iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Annmarie Kelly-Harbaugh

GET UPDATES FROM Annmarie Kelly-Harbaugh
 

I Hate Mother's Day

Posted: 05/ 1/2012 4:12 pm

I hate Mother's Day. I know this makes me a curmudgeon and an ingrate. But in the brief time that I've been celebrated by this so-called holiday, I've come to really, really detest it. I dislike greeting cards. Chocolates go straight to my hips. Orchid corsages make me sneeze. And don't even get me started on breakfast in bed.

Oh how I loathe it! In tromp the children, interrupting my sleep. Bleary-eyed, I must feign hunger and excitement: "Ooh, oatmeal scrambled eggs! What fun! And are those jelly beans floating in the smoothie? Great! It will be sweet, just like you." Then there is the sharing, spilling, and witnessing. The kids suspect my enthusiasm, and actually want to see mommy consume the food. Last year, I ate cheesy, green eggs (my eldest daughter was on a food coloring kick) until I nearly vomited, which, truthfully, would have neither looked nor tasted very different than the eggs did the first time around. I was only reprieved from the feast when my youngest daughter overturned pink apple juice on the comforter. That was the first 15 minutes of Mother's Day.

Following the grease smears on my pillow are a well-intentioned, but ultimately off-putting parade of cards, gifts, or activities. My children seldom buy me presents. After all, they are only seven and two. Usually, they just wrap up things they find around the house: my stapler; a box of Kleenex; a pear. However, that doesn't stop my husband. There are the gadgets -- the orange juicer (a gift he'd always wanted), the portable speakers for my kitchen radio (I found them yesterday, dismembered, in my daughter's crib). Occasionally, there are signed IOUs, intentions to complete household chores on a later date. Last year, for example, he promised to lay a patio, an endeavor that we are still pondering today.

I saw a billboard recently that advertised: "Take Mom to the Zoo." Moms, it seems, get in free on Mother's Day. My mind flashed to all those poor mothers, whose families drag them off to see kangaroos and giraffes, moms armed only with macaroni necklaces and construction paper broaches, rather than the picnic lunches, wide-brimmed hats, and sunscreen that, on a good day, make visiting the zoo with one's children just barely tolerable. By day's end, most of these moms will have changed poopy diapers outside the monkey cages, and carried their exhausted and sunburned children the thousand or so yards back to the car. Happy freaking Mother's Day indeed.

I long to celebrate Mother's Day my way: quietly, selfishly. I spend every day with my family. On Mother's Day, I just want to be left alone, to do whatever I want, whenever I want, the way I could before I became a mother. I fantasize about sitting on my front porch with a seasonal beverage, and reading in the breeze. I want to garden, but only a little. I want to jog without a stroller. I want to eat a salad from start to finish, with no interruptions, vegetable complaints, or ketchup. I wouldn't mind pushing a button to summon my children, briefly. I would smile at them, feel pride. But then I would want to push another button and send them away again. I wouldn't mind a date with my husband, but preferably to two different movies. In his, some fellow could make clever quips as he kills bad guys, stops runaway trains, and beds large-bosomed beauties. My film would be foreign, subtitled, and evoke memories of my time as a college student overseas. Perhaps we could meet for dinner afterwards, but only at a restaurant where they use real napkins and none of the choices is macaroni and cheese.

I read recently that Mother's Day in America has its roots in the post-Civil War era. Julia Ward Howe, who wrote the words to "The Battle Hymn of the Republic," was an early advocate. In 1870, Howe wrote a Mother's Day Proclamation, decrying war and inviting mothers into political dialogue to avoid losing more of their sons on the battlefield. In later years, mothers were urged to fight for other causes, including improved sanitation and public health. And in 1914, Woodrow Wilson finally declared a national holiday, setting aside one day every year to pay homage to the good work that mothers were doing. Surely these early founders would be baffled by the transformation of a day urging feminist political action into a day encouraging men to buy women flowers.

So maybe my daydream of lolling around at a spa in a swimsuit that doesn't also include a skirt or cape is just as off the mark as my daughters' cornflake pancakes. Perhaps Mother's Day should include that kind of quiet reflection, but only as a catalyst to higher ground. What cause am I ignoring these days? What community problem needs my help? Maybe next year, I'll be up early to run in a Mother's Day 5K to raise money for a local charity or homeless shelter.

At least that would get me out of breakfast in bed.

 
FOLLOW PARENTS
I hate Mother's Day. I know this makes me a curmudgeon and an ingrate. But in the brief time that I've been celebrated by this so-called holiday, I've come to really, really detest it. I dislike gr...
I hate Mother's Day. I know this makes me a curmudgeon and an ingrate. But in the brief time that I've been celebrated by this so-called holiday, I've come to really, really detest it. I dislike gr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 224
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
12:02 AM on 05/13/2012
To continue (there seems to be a word limit, so I had to break this up into two separate posts), it is not just Mother's Day, but every day that is hard for me. I can hardly even leave my house anymore because every time that I do, I am surrounded by pregnant women and women with babies. I have abandoned more than one cart in line when I got stuck behind said women. I have run out of more than one mall/restaurant/store when I saw these women. Now my husband does all of the shopping because it causes me too much pain. I would die to hear my child's voice, but all that exists is silence coming from the next room where my son's crib is still set up - the crib that I have spent countless hours crying next to. You can't even begin to imagine what I go through every day, and how "Mother's Day," and the month leading up to it, affects me. I have a reason to hate it. You don't. I still can't believe what I just read...
01:47 AM on 05/13/2012
Hey Maiah, I totally understand. I'm so sorry that you've had to go through such a horrible loss, and I'll be thinking of you on this very difficult holiday.
08:28 PM on 05/13/2012
Thank you so much for that, Jan. Your comment actually made me cry. Your kindness is so much appreciated; sometimes, just a few simple words are what is needed. You are a beautiful person, and again, thank you so much.
07:24 PM on 05/13/2012
Wow, I was sitting here feeling sorry for myself because my mother's day stinks, but I attitude has been checked big time. So sorry for you. I will recount my blessings.
08:59 PM on 05/12/2012
I hate mother's day because I am the 32 year old version of your children. You see, nothing I ever did was good enough for my mom. For years, we had no communication at all. The first year we began speaking to one another again, I went all out on mother's day. I bought her a 1.5 tcw diamond and white gold pendant. She sold it. How do I know she sold it? She told me. She told me she sold it to a pawn shop for less than $100 because she likes "yeller" gold. Now, I just send her a text - out of a sense of obligation.
05:38 PM on 05/12/2012
One more thing. I only found your post by Google searching, "I hate Mother's Day," hoping to find posts from other grieving women in pain because of this holiday. I didn't expect to find a mother lamenting about her blessings.
07:25 PM on 05/13/2012
Totally agree! I wish my family would have done 25% as much for me.
05:34 PM on 05/12/2012
Reading your post not only pissed me off, but it also made me physically ill. You are so UNGRATEFUL, and that is the least of what I want to call you/say to you! You disgust me. I seriously detest people like you. I would give anything to have everything that you just complained about having, but as someone who, over the course of eight years, has had to live with loss after loss (a placental abruption stillbirth just THREE WEEKS BEFORE THIS DREADFUL DAY followed by eight miscarriages and my current inability to conceive whatsoever post-cancer) and still-empty arms, I have become a bitter infertile woman. No adoption comments! Just don't! That tops the list of what not to say to infertile women. Adoption is neither easy nor for everyone, and it's OKAY that I wanted to have my husband's child. Anyway, you have children who love you, and you complain about wanting a day away from them on the very day that brings me anger, hatred, jealousy, and most of all pain because I can't have the very thing that you are trying to "take a break from." Seriously, you make me sick to my stomach.
01:18 PM on 05/09/2012
Annmarie--I love you!! You reminded me so much of Erma Bombeck back in the day!! Some of the stuff she wrote (and now you do) would have the PC police banging on the front door. But not for one moment of those rants, did anyone ever doubt there was true love for her children and husband. Just sometimes and maybe even on Mother's Day, a mom might want it to be about HER. I'll be thinking about that cool drink on the porch with a favorite book while I'm at the action movie we're going to go see (I hate action movies BTW, and yes I've told them--but "I'm told I'm gonna love this one") and my "kids" are in their 20s--bless 'em! Happy Mother's Day!!
walk1111
Common sense isn't so common anymore
06:16 AM on 05/08/2012
The mothers that are whining and complaining about Mother's day will one day regret it.
08:26 PM on 05/13/2012
The mothers that are whining and complaining about Mother's Day should have to live a life in the day of an infertile woman and feel our pain. Once they returned to their lives, they would shut right up because they would have a whole new appreciation for what we have to live every day without.
01:13 PM on 05/07/2012
Yes, I can see how a child trying their best to please you and make you happy would be so terrible to have to deal with. Last week my toddler picked weeds and brought them too me. He held them up so proud as he said "I love you Mommy". Those (now) dead weeds are still sitting in a vase on my window because they remind me of how much that child loves me. I think you need to try looking at things completely different.
walk1111
Common sense isn't so common anymore
06:11 AM on 05/08/2012
What a wonderful story. You are probably very deserving of the special love of your son. I wish there were more positive posts like yours.
08:30 PM on 05/13/2012
Indeed. Even someone such as myself can appreciate that this mother deserves her blessings, and I am happy to see how grateful she is for them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dede4007
11:47 PM on 05/03/2012
AnneMarie, I'm so sorry you have been lambasted in these posts. I know you love your children and truly give of yourself to them every day of the year. I hear exhaustion and some sadness in what you wrote, and it sounds as if you just need someone to notice YOU for a little bit. I know how that is. No, it doesn't mean you love your kids or husband any less, it just means you feel a little bit overwhelmed occasionally and just needed to let off steam. It's okay, I understand. I used to hate mother's day too, because I had a mother that was very controlling and demanded that she get presents (that she never liked unless you spend a LOT of money, which we didn't have) And, she caused a lot of division and hurt in our entire family. I began to hate mother's day, and my daughter's started picking up on that. When I saw that I was passing that opinion down to my own girls, I knew I had to change my attitude. Glad to say, my married daughters are joys to me, and now sincerely appreciate me (and they show it) and I would do ANYTHING for them.
I do hope your husband gives you some time and appreciation, even if it means letting you have a day to yourself. Maybe not on Mother's Day, but the day before or after so you don't feel so pressured. I really do wish you well.
photo
averagezoe
Don't breed or buy while homeless animals die!
10:02 PM on 05/03/2012
I totally agree with you, Mother's Day is asinine. I spent most of my daughter's life just with her (between marriages), so there was usually just the two of us and even when she was little, she succumbed to pressure at school to make me a card or a gift or do something for that day. Not until she was older, did I finally convince her that it was a Sunday like every other Sunday and that being a mother was neither an accomplishment nor any great feat and that I am her mother every day of the year. We finally put it behind us and now treat it as any other day.
09:05 PM on 05/03/2012
Oh to be a fly on the wall at your house should your children ever inadvertently run across this ungrateful online diatribe! Hopefully it won't be until they're old enough not to be terribly hurt by your attitude.
08:29 PM on 05/03/2012
All that ridiculous whining? Why not just tell your family how you want to spend Mother's Day if it's THAT big a deal for you? Here's another thought: Maybe you need to realize that people may have different ideas about showing love. I mean; you spend the super majority of your days like you want. Does Mother's Day mess you up that much? I figured HP would have some weird stupid article on Mother's Day and this did not disappoint.
08:28 PM on 05/03/2012
I think many of us whose children have grown up and moved into houses of their own, have very fond memories of breakfast in bed, hand crafted gifts, and happy excited children on Mother's day. Those years which seem slow now, actually fly by. Cherish it. I love my current Mother's day. The kids come over and bring their families. Every stage is great.
08:26 PM on 05/03/2012
What would you do if your family disappeared/left?
08:33 PM on 05/13/2012
Or if you were like me, and could never have one?
08:09 PM on 05/03/2012
Has it occurred to you to tell your family how you want to spend Mother's Day? I'm sure they only want to make you happy, and if you have never spoken up, they can't possibly know. My husband and kids ask me every year what I want to do. One year, yes, I chose to go WITH my kids to the zoo. We have an awesome zoo, and the entire family had a blast. That was the first year after my own mother died, and it was poignant. Another year we all went to the botanical gardens. That, too, was wonderful.

Go, spend a day alone, and then meet your family for dinner relaxed and rejuvenated so that they, too, can enjoy spending time with their mom on Mother's Day. I wish I could spend it with my mom.
10:06 PM on 05/03/2012
should it be so much work to love you Annemarie? Really?
10:39 PM on 05/03/2012
Some people make themselves pretty unlovable by their attitudes.
07:27 PM on 05/13/2012
Amen sister. WTF.
08:05 PM on 05/03/2012
The best Mother's Day gift would probably be Dad taking the kids out of the house all day and letting Mom sleep in. They would then return and take Mom out to dinner.
Just an observation, taking into account the day in day out chores that women do - it would appear she should get something she doesn't usually get - sleeping in, getting time to herself and then some family time at the end of the day.