More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Anne L. Thompson

GET UPDATES FROM Anne L. Thompson
 

Why Wages Can't Wait This Valentine's Day

Posted: 02/11/11 11:25 AM ET

On Valentine's Day, millions of couples will head to their local eateries for a romantic dinner for two. It's the most popular date night of the year -- and also the highest grossing day for the restaurant industry. Our nation's en masse dinner date will be made possible by a bastion of poverty-wage earners working overtime to cook our food, serve our drinks, clean our dishes, and provide a special evening out.

Restaurants are the single largest employers of minimum wage workers, with one in three employees earning the lowest legal wage. The federal minimum wage for servers, busboys and other tipped employees is just $2.13 an hour. If that sounds like a wage from another era, that's because it is: the last time Congress raised these workers' pay was two decades ago -- in 1991.

While their take home pay is supplemented by tips, very few waiters and waitresses work in fine dining establishments that offer higher earnings -- picture the waitress at the diner on the New Jersey Turnpike. The median wage for servers is $9.22 an hour, or $20,000 a year for fulltime, full year work (though steady fulltime schedules are scarce in the restaurant industry). As a result, one in six waiters and waitresses fall below the federal poverty line.

In a protracted period of painfully high unemployment, it's tempting to disregard the importance of wages. That's why we've heard repeatedly that in these tough economic times people just need a job -- any job -- and the pay doesn't matter. But when you replace a $50,000 a year job, home and retirement savings with a $20,000 a year job, a foreclosure and a decimated retirement, where is the prospect for economic recovery?

While job losses during the recession were widely distributed and included significant losses in higher-wage industries, an analysis by the National Employment Law Project finds that net job growth in 2010 has occurred disproportionately in low-wage industries. Jobs in construction and manufacturing are still missing in action, while low-paying service sector jobs are rebounding.

According to the Economic Policy Institute, although the economy lost 5 million jobs from 2007 to 2009, the number of waiters grew by about 68,000. The overall workforce has grown by 1.8 percent since 2000, but the number of waiters has grown by 7.5 percent.

More and more, America will be depending on service sector workers like waiters and waitresses to support our families and propel economic recovery with increased consumer spending. That's why we must raise wages for our lowest paid service workers, which includes restoring the long-eroded wages of tipped employees.

Thirty-two states have raised the tipped wage above the federal rate of $2.13, and legislation is being introduced this session in states including Maryland, Illinois, California, and Massachusetts to give a pay boost to tipped workers. In the coming weeks, Maryland Representative Donna Edwards will be reintroducing the WAGES Act in Congress, which would raise the federal tipped minimum wage to 70 percent of the regular minimum wage by 2012 -- an increase to $5.03 an hour based on the current minimum wage of $7.25.

When Franklin Roosevelt enacted the nation's first minimum wage law during the depths of the Great Depression in 1938, he emphasized that a strong wage floor is "an essential part of economic recovery." Raising the lowest wage puts money into the hands of people who will spend it immediately in their communities. Rather than waiting for the economy to improve, raising wages now for our lowest paid workers can help jumpstart the economy and spur job growth.

At one time, the manufacturing jobs that we now yearn for were dangerous, low-wage, undesirable jobs. But we turned them into good jobs, improving workplace safety and raising pay to create the middle class that fueled American economic prosperity for half a century. We should do the same for waiters, waitresses, and the rest of the growing ranks of our service sector.

This Valentine's Day, as we enjoy a special evening out, we must recommit to better serve the workers who work so hard serving us.

 
On Valentine's Day, millions of couples will head to their local eateries for a romantic dinner for two. It's the most popular date night of the year -- and also the highest grossing day for the resta...
On Valentine's Day, millions of couples will head to their local eateries for a romantic dinner for two. It's the most popular date night of the year -- and also the highest grossing day for the resta...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
10:19 AM on 02/14/2011
So am I screwing over the working poor (in restaurants) by cooking dinner for my wife tonight?

Regarind the minimum wage/economics arguments, many of us think that CEOs are overpaid. But their being overpaid doesn't justify raising the minimum wage. When I wore a young man's clothes (don't worry, I asked first), I worked for a grocery store as a carryout boy. There were 21 of us. I went back to that store (to buy stuff for tonight's meal), and there are no carryout boys today. My oldest works for the local boys club as a lifeguard--when minimum wage increased the last time, they closed the slide (since it took a separate lifeguard to watch it). What happend? At $2.10 per hour it was worth it to carry groceries to someone's car; at $7.25 it isn't...

If the government really wants to help the working poor, keeping inflation very low is the best thing it can do.

BTW I took the wife out for dinner Friday night, and tipped about 22%...
11:53 AM on 02/13/2011
I agree completely with Ms. Thompson. I try never to eat in a restaurant without thinking of the waiters and waitresses and taking note of the fact that their job is difficult and often pretty thankless. But, I also realize that this year is difficult. Fixed income folks (seniors and retirees) have not had a raise (cost-of-living or otherwise) in awhile, and it does not look like any are forthcoming in the near future. The number of people who have been unemployed long-term is staggering. Costs all around us, including restaurant costs, are going up quickly (my health care premium went up 35% last month and the price of gas is at a all-time winter high). Restaurant workers are also in a good position to know that food prices have hit record highs. So, this year is going to be as difficult for the customers (those who can even afford to visit a restaurant for Valentine's or any other Day) as for the waiter/waitresses. We should tip as generously as possible, and we should hope that the rich folks who got those extended tax cuts last month make up the difference for us all.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mike dougles
11:00 AM on 02/12/2011
When I was youunger I worked as a bartender, and well my pay was about 2 bucks an hour I would walk out with about 150 to 200 bucks in tips. We would report about 50 bucks in tips to the IRS and pocket the rest it was nice.
12:48 AM on 02/12/2011
Yes, more can be done to aid those working in industries that pay the lowest of wages. In addition to low wages, they are least likely to have access to health care. I do want to point out that workers who make the majority of their income on tips largely under report their income. This results in both the employer and employee not paying the correct amount of money into social security and medicare system. In conclusion, yes pay them more money but fix of some the abuses.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawrence Bullock
06:43 PM on 02/11/2011
Hey, until it impacts ME why should I care? I'm kidding. But you know, the climate for unionization ain't the best right now and most of these comments will be brimming with "They should feel lucky to have that crap job" soon, if they already aren't. We should face the facts: We have been trained not to care about anyone but ourselves because that's the way the beast wants it. And the beast will feed no matter what we say. Mmmmmmooooowah! (Cue scary music) But hey, maybe Michael Moore will do a film about it! That'll make us feel outraged for oh, say a day or two.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
epochme
06:42 PM on 02/11/2011
real wages for real work... and everybody makes money... sending jobs overseas... is a losing proposition for everyone... including the ridiculous slave labor seeking elites
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
epochme
06:40 PM on 02/11/2011
gm shipped its jobs overseas and down to mexico... gmc went bankrupt... chrysler ditto... ford... ditto... but they came crawling to the American taxpayer to bail them out... the financial sector... sold a ponsi scheme to the world... and went belly up... and then they too came crawling to the American taxpayer for a bailout... are we starting to see the pattern here...
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
10:25 PM on 02/11/2011
Actually, Ford has never needed nor taken a dime of tax payer bailout.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mike dougles
10:58 AM on 02/12/2011
You understand by claiming Ford went bankrupt and took bailout money it shows you have zero clue what you are talking about and makes your whole post pointless.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
epochme
06:34 PM on 02/11/2011
hooray free trade... free for corporations to seek out slave labor in all corners of the globe... the freedom to exploit... the freedom to pillage and plunder America... the once great nation
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
epochme
06:30 PM on 02/11/2011
blah blah blah... we don't care... we are going shopping at walmart after dinner... to buy some cheap goods made with slave labor... and then we are buying a new iphone... the ones made at the factory in china where the workers are offing themselves... and then we are buying a new honda... from a factory in china where the workers are offing themselves... and then we are buying brand new nikes... where the workers are paid 7 cents per shoe and are all under age young women who should be in junior high... because we don't care... we just can't get enough of that cheap stuff... no matter how many Americans lose their jobs... no matter the atrocious virtual slave labor...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HeadAches
I'm here, getting into your head giving you...
04:37 PM on 02/11/2011
And you can thank the non-existing labor movement in the US for these horrendous conditions.

As the only civilized country without a decent and involved labor movement, it can be clearly seen in all areas of life. Low paid jobs, no workers protection, crappy work conditions, no law mandated vacations, no systems for maternity leaves, no UHC etc.

If all civilized countries, the US is the one looking the most like a third world banana republic at the moment!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dana Ace
Achieving peace through superior firepower
03:42 PM on 02/11/2011
Time to address the gorilla in the room. When you raise the minimum wage you raise unemployment. Look at our current situation and see the step up in unemployment that matched each of the increases from 5.25 to 7.25 per hour.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
HeadAches
I'm here, getting into your head giving you...
04:38 PM on 02/11/2011
Interesting argument, a country like Norway must have an insane amount of unemployed workers then. Have you really checked the real world lately?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawrence Bullock
06:44 PM on 02/11/2011
Well, why stop there? Give 'em 50 cents an hour and make 'em sleep in tents. I mean, that'll jack up employment rates big time.
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
10:33 PM on 02/11/2011
Why would they sleep in tents? When everyone is making lower wages, prices drop in accord.
03:29 PM on 02/11/2011
"The median wage for servers is $9.22 an hour, or $20,000 a year for fulltime, full year work"

Yeah, problem with citing their hourly wage is that they make a lot in tips and a lot of them don't claim the tips on their taxes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:53 PM on 02/11/2011
That median wage of $9.22 most likely includes their tips, friend. And the IRS is pretty good at estimating how much income a server makes in tips. In addition, there's no job security--you can get fired if a customer complains about you once--and pretty much nothing by way of bennies. If you're envying the life and income of a waiter (or busperson, or bartender, or line cook), you've never done the job.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tiggerchick
if your view is myopic, go get Lasik
06:14 PM on 02/11/2011
You are forced by the restaurant to claim a certain percentage of your sales, usually 10% in tips - whether that's the actual amount or not. Credit card tips are claimed automatically.

So when you get stiffed by a patron, not only are you earning next to nothing, but you are paying taxes on an amount you never received.

Also, the article made it clear that the federal wage is $2.13 ~ the median wage cited includes tips.

Yes, there are some patrons who tip rather generously 20% or so - unfortunately, they only make up for those who tip along these lines - party of 8, $180 check, $5 tip.
03:15 PM on 02/11/2011
I worked in restaurants where I made as little 12K a year, and I worked in one where I made 50K - now I am an underemployed IT professional. Go figure
itolduso
lateral thinker
01:37 PM on 02/11/2011
Most food service workers do not receive any benefits- no paid vacations, no paid sick days (no health insurance), no pensions or IRA's - so the low wages must cover things that workers in other industries take for granted. It's a very dangerous, shortsighted and foolish policy that the one's that handle the nation's food are among those least likely to have access to basic preventable health care, and the least likely to stay home when they are sick. It's a pandemic just waiting to happen.
01:30 PM on 02/11/2011
hahaha, economics is confusing. Why not just mandate everyone gets paid $500 an hr, or even $5,000,000 an hr? Without increasing profits the marginal worker becomes not worth the cost and is no longer needed at the higher wage. Horay! Higher Unemployment!!!!
itolduso
lateral thinker
01:49 PM on 02/11/2011
I'm only confused by the so-called economic experts that justify the outrageously over-the-top salaries & bonuses of heads of corporations (regardless of results) while at the same time criticising 'fair' wages for those workers that actually produce.
02:59 PM on 02/11/2011
Using that form of logic then we should eliminate unemployment by abolishing the minimum wage and child labor laws. Sure everyone will have a job but it'll be working for peanuts and pennies. Repubs actually proposed this idea too is the insanity that is reality.