iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ann Brenoff

GET UPDATES FROM Ann Brenoff
 

Yom Kippur: You Can't Atone On Facebook

Posted: 09/25/2012 1:25 pm

Social media plays a huge role in my life, but not on Yom Kippur -- the day of atonement. As Jews worldwide mark the holiday that begins at sundown, my Facebook feed has been filling up with "friends" issuing blanket apologies to me and the rest of the Facebook for however they may have offended us.

Sorry, but it just feels wrong; you can't just e-mail in your sins and call it a day.

Yom Kippur, for strangers to Judaism, is the last chance Jews have to wipe our slates clean of the debris of the previous year and be inscribed in the book of life. We begin by apologizing to those who we have offended, slighted, hurt by exclusion, wounded by intention. It's part of a process of examining how we behave and how we can improve ourselves in the coming year.

Yet here is an example of what I read on Facebook:
"To all my family, friends and anyone out there that i may have hurt, offended or pissed off in anyway shape of form. I wanted to apologize from the bottom of my heart. I am very sorry and i truly hope you can forgive me. I wish this year only bring us smiles, laughter, good health, wealth and Happiness. I love u all. Gmar hatima tova and an easy fast."

I'd like to say it's better than nothing, but truth is, I don't think it is. At least this friend acknowledges she procrastinated -- and stole the post from another:

"To all of my friends and family members who I have wronged or hurt during the last year: I am sorry and I ask your forgiveness. I am also sorry that I waited until the day of Yom Kippur and sent a Facebook post, instead of contacting everyone personally. I hope that next year that I can turn and be a better friend and person and be there where I was not and in a better way than I was. G'mar Hatimah Tovah!! May You Be Sealed for a Good Year!! P.S. Forgive me for stealing this from XXX"

A wise rabbi once told me that the reason we visit sick friends in the hospital -- when clearly it is easier to just call them or send flowers -- is because the effort we make becomes part of the measurement of our sincerity. Think about it. What will make our hospitalized friend feel better: an e-mail saying, "hope you feel better, call when yr out" or a visit that required you carved the time out of your day, drove all the way over, paid to park the car and sat with him for an hour? Clearly, the latter. Why? Because it shows our friend how much he matters to us, which in itself, is a healing gift. You are valued; you are important to me.

It's been said that social media has managed to connect us all, yet leaves us communicating less. Facebook allows us to communicate with the people we know en masse, but just because we can doesn't mean we always should.

Yom Kippur is not about convenience. It's about reflecting on how we treat others. This isn't a holiday where a simple "Happy new year" is our greeting. And "I'm sorry" means looking someone in the eye and talking things over. Except in this case, where I'd like to say upfront: To any Facebook friends who I've offended with this post -- I'm sorry. Let's all do better next year, eh?

Please join us throughout the Jewish High Holidays, on the HuffPost Religion live-blog, updated daily with spiritual reflections, blogs, photos, videos and verses. Tell us your story.

 

Follow Ann Brenoff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/AnnBrenoff

FOLLOW RELIGION
Social media plays a huge role in my life, but not on Yom Kippur -- the day of atonement. As Jews worldwide mark the holiday that begins at sundown, my Facebook feed has been filling up with "friends"...
Social media plays a huge role in my life, but not on Yom Kippur -- the day of atonement. As Jews worldwide mark the holiday that begins at sundown, my Facebook feed has been filling up with "friends"...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nick Vanocur
Part philosopher, Part cartoon character
05:08 PM on 10/07/2012
What do you want when the guy who founded Facebook is named Zuckerberg?
03:57 AM on 10/04/2012
Couldn't agree more, esepcially about your example at the hospital. People have become lazy, which means our expectations of what's acceptable has become slack! People instead of saying we're social, let's start actually being social!

Fiona,
discover your next favorite bra
www.brayola.com
photo
AntithiChrist
Rhymes with Grist
10:51 PM on 09/27/2012
I wouldn't get wigged out so much about Facebook atonement. Many folks I know call their atonements in telepathically, on a daily basis, via a thing they call "prayer." It's a real time-saver, I'm told, and you can get the warm, fuzzy feeling of all the forgiveness you'd ever want, before your head even hits the pillow.

Such a deal.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ailadinya
Professional kitten herder.
11:42 PM on 09/26/2012
I think that people are trying to adapt their faith into the modern world, and Facebook/Twitter/blogs are a part of that. I think it is wonderful to see people asking for forgiveness for things they have done to harm or slight others in some way. It shows a level of caring and compassion that is lacking greatly in a lot of people today. Hopefully that will spread.
10:39 PM on 09/26/2012
I must respectfully disagree with you, Ann, although I did bot post such a notice.
My friends on Facebook are mostly people who I've never met. I live in Brooklyn, NY. On my list are people from Africa; Asia; Russia; The Middle East as well as all over the US and the UK. Facebook allows me to maintain business and personal reationships with these people I've never seen, but still value. It may be more "personal" to send each of them an individual e-mail. but I would stil have been reduced to sending out CC'sd to all of them - the electronic equavalent to the pre-printed Shana Tovah cards invented in the 19th Century by our English cousins, which lead to the greeting card industry. This was an earlier generation's adpatation of technology to replace the personal letters suggested in the Talmud for the New Year.
Another reason remains for Jewish members of social media to share foten about our faith: we Jews are one of the most misunderstood religions in the west, along with Islam, the Sikhs and Mormons. The more often we explain why we are different to our friends of various faiths, the more likely they are to begin to understand how fundamentally differnt our beliefs are, but how at the same time we believe in the same core values of Justice, Mercy, Love of our Fellow Humans, and Obedience of the G*D we share.
08:34 PM on 09/26/2012
I am with you atoning online or via facebook is certainly not ideal. That said why should we be belittling how people choose to right their wrongs. While some may send out mass emails/posts others are not directing their hearts towards 'teshuva' (repentance) at all. We can all agree that there are problems with the way we as a society are addicted to technology but lets give people are break who are using tech in any way to bring light into the world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:01 PM on 09/26/2012
I'm not Jewish. I'm not even religious. But I like and respect a day of atonement, because it forces us to face the damage we may have done to others, thus encouraging us to become better people. I heartily agree that this benefit is completely thwarted by a mass apology to erase all our (unspecified) sins, using a medium we were probably logged onto anyway. Frankly, I'm glad I didn't receive anything like this, because it seems like a faceless and shallow boxtick.
12:57 PM on 09/26/2012
I don't disagree with the sentiment of your article. You can't ask for blanket forgiveness... that being said, i did post a message on facebook - from the reactions I think it was well received (even my Rabbi reposted it on his own page) - asking for those who I may not be aware I offended or hurt let me know (privately) so that I can find the words to ask their forgiveness... I think if you know you've done something you have a responsibility to atone properly for that, but there is so much we dont know we do and I believe social media is an acceptable way to find out from those you may not be aware you offended if you did!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shira Hirschman Weiss
03:27 PM on 09/27/2012
well said
11:05 AM on 09/26/2012
I agree with the general sentiment of the article. Clearly repentance can not just be phoned in. But just because one repents on fb does not mean that they have not done so in person as well. I have friends all around the world and it is not possible to call each one individually. I asked in person for forgiveness when possible and sen a fb message to reach out to the friends I had inevitably missed. The holiday is ultimately about personal introspection. Of course we should be trying to improve all of the time. Yom Kippur merely gives us a moment to pause and re-remember the consequences of our actions and reflect on them.
09:26 AM on 09/26/2012
I have to agree - Making amends is a very personal thing. And should be done in person. It takes time, effort and suggests a caring that an email (or facebook post) does not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jreeves1425
The Dragon of the West
08:48 AM on 09/26/2012
I'd much rather a person put atonement into action by living as better human beings, than apologize every year at the same time because they have to.
photo
Indigo1941
Time traveler.
08:35 AM on 09/26/2012
Now, now. Let's look at our own transgressions and let others worry about theirs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
A Dub
Conservative government is an organized hypocrisy
07:00 AM on 09/26/2012
I am sure there is an atonement app!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:59 AM on 09/26/2012
Atoning on Stephen Colbert's Atone Phone (1-888-OOPS-JEW) is so much better.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
01:20 AM on 09/26/2012
JESUS CHRIST is the only atonement."But HE was wounded for our transgressions, HE was bruised for our iniquities: the chastisement of our peace was upon HIM; and with HIS stripes we are healed." Isaiah 53:5. Life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:06 AM on 09/26/2012
Can you please TRY not to be so offensive? We are talking about Judaism here. Its not like you get a Jewish viewpoint every time you Christians talk about whether its ok to talk about Santa during Christmas or if Jesus should be centre stage.
I KNOW that you dont hold my faith, thats fine. Believe what you will.
But don't try to convert us for godsakes! We never try to convert Christians!
A little courtesy goes a long way in this world
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sistagirl Young
11:32 AM on 09/26/2012
Hello Tsadik; "He that despised Moses law died without mercy under two or three witnesses:Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot The SON of GOD, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, wherewith HE was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hat done despite unto the SPIRIT of grace?For we know hiim that hath said, Vengeance belongeth unto me, I will recompense, saith The LORD. And again, The LORD shal judge HIS people.It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living GOD" Hebrews 10: 28-31. I am not trying to convert anyone. You guys didn't believe Moses. Who am I. I am curious though. Is GOD of the Old Testament the same GOD of the New Testament? The same Bible. How does one determine what is true and what isn't. It's "all" the same GOD. Isn't it? Life.
09:59 PM on 09/26/2012
Tsadik, I agree with you completely. Thank you for graciously posting what anyone should know. How difficult can it be?