iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Anav Silverman

Anav Silverman

Posted: October 5, 2010 02:00 PM

It becomes more apparent that with each passing year, the Arab-Israeli conflict seems to get an additional facelift in the media headlines. Many notable news sources seek to demonize Israel in the most "objective" manner possible, concentrating always on angles irrelevant to the real sources of conflict. Subsequently, when foreign journalists come to Israel with their notebooks, pens and preconceived notions, there is very little chance that their audience back home will have the opportunity to understand the conflict in an unbiased way. So much misinformation and shoddy reporting place Israel and her citizens in a very vulnerable position.

On the day that the settlement freeze expired, CNN featured the following headline in big bold lettering on its news site: "Palestinians: We fear Violent Israeli Settlers." The article focused on one Palestinian family, using them as the only example to support the story's sensational title. What the article did not point out was that that for many Palestinians, settlement construction is a major part of their livelihood and that many are currently out of work due to the freeze. Even more sadly, stories highlighting friendly relations that do exist between Israeli settlers and Palestinians, rarely appear in western media networks. The first West Bank team in Israel's amateur American football league, which includes Israeli settlers and Palestinians, has largely been ignored by most mainstream news outlets including CNN.

This sort of misrepresentation of the conflict is further strengthened with such articles, as "Why Israel Doesn't Care About Peace" published in Time on September 2. The author, Karl Vicks, writes that "The truth is that Israelis are no longer preoccupied [with peace]," rather they are busy "making money and enjoying the rays of late summer." Photos of Israelis smoking hookah on the Ashdod beach appear alongside the article. Vicks bases his argument primarily on two Israeli real-estate agents, Eli and Heli from Ashdod, whose viewpoints he uses to represent the opinions of close to six million other Israeli Jews.

But media networks aren't the only ones assigning wrongful and misdirected blame as to who is at fault for Mideast tensions; government officials are also echoing their sentiments. Former US President Bill Clinton recently seized the opportunity to also assign blame on Israelis, but to a more specific sector -- the Russian immigrant population in Israel. Clinton told US press that Israeli Russians "are the hardest-core people against the division of the land," and "present a staggering problem" to peace.

In truth, the staggering problems facing the Middle East peace process have nothing to do with Israeli Russians, nor with the settler community.

The obstacles have all to do with the rising nuclear power of Iran and the republic's fervent financial and military support of terrorist organizations in Gaza and Lebanon as well as in other areas across the world.

Without the financial support of Iran, Hamas's network could not exist and keep Gaza under its hold. With a $540 million budget for 2010, of which Iran provides the largest share, Hamas's connection with Ahmadinejad's government is rooted not only in money but in guns as well.

On a military level, Iran provides Hamas fighters with top military training and instruction from the commanders of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). The Islamic Republic also engages in delivering weapons in single components to the Sinai, paying the Sinai Bedouins for transferring the weapons through the Gaza tunnels.

The outcome that results from a strong Iran-Hamas relationship was demonstrated this past summer when Egyptian police took control of nine weapons caches across hideouts the Sinai Peninsula. The weapons caches, which were hidden in Rafah city and the port city, Al-Arish, were about to be smuggled into the Gaza Strip.

Nearly 200 anti-aircraft missiles, 90 artillery shells, 200 bullets of varying sizes and anti-tank landmines, machine guns and ammunitions were among the weapons found according to the Palestinian Ma'an news agency. Egyptian security also seized 100 kilograms of TNT explosives from a hideout in a Rafah cemetery as well as 500 smuggling tunnels. The large number of missiles indicates that Palestinian terror groups in Gaza may possess a higher number of projectiles than originally assumed.

Both Iran and Syria continue to be the chief sources for weapons bound for the Gaza Strip, as Hamas builds a stockpile of rockets targeting close to one million Israelis in range.

But readers of the Newsweek article (June 1), "Gaza is about Butter, Not Guns," by Dan Ephron, would have gained a completely different understanding of this situation. Ephron highlights what is in his view, are the economic benefits that Israel elicits from the blockade, while completely downplaying any security threats that Gaza terror groups pose to Israelis.

And the threats are very real. This past September alone, the number of Gaza rocket attacks on southern Israel sharply increased, with close to 20 Qassams and mortar rockets fired at residential areas in the western Negev and Ashkelon. One rocket struck between two day-care centers on a southern Israeli kibbutzin the morning on September 12, right before children were scheduled to arrive. No one was injured although one nursery sustained damages.

As articles blaming Israel for failed Mideast peace continue to stream into the headlines, it is clear that the Mideast reality will continue just as it always has-- with Iran as an increasingly mobilizing force. With statements like that of Ahmed Jaabari, the leader of Hamas' military wing, who threatened a wave of violence intended to derail the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian peace talks just two weeks ago, Israelis have no choice but to prepare themselves for war. For Israel, terror and war are always a few steps behind peace, whether mainstream media chooses to document this angle or not.

Anav Silverman, a native of Maine, writes from Jerusalem, Israel where she is an educator at Hebrew University's Secondary School of Education. She also works as an international correspondent at Sderot Media Center: www.SderotMedia.org.il.

 

Follow Anav Silverman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/SderotAlert

It becomes more apparent that with each passing year, the Arab-Israeli conflict seems to get an additional facelift in the media headlines. Many notable news sources seek to demonize Israel in the mos...
It becomes more apparent that with each passing year, the Arab-Israeli conflict seems to get an additional facelift in the media headlines. Many notable news sources seek to demonize Israel in the mos...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 579
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
01:22 AM on 10/10/2010
This article is almost laughable propaganda. Sure, the only violently enforced colonial settler movement in the world is not the problem, it's the Iranians. That makes sense.

The Problem is not with the people who are stealing land with the help of an army and dramatically growing in size and population every year. Not the people who systematically torment Palestinian women and children in order to encourage them to leave the area, as is shown in multiple videos in Sharmine Narwani's latest article here, but rather the problem is in Iran. It's Iran's fault, and not the settlers. I hope that is clear.

The fact that the settlers are in violation of the Geneva Convention is of no matter, the real problem lies in Iran, which apparently, the authors of the Geneva convention failed to see, when they condemned settling occupied territory.

You know the housing crisis, here in the US? Don't be angry at the government or the banking industry, that is really Iran's fault as well.

You see how that works? violently enforced, constantly growing settlements, that can only persist and grow with the assistance of a brutal and crippling occupation, are not the problem. Fanatical, violent, ultra nationalist settlers who will tell you plainly they intend to take every inch of land there are not the problem. Its ALL Iran's fault. So give up, leave it alone. It's too big and complicated for your simple mind to comprehend, so just walk away. Get it?

2nd time
06:41 AM on 10/11/2010
I read the tag - and reached for the sick bag.
It is unbelievably awful.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NewAmericanCenturySucks
Clearcutting humans to prop up the petro$ is wrong
12:04 PM on 10/08/2010
Militant nationalists snarling at each other across borders remind me of a single mad dog snarling at itself in the mirror.

Articles which willfully choose to ignore the snarling mad dogs of the "home team" should be cheerfully ignored.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
05:30 AM on 10/08/2010
Militant Zionists seem to confuse criticism and opposition to the Israeli occupation and colonization of Palestine with the "de-legitimizing of Israel". Many do it deliberately.

For Israels neighbors and the rest of the world, accepting Israel as a valid and viable state and accepting the occupation as legitimate are two very different and separate policies.

If Israelis want the world to accept them as a state and also accept a permanent occupation as a measure of "viability" Israel will always be disappointed and will never have peace and security. Ever.
07:54 AM on 10/08/2010
A simple as! Well said Nwo2012!

F & F x100!
03:24 PM on 10/08/2010
F & F
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fred303
Let's Be Friends ^_^
01:29 AM on 10/08/2010
if you hadn't stolen the land thing wouldn't be blowing up , Just saying!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StCuthbert
Anytime the mods are ready...
08:21 AM on 10/08/2010
Hooray for killing for property!
photo
batguano
As Long As Grass Grow, Wind Blow & The Sky Is Blue
09:22 AM on 10/08/2010
Well, at least you stand-up for the half-century Israeli brutality and inhumanity in their pre-meditated racist territorial expansion - even if that was not your intent. Freudian slip?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lawrence of america
07:03 PM on 10/11/2010
at least your being honest about the actions you support for once
10:20 PM on 10/07/2010
"And the threats are very real. This past September alone, the number of Gaza rocket attacks on southern Israel sharply increased, with close to 20 Qassams and mortar rockets fired at residential areas" - Silverman writes. If she really wanted to put things in perspective she would also include how many Israeli tank shells and bullets were fired in September. She would also write how many people from each side died. She would also write about how many Israeli and how many Palestinian homes were destroyed in September. The list could go on and on. But I fear Silverman might find such a list only a "red herring." She might even find such a list boring, ridiculous, irrelevant. She would rather write about how the occupied and the occupiers play ameteur American Football.
09:12 PM on 10/07/2010
And my tooth ache last week had nothing to do with my tooth, it was my mean neighbor who gave me a beer when he saw me pull in to my driveway, and forced me to talk to him and made me laugh so hard.
photo
batguano
As Long As Grass Grow, Wind Blow & The Sky Is Blue
05:54 PM on 10/07/2010
Re-posts of three published comments I believe are important & should be read:

Comment by jollyelle
“Is this article for real?

The settlements provide employment for the Palestinians? Tell that to the IDF who shot and killed this man trying to get "to work" following the same route he has for the last 15 years. Now a family of five is fatherless”.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/10/03/izzedine-kawazbeh-palestine-israel_n_748659.html


Comment by useraccess
“Anav, Could you be more biased in writing this article? What a surprising position from a Jewish person teaching at a secondary Hebrew school in Jerusalem. Yes, the Palestinians love building your settlements the same way a person stranded in the desert likes to drink his own piss to stay alive. You give them no other choice”.


Comment by Cynthia Rays
“Has the author stood at a check point with Palestinians trying to get to work? Has she seen them forced to remove their shoes and stand in the rain or under the broiling summer sun for hours? Has she seen soldiers pointing guns at a mother trying to take her child to the doctor as her children watch? She doesn't seem to notice that some Palestinians are living in tents on the street while Jewish settlers from Brooklyn with armed guards take over their homes. Has she not noticed the wall that has confiscated the Palestinian's land and olive trees so that settlers can speed by on their own highway”?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
09:38 PM on 10/07/2010
A godd summary of how I felt about this article. The author appears to not know or discount the terrible suffering Palestinians endure at Israeli hands.
10:22 PM on 10/07/2010
fantastic summary. Copy it. Save it. Repost it. Because it WILL be deleted.
02:18 PM on 10/07/2010
Silverman attacks media assuming we're "dumb goyim" who will automatically accept her version if declared forcefully unverified. But I offer Prof. DannyBenMoshe's version that makes more sense, expaling failure of OsloPeaceProcess:
****************************************
"The first reason was the timing of the deal. In contrast to other periods, such as 1982 peace agreement with Egypt, Declaratio­nOfPrincip­les negotiated inOslo came at a time when Israel's Jewish/Zionist identity was being challenged by postZionism [Zionist selfdoubt]

"The second was that Oslo process directly affected Zionist mission of settlement in GreaterIsrael articulated by GushEmunim&endorsed by LikudGovernments.

"Finally, the Oslo process meant a change in the Zionist belief in selfdefense."
*****************************************************************
and,
*****************************************************
"The Oslo process amplified debate about contemporary Jewish identity in Israel. This occured because peace process affected issues seen as an integral part of national identity and because issues of JewishZionist identity inIsrael have become intertwined with definition of left&right. Research has shown that gap between religious&nonOrthodox widened as a result of Oslo process."
***************************************************************
So,Oslo failed because, "In absence of a post-peaceZionist vision, Rabin&Peres let Oslo process become identified with goals of the secular materialistic postZionism."
*******************************************************
So, it all failed because Zionists were afraid that as "NORMAL" Mideast nation, Israel would no longer be a magnet for DiasporaJews to ZionistRight. Settlements are unpopulated and fear is that, with peace, Jews will cease giving to &coming to live in Israel. ZionistRight is afraid of peace because it's afraid of losing Jewish support. We're stuck in fight between Zionism&DiasporaJews.
photo
AGooglyMinotaur
Ahh, Theseus. It appears you are out of thread.
01:56 PM on 10/07/2010
The author gives barely a single line to the ultranationalist parties in the cabinet and Knesset. You'd think she'd have a better understanding of Israeli politics, if she considers herself qualified to write about them.

One of the worst articles I've ever read on Huffington Post. Could have just uploaded a JPG of someone pointing a finger.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Fred303
Let's Be Friends ^_^
01:37 PM on 10/07/2010
People have a right to resist illegal occupation.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
12:35 PM on 10/07/2010
Here is what happens to Palestinians who peacefully protest the theft of their land. If they are treated like this, then Israel cannot be surprised when there is armed resistance to the criminal occupation.

http://salsa.democracyinaction.org/o/301/p/dia/action/public/?action_KEY=4861
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:10 AM on 10/07/2010
"What the article did not point out was that that for many Palestinians, settlement construction is a major part of their livelihood and that many are currently out of work due to the freeze. "

Modify this sentence a bit:

"...that for many Jews, [IG Farben/Siemens/Krupps] is a major part of their livelihood and that many are currently out of work due to the Allied bombings."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lbsaltzman
Permaculture and Sustainability
12:16 PM on 10/07/2010
Well put! fanned.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sherifdxb
09:46 AM on 10/07/2010
How can Palestinians base their livelihood on someone who has stolen their lands under an occupation force that deprives them of all their rights. If you can't believe what international journalists and millions of Jews inside and outside Israel agree about the threat of the settlement expansion to peace in the Middle East, why don't you talk yourself to few Palestinian families, living near those settlements?

Yes, there is a great possibility that Israelis and Palestinians can share a better future for their children and grandchildren if each live in two states living in peaceful coexistence with each other. Settlements are the biggest obstacle to a true Palestinian state. You'll find scores of Israeli politicians who will also agree with this glaring fact.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thewho77
06:10 AM on 10/07/2010
an medical report found that US Citizen Dogan was shot at point blank range while he was lying flat on the desk of the Turkish ship. This was an execution of an unarmed US Citizen. The ship was a flotilla of humanitarian aid. Ships in International Waters are not to be boarded. Killing US citizens will get your miiltary aid cut off.
photo
AGooglyMinotaur
Ahh, Theseus. It appears you are out of thread.
02:53 PM on 10/07/2010
I highly doubt it will get their military aid cut off. Why do you think it's barely been discussed in the press? The U.S. government sure hasn't said anything about it. For more, look up the U.S.S. Liberty.
03:37 PM on 10/07/2010
I made exactly the same point.

I included the AIPAC connection.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thewho77
06:08 AM on 10/07/2010
There were 12 tribes of Israel, and the Jewish tribe was but one of the twelve tribes. Their lands were around Ber Sheba, south of Jeruslem, and the old City of David in eastern Jeruselum.. They are claiming the other 11 tribes of Israel historical lands as their own. Look it up in the Bible.