Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Alex Castellanos

GET UPDATES FROM Alex Castellanos
 

Obama, the Marxist?

Posted: 03/24/11 06:53 PM ET

Since he debuted on the political stage with the keynote address at the 2004 Democratic Convention, Republicans have suspected that Barack Obama was a Marxist. It turns out they were right: He's Groucho.

In the 1930 film Animal Crackers, Groucho Marx, a comedic genius and wit, played Captain Jeffrey Spaulding. He sang a lyric called "Hello, I Must Be Going."

Hello, I must be going.
 I cannot stay, 
I came to say, 
I must be going.
 I'm glad I came
 but just the same, 
I must be going.

Through his brief career, our president has sung a similar tune. He has been for what he is against, too.

Obama was the candidate who supported "pay as you go budgeting." He is now the president who plans trillion-dollar a year deficits for the next decade. He spent a trillion dollars on health care and explained it was a strategy to save money. He deepened our commitment to war in Afghanistan while pledging to exit earlier. He supports American energy independence while limiting energy production. He has shunned earmarks while embracing 8,600 of them. In the same breath, he urges both costly economic stimulus and deficit reduction. He tells his party, "Democrats are not for a bigger government," as he prescribes a new federal pill for every ill.

Obama repeatedly said he did not want the government running the car industry -- as his government took over Chrysler and GM, fired the latter's CEO, and guaranteed their service contracts. He won election by attacking Hilary Clinton's plan to mandate health insurance coverage and John McCain's tax on Cadillac health plans. He was not long in office before he proposed both, himself. He slammed President Bush's tax cuts and the "tired and cynical philosophy," behind them. Then he extended those tax cuts. He said, "Lobbyists will not find a job in my White House," which was true, until they looked and did. And now, he confounds himself again as he confronts a president's most serious responsibility. Even as he sends Americans into harm's path, he is coming while going again.

In Libya, the president has embarked upon the war he says is not a war, announcing while getting in that our purpose is to get out. He says Gaddafi must go while the Chairman of his Joint Chiefs of Staff clarifies that is not our objective. This zigzagging serenade would impress even Captain Spaulding.

I've written before in these pages about the molten core of Barack Obama. He is not a false-hearted man. He is, however, an uncertain one. In his own eyes, as voiced in his poetic autobiography, Dreams From My Father, he is many men, the son of one race and also another. He is as much Harvard tea as Chicago grit. The dry dust of Kansas and the red soil of Kenya both mark his hands. But life has not yet hardened Obama to follow one star above all others. He remains a wanderer, a president in progress. With equal passion, his bright mind displays its capacity to defend and even adopt incompatible points of view. He has not yet learned that the man who defends everything defends nothing. And, eventually, becomes nothing. Obama remains unformed, an ever-changing president in pieces. Maturity has not yet found him. Our first black president is not yet an integrated man.

The original Groucho Marx enjoyed a decade of success hosting a game show called "You Bet Your Life." The new one, dangerously unknown, even to himself, is betting many lives, as well.

I'll stay a week or two, 
I'll stay the summer through,
 but I am telling you,
 I must be going.

Alex Castellanos is a Republican media consultant and a partner in the public affairs firm Purple Strategies.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 371
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
07:30 PM on 04/04/2011
I don't think that corporations should pay taxes... But the stock holders and owners should. But now A corporation should not have the same rights in court as an individual. An individuals rights should always take precedence over a corporations rights.A corporation should have no rights over an individual. It's a non-entity, its a thing.
07:09 PM on 04/04/2011
Christ never said bring me your rich and well fed... He said bring me your hungry,your sick and poor... What does the good American Christians say... Heck with the poor and let the hungry look through their garbage can... As a true Christian I must Vote the way Jesus would vote and If that makes me a Marxist then I don't mind being in the same club as Jesus.
06:01 PM on 04/25/2011
Sorry, Christ never said "bring me your hungry, your sick, your poor"... you're thinking about the poem on the Statute of Liberty. Christ stressed individual responsibility and individual salvation, not the collective Obama espouses.
07:02 PM on 04/04/2011
For the right wing GOP pounding the table, saying that this is a country built on Christian beliefs is a joke. The way the GOP vote is not the way Jesus Christ would want us to vote and all Christians know this. If we are a christian nation then we would vote for a system that would help us all and not put anyone in financial duress. Not have to ask if they can afford their medicine or go to the doctor. So if you are a right wing Christian then ask your self how Jesus would Vote and if he would fight it in court.... instead of paying attorneys to fight the new law, lets hire people to make it a better law and one that will work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cgin
01:19 AM on 03/28/2011
When you don’t have the facts, pound the table. What audacity this right wing amateur ideologue has to call out the president while conveniently ignoring the hell his cohorts put this nation through. One would think that after driving the nation into a ditch while drunk with malfeasance, one would be a bit less righteous and a little more humble. Instead of offering constructive proposals, they choose this childish tactic - which is nothing more than a deflection, to cover for the obvious lack of solutions, substance and vision. So, continuing throwing everything at POTUS and hoping stuff sticks, will again prove that the right wing ideology is indeed devoid of reflection, imagination and vision.
07:12 PM on 04/04/2011
But the GOP started the party and they were drunk for 8 years and their driving wasn't to hot either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patches12
09:24 PM on 03/27/2011
All I can say is WOW.. welcome and what a pleasant surprise... a truly conservative voice gets an article on the HuffPo

I look forward to more.. good work.. you've made several excellent points
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:44 PM on 03/27/2011
Strange that trying to fix the Republican clusterf**k left to him is somehow a bad thing. If the GOP stopped screwing over America's middle class and poor we would not be so deeply in the hole.

Now we have a Repunlican media consultant worried that Obama can't quickly correct many years of Republican screwups. If you don't like what happened to this nation, why did you sit idly by while the GOP created the mess?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:30 PM on 03/27/2011
Trying to fix would be commendable. O. is barely trying to do anything except complete the ruination caused by his predecessor & mentor, W.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:35 AM on 03/28/2011
The only people ever mentored by W. are his daughters both of whom have felony records in Texas and one of whom is in jeopardy of a life sentence under 3rd strike provisions which W. signed into law. Since Texas is full of prisons the law was needed to try and keep them full.

Obama's failure to immediately clean up the mess created by the GOP is not his fault. The GOP is determined to obstruct any measures that may succeed. They fully remember that their policies kept them out the majority for 4 decades. They are determined to avoid repeating that fate by making sure that no executive can repair the damage they cause this nation which they then blame on the persons who failed to stop them from causing the damage.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:24 PM on 03/27/2011
Red Herring article. Obama is a corporatist, just like Bush.
Dad of Marine
Army Vet and Latino Progressive - and proud of it
02:56 PM on 03/27/2011
Alex; did you get concurrence from Ileana Ros-Lehtinen and Rubio, and maybe the aunts and cousins of Elian Gonzalez.
Deftguy
I train people and rehabilitate dogs
12:41 PM on 03/27/2011
Alright Alex, you have had your say. Now go back to your Faux hole where you belong.

It's amazing how these GOP talking heads can speak in stereo with a single mouth. They talk out of both sides, and yet their policies lead us to the worst financial crises we have had since the depression. I have seen what their policies do, and all I can say is no thanks.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:31 PM on 03/27/2011
lol O. is cut from the SAME fabric.
12:24 PM on 03/27/2011
Some of Alex's criticisms of Obama sound like typical GOP rantings that don't place decisions in context. I'm thinking about health care in particular, although I also have other sharp criticisms about Obama's unending desire to please corporatists. But Alex's basic theme sounds valid: Obama hasn't really stood for anything but the unrelenting desire to mediate when mediation itself is proposed on a presumption of a false dichotomy, and by doing so, his only consistent theme is the resolution of political conflicts from a personal and philosophical distance. He is NOT standing by the commitments that he so eloquently stated in his campaign. He's abandoned them from the moment he was inaugurated.

It is Obama's desertion from his own stated political positions, so obvious to any casual follower, that caused the collapse of the grassroots Democratic movement during the 2010 political season, and left a wide opening for the emergence of fascism that we're now seeing in several states.

Because of Obama's abandoning of all of the things that he stood for, he's been a major failure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
petef59
my micro-bio is empty
07:45 PM on 03/27/2011
More like the collapse of his original voting base: a public so acclimated to instant gratification that they find everything less than 100% success from a political party that they cower at home or run to the next popular tea party.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:33 PM on 03/27/2011
How about success exceeding 0%? His ONLY success has been a becoming the WORST failure to ever occupy the White House.
photo
RedneckDem
The top 1% stole my made in china bootstraps
12:13 PM on 03/27/2011
Another neo-con trolling for money. Hopes the Koch bros will see his rants and sign him up. Conveniently leaves out the mess Obama inherited at every turn...
12:06 PM on 03/27/2011
In times or crisis...you have three options..fight...flight...or capitulate

Obama clearly does not fight. He has capitulated on major issues (public option; tax cuts; Gitmo, etc.)

Recently, he takes a number of vacations at the most inoppurtune times. His flight (um trip) to South America is a case in point.

The man does not fight. He does not have the backbone to fight the ongoing onslaught of corporate America. We pay taxes, but multinational corporations dont pay a dime? Are we serious? And now talk of a VAT tax? Listen, in 1904 we had a President who stared down corporate America and helped America become the world's preeminent nation. His name was Teddy Roosevelt- my favorite Republican President. Obama should either begin fighting for the working and middle class, or he should have the class to step aside and let the DEMS find a candidate who is NOT another corporate puppet. The Repubs should be thinking Teddy Roosevelt as well. The business is all good and regulation is all bad mantra is not going to work in this election.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
isis
I, Robot
09:06 AM on 03/27/2011
Democrats like pay as you go so get out of our way and stop threatening and blocking us. Let's get back to Clinton era taxes just as Obama says. And close the tax loop holes. People know who the jokers are in this regard.
09:15 PM on 03/27/2011
Fanned!
08:59 AM on 03/27/2011
No Castellanos, you look and act like a much better Groucho.
RobbieB
Learner, Intellect, Input, Strategic & Ideation.
07:00 AM on 03/27/2011
Right now I'm doing the Alex C simultaneous eye and head roll, you know where one of his eyes goes one way and his entire head the other... What Obama is doing is GOVERNING in the face of a highly organized, angry, obstructionist regressive party hell bent on his political destruction. And he's getting things done, mugh to the chagrin of Alex and his big-money friends. Sure, there's still room to accomplish more, but on margin, BO is doing fine... and he'll continue to do so until 2016.
07:57 AM on 03/27/2011
Yours is an interesting take on the situation. You say the President is governing in spite of the party that opposes him. In fact, he is supporting many, many of the things for which that party stands -- not the things for which our Democratic party stands. The President's positions on most things -- escalating the Afghan war, the Libyan war, tax cuts for the rich, jettisoning universality and the public option from health care (both were decisions made by him after meeting privately with the health care industry), financial reform written by lobbyists from Wall Street, keeping Gitmo open and maintaining the Bush/Cheney incarceration rules and tribunals, keeping BP in charge of our worst environmental disaster, etc. -- are more like Republican positions than Democratic ones. You say the Republicans are obstructionist. Sadly, they have had to obstruct very little, since once they outline their positions, the President has generally given them what they want. He is rarely critical of them, but is frequently critical of those of us in his own party who remember his campaign and would like him to remember it, too. In his latest endeavor in Libya, polls show that Republicans (especially conservative Republicans) are his strongest supporters. Naturally, the Republicans criticize the President publicly. That is what opposition parties do, and even now, they would rather have their own person in office. But, much of their wish list has been accomplished with President Obama in office, and that is a real shame.
RobbieB
Learner, Intellect, Input, Strategic & Ideation.
09:09 AM on 03/27/2011
Thanks for the thoughtful reply, ken... and I understand your take. It just appears to me that BO is the ultimate (maybe too ultimate) pragmatist, and he cuts a lot of deals with the dark side... he's governing. The alternative - disappointed folks staying home or voting in protest - is to me unthinkable given our realistic alternatives.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:38 PM on 03/27/2011
Fanned. :-)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
appacom
Artist for Obama 2012
11:18 PM on 03/27/2011
Fanned, and faved. Governing, so that's what its called.