iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alan Singer

GET UPDATES FROM Alan Singer
 

Tomahawks and Teachers

Posted: 04/01/2011 12:52 pm

In his address to the nation on Monday, March 28, President Obama justified the bombing of Libya as a defense of vital national interests in the region and as part of the traditional role of the United States as the world's primary defender of global security and advocate for human freedom. He also assured the American people that the military actions would be temporary and that the U.S. would turn over military operations to its allies in NATO.

Opinions on the bombing of Libya and of Obama's promise that the U.S. actions are temporary will vary, but what was undeniably missing from the speech was any discussion of the cost of the new war. Given the rising costs of prolonged military ventures in Iraq and Afghanistan, which were also supposed to be temporary but have turned out to be a decade long, the American people have a right to be suspicious. This is especially the case given the slumping national economy, persistent unemployment, and threatened new rounds of teacher lay-offs across the nation.

On March 15, more than 30,000 pink slips were mailed to teachers in California, including 2,800 in the Bay Area, according to the California Teachers Association. Detroit, Michigan will have to close 70 of its 142 schools. In Providence, Rhode Island layoff notices were sent to every single teacher. In New York City, Mayor Bloomberg projects over 4,500 teacher layoffs at the end of the school year.

Between March 19 and March 28 alone the United States spent approximately $550 million on military operations in Libya, mostly on Tomahawk missiles. "Future costs are highly uncertain," said Commander Kathleen Kesler, a Pentagon spokeswoman. However, she confirmed the U.S. would likely spend another $40 million over the next several weeks. As of Monday, March 28, U.S. warships had fired nearly 200 Tomahawk land attack cruise missiles, which cost almost $1.5 million each. In addition, U.S. aircraft had dropped 455 precision-guided bombs. Those weapons vary in price, but according to an Air Force fact sheet, cost roughly $22,000 each. The government's assessment does not include the $30 million cost of a F-15E Strike Eagle fighter that crashed in Libya.

In New York State, the average starting salary for a new teacher is $37,321 a year and the overall average salary for teachers is $57,354. That means that each Tomahawk missile dropped on Libya costs the equivalent of the annual salary of forty new New York State teachers or twenty-six experienced teachers. The 200 Tomahawk missiles were worth 8,000 new teachers or 5,200 experienced teachers. In states like North Dakota, where teacher salaries are much lower, those Tomahawks would have bought at least a third more teachers.

The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have lasted much longer and are much more expensive. In March 2003 Vice President Dick Cheney estimated U.S. involvement in Iraq would last two years and cost approximately $100 billion (or 27,000 new New York State teachers). As of February 2010, the official estimate is that the war in Iraq has cost a $700 billion (190,000 new New York State teachers), however Nobel Prize wining economist Joseph Stiglitz puts the real total cost of the war in Iraq alone at $3 trillion or the equivalent of 810,000 new New York State teachers. Using Stiglitz's estimates, the combined cost of Iraq and Afghanistan approaches $5 trillion or well over a million new New York State teachers.

Before Presidents try to sell us a new war, they should at least tell us the cost, especially when firing one lowly Tomahawk missile means laying-off forty teachers.

 
 
 
FOLLOW EDUCATION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 39
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
10:14 AM on 05/04/2011
550 milloin dollars spent on military, but none spent to help save the school systems. atleast 4,500 teachers will be laid off by the end of the school year, but its obvious that the government doesnt care. they rather waste money on a "temporary help effort" in another country rather than help the school systems in dire need in this country. all together, more than 3 trillion dollars has been estimated as the cost for the wars fought in Iraq and Afganistan, and not even half of that has been put into shcools to help save teachers.
11:21 PM on 05/03/2011
WOW! really we have money and we don't use it for what really counts. We use it to built things that we don't need we use it to destroy other places. What is the world coming to nowadays like serious some people have to open their eyes and do something bout this money issue. We have to lesrn how to divid our money and learn how to spend it. Honestly money is just a piece of paper like seriously people get killed for that little piece of paper. So paper is more precious than a life. I'm honestly afraid of what might happen in a few year or possible months for all us looking at what is happening in the world its like a movie but it doesn't end in 2 hours it goes on and on. We all have to find a solution even if it takes time but we really do need a solution.
09:43 PM on 05/01/2011
Its amazing how government officials explain that we temporarily attack Libya which is the exact cost of thousands of jobs, but what’s shocking is that they lied in public television about not having "sufficient funds" for jobs and teachers. How long is this going to happen and how long is it going to be for a American to have a job and not fight another world war because even in a high school students eyes it seems that its what America is going towards.
02:59 PM on 04/19/2011
I believe that obviously they are taking away from our education because they want to make it extremely hard for us to go to college and therefore the only path we'll have left is to join the military which is what they want. Next thing thats probably going to happen is that parents are going to have to pay for their children to be in highschool. Everything is about money, war, and oil now. Nobody cares about poor people and their education.
04:10 PM on 04/09/2011
Wow!, It's almost unbelievable how "Our Government" is putting Missiles and Bombs over teachers and education. If this continues at this pace, our next stop would be misery. Less teacher for students, less money for books and materials. In my country teachers do not produce oil, but at least they have a decent job. I feel so bad because our teachers don't sweat oil...
09:23 PM on 04/06/2011
President Obama' s eagerness of wanting water and oil is what made him bomb Libya, which is a country known for having oil.since the U.S. is bringing cars from other countries to sell they need more oil to be produce so it can supply those vehicle's.Also so he can then make the oil private so people can pay more money for it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larri Brady McKnight
12:17 PM on 04/21/2011
I notice that you didn't mention's GWB's war in Iraq as a play for oil. It's well known that Iraq had no part in 9/11, and still we went. Secondly, oil companies are already private corporations, and making record profits on the backs of American's and others. The reason that American's import cars from other countries, is that American's WANT those cars, and prefer them over American made cars. That is the way the Free market and Capitalism works. Did you miss that part of Civics Class? American's don't fully support either oil economy nor research into alternative fuels. We'd rather buy gas guzzlers and complain about gas prices.
11:54 PM on 04/05/2011
If any activity taking place in Libya, according to the president, is of traditional courtesy to take the responsibility as "the world's primary defender of global security", then why is exaggerating the amount of expensive artillery necessary? It sounds like a contradiction to me. I remember watching the coverage on the 'reinforcement' implementing a no-fly zone on Libya,and jokingly thought about each missile as a student's potential education literally wasted at the hands of our "overseers". It's also baffling to hear that teachers' lay-offs are on account of insufficient resources, when clearly they are instead used for sanctions on the Qadhafi regime, executed by the most extreme measures possible.
11:33 PM on 04/05/2011
Reading this article left me speechless. I truly believe that our main issue is that the U.S really has a problem in dividing the money to things that will benefit us in the long shot. What are we getting out of war. I know, destruction, chaos, and debt. And then we wonder why our economy is in danger. The money spent on war should be put on the teachers, the people who help shape our future. I agree with the fact that it's not right that the government doesn't state the real usage of the money. Thats insane how one just one Tomahawk missile is equivalent to 40 new teacher's salaries. Like I said speechless.
10:45 PM on 04/05/2011
wow. The world we live in is just horrible. Teachers are being laid off because the money that they should be recieving is being used for bombs. It is just horrible that instead of just keeping the teachers which is less expensive, we choose to go to war which is much more expensive. The worst part of it all is that its not to help another country, but for a self gain(profit).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:24 PM on 04/05/2011
We have all the money, all this power, yet we as a country are decadent in the form of education. For every missile that was launched to Libya, might as well been a big middle finger to the education and the jobs of thousands of teachers, I don't understand why they didn't just have Donald Trump just fire them as opposed to doing it in a indirect manner. We are exploited daily, no one who isn't educated in this sense doesn't care, but it effects them regardless. We have to see this through, it can't be justified for one second that billions of dollars are going to redundant matters, and not the one thing that creates opportunities for millions of our people, and that one thing has been cut off so many times.
08:48 PM on 04/05/2011
What does anyone expect from our politicians, we as Americans whether we know it or not is part of a military force we are the Roman Empire of the modern age with the military proficiency of the Spartan Empire. So of course they’ll do what ever it takes to keep our military afloat above all else, even education. Just look at it like this, if a “Tomahawk missile costs the equivalent of the annual salary of forty new New York State teachers or twenty-six experienced teachers.” What else do you think politicians would do? Also why is it that Joseph Stiglitz is the only economist willing to say much debt we are in due to the wars, so what are the other economists calculating then.
08:32 PM on 04/05/2011
Wait let me get this right, the United States is spending $550 million on a military operation in Libya, but every time I turn on the news I hear another story about the United States being "broke" and the budget for education is being cut? Really?!?!?!?!?!?! the military is more important than the education of the children in this country. I'm afraid of what I continue to see, and hear about, teachers are being laid off for what exactly? Let me guess so the pay checks that were for them can go to the military. I figured it out teachers get fired so the military could afford new toys, and we could have those toys for a war that has nothing to do with the United States woohooooooo. Congrats Obama great way to mess up the country and the future of many children this deserves a round of applause.
07:47 PM on 04/05/2011
This is crazy I cant believe we are really letting this happen. The government is messing with our future and there is really no one with power on our side. Obama is not doing anything what happen to the "Hope" when he was running for elections. "President Obama justified the bombing of Libya as a defense of vital national interests in the region and as part of the traditional role of the United States as the world's primary defender of global security and advocate for human freedom." How do we have money to kill people in Libya and have money to make bombs but we don' have money for book, new computers and materials we need for our education. But we can layoff teachers the foundation of education without them who will teach us? and they are using our money the money we work for and depend on to survive. I honestly think the government doesn't want us to have knowledge they just want a bunch of dumb people so they can do what ever they want which is not fair. Is not fair the little kids growing up will have 50 other kids in one classroom and wont have the attention they need. Is not fair our clean money is being used for their nasty evil plans. But a revolution will be made soon. We wont let this happen for long.
04:31 AM on 04/05/2011
ambition and greed is distracting the government from realizing the reason we made it. We created our government to serve the people. it is true that the oil we will probably gain will benefit some americans, how ever, if the majority of money is being sent to fight for oil [once again], and they are laying off alot of americans from their jobs, then we will have oil but the prices will most likely remian expensive because sales wont have the succes rate it had before the prices hiked. so all of this is pointless and a waste of time.
04:13 AM on 04/05/2011
prd 3
i think that obama need to stop spending money on unnecessary things and start focusing more on whats important. starting a new war isn't a smart idea at all, especially if we havent yet ended the war that we are already in. starting a new war , means losing more money that we dont have. if we start a new war, this means there will be more budget cuts.

cutting teachers isnt a smart idea neither. the money he is trying to spend on dropping a bomb on another country, he can be using to pay teachers. we need more teachers. the population is growing , which means more people are enrolling into school. without having enough teachers, classrooms will be over populated and are students will not get the education they deserve.