iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alana Lea

GET UPDATES FROM Alana Lea
 

Climate Impact Day

Posted: 05/05/2012 1:12 pm

2012-05-05-ClimateDot2012.jpgI made my climate change dot out of the information I've discovered, slowly, painfully, over the last couple of years developing a reforestation project in Brazil, where I was born. There were so many things that just didn't fit together, until last week when I found the missing piece: deforestation and reforestation are both profitable. Climate change is just one of the costs of doing business, if you happen to be in the right business. Dow Chemical and Monsanto are.

So I put myself in their shoes to take a different perspective:

If you have a bad rap for your history creating Agent Orange, first of all, get rid of the stockpile. You could send it to South America and maybe people there would forget about it. Carnival and all. Or not. Maybe someday, someone would find it and figure out that it's an easy way to take out the rainforest without smoke being detected.

Once the trees are gone, you might as well sell your GMO soy and corn seed, and all the fertilizers it takes to grow them the (North) American way. Oh yeah. Cotton too. Lots of GMO cotton. It's a big country, you can really plant a lot of stuff there.

And business is all about partnerships, strategic alliances. So it would be a good idea to partner with some good guys, with well known names and stellar reputations to clean up any misgivings folks might have about you. Dow chose The Nature Conservancy (or maybe TNC chose Dow?), while Monsanto chose Conservation International.

Whoa, what do know? Those two organizations have big reforestation projects in the 93 percent deforested Atlantic Rainforest! What a great opportunity to help them with supplying all the seedlings they'll need for their billion tree initiative.

And since TNC/Dow were able to make arrangements with the state of Sao Paulo's Water Supply Managers (SABESP) to help supply trees for planting along the source of water for nearly nine million people, it's really good news for these guys. Not so good for the network of rural Brazilians who started nurseries to supply the demand organically, but those guys don't have good internet access or read English, so they're not going to figure this out for a long time.

And this is 2012, a year when all sorts of things are aligning nicely. The Dr. Seuss story The Lorax was made into a movie by Universal this year, and since they were green enough to know they ought to partner with BINGOs (Big International NGOs) who could plant trees for them, they chose TNC and CI to do the heavy lifting for them.

Isn't it amazing what you can learn from Google, if you just ask the right questions?

 
FOLLOW GREEN
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
03:04 AM on 05/06/2012
The subject of reforestation interests more than anything else, but I found this article too hard to understand.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
11:31 AM on 05/06/2012
Art, if you'd like to read the my blog over at http://www.changents.com/rainforesteco, you'll read the story behind all of this, telling you much more about the reforestation. That's the place needing our support - organic and permaculture reforestation.

I tried putting this into my last comment below but it was too long. It finishes the thoughts:

What we discovered though (as I joined forces with the organic tree growers in 2009), was that it was very difficult to sell their trees at a fair trade price because contracts were already tied up by the entities I've named. There are mandates in place for chemicals to be used in nurseries and in the field. The organic growers need support to stay in business, and supply the people who want their trees but struggle to pay for them at any price.

That's a story I can tell without getting snarky. I promise you, I will do what I can to heal and grow beyond the turmoil of emotions my encounters with TNC brought up, and write about it here. Thank you for being interested.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
11:58 PM on 05/14/2012
I tried writing something in the blog, and it posted twice. Hopeless computer skills. Very, very, very impressive and deep work. I have to go over this till I get it straight. Thanks for sending the link, but even moreso for your work!
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
04:57 PM on 05/15/2012
Alana, I'm groping for a proper way to connect. I'm not even sure I've figured out the blog. If I click on the Changents link you sent, I get to a page with people other than you. But if I cut and paste the link into my browser your program comes up. I'm confident I can get back to your blog and its many posts, but that will come eventually. Right now I'm just trying to respond to the streaming images with a long list of titled images. Just want you to know that my slowness has more to do with technical ineptitude than lack of interest. More soon.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
06:58 PM on 05/06/2012
I have written other blogs for the last few years as I learned about reforestation first hand. It appears I can't link it in here, but if you go to the website under my name, it will lead you through to my blog on Changents that tells much more of the reforestation story. I'll bring some of that info over here, since you're interested...
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
10:27 PM on 05/06/2012
Quite amazing. So see? I wasn't expecting to find someone who was doing EXACTLY what I've been posting about like a voice in the wilderness! It just illustrates how things come together through a spiritual power.

I can't help with money, but if an art piece can help, I might be able to contribute. I will caution, however, that I'm very centered on my own thing--I founded a remarkable nonprofit that got Wangari Maathai to visit and later kick off a tree-planting project for the community. But due to my inability to act politically, I fell afoul of the board. Now I am indeed focusing on the trees in my own backyard. I'm most definitely not a follower or a supporter. I cut wood and let the chips fall where they may. I am the program that I follow.

You have opened my eyes on the relative advantage of tree planting in the Tropics, but muddling around with my own trees in the Southwest will have repercussions for place, like yours, that I could never have predicted. Spirit works that way.

I am honored to make your acquaintance and learn about your perfect work!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Linus521
In wildness is the salvation of mankind
08:39 PM on 05/05/2012
According to the science of ecology, man can reforest an ecosystem once it's gone, but he cannot restore it. Man may never learn everything that is needed to re-create an ecosystem once it is gone. This is a magical secret that Earth fails to share.

All ecosystems are integrated, and they all have loops and feedbacks to the climate and the atmosphere, and they all, altogether create the very life zone of the Earth, her biosphere/ecosphere or life itself. Deforestation heats up and dries out the climate.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
11:44 AM on 05/06/2012
One of the things I observed in the process of working with the organic growers and rural NGOs in Brazil, was that while we can't reach 100% of what nature gave us, we can restore an incredible amount of life. When we create corridors between existing patches of untouched forest, protect those corridors from being trampled by cattle, and plant a diverse selection of the native species trees in those areas, the birds and wildlife will do most of the rest. Humans are needed for the first few years to make sure the young trees are not overtaken by grasses. But once they're established, the cycle of life giving life returns.

I saw young forests of 4-10 years that were flourishing after being planted in this manner. Have a look at the work of Willie Smits in Borneo to see what is possible when we work with Nature: http://www.ted.com/talks/willie_smits_restores_a_rainforest.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Linus521
In wildness is the salvation of mankind
01:55 PM on 05/06/2012
I am not saying, this isn't a positive for the environment and the Earth. I have planted many a native plant specie, native to my area. Many ecological sources state, man cannot restore an ecosystem. An ecosystem functions and cycles as one, whole organism, created by all its plant and animal biodiversity or native species, from microorganisms in the soil that keep the soil renewed, weaving through the strands in the web of life to trees, to top predators, like wolves and mountain lions.

Today, after eastern forests were in their second to fourth growths, we have more eastern forests than since the white Europeans arrived. The more diversity of both plant and animal biodiversity, the more stable and life giving the ecosystem. However, long ago countless species disappeared from these ecosystems, like the wood bison, the wolf, the mountain lion, elk, and many of the native birds to these forests fell extinct and our native chestnut tree died off. Many strands in this web of life have disappeared.

Also, old growth trees are larger than second, third growth. The trunks of 1,000 year old oak trees are as wide as a car! They say before the white man began doing away with these forests, a flying squirrel could reach the Mississippi without ever touching the ground.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
05:04 PM on 05/05/2012
Sorry about that Eric. It's the only way I've found to lighten up in the least while facing it all. It's like the reaction of laughing as you witness something painful. I'm still learning how to share this information without bursting into tears, because my real focus has been the planting of organic trees. Never intended to become an investigative reporter.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
03:08 AM on 05/06/2012
Planting organic trees is, arguably, the most important thing we can do to alleviate climate woes on Planet Earth. But I'm too old to understand the "humor" in your article. Slow to pick up too. Square. Real earnest. But I hope we'll hear from you again in a more straightforward way.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
11:25 AM on 05/06/2012
Art, thank you. I'm working to get underneath the rage, the pain and the tears to be able to tell others what we're seeing, without sounding like a lunatic. I'm getting there. I can write lovely straightforward pieces about the benefits of organic reforestation, and certainly will here since you seem interested.

But this part of the story, discovering the greenwashing and corruption has emerged one piece at a time since returning to the US last year. I've send info to other bloggers and reporters, asking for them to expose the truth. No one has. I just need people to understand that the Big International NGOs I've named, are partnered with the chemical companies who've not only created the herbicide known as Agent Orange, that has mysteriously turned up for use in the Amazon, as well as spread their GMO seed all over the Brazilian landscape, and made contracts that will keep them there for years. That I could build upon if need be, but I loathe to.

I vastly prefer to tell you the stories of the organic growers who dug deep into their own pockets, unsubsidized by anyone, to create native tree nurseries to fulfill the demand of their own state government, for billions of tree seedlings...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hikerguy22
This is your carbon footprint
04:55 PM on 05/05/2012
Does this information make Monsanto and Dow ,not so bad industries? I think not.
photo
Alana Lea
iGiveTrees www.igivetrees.com
05:35 PM on 05/05/2012
Of course not, and if my "slacker humor" led you to believe for a second that they are serving anything but themselves by doing this, let me clarify... Pay attention to greenwashing... Find out who corporate partners of big NGOs are by asking questions. There is so much information under our noses, while people don't access it. What do you think of big NGOs who take money from these sources and make it easy for them to move farther, faster?
11:59 AM on 05/11/2012
Hi, Alana. What is the benefit to TNC and Conservation International to partner with Dow and Monsanto? Is it that TNC and CI got major funding from them to reforest? Having worked in non-profit development for the earth in the past, I know corporate partnerships are a tricky thing, as non-profits long for big sources of money. But partnering with Dow and Monsanto is making a pact with the devil, so to speak. I say, there are better sources of income to be found and TNC and CI should know better.
04:43 PM on 05/05/2012
Interesting. However, the use of slacker irony detracts from the overall presentation of information.