting the case," presiding judge Mohammed Nagi Shehata said after the footage was aired.

Khaled Abu Bakr, Fahmy's lawyer, mocked the prosecutors, contending they didn't even know the content of the footage before submitting it as evidence.

"The prosecutor clearly didn't see the videos," he said, reiterating his request to release the journalists on bail. "The world is watching."

The judge refused bail and adjourned the trial to April 22.

The prosecution made no comment about the videos, though the defense lawyers said it is expected to present more videos in later sessions.

"This is a complete joke!" Greste shouted from behind the bars.

"This is a joke. ... It's an embarrassment to Egypt," Fahmy said.

Shortly after the court session started Thursday, one of the student defendants, Khaled Abdel-Raouf, collapsed in the cage after he complained to the judge that he has been in hunger strike because of bad treatment and lack of medical care and because the prison was barring his visitors.

Separately, a military tribunal sentenced a conscript and three people working for news website Rassd to one to three years in prison on charges related to leaked video clips of presidential candidate and former military chief Field Marshal Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi. The tribunal tried two defendants in absentia and acquitted the website's founder.

Meanwhile, a bomb thrown under a police car in a busy square west of Cairo exploded Thursday night, wounding a police officer's leg, Egypt's Interior Ministry spokesman Hani Abdel-Latif said. Violence has spread across the country since Morsi ouster as the government intensifies its campaign against the Brotherhood and his supporters.

Around the Web

Egypt judge dismisses videos in Al-Jazeera trial

Abdullah al-Shami: 77 days on hunger strike

Egypt arrests journalist said to work for Al Jazeera – agency

Egypt must end 'vindictive' detention of Al Jazeera journalists